Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To refuse to tell DSS what’s for dinner?

141 replies

Haveyouanyjam · 12/11/2023 18:43

So my DSS (nearly 9) is something of a fussy eater. He’s gotten a lot better since he’s lived with us (two and a bit years).

I don’t feed him any foods he doesn’t eat, and over time he’s tried a lot more food and won’t baulk at having things such as mushroom in his food (he won’t eat them but will still eat the rest, before he wouldn’t have touched the whole meal if he saw something in it he doesn’t like).

Every day he asks me what’s for dinner at the earliest opportunity (on the weekend he will regularly ask before lunch). Half the time it’s before I’ve even considered what’s for dinner.

If I tell him and it’s something he doesn’t fancy (though as I said it will still be a meal he’s fine to eat) then he sulks and moans. If it’s something he wants, then he will go on and on asking when dinner is going to be ready.

I carry the mental load and thinking of what for dinner is a key frustration I have, especially where I do my best to take into account what he will and won’t eat (our two year old DD isn’t fussy at all and will eat basically everything).

I am being unreasonable to tell him he will find out what’s for dinner when it’s served and not before?

I have tried explaining why it’s frustrating when he asks, or if he reacts badly that it can make me feel not great as I go through a lot of effort to try and make healthy but tasty meals that he will actually eat without it being too repetitive, but that has had zero effect. In an ideal world it wouldn’t bother me him asking, but it does (for the reasons above) and I don’t want to get snappy with him for it!

Seems really minor but as it comes up every day! I will also say this doesn’t seem to come from a place of anxiety as he knows he doesn’t have to eat anything he really doesn’t like etc.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
converseandjeans · 18/11/2023 08:48

@Chipsahoyagain

His choice is eat it or starve. There isn't an offer of fruit or toast later, because that just makes the problem worse

That sounds good in theory but my son would definitely choose to starve than eat something that other people would consider harmless. Look into ARFID.

Northernladdette · 17/11/2023 15:17

“Spit on toast” 🤷‍♀️

steppemum · 14/11/2023 10:03

Chipsahoyagain · 14/11/2023 09:16

Why? Why should he have separate meals catered to him?

I too have a fussy, slow eater. There's some things he just won't eat and fair enough I have my own dislikes. But I wouldn't tolerate fussiness to the point you don't eat the entire meal. My ds would pick out the mushrooms but he's not allowed to say no to the entire meal. His choice is eat it or starve. There isn't an offer of fruit or toast later, because that just makes the problem worse. He eats perfectly fine at school so if he can manage that then he has no choice at home.

I am not a fussy eater, I pretty much eat all foods. But there are about 3 or 4 things which I really dislike.

I am trying to imagine what it must be like to be hungry and sit down to a plate of (my hates) broad beans, walnuts and peanut butter and that those are the only things I am allowed to eat. Even picking those things out of a dish would leave their flavour.

It must make meal times like a form of torture.

Each of my kids have things they dislike. If we are eating that, and they can't pick it out, then of course I will make sure there is something they can eat available.
Sometimes I do that by taking some of the sauce out before I add the mushroom for example, and they have separate sauce. Sometimes I make two saucepans with all the same stuff expect one ingredient (did this for years with spicy foods to make one portion without heat). Sometimes I will make some rice when the rest of us have couscous.
Often I will plan it so there is left overs from yesterday for dd when we eat something she doesn't like.

I don't cook 2 meals, but I do cook 1.5 meals sometimes, or cook extra on one day for leftovers the next. It isn't a massive amount, maybe one meal a week when I have to make accommodations. I do it so that my kids have something decent to eat when they come home tired and hungry.

I am baffled by the attitude which is - eat food you don't like or go hungry.

Chipsahoyagain · 14/11/2023 09:16

Doggymummar · 12/11/2023 18:45

Can you get him to tell you what he wants, then make that? Easier in the long run

Why? Why should he have separate meals catered to him?

I too have a fussy, slow eater. There's some things he just won't eat and fair enough I have my own dislikes. But I wouldn't tolerate fussiness to the point you don't eat the entire meal. My ds would pick out the mushrooms but he's not allowed to say no to the entire meal. His choice is eat it or starve. There isn't an offer of fruit or toast later, because that just makes the problem worse. He eats perfectly fine at school so if he can manage that then he has no choice at home.

steppemum · 14/11/2023 09:12

ILJ28 · 14/11/2023 02:16

@steppemum this sounds like such a great idea!! Don’t suppose you could PM me your lists for some recipe inspiration could you!?!?

it is quite a personal list as I have lived in several countries and so cook dishes from there. And it is scribbled all over!

I have several times printed off lists of recipes from mn threads of 'What is for dinner?' and tried tham out, then added a couple of favourites from there. They are good places to start.

I just started with my recipe folder. Everything I cook goes on the master list, even if it is frozen pizza. So the list is a list of meals. That makes it easy to look at and choose according to the day eg need a quick meal for Tuesday, whats on the list that's quick?

steppemum · 14/11/2023 09:09

Londontown12 · 14/11/2023 08:03

If I’m honest kids have to much choice they should eat what your cooking take choices away don’t increase them it’s too much for a child !

I think you are missing the point.

The child is anxious around food. So he is spending a lot of time worrying about what is for dinnner.
To plan the meals so that he can see what is coming and feel resssured that it is something he can eat will help his anxiety and in the long run also help him to expand his list of foods he can eat.

I am a bit 🤔at all the posters saying - OH my mum said it was Wait and See Pudding or whatever, just don't tell him, he can wait.
Have none of you come across neuro diverse kids or kids with anxiety? Taking the unknowns out of the day is extrememly helpful. It also acknowledges to the child that you understand his anxiety.

It doesn't mean that he gets pampered to. But it may well mean that you have to provide food that he feels comfortable eating.
try and imagine for a moment how stressful it is to be a kid and be worried that you won't be able to eat dinner. 🙁

TwoShades1 · 14/11/2023 09:04

Haveyouanyjam · 12/11/2023 18:50

Like the idea of a meal plan, and I do do that sometimes. I think the only issue there is work wise I am never totally sure when I’ll be done (work from home most days) so tend to do a shorter or longer meal depending. But I could swap some around and still do the ones for the week! Could definitely give it a go.

With this in mind maybe just write a list of meals for the week with no set days and cross them off as you cook them. At least then he knows it will be one of the listed ones, and if he keeps asking you can refer him back to the list.

user1492757084 · 14/11/2023 08:18

I rememeber my Dad and Mum answering our questions of What is for tea?
They always answered .. Air Pie.

Londontown12 · 14/11/2023 08:03

If I’m honest kids have to much choice they should eat what your cooking take choices away don’t increase them it’s too much for a child !

Londontown12 · 14/11/2023 08:01

Egg shapes !! This is what I used to say when my kids kept on and on asking !!
what are egg shapes ?? You will find out at dinner time 🤣🤣🤣
Everytime !!! He will soon get fed up asking !!

Clarabell77 · 14/11/2023 06:37

Sounds like the child has sensory issues with food. You can’t assume that it doesn’t come from a place of stress, the stress might not be about your reaction/whether he has to eat it or not. My son can’t even look at a plate with toast crumbs on it without gagging. I agree with pp, do a weekly meal plan. Get him to help you with it. That will save you the hassle of thinking about what to cook every day and it will stop him reacting to it.

Mumof2girls2121 · 14/11/2023 06:26

Try Putting a dinner menu up on the wall for the week.
my daughter was like this, it’s got better since I involved her in menu choices for the week and told her it’s not always going to be her favourite sometimes it’ll be another family members choice

sashh · 14/11/2023 05:18

My dad would say, "bread and catch it" ie whatever you can catch.

It sounds like he is anxious about his dinner.

Get HIM to do a meal plan. Or do it with him. That can go on the fridge and he can see what it is.

9 is a great time to learn cooking, start with something he likes to eat.

Once he can make something then he can cook with dad one day a week. Then he can learn something new. Pizza is fairly easy and a good place to start.

ILJ28 · 14/11/2023 02:16

@steppemum this sounds like such a great idea!! Don’t suppose you could PM me your lists for some recipe inspiration could you!?!?

Lastnightsbolognese · 14/11/2023 00:22

I don't know as its been mentioned as I've not time to rtft but when I was child and used to demand to know what we were having for dinner for this same reason, my mother used to screech, "Shit with hair on!" It might be worth a try.

You are being perfectly reasonable as you aren't giving things dc will freak out at andbwe do all have to try new things. My DC has ASC and its an absolute nightmare do I feel your pain. You should be getting his dad to cook more, then he'll see how hard it is.

MarvellousMonsters · 14/11/2023 00:14

Haveyouanyjam · 12/11/2023 19:04

His dad does cook but is very simple with meals so he knows he’s most likely getting oven food on dad’s nights. He has ADHD (my husband) and gets overwhelmed with lots of different elements of cooking. I also do actually like to cook I just hate having to decide all the time what to make.

Your DH has ADHD, and his son is showing signs of ASD/ADHD behaviours. This anxiety around food is classic. Fussy eating is not just about control, but is also about texture and dopamine. You mentioned he'd choose fish & chips or pizza every day given the chance, and gets 'entitled' about choices, these are anxiety behaviours, and safe foods that provide him with comfort and dopamine.

Try 'either/or' choices and meal plan. Get a white board or chalk board, and involve him. Discuss healthy eating and explain that pizza/fish and chips can't be a daily choice, but give him a sense of control and security by letting him help choose the menu for the week. Suggest he watch recipe videos, on tiktok or YouTube, for inspiration. Watching cooking/food programs on tv expanded my kids food choices, and now they send me links to tiktok recipes and ask if we can make them.

But don't leave him hanging, the suggestion to say 'strawberry surprise' etc is going to make him even more anxious, he's asking you about meals in advance so he's got time to prepare himself.

junbean · 14/11/2023 00:10

No you don't have to bend to his demands. You're doing enough by accommodating and offering healthy foods. Just don't let it be a thing. You make the food and he can be grateful for it or not, but he doesn't get to cause you constant grief!

neilyoungismyhero · 13/11/2023 23:57

@Snugglemonkey fair point.

Renamed · 13/11/2023 23:47

Cinateel · 12/11/2023 22:44

If I asked when I was a child, my dad would always say " 'am, jam and baa lamb'. I knew that meant there was no use asking. I didn't have any anxiety around food though.

My mum would say Bum on Toast

Katbum · 13/11/2023 23:32

I need to know what I will be eating as I have to mentally prepare. Maybe it’s an ND thing? I don’t know but if I am having fish for dinner, for e.g. but haven’t sort of mentally prepped for that, I would struggle to stomach it. This goes for whatever and if I don’t fancy something on a particular day I can’t eat it at all. Anyway, I sympathise with your ss and would suggest you do something like a weekly menu on a kitchen chalk board.

Abbyant · 13/11/2023 23:31

I have a weekly menu up on the fridge it takes some of the load off me because I know what I’m making and meal prep some of it plus it stops everyone else from asking me what’s got tea.

Psychonabike · 13/11/2023 23:30

Hi @Haveyouanyjam

I have a child who does exactly what you describe. The incessant questions are very tiring.

Interestingly, both he and my DH have ADHD.

It is really common for ADHD to co-exist with Anxiety Disorders, OCD, phobias etc. ADHD is one of the most commonly inherited conditions.

I am very sure that the need to know and control over everything are very much anxiety driven. It's like he can't tolerate any uncertainty at all and as soon as a thought pops into his head "I wonder what's going to be for dinner" he then must have the answer to it.

We also get it about what we're doing that day, who will put his younger sibling to bed, what time X will happen etc. It can feel like having a little dictator around but from his perspective I am sure that the uncertainty and anxiety is crippling.

I deal with it by having a rational discussion with him, that finds a compromise. In this case it would be agreeing with him that a variety of foods are necessary for a healthy diet and writing up a meal plan with him -well with the whole family at the table. What is kind of interesting is that when I think he will be absolutely opposed to XYZ, his rigidity is such that if we all agree XYZ at a dinner table family discussion, then he will then become the enforcer of XYZ because we agreed it! I do have to write some flexibility into these plans and make sure we don't agree anything too unrealistic and rigid, just to suit him. I think it's about giving him the consistency and security of a plan without reinforcing the need for absolute control and rigidity.

Unfortunately I don't think this kind of anxiety and control can be overturned by not working with him on it. Driving more anxiety and insecurity here will likely create bigger problems.

user1492757084 · 13/11/2023 23:28

The idea of a posted meal plan might work.
You sound like you have been successfully improving his palete.
Tell him to not ask before a certain time (teach him to read a clock) as you have to decide when you know how much time you have.

My fussy eater son had one night where we had his favourite nutritious meal each week. Does he have a favourite?
Another night could be based around his favourite vegetable.
You have two children so that would help decide four meals.

Start to involve him in the making of the meals that he likes.

TeenLifeMum · 13/11/2023 23:17

I’d have a menu for the week with one “open” day that’s DSS choice - pizza/fish and chips anything he wants. It gives the message that this is the plan and it’s not changing but he has an element of control.

celticprincess · 13/11/2023 23:07

Several things going on here.

Your husband has adhd. Definitely look into how that can appear through the family. ND can have lots of issues around food - many related to sensory issues.

Your stepson sounds like he has some kind of trauma attached to living with his mother. This might need addressing by a specialist who works with attachment issues. This is not something you and your husband can sort out between you.

His anxiety- whatever the root cause (ND/attatchment) - is causing issues with food. Have a read up on AFRID. Whilst he doesn’t currently have severe issues with restricting his intake of food, dismissing it as fussing eating and not tackling the cause with specialists could result in an eating disorder I the future.

Oh and ignore any advice around ‘surprises’ and handing over food which is different to what has been suggested. This is a one track way to him refusing to eat. If people joke about safe foods or try to hide ingredients or mislead someone about what they’re eating then they au just refuse their safe foods. I see you always offer a safe food alongside new things and this is definitely the best thing to be doing.

I’ve got an autistic child and one with possible adhd. The autistic one eats a massive range of foods and not the typically beige diet associated with autism, however she can be very routine about what she eats on what days and checking the dates on foods as well. The food she prefers n certain days can change but with discussion and an explanation about why what she’s expecting to eat has changed. We never really planned a fixed meal pan but fell into one for various reasons. She’s not a big fruit eater but I’ve become less so myself as I’m getting put off with fruit when I buy something and it not nice.

My possibly adhd child is the fussy beige eater. She’s gradually increasing her palate now but it’s often a struggle. At one point I had her make a list of foods she would eat and we would rock them off through the week to try and make sure we weren’t having the same every day. Whilst we tend to have different hot meals she does have the same wrap/crisps/cucumber/yoghurt every single day.

Menu planning as best you can would be a good option for you. Sit down with him and agree before you do the shopping, taking into account schedules, and try hard to stick to it. Menu could change weekly but once it’s written then stick with it. You’ll find that he doesn’t ask as much and his anxiety around it all lessens.

Fussy eaters are tricky. I was one. I ate zero veg as a child. Cheese sandwiches daily. The 80s was a time of lots of meals being served with chips. I will not eat a mushroom ever!! It’s a texture thing. Same with tomatoes. I understand the whole beige food being predictable. Although I eat mushroom or tomatoes flavoured sauces. But as an adult I can make choices and cook what I want. Both my kids eat foods I won’t eat so I haven’t passed anything down to them. But o get that it’s not them just being awkward.