Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Air bnb owner ott or do we deserve to be chucked out?

711 replies

Pilloh · 12/11/2023 19:25

We were forced out of our house due to a water leak in the house. The insurance company said we had to move out due to the severity of the work.

A bit of a nightmare for us as we have a large dog. He’s been called a wonderfully mannered dog by a qualified behaviourist outside the house who really doesn’t care about people/other dogs. But he is a breed used for guarding and therefore very barky at home (we have a command that gets him to be quiet but it doesn’t stop the impulse to bark initially). Not to make excuses, we were working on this with the behaviourist pre-pandemic but our progress stalled so we just manage the situation. Ie we have gates all around our house/garden, don’t allow strangers and the dog to meet inside the house (he’s totally fine with people when they are not on “his” property). Our house is basically Fort Knox and only DH and I are here so it’s all pretty easy to manage.

We told the air bnb owner that please tell the cleaner not to enter house or garden without telling us as dog will run up and bark at strangers. He agreed. We explained the situation and he said he understood.

Yesterday pm, cleaner comes into the garden when I was playing footy - she was fetching something from shed. Dog ran towards her and barked. I gave the recall command which worked initially but then my dog ran back to cleaner and barked. It’s no doubt intimidating. After 20 ish secs dog was in the house and I apologised. Recall is not full proof hence why we never rely on it. We would never have found an Airbnb where we were not assured we would be informed of any person entering the property.

Owner has messaged now saying the cleaner won’t return whilst we are here and that means we have to leave as the owner is not ok with the house not being maintenanced.

Cleaner has visited 4 times without incident as the right procedures were followed.

Who is being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
MsBea · 14/11/2023 20:40

All this fuss because of a dog. You seem to be making life harder for yourself.

sandyhappypeople · 14/11/2023 20:10

Jumpingthruhoops · 14/11/2023 19:47

Don't patronise me! I'm not thick.

I'm fully aware the cleaner wasn't bitten. However, there's no saying that she wouldn't have been... or won't be in the future.

As another PP said, we can argue all we like about whether the cleaner is at fault, for going in unannounced or whether the landlord has broken the Ts & Cs of the agreement. None of that is relevant.

The only thing that is relevant is that this dog - by OP's own admission - is untrained, which makes him volatile and liable to cause serious injury. The End.

Happy to clear that up for you. 🙄

I'm fully aware the cleaner wasn't bitten. However, there's no saying that she wouldn't have been... or won't be in the future.

If she keeps randomly walking into peoples back gardens uninvited then she may well get bitten in the future.. it would be prudent for her to stop doing that.. for her own safety.

Jumpingthruhoops · 14/11/2023 19:47

GuessItsANameChange · 14/11/2023 17:36

As for your hypothetical scenario about the cleaner making a personal injury claim (after being attacked) and the dog being put down - all that could totally be avoided if the OP just trained her dog.
It was totally avoided in actuality too. The cleaner wasn’t bitten. Happy to clear that up for you.

Don't patronise me! I'm not thick.

I'm fully aware the cleaner wasn't bitten. However, there's no saying that she wouldn't have been... or won't be in the future.

As another PP said, we can argue all we like about whether the cleaner is at fault, for going in unannounced or whether the landlord has broken the Ts & Cs of the agreement. None of that is relevant.

The only thing that is relevant is that this dog - by OP's own admission - is untrained, which makes him volatile and liable to cause serious injury. The End.

Happy to clear that up for you. 🙄

RubyRoseVioletLillyJasminePeach · 14/11/2023 18:44

GuinnessBird · 12/11/2023 20:44

The Air BNB host doesn't give a shit about what your dog behaviourist and vet think.

Yup

RubyRoseVioletLillyJasminePeach · 14/11/2023 18:40

Pilloh · 12/11/2023 19:50

Yes we can move on. Putting dog in kennels is not something I am willing to do.

Just think it’s a bit rich to give assurances/take money and then kick us out.

Get your money back on time taken away.

RubyRoseVioletLillyJasminePeach · 14/11/2023 18:39

Pilloh · 12/11/2023 19:48

We are not here by choice.

But the Air B&B owner is not forcing you to stay. Just find another place.

RubyRoseVioletLillyJasminePeach · 14/11/2023 18:37

Pilloh · 12/11/2023 19:35

@Kitcaterpillar I mentioned the pandemic as we were doing really well on the desensitising training - having people come into the house with dog remaining calm. Obviously with lockdown this came to an abrupt halt. And tbh we have just got used to not having people in our house so have not picked up training again.

Lockdown was years ago!

RubyRoseVioletLillyJasminePeach · 14/11/2023 18:37

Pilloh · 12/11/2023 19:33

Every week I ask the owner to let me know when the cleaner is coming so I can take dog out. This visit was unannounced. I explained fully why we HAVE to know. Owner said “no, problem”.

You sound stressful.
What breed of dog us it OP?

sandyhappypeople · 14/11/2023 17:59

Jumpingthruhoops · 14/11/2023 15:51

What rubbish! Attackers 'don't operate within human moral boundaries' either. That's what makes them attackers!

Meanwhile, dogs ARE trained to operate within certain boundaries. And that's the point: OP's dog is NOT trained!

But people on here are literally saying that if the cleaner had been seriously injured, it would have been her fault for entering the space of a potential threat unannounced.

I give up!

'dogs don't operate within human moral boundaries' is exactly the point here, a human has a complex thought process when carrying out any task, 'attackers' DO have moral boundaries, they just choose to ignore them, they know exactly what there actions will do to someone and how it will make them feel and they do it regardless.

A dog has NO moral boundaries and a very limited 'thought' process and responds instinctively, it looks to you as it's owner to see how to react from there but nothing will stop that first instinct to warn and protect from kicking in, it's a defence mechanism that serves them well. The dog is saying 'I don't know who you are or if you'll hurt me so don't come any closer' but it communicates that by claiming its territory and barking. To the people saying it's a pre-curser to an attack, it's a load of bollocks, if the dog wanted to attack the cleaner it would have done, it didn't.

Holding dogs to human standards of behaviour and likening it to a person running at you with a knife is quite frankly, ridiculous.

Meanwhile, dogs ARE trained to operate within certain boundaries

I would argue that OPs dog operated within those boundaries, it didn't launch itself at her in a feeding frenzy like some of you are suggesting.

the only difference was it took two commands to recall it, without further info it's hard to know why, it may have still felt threatened, or the 'intruder' may have come further into the garden when the dog retreated the first time, hard to say.

If the cleaner had been seriously injured, the dog owners on here, like myself, would be responding entirely differently to this thread I'm sure, any dog that would attack a person who accidentally stumbles upon it should not be alive IMO, at a bare minimum they should be behind a LOCKED gate, so OP would be held to a higher standard, a dog running up to an unexpected intruder and barking at them is just natural dog behaviour, it's unfortunate that the cleaner was scared by it, but they really shouldn't have done what they did, I'd have been livid over the intrusion of privacy, whether my dogs barked at them or not!

GuessItsANameChange · 14/11/2023 17:53

And incidentally, I was not posing a hypothetical scenario- I was addressing yours and where blame would lay in those circumstances, with reference to how it would likely be treated under the law.

GuessItsANameChange · 14/11/2023 17:36

As for your hypothetical scenario about the cleaner making a personal injury claim (after being attacked) and the dog being put down - all that could totally be avoided if the OP just trained her dog.
It was totally avoided in actuality too. The cleaner wasn’t bitten. Happy to clear that up for you.

Jumpingthruhoops · 14/11/2023 17:29

GuessItsANameChange · 14/11/2023 17:11

No, people are not ‘literally’ saying that. Most people are commenting on the event that actually happened (the cleaner getting barked at), not a hypothetical situation in which the cleaner was seriously maimed (by a dog that doesn’t have any bite history).

If events had been different, the responses would be different.

That said, yes, in your scenario the cleaner would be partially at fault and, though I have little doubt she would rightfully be successful in a personal injury claim (and the dog destroyed), there would likely be a finding of some contributory negligence on her part.

But, that's the point, life is full of 'what ifs' and 'hypotheticals'. It's the entire reason why the landlord has had to let OP go: because of what could happen in future.

As for your hypothetical scenario about the cleaner making a personal injury claim (after being attacked) and the dog being put down - all that could totally be avoided if the OP just trained her dog. THAT is the issue here!

GuessItsANameChange · 14/11/2023 17:13

Smilencuddlesthenstab · 14/11/2023 17:08

YANBU
Owners ownership. You told him and he should have told the cleaner and there would be no issue.

All dogs bark. Bit unfair to call it an ‘untrained’ dog. It has had training and OP is working on it.

Comments are quite harsh OP. You did your due diligence

The cleaner was aware too, not just the owner - and had duly texted in advance on multiple prior occasions.

GuessItsANameChange · 14/11/2023 17:11

Jumpingthruhoops · 14/11/2023 15:51

What rubbish! Attackers 'don't operate within human moral boundaries' either. That's what makes them attackers!

Meanwhile, dogs ARE trained to operate within certain boundaries. And that's the point: OP's dog is NOT trained!

But people on here are literally saying that if the cleaner had been seriously injured, it would have been her fault for entering the space of a potential threat unannounced.

I give up!

No, people are not ‘literally’ saying that. Most people are commenting on the event that actually happened (the cleaner getting barked at), not a hypothetical situation in which the cleaner was seriously maimed (by a dog that doesn’t have any bite history).

If events had been different, the responses would be different.

That said, yes, in your scenario the cleaner would be partially at fault and, though I have little doubt she would rightfully be successful in a personal injury claim (and the dog destroyed), there would likely be a finding of some contributory negligence on her part.

Smilencuddlesthenstab · 14/11/2023 17:08

DoktorPeppa · 12/11/2023 19:29

Yes but they weren't aware that their cleaner wouldn't be happy with it

YANBU
Owners ownership. You told him and he should have told the cleaner and there would be no issue.

All dogs bark. Bit unfair to call it an ‘untrained’ dog. It has had training and OP is working on it.

Comments are quite harsh OP. You did your due diligence

Clarich007 · 14/11/2023 17:06

I'm with the owner here, sorry The words you use such as safety issues, nightmare and impenetrable, are scary to say the least.Why do you need to live with such rules and regulations.

amicissimma · 14/11/2023 16:56

While we can (and probably will) argue till the cows come home about the ins and outs of the cleaner entering without the guest's permission, the fact remains that, according to the OP, she has a poorly-trained dog on the premises which may bite.

The owner has decided that after all, he does not wish to have that dog in the property and has asked the OP to leave.

It's worth bearing in mind that, in certain circumstances, a trespasser or even burglar, may have a case against the owner of a dog who attacks them. It's not a given as it used to be, but it could lead to a court case. Even on private property an owner has a responsibility to other people who may be on the premises.

melj1213 · 14/11/2023 16:16

Maverickess · 14/11/2023 11:54

"Hey boss I need to go to X property shed to collect the mop bucket, about an hour"

"Sure I'll let them know"

Usual protocol is the dog is out the way when cleaner expected. Cleaner believes she is expected therefore dog is out of the way. Airbnb host doesn't contact OP. OP not expecting cleaner. Cleaner goes into garden as thinks she's expected as with cleaning days.

Again, I don't think OP is unreasonable in this situation, clearly miscommunication between the cleaner and Airbnb owner, my issue is that it's automatically the cleaners fault and it's fine to slag them off and call them names based on the assumptions made.

But that's not how it works as per the AurBnB contract - unless they have explicit permission from the guest they are not allowed to enter the property unless it's an emergency.

"Hey boss I need to go to X property shed to collect the mop bucket, about an hour"

"Ok, let me message the guest and check they're OK with that and I'll let you know, if/when you can enter." ... "Ceaner, I have spoken to the guest and you are OK to enter/Can only enter after 3pm/it's not convenient today so do not enter the property"

It's not a case of "Host can enter any time as long as they tell you in advance" it's a case of "If the host needs to enter during a guests reservation they must ask and receive permission." If they don't receive permission then they cannot enter the property at all.

Afteropening · 14/11/2023 16:06

Pilloh · 12/11/2023 19:43

We did not only ask owner to inform us when the weekly clean was. We were EXPLICIT in describing how our dog reacts to strangers. And that we needed the assurance of not having strangers access the property at any time. Owner said sure, not a problem at all.

and then the reality of her cleaner, possibly someone that she has employed for many years and is close to, a trusted employer, rings her distraught and scared.

She is obviously going to support her cleaner and respond accordingly. She recognises it is not “fair” though by returning pro rats what you’ve paid

Jumpingthruhoops · 14/11/2023 15:51

MarkWithaC · 14/11/2023 15:33

This isn't a meaningful comparison. Dogs don't operate within human moral boundaries and can't/shouldn't be expected to behave in certain ways like we are, having our human framework of the rule of law etc.

The cleaner had already been in more than once, without incident, having given notice. Suddenly moving the goalposts by turning up unannounced was foolish.

What rubbish! Attackers 'don't operate within human moral boundaries' either. That's what makes them attackers!

Meanwhile, dogs ARE trained to operate within certain boundaries. And that's the point: OP's dog is NOT trained!

But people on here are literally saying that if the cleaner had been seriously injured, it would have been her fault for entering the space of a potential threat unannounced.

I give up!

MarkWithaC · 14/11/2023 15:33

Jumpingthruhoops · 14/11/2023 15:26

Nuts? Really?

So, if the dog's 'bark' turned into a horrifying attack - which could quite easily happen - it would be the 'stupid cleaner's' fault for going in unannounced?

This is akin to saying a woman deserves to be attacked on a night out because she walked down a dark alley. Nooooo... she was attacked because there was an attacker on the loose!

Honestly, one of us is nuts and it certainly ain't me...

This isn't a meaningful comparison. Dogs don't operate within human moral boundaries and can't/shouldn't be expected to behave in certain ways like we are, having our human framework of the rule of law etc.

The cleaner had already been in more than once, without incident, having given notice. Suddenly moving the goalposts by turning up unannounced was foolish.

Jumpingthruhoops · 14/11/2023 15:26

GuessItsANameChange · 14/11/2023 03:49

This is fucking nuts 😂

The cleaner was not allowed to enter without notice.

She was told that, if she entered without notice, there’s a high likelihood that a dog would bark at her.

She entered without notice and a dog barked at her.

And a dog barking does not, and should not, void a contract.

The cleaner was being really very stupid.

Nuts? Really?

So, if the dog's 'bark' turned into a horrifying attack - which could quite easily happen - it would be the 'stupid cleaner's' fault for going in unannounced?

This is akin to saying a woman deserves to be attacked on a night out because she walked down a dark alley. Nooooo... she was attacked because there was an attacker on the loose!

Honestly, one of us is nuts and it certainly ain't me...

Jumpingthruhoops · 14/11/2023 15:17

Mcal · 14/11/2023 03:07

That's quite a strange theory.
It is just like saying that somebody threatening to punch you in the face is not dangerous, they are just threatening you.
Dogs bark for reasons. Given the context provided, barking was meant as a warning and a way to incute fear, to be followed by an attack if the intruder did not back off.
Guard and attack dogs do not limit themselves to barking, dog breeders make sure of that, owners pay good money for that. That's similar logic, not a matter of opinions.

With all the recent and factual news about people being attacked, the landlord would be a fool to keep the guests and the dog. If anything happens he might well be sued for negligence, having agreed to the whole thing and done nothing after the incident described. OP clearly described not being in control of the dog, in that context, and the cleaner must have noticed.

Really not worth losing a cleaner and running a legal risk.
OP is better off staying with family or leaving the guard dog with someone trusted. If not a kennel, maybe with the vet or the trainer for a fee? After all they are very happy with the dog and, in the case of the trainer, perhaps more able right now to control it?

Regarding the cleaner entering with no permission, of course it is not right. But that does not excuse the threat. If you have a certain kind of dog, behaving in a certain kind of way, it might be a lovely companion in certain situations, but it still a loaded gun.
Sometimes I think that if the law was less lenient with the owners of dangerous dogs which happen to kill or maim, it would be better for everybody.
People would know that there is a risk to end up in jail or financially ruined for indirect responsibility, and they would simply act and plan more sensibly.

Exactly this! Brilliant post 👏👏

sandyhappypeople · 14/11/2023 14:55

TheWorldisGoingMad · 14/11/2023 13:28

How long have you booked and paid for?

Do you have your communication in writing about the dog? You communicated the situation with the dog perfectly, before you made the booking.

Does the cleaner come at the same time each day/week? If so, you can tell the ABB owner the dog will be tethered at the time of future visits, it won't happen again. However, the cleaner failed to follow instructions. If they were apprehensive about the dog they should have followed them. The dog did not bite, the dog gave a verbal warning. As you were aware of the cleaner being around, it would have been prudent to immediately leash the dog and put it somewhere so the cleaner felt safe.

As you were aware of the cleaner being around, it would have been prudent to immediately leash the dog and put it somewhere so the cleaner felt safe.

OP wasn’t aware.. not sure how many times people can say this... the cleaner turned up UNANNOUNCED and let themselves into the back garden (where OP and dog just happened to be) to get something out of the shed.. it wasn’t a cleaning visit.. it wasn’t scheduled and it wasn’t pre-warned (as the contract stated)

the cleaner could have called/text, she could have knocked on the door first, she could have called over the garden gate, she put herself in a position to come face to face with the dog. There was no way OP could have pre-empted her just turning up in the garden like that.

telling the OP to leash her dog is a little condescending seeing as she’s been taking the dog out all together when she knows the cleaner is coming, and only brings it back when the cleaner has gone.

Hippobot · 14/11/2023 14:44

MrsSlocombesCat · 14/11/2023 12:53

Did you read the post properly? She was saying that an autistic person would be scared of the dog! Not that they would hurt anyone 🤦🏼‍♀️

I did but you clearly didn't. She was most definitely NOT saying an autistic person would be scared of the dog. She was saying that people with autism can react/become anxious when someone comes unexpectedly into their space like the dog reacted to the cleaner appearing in the garden - she was comparing the dog's reaction to that of a human with autism. I took objection to that comparison. Dogs are animals that take their lead from their human owners on how to behave and can therefore be trained not to be aggressive towards strangers that enter their garden. This has absolutely nothing to do with people who have a disability.

Swipe left for the next trending thread