Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pay equality will be hard to achieve while we continue to prioritise lifestyle

216 replies

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 17:51

Had an interesting discussion with a colleague last night whilst out for drinks and she made some points I've never really considered.

She pointed out that the woman often takes on the carer role as 'it made more sense due to his salary being higher'. This is no doubt true because even without the pay bias towards men there's also the fact that the husband is often a few years older and hence further along in his career. Also that men are more likely to ask for pay rises and choose high paying jobs - even more so in working class demographics where men often learn trades and women become carers etc.

So of course it makes financial sense for a family to do this. But what if the man took some of the hit and the woman continued building her career? In the long run this might even be better as the man might bounce back more easily (women may still continue to face prejudice from some for the perceived risk of them becoming pregant again).

Of course there's the issue of men not being able to give birth but the fact that only 1% women utilise shared parental leave does suggest that there's plenty of room for men to be more involved. My colleague believes that a lot of us want to have our cake and eat it.

Another colleague chipped in to say that a lot of families can't afford to take the hit on the main salary, but the original colleague said "well, that's a lifestyle choice". She said that she deliberately waited a couple of years until her salary/experience had reached the level where she wasn't reliant on her husband's salary. Obv not an option for everyone but it was an interesting point. She said that it can be a mistake to build your life on the foundation of a rich partner.

She said that she understands why people prioritise things like nice houses/areas, private schooling, nice holidays, etc, but that in many cases these choices funnel you in a direction that isn't necessarily the path to achieving true equality. She said she told her husband early on that she wouldn't be sacrificing her career and she 100% claims she would've left him had he gone back on his promise to share the leave.

I'm not sure what my thoughts are not having kids myself but I thought it was an interesting discussion. Do we end up forgoing equality for a better lifestyle?

OP posts:
CaramelMac · 12/11/2023 19:43

We didn’t “utilise” shared parental leave because I was breastfeeding and I didn’t want the stress of going back to work while pumping milk, and trying to breastfeed to a schedule. Obviously I would’ve done if it had been that or starve but it wasn’t. If men could take parental leave once the baby was a year old we would’ve used it.

RosaGallica · 12/11/2023 19:39

Unfortunately the impact of individual ‘choice’ tends to be somewhat small compared to the impacts of social choices.

It is a fact that girls and women have fewer paths open to them in life than men: they are not treated seriously in the trades and still mostly have the option of education, health and roles where looks are important such as customer services. It is also a fact that education and health, being public sector areas, have been absolutely hammered: wages have not kept up and are now outstripped by many predominantly male areas of employment. Part time work appears to have been reduced too and those same areas of education and health have had expectations on hours raised. It’s also a fact that wider social economic issues means more people have to work full time or longer hours to make ends meet.

I remember the 90s when both men and women were going to work part time so that both could be looking after the kids part time, which would have offered us more equality. But the option of flexibility has gone. More are simply choosing not to have kids at all, because it’s not affordable.

Thepeopleversuswork · 12/11/2023 19:39

@CaramacFiend

Hmm, I still feel like a lot of women wantto marry up. Maybe this is where feminism and our modern reality don't always meet. We still view low earning men a lot more negatively than low earning women as a society, so if there is a societal influence I'd say this is likely part of it.

This is interesting: I have never "married up" or even "dated up". I'm actually frightened and turned off at the prospect of a man out-earning me and I've (consciously or unconsciously) chosen men who earn less than me. I would hate to be in a partnership where a man was calling the shots financially, it's my biggest fear.

I've out-earned every partner I've had (including my ex husband) by a factor of at least three to one. I haven't deliberately gone out looking for men who earn less than me, but I think at some level I've sought them out.

My mum gave up her career to "facilitate" my dad's career and look after kids and was miserable and trapped and I knew I didn't want that.

This has upsides and downsides. The main upside is that my money is mine (and my daughter's). I don't have to share it with anyone (unless I want to) and I don't have to consult anyone else or get their views on it or compromise what I want to do to fit in with their life. The downside is obvious: I have to earn all the money and I can't ever take my foot off the gas but it's a price I'm willing to pay for financial autonomy and I never regret it.

The thing is even in my current partnership, with a man I love and who earns decent money but a lot less than me, and whom I trust and who tries to be a good domestic partner, I'm still doing more of the domestic work and mental load than I should.

Even the most progressive men and even the men who know they are the financially more "junior" partner still at some level have a gene that tells them they are the hunter-gatherers and the leaders. It's changing, and there are some men who are genuine outliers and who genuinely see themselves as needing to play a role in domestic life etc. But very very few.

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 19:38

It makes my blood boil how underrated motherhood is and how the equal and feminist way to do things is apparently to be as much like a man as possible, and the discussion is around making the man take on childcare because that's equality with no thought that some women might actually want to prioritise motherhood. It's as though some younger childless women simply can't even imagine that might be something a women wants rather than something she is pushed into.

I do agree with this. I've seen it discussed on here from time to time but feminists don't usually seem to agree with the 'acting like a man' bit. Often they point out that this is actually down to our perception of what constitutes a man, which is a fair point but I also believe that the sexes are fundamentally different and that we're more nurturing than men - this can be observed in nature.

OP posts:
yellowlane · 12/11/2023 19:36

I'm my friend group (4 women) and my sister and SIL the women all out earn the men. In 4 couples the men took extended parental leave (after between 6-9 months) and women went back to work. My dh didn't as at the time he out earned me and I wanted the year off. I now out earn him (I retrained) even though I now work part time. Whilst my dh is a great dad, the dads that did have more caring duties are definitely more hands on and do things naturally that my dh never would've (e.g packing napping bag or meal planning for baby).
All the women are younger than the men.

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 19:32

The thing a lot of people miss, you and your friend included, is a lot of women want to 'take the hit' salary/career wise when they have kids because they want to spend their time being mother

Would this not come under the 'changing priorities' I mentioned above?

I'm not judging anyone's choices btw. I think it's just an interesting discussion to compare individual choices as they impact the societal trends we see. I think a lot of perceived inequality is actually just the result of the choices we make, whilst I also recognise that choices aren't made in a vacuum.

But definitely women wanting to spend time with their kids is a big factor in the pay gap IMO. There's already been some research that shows that childless female execs continue to outearn their male peers and are promoted more often.

OP posts:
telestrations · 12/11/2023 19:29

Surely the point of equality is to increase lifestyle not decrease it. And the issue of pay equality is women not earning the same for the same work as men, not if they choose to work less.

G5000 · 12/11/2023 19:26

The thing a lot of people miss, you and your friend included, is a lot of women want to 'take the hit' salary/career wise when they have kids because they want to spend their time being mother

I think we should ask why so few men in the UK seem to want to "be fathers", as you put it. And that after having children.

Changingeveryth · 12/11/2023 19:10

in the language of economics, it is often economically rational to prioritise one career over the other. I read an article on this (American based) but can’t find it now annoyingly.

It is a structural problem though. I don’t think one family making a choice to make themselves poorer will make a large enough impact. It requires policy changes to make a difference (shared parental leave, corporate policies that support fathers being more active, etc). We need to properly value caring.

I don’t think women should apologise for making decisions that are right for their family. In particular they shouldn’t be expected to do it all to make up for those structural failings.

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 19:10

KaiserChefs · 12/11/2023 19:03

For the top 10% of earners who have all those baubles you listed, yeah that's probably a choice.
For the other 90%, it's the difference between being able to pay the mortgage and buy food.
Are you really so spectacularly dense as to not understand that? Maybe you and your friend could change society by donating your big piles of unwanted cash to those women who don't have a choice about how or when they work because they didn't get the opportunities or didn't have the things society values and pays big money for. Many women don't have a career or a career path, they have jobs and that's all they get.

Well, it's a choice to buy a house that you can only afford through maintaining your husband's salary. That was part of the original point.

As I originally stated, this may not apply to everybody but certainly for most of the middle class families on here there is a choice in where they live and they've often chosen a naice area or prioritised things like catchment areas for good schools. Again, this is a choice.

OP posts:
PlantMum23 · 12/11/2023 19:05

Blueey · 12/11/2023 19:01

The thing a lot of people miss, you and your friend included, is a lot of women want to 'take the hit' salary/career wise when they have kids because they want to spend their time being mothers as much as they can over working more. It's not something you'll necessarily know about yourself either way until you have a child.

Not everyone of course, and it's good that nowadays we have the choice to work, be a SAHM or somewhere in between. But I personally work as little as I can get away with in order to maximise time with my kids. If I could stay at home full time until they were a bit older I would in a heartbeat.

It makes my blood boil how underrated motherhood is and how the equal and feminist way to do things is apparently to be as much like a man as possible, and the discussion is around making the man take on childcare because that's equality with no thought that some women might actually want to prioritise motherhood. It's as though some younger childless women simply can't even imagine that might be something a women wants rather than something she is pushed into.

But is that because we bring up girls to a world where they are conditioned to think like this? We buy them baby dolls, prams and expect them to be kind, caring and considerate, whereas we buy boys “career” associated and STEM toys, and tell them to be strong, brave and successful.

And then we wonder why men go on to earn more, be disinterested fathers, and their female partners are left at home literally holding the baby.

Do women feel the need to stay at home because they believe they are better at doing it than their partners?

Boomboom22 · 12/11/2023 19:05

In sixth form there are always a few girls who think it sounds great. They are often very clever. Also know lots of high fliers who said they'd never give up and it all changed when the baby was here. And those who thought they wanted to stay at home tearing their hair out after 9 months wanting to work again.

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 19:04

LaChienneDesFromages · 12/11/2023 18:59

It’s not just an individual choice though. This is a structural issue.

Scandinavian families, living within different structures and norms manage both a higher level of equality and a higher standard of living than those in Anglo Saxon nations.

Doesn't the research say that in the most 'equal' societies women are actually more likely to adopt traditional roles, whilst in patriarchal societies (India etc) women are more likely to go into tech/pharma (which may be a completely separate issue tbf as this provides an escape for them through being independent).

I do remember seeing a fairly recent poll where only 40% of Swedish women claimed to be feminists, which is much higher than here but still surprisingly low.

OP posts:
KaiserChefs · 12/11/2023 19:03

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 18:46

How do you mean? That it's a belief borne out of a privileged perspective?

Strictly speaking, private education, multiple foreign holidays a year etc....these things are lifestyle choices IMHO.

For the top 10% of earners who have all those baubles you listed, yeah that's probably a choice.
For the other 90%, it's the difference between being able to pay the mortgage and buy food.
Are you really so spectacularly dense as to not understand that? Maybe you and your friend could change society by donating your big piles of unwanted cash to those women who don't have a choice about how or when they work because they didn't get the opportunities or didn't have the things society values and pays big money for. Many women don't have a career or a career path, they have jobs and that's all they get.

shockeditellyou · 12/11/2023 19:02

Blueey · 12/11/2023 19:01

The thing a lot of people miss, you and your friend included, is a lot of women want to 'take the hit' salary/career wise when they have kids because they want to spend their time being mothers as much as they can over working more. It's not something you'll necessarily know about yourself either way until you have a child.

Not everyone of course, and it's good that nowadays we have the choice to work, be a SAHM or somewhere in between. But I personally work as little as I can get away with in order to maximise time with my kids. If I could stay at home full time until they were a bit older I would in a heartbeat.

It makes my blood boil how underrated motherhood is and how the equal and feminist way to do things is apparently to be as much like a man as possible, and the discussion is around making the man take on childcare because that's equality with no thought that some women might actually want to prioritise motherhood. It's as though some younger childless women simply can't even imagine that might be something a women wants rather than something she is pushed into.

If you think motherhood is underrated, try fatherhood….it’s seen as completely optional by society.

thecatsthecats · 12/11/2023 19:02

We're taking ten months and five months leave respectively (three month overlap), and both hoping to compress/reduce our hours afterwards to have a day each off.

It's a case of not buying into the five day work week for both of us. We've had our son later than friends, expect to stick at one, and neither of us consider it a sacrifice. We're both prioritising what we want.

Blueey · 12/11/2023 19:01

The thing a lot of people miss, you and your friend included, is a lot of women want to 'take the hit' salary/career wise when they have kids because they want to spend their time being mothers as much as they can over working more. It's not something you'll necessarily know about yourself either way until you have a child.

Not everyone of course, and it's good that nowadays we have the choice to work, be a SAHM or somewhere in between. But I personally work as little as I can get away with in order to maximise time with my kids. If I could stay at home full time until they were a bit older I would in a heartbeat.

It makes my blood boil how underrated motherhood is and how the equal and feminist way to do things is apparently to be as much like a man as possible, and the discussion is around making the man take on childcare because that's equality with no thought that some women might actually want to prioritise motherhood. It's as though some younger childless women simply can't even imagine that might be something a women wants rather than something she is pushed into.

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 18:59

I can also only think of one (heterosexual) couple I know where the woman out-earns the man.

I'm quite curious about the gay couples consisting of a man and a woman. 🤔😂

OP posts:
LaChienneDesFromages · 12/11/2023 18:59

It’s not just an individual choice though. This is a structural issue.

Scandinavian families, living within different structures and norms manage both a higher level of equality and a higher standard of living than those in Anglo Saxon nations.

shockeditellyou · 12/11/2023 18:58

At our school gates, where both parents work (whether that’s full time or part time), it’s rare that pick-up or drop off is not done by a combination of both parents. There are several couples where the wife has the “proper” job and the husband is part time.

I would say the most equal partnerships are where the wife has prioritised a professional career - there is one doctor/surgeon couple in particular where the surgeon can’t be Billy Big Bollocks because his wife’s job is at least as important. That said, they do have a nanny and the cash to throw at problems.

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 18:54

swayingstreetlamp · 12/11/2023 18:47

I don't know the answer but something I've found very, very interesting to observe is how in my peer group of early 30s, highly educated friends with professional careers, I now know 5 women who have reduced their hours in some capacity (4 day weeks, 9 day fortnights, one has quit work entirely) and not a single man who has. None of the women I'm talking about have children, they just want to have more time for themselves. I'm not necessarily saying it's wrong for them to do so, but I think the fact that none of the men I know seem to consider it an option is really interesting.

I can also only think of one (heterosexual) couple I know where the woman out-earns the man.

That's interesting.

I must admit that as I was reading your post I was thinking "well, yes, many women's priorities seem to change after having kids". Then I got to the bit about them not having kids.

I firmly believe that most people put personal benefit before ideology but don't like to say as much (and to be fair nobody has to justify their choices to others as long as they're prepared to sleep in the bed they've made).

I think men are often too proud/competitive to want to step back. I'm fairly sure my partner however would be more than happy to work PT and spend more time in the gym/on the xbox. 😂

OP posts:
PlantMum23 · 12/11/2023 18:54

PlantMum23 · 12/11/2023 18:53

Similar to me, tbh.

All my female friend have higher earning potential than their partners (we are all university educated; our partners generally aren’t) yet only myself and one other work full-time, because apparently if they were full time and their partners were part time, things wouldn’t be done to their standard.

I think people need to raise their standards. My house is always tidy, my kids are always happy and well-fed, and yes sometimes the odd appointment gets missed or a gym kit gets left behind, but on the whole things run smoothly, because if they didn’t I’d simply drop down to part time and do it myself (thus meaning we had no disposable income) or I’d leave him.

Just to clarify, I’m speaking specifically about women who have a higher potential salary then their partners, and not generally about all women.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 12/11/2023 18:54

TBH this all sounds like a massive way to blame women for men’s fuck ups.

only 1% women utilise shared parental leave

You mean women AND MEN.

The fact is women do the vast majority of the childcare and housework because if they didn’t the men wouldn’t and the children would suffer.

Ask yourself why men ‘choose higher paid jobs’ (remember they still need to be offered the job so it’s not so much a choice) and are more likely to ask for pay rises

PlantMum23 · 12/11/2023 18:53

swayingstreetlamp · 12/11/2023 18:47

I don't know the answer but something I've found very, very interesting to observe is how in my peer group of early 30s, highly educated friends with professional careers, I now know 5 women who have reduced their hours in some capacity (4 day weeks, 9 day fortnights, one has quit work entirely) and not a single man who has. None of the women I'm talking about have children, they just want to have more time for themselves. I'm not necessarily saying it's wrong for them to do so, but I think the fact that none of the men I know seem to consider it an option is really interesting.

I can also only think of one (heterosexual) couple I know where the woman out-earns the man.

Similar to me, tbh.

All my female friend have higher earning potential than their partners (we are all university educated; our partners generally aren’t) yet only myself and one other work full-time, because apparently if they were full time and their partners were part time, things wouldn’t be done to their standard.

I think people need to raise their standards. My house is always tidy, my kids are always happy and well-fed, and yes sometimes the odd appointment gets missed or a gym kit gets left behind, but on the whole things run smoothly, because if they didn’t I’d simply drop down to part time and do it myself (thus meaning we had no disposable income) or I’d leave him.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 12/11/2023 18:51

I think if we made childcare fully tax deductible it would change things. There would be a lot fewer women saying it didn't make sense for them to work (even though their share of childcare should only be half) and in my view it is good for women to earn money - it's not good for women to be dependent on a man. OK it's not that great to be dependent on a capricious employer, but there are other employers.

For the record have outearned my husband (by some margin) for most of my working life. We've been together 25 years and I think I've earned less than him for two of those years.