Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Air bnb owner ott or do we deserve to be chucked out?

711 replies

Pilloh · 12/11/2023 19:25

We were forced out of our house due to a water leak in the house. The insurance company said we had to move out due to the severity of the work.

A bit of a nightmare for us as we have a large dog. He’s been called a wonderfully mannered dog by a qualified behaviourist outside the house who really doesn’t care about people/other dogs. But he is a breed used for guarding and therefore very barky at home (we have a command that gets him to be quiet but it doesn’t stop the impulse to bark initially). Not to make excuses, we were working on this with the behaviourist pre-pandemic but our progress stalled so we just manage the situation. Ie we have gates all around our house/garden, don’t allow strangers and the dog to meet inside the house (he’s totally fine with people when they are not on “his” property). Our house is basically Fort Knox and only DH and I are here so it’s all pretty easy to manage.

We told the air bnb owner that please tell the cleaner not to enter house or garden without telling us as dog will run up and bark at strangers. He agreed. We explained the situation and he said he understood.

Yesterday pm, cleaner comes into the garden when I was playing footy - she was fetching something from shed. Dog ran towards her and barked. I gave the recall command which worked initially but then my dog ran back to cleaner and barked. It’s no doubt intimidating. After 20 ish secs dog was in the house and I apologised. Recall is not full proof hence why we never rely on it. We would never have found an Airbnb where we were not assured we would be informed of any person entering the property.

Owner has messaged now saying the cleaner won’t return whilst we are here and that means we have to leave as the owner is not ok with the house not being maintenanced.

Cleaner has visited 4 times without incident as the right procedures were followed.

Who is being unreasonable?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Hippobot · 12/11/2023 23:07

Caerulea · 12/11/2023 22:57

It's not a wolf, it's a dog. It's not a pack, it's a family with humans in that the dog isn't in competition with for food or mating purposes.

Unless you're a dog & maybe this applies to you?

Just because dogs live in homes doesn't make them people. They are pack animals and they will adopt a hierarchy whether you think so or not. Wolves and dogs are both Canidae.

GuessItsANameChange · 12/11/2023 23:06

Hippobot · 12/11/2023 22:55

Alpha is the top dog in a pack, that's not a disputed term. How do you suggest one refers to the alpha pair in a wolf pack for example?

The whole alpha-dominance method of dog training has fallen entirely out of favour, the rationale behind it having been largely debunked.

The idea of an alpha wolf is, in itself, a myth:

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/is-the-alpha-wolf-idea-a-myth/?amp=true

Hippobot · 12/11/2023 23:02

maratara · 12/11/2023 22:57

I have 3 large dogs. They bark at everyone who comes to the door. I think most dogs do?
A dog that was silent when a stranger was at the door ( or in the garden!) would be very unusual indeed. Once the door is opened they can see through the screen door and either carrying on barking in excitement at seeing someone they recognise or get a bit defensive if they don't know the person. A soft growl, slight hackles. I then say "thanks " to the postie or whoever who walks away. If it is a new person that I have invited over , they stop barking the minute they cross the threshold into our house. They then expect pats and general loving😁 I thought that was pretty standard. Total amount of barking is about 3 minutes.
I don;t consider them reactive at all. All good when out and about, cafes, walks etc. We have had 100 people at a party and the dogs just wandered around saying hello.
When they bark they are just protecting their home and their family. It's what dogs do.

Sounds horrible and scary. Glad I'm not your postie.

GuessItsANameChange · 12/11/2023 23:00

I have a dog phobia and usually find myself on the ‘anti-dog’ side of arguments.

That said, I don’t think the OP is being unreasonable.

They we’re upfront about their dog’s barking issue at the time of booking, and explained that they’d need a small amount of advance notice when the cleaner attended. The owner accepted this and took the OP’s money on that clear understanding.

When advance notice of the cleaner’s attendance has been given, there has been no issue. Giving some degree of notice is not much of a hardship.

If the OP was staying somewhere rent-free then it would be more arguable but money was accepted on the basis of a small accommodation being made for the dog, it’s unreasonable for the owner to do a 180 in the circumstances.

maratara · 12/11/2023 22:59

Oh forgot. OP you YANBU as the cleaner shoudn''t have let themselves into the garden without letting you know , dog or no dog. That's just plain rude. I doubt they would like it if you let yourself into their backyard.

Caroparo52 · 12/11/2023 22:59

Have you left yet?
Not sure why you are even posting....
Situation quite clear.
Good cleaners hard to get.
Troublesome guests 10 a penny.
It's game over but ask for refund of unused time.

StarlightLime · 12/11/2023 22:58

maratara · 12/11/2023 22:57

I have 3 large dogs. They bark at everyone who comes to the door. I think most dogs do?
A dog that was silent when a stranger was at the door ( or in the garden!) would be very unusual indeed. Once the door is opened they can see through the screen door and either carrying on barking in excitement at seeing someone they recognise or get a bit defensive if they don't know the person. A soft growl, slight hackles. I then say "thanks " to the postie or whoever who walks away. If it is a new person that I have invited over , they stop barking the minute they cross the threshold into our house. They then expect pats and general loving😁 I thought that was pretty standard. Total amount of barking is about 3 minutes.
I don;t consider them reactive at all. All good when out and about, cafes, walks etc. We have had 100 people at a party and the dogs just wandered around saying hello.
When they bark they are just protecting their home and their family. It's what dogs do.

No, none of mine do this.

Dinglewoop · 12/11/2023 22:58

DragonFly98 · 12/11/2023 22:53

You need to get your dog PTS by your own admission he is intimidating and will bite. You didn't train him and this is the consequence. This was the wake up call you needed.

Ridiculous. Dog barked at a stranger coming unannounced on to the property when they shouldn't of been, as I imagine many dogs would. OP literally said on the thread dog has never bitten anyone. PTS - what a stupid thing to say.

maratara · 12/11/2023 22:57

I have 3 large dogs. They bark at everyone who comes to the door. I think most dogs do?
A dog that was silent when a stranger was at the door ( or in the garden!) would be very unusual indeed. Once the door is opened they can see through the screen door and either carrying on barking in excitement at seeing someone they recognise or get a bit defensive if they don't know the person. A soft growl, slight hackles. I then say "thanks " to the postie or whoever who walks away. If it is a new person that I have invited over , they stop barking the minute they cross the threshold into our house. They then expect pats and general loving😁 I thought that was pretty standard. Total amount of barking is about 3 minutes.
I don;t consider them reactive at all. All good when out and about, cafes, walks etc. We have had 100 people at a party and the dogs just wandered around saying hello.
When they bark they are just protecting their home and their family. It's what dogs do.

Pinkpinkpink15 · 12/11/2023 22:57

DragonFly98 · 12/11/2023 22:53

You need to get your dog PTS by your own admission he is intimidating and will bite. You didn't train him and this is the consequence. This was the wake up call you needed.

@DragonFly98

the dog doesn't need to be PTS FFS.

its fine outside of its own territory, they'll soon be back home after this flooding drama, where it's set up for their dog.

you don't kill an animal because of a temporary issue which would be easily solved by the Air BnB using a brain cell.

Caerulea · 12/11/2023 22:57

Hippobot · 12/11/2023 22:55

Alpha is the top dog in a pack, that's not a disputed term. How do you suggest one refers to the alpha pair in a wolf pack for example?

It's not a wolf, it's a dog. It's not a pack, it's a family with humans in that the dog isn't in competition with for food or mating purposes.

Unless you're a dog & maybe this applies to you?

Caerulea · 12/11/2023 22:55

mydogisthebest · 12/11/2023 22:53

No, it means the majority of posters are either dog haters and/or idiots just like the Airbnb owner and the cleaner

I nearly typed out this exact message, word for word 😂

Hippobot · 12/11/2023 22:55

Caerulea · 12/11/2023 22:50

'alpha'? That right there shows you've no clue about modern dog training & advancements in understanding their behaviour. Alpha indeed.

And sure... Everything you see on TV with dog trainers is exactly what happens behind the scenes...

Alpha is the top dog in a pack, that's not a disputed term. How do you suggest one refers to the alpha pair in a wolf pack for example?

StarlightLime · 12/11/2023 22:54

mydogisthebest · 12/11/2023 22:53

No, it means the majority of posters are either dog haters and/or idiots just like the Airbnb owner and the cleaner

Oh Jesus... It really doesn't.

Pinkpinkpink15 · 12/11/2023 22:54

Judydoes2 · 12/11/2023 20:29

Warburton's.

I thought more hovis 50:50

DragonFly98 · 12/11/2023 22:53

You need to get your dog PTS by your own admission he is intimidating and will bite. You didn't train him and this is the consequence. This was the wake up call you needed.

mydogisthebest · 12/11/2023 22:53

Dacadactyl · 12/11/2023 22:31

On a thread where someone is asking "is the airbnb owner being unreasonable" and the majority of posters say "no", it means that the majority of posters agree with the airbnb owner.

Therefore, his actions are not unreasonable.

No, it means the majority of posters are either dog haters and/or idiots just like the Airbnb owner and the cleaner

MuddlingMackem · 12/11/2023 22:51

I don't like dogs, avoid houses with dogs and am pretty scathing about owners who can't control their dogs in public places, but even I think that YADNBU.

I don't understand why the owner is notifying you of the cleaner's arrival, surely she should have your mobile number to drop you a quick text when she's on her way on cleaning days, and should have been able to drop a quick text to ask if it would be convenient to call round to collect something from the shed on a non-cleaning day.

In my opinion, the owner and cleaner are definitely in the wrong here, but like PPs have said I can understand that for the longer-term it's the cleaner the owner will need to keep on-side, so you will need to cut your losses and move out.

Caerulea · 12/11/2023 22:50

Hippobot · 12/11/2023 22:43

The answer to that is that I expect the dog to be trained appropriately not to bark at strangers. It's not a hard thing to train and is perfectly reasonable. The owner should be in charge of the dog and the dog take their lead from the owner. A dog that thinks it's the gatekeeper of the owner's house is a dog that doesn't know it's not the alpha in the pecking order. That's dangerous. Outwith working dogs that are used to guard, a dog should not display that level of autonomy. These are pack animals and should not be the leader of the pack when living with humans. The dog should look to the human to decide who comes into the property. Watch an episode of It's Me or the Dog with Victoria Stilwell and you will see exactly how to train a dog to not bark or be aggressive when people come to the door. People shouldn't be threatened by intimidating barking or lunging from large dogs when they pose no threat to the dog owners or the household.

'alpha'? That right there shows you've no clue about modern dog training & advancements in understanding their behaviour. Alpha indeed.

And sure... Everything you see on TV with dog trainers is exactly what happens behind the scenes...

mydogisthebest · 12/11/2023 22:49

Viviennemary · 12/11/2023 22:00

Your dog is a total menace and needs to learn how to behave. Honestly, some folk. The poor cleaner.

The cleaner is an idiot and needs to get a brain and follow instructions. You don't just waltz into a house where someone is living unannounced. They are entitled to privacy even in an Airbnb.

The dog is protecting its owners and its property. That is what a lot of dogs do. My neighbour has a dog and I know if I walked into their garden it would bite me. It's only a small breed but it is protecting its owners and property

Caerulea · 12/11/2023 22:48

Pilloh · 12/11/2023 22:40

I mentioned the pandemic as we were doing really well with having unknown people into our home before. We have since lost steam for various reasons. A bit weak but still relevant imo.

You're literally not going to get anything other than sneering on here now. Some of the comments are just so bloody ignorant from ppl who don't like dogs or only like the kind of dogs who behave like they are on Crufts (🤢) but claim they love all dogs (they don't).

Fwiw the pandemic was a huge issue for anyone with a reactive dog & I can totally see how the combination of things meant the training dropped off & you got comfy with how to manage him in your home & that's actually ok.

I'd legit not come back to this thread if I were you, for your own wellbeing

Dinglewoop · 12/11/2023 22:44

Hippobot · 12/11/2023 22:31

@Dinglewoop

My post that you are quoting was in reply to you writing this:

"To all the people saying it's fine that the Airbnb owner has changed their mind - I'd love to see how you would react if you got kicked out of your Airbnb mid holiday"

You started the human comparison and I replied to illustrate how ridiculous it is to compare human behaviour to that of dogs.
You are determined to be facetious and I'm bored of you quoting me and writing ridiculous and irrelevant things that have nothing to do with the OP's situation.

Edited

I have no idea how you think my original post was comparing dogs to people.

My point was to all the people saying it's fine for the Airbnb owner to just change his mind about them staying for whatever reason and ask them to leave with no grounds (i.e no rules broken) and that it's just tough luck - how would they feel if this happened to them.

Hippobot · 12/11/2023 22:43

melj1213 · 12/11/2023 22:25

That doesn't answer the question of what people expect a dog to do when an unexpected stranger appears in their home.

The OP knows the the dog is reactive in their home and has made every precaution to safeguard the dog and anyone else by ensuring they get some prior warning of visitors. I doubt the OP has notes at their actual home but when you're in a temporary space where you have no idea who will try and enter (landlord, cleaner, gardener etc) it is courteous to prewarn them that there is a dog on the property and to let the owner know of your presence so they can secure the dog.

The cleaner decided to ignore the set protocol - let the OP know ahead of time that they are coming - and common courtesy - knocking and not just letting yourself in to someone else's space and was surprised to be confronted by a barking dog. This is 100% a situation caused by the cleaner

The answer to that is that I expect the dog to be trained appropriately not to bark at strangers. It's not a hard thing to train and is perfectly reasonable. The owner should be in charge of the dog and the dog take their lead from the owner. A dog that thinks it's the gatekeeper of the owner's house is a dog that doesn't know it's not the alpha in the pecking order. That's dangerous. Outwith working dogs that are used to guard, a dog should not display that level of autonomy. These are pack animals and should not be the leader of the pack when living with humans. The dog should look to the human to decide who comes into the property. Watch an episode of It's Me or the Dog with Victoria Stilwell and you will see exactly how to train a dog to not bark or be aggressive when people come to the door. People shouldn't be threatened by intimidating barking or lunging from large dogs when they pose no threat to the dog owners or the household.

StarlightLime · 12/11/2023 22:43

Pilloh · 12/11/2023 22:40

I mentioned the pandemic as we were doing really well with having unknown people into our home before. We have since lost steam for various reasons. A bit weak but still relevant imo.

Not that relevant three years later, no.

Pilloh · 12/11/2023 22:40

I mentioned the pandemic as we were doing really well with having unknown people into our home before. We have since lost steam for various reasons. A bit weak but still relevant imo.

OP posts: