Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to tell DSS what’s for dinner?

141 replies

Haveyouanyjam · 12/11/2023 18:43

So my DSS (nearly 9) is something of a fussy eater. He’s gotten a lot better since he’s lived with us (two and a bit years).

I don’t feed him any foods he doesn’t eat, and over time he’s tried a lot more food and won’t baulk at having things such as mushroom in his food (he won’t eat them but will still eat the rest, before he wouldn’t have touched the whole meal if he saw something in it he doesn’t like).

Every day he asks me what’s for dinner at the earliest opportunity (on the weekend he will regularly ask before lunch). Half the time it’s before I’ve even considered what’s for dinner.

If I tell him and it’s something he doesn’t fancy (though as I said it will still be a meal he’s fine to eat) then he sulks and moans. If it’s something he wants, then he will go on and on asking when dinner is going to be ready.

I carry the mental load and thinking of what for dinner is a key frustration I have, especially where I do my best to take into account what he will and won’t eat (our two year old DD isn’t fussy at all and will eat basically everything).

I am being unreasonable to tell him he will find out what’s for dinner when it’s served and not before?

I have tried explaining why it’s frustrating when he asks, or if he reacts badly that it can make me feel not great as I go through a lot of effort to try and make healthy but tasty meals that he will actually eat without it being too repetitive, but that has had zero effect. In an ideal world it wouldn’t bother me him asking, but it does (for the reasons above) and I don’t want to get snappy with him for it!

Seems really minor but as it comes up every day! I will also say this doesn’t seem to come from a place of anxiety as he knows he doesn’t have to eat anything he really doesn’t like etc.

OP posts:
MelLT · 13/11/2023 22:45

Sounds like you've done a great job in supporting him to expand his meal choices already. Maybe you could involve him in planning the weeks meals? Share the choices across the week so he is empowered to make his own choices but also including him to make a choice for the rest of the family and come to some compromises.

maddiemookins16mum · 13/11/2023 12:48

Compromise. He can ask, but only after a certain time. He’s clearly anxious about it, I really wouldn’t let this become a divisive issue between you.

JudyP · 13/11/2023 00:05

We used to have 2 fussy eaters ( 1 is totally fine and the other just doesn't like fish now - just to give you hope!) but we meal plan together- I have a list of acceptable meals on the fridge ( aporox 30 options) and they choose from there or make suggestions ( pizza/fast food is not in there as it's for emergency no time to cook nights) and then there's a list on the fridge of 7 meals for the week and they know what is coming ( I often remind the fish hater that we are going with his choices on other nights and we all as a family get to choose so he cannot complain! )

Xmasbaby11 · 13/11/2023 00:03

Definitely a meal plan. Maybe we are just used to it but everyone in our house likes to know the menu. We have a weekly plan on the fridge and it does change sometimes but it helps a lot to know what we’re having, especially fussy 9yo dd. Even if you have to say it’s x or y, so much better than no hint at all.

howdoesyourgardengrowinmay · 13/11/2023 00:00

Can you establish the meals he likes and will eat without a fuss, then batch cook and freeze in single portions for him and whoever else wants that meal

steppemum · 12/11/2023 23:31

just a tip for meal planning.
I have 2 master lists.
One is every meal that I cook. I go down the list and see what I haven't done for a while and what fits with this week. That list saves so much head space of what shall we eat.
I also use my freezer a lot, meat and bread go in there, so if we do have to swap of change meals, they aren't wasted.
My second list is a master shopping list of everything we buy, from wahsing powder to frozen peas. When I do my online shop I go down the list, and it is a great way to remember to keep store cupboard basics topped up.

With those 2 things it makes meal planning much easier. The key is be realistic. Only put down meals that you will actually cook at 6 pm when you have had a busy day.

steppemum · 12/11/2023 23:26

my friends son always asks what is for dinner when he is anxious. When things are a bit unpredictable, one of his coping mechanisms is to ask what is for dinner (and lunch and breakfast!)
My friend says that for him knowing the meals is like giving the day shape, like having hooks that he can hang the rest of the day around.

My own kids often look at the meal list on the fridge door, and they like to know what dinner is, I get moans when I swap something round so that it isn't what they are expecting.

I think for children where so much of life is out of their control, taking one unknown out of the equation makes them feel more secure in what the world is doing around them.
You dss obviously feels more secure with routine and predictability. He feels safe with structure. Giving him a little more of that will help him and then ultimately you.

Codlingmoths · 12/11/2023 23:12

You sound amazing op 😊

Teenagehorrorbag · 12/11/2023 23:04

OP it sounds as though you are doing a great job all round!

DS has ASD and ADHD and I have been part of a parent support group for 10 years or so. DS was really fussy when younger (although he would eat things like fish and seafood, all veg, all meat etc, but not weird shaped sausages or lumpy yogurts or fruit.....Very strange)! But many of the other parents had much trickier children - and the general rule was - if they will only eat beige food (nuggets/pizza and chips) then let them. They won't die and always improve over time. Life is too short to be stressed about it.

DS is now 15 and eats a far wider selection of foods than I do (although some fruits still have a texture he can't cope with).

But it sounds as though DSS is doing pretty well - probably due to your efforts, so well done. I agree with PPs that control sounds like the thing here, so a weekly meal plan would be really helpful. Tbh I wish I could do that too - meal planning is my worst nightmare and I HATE trying to think about what to feed people, day in, day out, it's soul destroying.......😫! Might be something I need to think about too.......

Cinateel · 12/11/2023 22:44

If I asked when I was a child, my dad would always say " 'am, jam and baa lamb'. I knew that meant there was no use asking. I didn't have any anxiety around food though.

converseandjeans · 12/11/2023 22:33

With a fussy eater, giving him a surprise is just going to make things worse.

i would go with the complete opposite approach, meal plan, and post a menu for the week.

Agree with this. Just do simple food you know he will eat. He might have ARFID. My son does & gets quite anxious about unknown foods. Get him to plan with you?

Haveyouanyjam · 12/11/2023 22:28

To those commenting that my two year old may become fussy…don’t worry I’m aware that there are no guarantees on that end! I just mean that at the minute a lot of work goes into taking into account DSS’ needs specifically. It’s also bound to happen that she will go through choosy phases but I feel prepared for that. It’s hard coming in to parenting a child at an older age where so much has been done that you wouldn’t have done. You can do everything ‘right’ and still end up with a fussy eater.

OP posts:
Snugglemonkey · 12/11/2023 22:16

ColleenDonaghy · 12/11/2023 20:44

I came into kitchen halfway into him making himself Nutella on toast the other day to find he had stuck an unwashed finger in the jar and helped himself!!

I know that's gross, but I also suspect many 9yos have done it!

This is why I just let the jar be for dc7 only.

Nn9011 · 12/11/2023 22:14

It sounds like he has a lot going on bless him. If he has ADHD there could also be sensory reasons why he refuses to eat certain food. I have ADHD and am in my 30s and I still can't bring myself to eat certain foods.
Could there be a way you compromise - maybe come up with a visual wall chart and meal plan for the week. That way he knows what to expect and won't need to question it and he also can be prepared for what's coming. You could also use this as a way to bring in other foods and textures - e.g. you're making a curry whilst he has plain chicken and rice. He knows that's what he's having so when you put a little bowl of sauce beside him which he can choose to try or not. This will help as he's not already in a tizz and can gradually get used to textures and taste. He may never like them but it will help to build his food bank without causing more stress.
With ADHD or even trauma related difficulties it's so important not to dismiss as bad behavior but also obviously as you're doing continue to parent. Visual cues and clear boundaries with one step and a time will be your best friend when navigating issues like this.

Snugglemonkey · 12/11/2023 22:13

Gettingbysomehow · 12/11/2023 19:53

I'd just tell him it's a surprise and repeat until he gets bored of asking.

Why on earth would you want to rachet up the anxiety?

Snugglemonkey · 12/11/2023 22:10

neilyoungismyhero · 12/11/2023 19:09

I always gave my children a choice every night..take it or leave it...they pretty much always took it.

I take it your children had no issues with neurodivesity? My autistic would rather starve than eat a food he struggles with.

Peachyscream · 12/11/2023 22:06

A meal plan with 2 options for dinner. Easy/fast meal and a more time consuming one. So it’ll be one or the other. Just make sure the easy one uses staple ingredients, frozen veg etc.
my sons autistic, it’s what I do for him

ExplodingSmittens · 12/11/2023 22:00

Could he have ARFID? DC with ARFID often ask this question early in the day and can have a lot of anxiety around food.

We get around it by having "safe" foods in the freezer, so if they are overwhelmed by what's for Dinner, they know that they can cook one if their safe foods.

If it is ARFID, he's not being fussy or difficult, he's incredibly anxious Flowers

NoCheaperTransactions · 12/11/2023 21:56

WYorkshireRose · 12/11/2023 21:40

I carry the mental load and thinking of what for dinner is a key frustration I have, especially where I do my best to take into account what he will and won’t eat (our two year old DD isn’t fussy at all and will eat basically everything).

Don't count your chickens. DS also ate everything at 2 and became increasingly fussy over the following few years.

It can be very difficult for children to have zero say in decisions which after their day to day lives. How would you feel if you had all of your food decisions made by someone else, and had to eat whatever was on offer, whether you fancied it or not? Personally, I'd try letting him choose his own meals at least a couple of days a week. Or introduce some kind of rota where everyone gets their chosen meal X number of nights per week.

That is a good idea. I will try that also. I do tend to just choose all the meals.

You are so right though about it hard to be a kid and having very little say about your life. I remember hating that when I was growing up. My school, my food, my bedroom decor, how i spent my evenings and weekends were all down to what my parents decided.

UsingChangeofName · 12/11/2023 21:50

He's anxious about food and you are not helping by making him wait to find out what he's eating. It won't help anything.

I have to agree with this.

Once you have done your shop for the week, can you not then write up what you've got - a whiteboard, blackboard, piece of paper stuck on the fridge ?
Not as restrictive as meal planning before you shop, or having the same things all the time, but a fairly easy way to ease his anxiety.

WYorkshireRose · 12/11/2023 21:40

I carry the mental load and thinking of what for dinner is a key frustration I have, especially where I do my best to take into account what he will and won’t eat (our two year old DD isn’t fussy at all and will eat basically everything).

Don't count your chickens. DS also ate everything at 2 and became increasingly fussy over the following few years.

It can be very difficult for children to have zero say in decisions which after their day to day lives. How would you feel if you had all of your food decisions made by someone else, and had to eat whatever was on offer, whether you fancied it or not? Personally, I'd try letting him choose his own meals at least a couple of days a week. Or introduce some kind of rota where everyone gets their chosen meal X number of nights per week.

Sickoffamilydrama · 12/11/2023 21:40

Don't rule out ADHD because the combination of symptoms he presents with aren't big or disruptive my DD presents as quite and easygoing inside she's in absolute turmoil.

All my children have either ADHD or Autism (genetics really are a bugger). My eldest has lots of food aversions and it was only when she got to 13/14 I started to realise she might have ADHD low and behold she does and she hid a lot of the anxiety it was causing her for years.

NoCheaperTransactions · 12/11/2023 21:37

I also agree the OP sounds like a terrific SM.

One of my children has autism and related sensory issues around food. Meal planning and putting it on a whiteboard really helped with his anxiety around food.

I love meal planning. I do it on a Sunday night with a cup of tea and then that takes care of the mental load for the week.

Graceymac99 · 12/11/2023 21:30

OP you sound like a really lovely step mum. I agree with the meal planning option. One of my DD’s was very picky with food and only liked a small range of meals so we would batch cook her favourites and freeze them. Much easier to cater for everyone that way.

theduchessofspork · 12/11/2023 21:24

Doggymummar · 12/11/2023 18:45

Can you get him to tell you what he wants, then make that? Easier in the long run

Well not really, because presumably the rest of the family don’t want to eat what he would choose the whole time

I’d just tell him you don’t know yet OP, rather than turn it into a battle of wills