Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pay equality will be hard to achieve while we continue to prioritise lifestyle

216 replies

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 17:51

Had an interesting discussion with a colleague last night whilst out for drinks and she made some points I've never really considered.

She pointed out that the woman often takes on the carer role as 'it made more sense due to his salary being higher'. This is no doubt true because even without the pay bias towards men there's also the fact that the husband is often a few years older and hence further along in his career. Also that men are more likely to ask for pay rises and choose high paying jobs - even more so in working class demographics where men often learn trades and women become carers etc.

So of course it makes financial sense for a family to do this. But what if the man took some of the hit and the woman continued building her career? In the long run this might even be better as the man might bounce back more easily (women may still continue to face prejudice from some for the perceived risk of them becoming pregant again).

Of course there's the issue of men not being able to give birth but the fact that only 1% women utilise shared parental leave does suggest that there's plenty of room for men to be more involved. My colleague believes that a lot of us want to have our cake and eat it.

Another colleague chipped in to say that a lot of families can't afford to take the hit on the main salary, but the original colleague said "well, that's a lifestyle choice". She said that she deliberately waited a couple of years until her salary/experience had reached the level where she wasn't reliant on her husband's salary. Obv not an option for everyone but it was an interesting point. She said that it can be a mistake to build your life on the foundation of a rich partner.

She said that she understands why people prioritise things like nice houses/areas, private schooling, nice holidays, etc, but that in many cases these choices funnel you in a direction that isn't necessarily the path to achieving true equality. She said she told her husband early on that she wouldn't be sacrificing her career and she 100% claims she would've left him had he gone back on his promise to share the leave.

I'm not sure what my thoughts are not having kids myself but I thought it was an interesting discussion. Do we end up forgoing equality for a better lifestyle?

OP posts:
CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 22:03

Dare I say it's perhaps not just the effect of having a year or two out so much as the permanent shift to being less work focused in many cases.

OP posts:
SoIRejoined · 12/11/2023 22:03

I completely disagree with the "lifestyle choice" idea, where I live there just isn't the childcare available that would allow both parents to do professional jobs.

In my area the women who work full time are generally relying on another woman, ie their mum, to do unpaid childcare. In some cases the DH is doing child care, but that's where the DH is self employed or working from home in a super flexible job.

Everyone is doing the best they can in their circumstances.

Poblano · 12/11/2023 22:01

It isn't impossible to do both - take your foot off the career pedal for a few years when the DC are young then ramp it back up later.

When DH and I were first married I earned around 25% more than him. I went back to work FT after DC1, but after DC2 went PT and didn't go for promotion etc for a good few years. When DC1 was at the end of primary school I stepped things back up. DC are now at university and I earn roughly 60% more than DH does.

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 21:59

MonsieurCrapeau · 12/11/2023 21:57

I don’t think valuing caring has to mean paying for it. It’s a cultural shift. At the moment the shift is in the other, more capitalist direction - more childcare, tax breaks etc to get mothers into work and away from unpaid caring.

True, but it always seems to end up coming down to money in some way.

OP posts:
MonsieurCrapeau · 12/11/2023 21:59

Creepy2023 · 12/11/2023 21:52

Quite sad on a feminist-leaning forum to see so much sexism. Women as 'nurturers' and men as 'earners.' Grim.

Men can nurture and women can earn, but ime on average women are more interested in looking after children than men. Do you disagree?

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 21:57

Creepy2023 · 12/11/2023 21:52

Quite sad on a feminist-leaning forum to see so much sexism. Women as 'nurturers' and men as 'earners.' Grim.

It's often how it is in the animal kingdom though. I do believe females are genuinely more nurturing. Things don't always align with human ideas and ideologies.

OP posts:
MonsieurCrapeau · 12/11/2023 21:57

I don’t think valuing caring has to mean paying for it. It’s a cultural shift. At the moment the shift is in the other, more capitalist direction - more childcare, tax breaks etc to get mothers into work and away from unpaid caring.

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 21:54

MonsieurCrapeau · 12/11/2023 21:46

Most men imo actually do not want to spend significant amounts of time doing domestic work and childcare.

Many women do want to be around a lot for their kids.

Some of this is socialisation I’m sure, but I think plenty is innate. I think instead of asking ‘how can we prevent women from taking the career hit?’, we should be asking ‘how can we get to a point where we value unpaid work?’ If society valued unpaid work it would mean men and women could make freer choices.

I agree. The struggle is how to make it work. Jobs are a contract with a company but who will foot the cost of carers? I can't see it being financially viable for the government to fund for a very long time unfortunately.

OP posts:
Creepy2023 · 12/11/2023 21:52

Quite sad on a feminist-leaning forum to see so much sexism. Women as 'nurturers' and men as 'earners.' Grim.

MonsieurCrapeau · 12/11/2023 21:51

I have a high status professional job, which I do part time, but I consider raising my children to be my most meaningful work and my vocation. Society does not agree! People are impressed by my job but no one gives a stuff about the child-rearing. If raising children was seen as a hugely important and skilled endeavour (which it is), it would change a lot for how men and women behave and how families work.

shockeditellyou · 12/11/2023 21:49

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 21:40

But a fair number do seem to look down on SAHM though. I've seen it on here.

There’s a difference between caring work being undervalued, and supporting a person to make it their entire identity. If caring work were equally valued with other work, then you’d see less of the “women’s work” nonsense.

I don’t think people looking down on SAHMs is devaluing caring work, more the despair at a woman putting herself in what is usually a vulnerable position where her wants, needs and self-actualisation are put on the back burner for everyone else. It is of course entirely possible to be a SAHM, not vulnerable financially or otherwise and perfectly content, but I would say it’s unusual.

Razorcroft · 12/11/2023 21:48

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 19:54

She said some women are actually a bit hostile towards the idea when she outlines the scheme.

I’m not bloody surprised.

Where there is shared parental leave in Sweden, you get 450ish days between both parents- allowed to be taken until 4 years old. This way mums get to recover from pregnancy for a decent whack of time, and men have the option of a decent pat leave.

The UK equivalent just takes the woman’s leave to give to the parent who didn’t grow the baby and generally the blokes don’t have it funded properly any way. And it’s only until the baby is 1, MAX.

At 9 months my supply hadn’t settled properly, and I was leaking all over the shop. And my c section scar had infections on and off. Sleeping poorly, still not myself.

My husband is an involved, equal parent- but he absolutely wouldn’t have ‘taken’ my leave entitlement. Nor would I have happily given it to rush into work, block out my diary and pump in my office when I just wanted my baby…. for reasons of ‘equality’.

There is no equality in biology. He didn’t have a baby cut out of him. He wasn’t the food source. He didn’t have a bad back leftover from pregnancy.

Men need their own option for scandi style, extended parental leave. Taking it from the mother isn’t good enough.

PlantMum23 · 12/11/2023 21:47

annahay · 12/11/2023 21:30

@PlantMum23 I've been part time before (0.8) and I agree with you. I'm hoping this time around I'll be able to hold firm on boundaries! That remains to be seen 🤞🏻

I’ve tried it three times (0.6) and each time drifted into f/t hours. I tried to go 0.8 this year but they “didn’t let me” (not quite true; they just made it verrry difficult) so I went back f/t. For my “extra” 0.2, I only make £100/month. And then I pay £200/month extra childcare for the privilege. So yeah, I pay money to work more hours. It’s shit.

MonsieurCrapeau · 12/11/2023 21:46

Most men imo actually do not want to spend significant amounts of time doing domestic work and childcare.

Many women do want to be around a lot for their kids.

Some of this is socialisation I’m sure, but I think plenty is innate. I think instead of asking ‘how can we prevent women from taking the career hit?’, we should be asking ‘how can we get to a point where we value unpaid work?’ If society valued unpaid work it would mean men and women could make freer choices.

Creepy2023 · 12/11/2023 21:45

I earn more than my previous partners and I've waited until I'm financially secure (high paying job and own a house) to consider having children. I just saw it as responsible and feminist.

I would hate to financially rely on a man.

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 21:40

shockeditellyou · 12/11/2023 21:37

It’s not feminists undervaluing caring work! Feminists have been pointing out for years that traditionally female activities are not valued by society.

I also think that many women go part time because it’s socially acceptable to do so - if you have a bullshit job, why would you stay in it if you didn’t have to? Men don’t get that option to the same degree.

But a fair number do seem to look down on SAHM though. I've seen it on here.

OP posts:
shockeditellyou · 12/11/2023 21:37

It’s not feminists undervaluing caring work! Feminists have been pointing out for years that traditionally female activities are not valued by society.

I also think that many women go part time because it’s socially acceptable to do so - if you have a bullshit job, why would you stay in it if you didn’t have to? Men don’t get that option to the same degree.

annahay · 12/11/2023 21:30

@PlantMum23 I've been part time before (0.8) and I agree with you. I'm hoping this time around I'll be able to hold firm on boundaries! That remains to be seen 🤞🏻

PlantMum23 · 12/11/2023 21:22

annahay · 12/11/2023 21:19

I'm currently on maternity leave and plan to go back part time, despite being the higher earner. Frankly, I've fallen out of love with teaching and I'm hoping that doing less of it will help me enjoy it a bit more. We're lucky in that we have family help for childcare. If that hasn't been an option, we had discussed my husband going pt as that would have made more sense financially. He is just about to start a new job though which is better paid so takes some of the pressure off me. I feel like things are falling into place, and I certainly don't feel like I'm sacrificing anything career wise. We'll see how it goes.

I’d recommend doing the part time thing temporarily if I was you.

Teaching part time is just doing full time hours for less pay.

annahay · 12/11/2023 21:19

I'm currently on maternity leave and plan to go back part time, despite being the higher earner. Frankly, I've fallen out of love with teaching and I'm hoping that doing less of it will help me enjoy it a bit more. We're lucky in that we have family help for childcare. If that hasn't been an option, we had discussed my husband going pt as that would have made more sense financially. He is just about to start a new job though which is better paid so takes some of the pressure off me. I feel like things are falling into place, and I certainly don't feel like I'm sacrificing anything career wise. We'll see how it goes.

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 21:08

Ironically, I feel like a lot of the jobs that women favour are the types that suffer the most from time out. In an office job you miss out on valuable promotions but as a tradesperson you can just start taking jobs on again.

A truck driver can leave a job and be in another one within days, earning a decent salary. I actually spoke to a friend earlier today who is doing her first shift for one of the big hauliers (DPD/Amazon type company) on £25 p/h. With bonuses and overtime she reckons she'll be on about £65k. You could easily take a year out and probably return on a higher salary as there's such demand for Class 1 drivers. 4on/4off also allows much more free time if you can be flexible with a rolling shift pattern. Her hubby wfh so does the school run for four days then she does them on her four days off. She said she could never go back to a two day weekend.

OP posts:
Rewis · 12/11/2023 21:07

I'm Finnish and the system here is far from perfect but in my social circle in the past 10ish years when couples have been having babies most the men have stayed 6-12 months at home. I also don't know anyone taking reduced hours cause the daycare fees are determined by the family income but the max is 300€/mo.

My bf hadn't even really thought about staying home until he saw how excited my brother was to spend a year with his son. And now my bf is all for staying at home. He needed the example. It's a slow institutional change that is needed. We're still far from equality and the workforce is slowly following.

I don't think this is as simple as choice. Of course there are some aspects that are a choice but culture and society is a big factor. And it is not as simple as a choice to change it.

Mrsjaffacakeys · 12/11/2023 20:55

Blueey · 12/11/2023 19:01

The thing a lot of people miss, you and your friend included, is a lot of women want to 'take the hit' salary/career wise when they have kids because they want to spend their time being mothers as much as they can over working more. It's not something you'll necessarily know about yourself either way until you have a child.

Not everyone of course, and it's good that nowadays we have the choice to work, be a SAHM or somewhere in between. But I personally work as little as I can get away with in order to maximise time with my kids. If I could stay at home full time until they were a bit older I would in a heartbeat.

It makes my blood boil how underrated motherhood is and how the equal and feminist way to do things is apparently to be as much like a man as possible, and the discussion is around making the man take on childcare because that's equality with no thought that some women might actually want to prioritise motherhood. It's as though some younger childless women simply can't even imagine that might be something a women wants rather than something she is pushed into.

👏

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 20:52

I honestly think perpetuated stereotypes are one of the biggest things putting girls off tbh. All of the big contractors I've dealt with are extremely professional but the general public seem to default to thinking of hairy arsed blokes in white vans doing house extensions, which isn't really the type of route you'd go as a construction graduate.

OP posts:
G5000 · 12/11/2023 20:50

yet every time it happens, he is asked why I can’t get them/leave etc.

DH had the same, told his company that the day he earns multiples of my salary and not vice versa, we will indeed consider prioritising his career for a while.

Swipe left for the next trending thread