Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pay equality will be hard to achieve while we continue to prioritise lifestyle

216 replies

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 17:51

Had an interesting discussion with a colleague last night whilst out for drinks and she made some points I've never really considered.

She pointed out that the woman often takes on the carer role as 'it made more sense due to his salary being higher'. This is no doubt true because even without the pay bias towards men there's also the fact that the husband is often a few years older and hence further along in his career. Also that men are more likely to ask for pay rises and choose high paying jobs - even more so in working class demographics where men often learn trades and women become carers etc.

So of course it makes financial sense for a family to do this. But what if the man took some of the hit and the woman continued building her career? In the long run this might even be better as the man might bounce back more easily (women may still continue to face prejudice from some for the perceived risk of them becoming pregant again).

Of course there's the issue of men not being able to give birth but the fact that only 1% women utilise shared parental leave does suggest that there's plenty of room for men to be more involved. My colleague believes that a lot of us want to have our cake and eat it.

Another colleague chipped in to say that a lot of families can't afford to take the hit on the main salary, but the original colleague said "well, that's a lifestyle choice". She said that she deliberately waited a couple of years until her salary/experience had reached the level where she wasn't reliant on her husband's salary. Obv not an option for everyone but it was an interesting point. She said that it can be a mistake to build your life on the foundation of a rich partner.

She said that she understands why people prioritise things like nice houses/areas, private schooling, nice holidays, etc, but that in many cases these choices funnel you in a direction that isn't necessarily the path to achieving true equality. She said she told her husband early on that she wouldn't be sacrificing her career and she 100% claims she would've left him had he gone back on his promise to share the leave.

I'm not sure what my thoughts are not having kids myself but I thought it was an interesting discussion. Do we end up forgoing equality for a better lifestyle?

OP posts:
CaramacFiend · 13/11/2023 00:21

I feel like biology is increasingly becoming seen as a narrative we can alter depending on our ideological stance. A decade ago nobody seriously believed that humans could change sex or that men and women were the same.

OP posts:
CaramacFiend · 13/11/2023 00:19

And equally you see a lot more gay men as hairdressers than you do straight men.

OP posts:
CaramacFiend · 13/11/2023 00:18

Creepy2023 · 12/11/2023 23:33

So what about lesbians etc?

What jobs are they allowed to do?

I'm not sure I understand your point. Anybody can do any job they want if they're physically/mentally capable, although it certainly seems that a higher proportion of lesbians do 'mens jobs', like butch lesbians working on the doors etc.

OP posts:
Creepy2023 · 12/11/2023 23:33

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 23:27

But there's a whole lot of chemistry involved though isn't there? Like how women are attracted to more masculine men when ovulating etc.

No doubt we can ignore/override instinct on an individual level but at a societal level I think there are clear differences between the sexes. Testosterone alone accounts for a lot of differences in behaviour and there's lots of scientific data backing this up.

So what about lesbians etc?

What jobs are they allowed to do?

stayathomer · 12/11/2023 23:32

I must be in the minority- most people I know the man and woman close to match salary wise, and a lot of women I know out earn the man. Most of my friends actually! At our school gates there are also as many sahds, and hands on ones. And I’m honestly not just saying that

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 23:27

Creepy2023 · 12/11/2023 23:09

I strongly disagree. I work in a sector that's traditionally male and fortunately have quite a few female colleagues.

I know plenty of women who are assertive, logical etc. Plenty of men who are more 'nurturing'.

We're not animals. Unless socialised into sexism (I'm lucky my parents were progessive) there's no gender to traits.

But there's a whole lot of chemistry involved though isn't there? Like how women are attracted to more masculine men when ovulating etc.

No doubt we can ignore/override instinct on an individual level but at a societal level I think there are clear differences between the sexes. Testosterone alone accounts for a lot of differences in behaviour and there's lots of scientific data backing this up.

OP posts:
IBlinkThereforeIAm · 12/11/2023 23:26

telestrations · 12/11/2023 19:29

Surely the point of equality is to increase lifestyle not decrease it. And the issue of pay equality is women not earning the same for the same work as men, not if they choose to work less.

No, it isn't just that. It's about having a meritocracy so that people are accepted and given equal opportunities for training and promotion in any industry they want to work in regardless of their sex, without being stereotyped or disadvantaged or subjected to toxic cultures that hold back their career progression and therefore pay.

It's about the fact that if you submit a CV for a role with the same experience and qualifications on it - identical in every respect other than the name of the candidate - but change the name from female to male, the identical male candidate is far more likely to be given an interview. Research has demonstrated this. It is about how women in senior positions are frequently ignored or ostracised and subjected to sexist terms like "bossy" when men would be called "assertive" for the same behaviour. It is about how these stereotypes are so insideous that research even shows that women are more likely to prefer to have a male boss than a female boss, and the majority of men will openly admit still that they dislike having a female boss.

It goes right back to the fact that these stereotypes are instilled from the moment a child is born, with studies showing how people interact with a young baby differently depending on whether they are dressed in typically "male" or "female" clothes. That a far higher proportion of girls in single sex schools choose STEM subjects for further study than do so in mixed sex schools, therefore bias in encouragement within school and sexist attitudes from teachers are the only plausible explanation, intentional or not. So despite girls achieving higher grades at every stage of education on average they are still fighting a never-ending wall of prejudice throughout life in order to become successful in a career.

And when they become mothers receive a level of judgement from friends and family that would never be heaped upon fathers for the same behaviour. It is insideous in every aspect of life. Choices are not made in a vacuum.

Creepy2023 · 12/11/2023 23:13

willWillSmithsmith · 12/11/2023 22:26

Are there pressures on girls not to take science subjects? My son’s school was forever trying to encourage the girls to take up stem but they just didn’t want to. My son’s going to be doing engineering at Uni, his female friends from school are doing history and art🤷‍♀️

Eyeroll.

I work in STEM. So do many women.

Creepy2023 · 12/11/2023 23:09

MonsieurCrapeau · 12/11/2023 21:59

Men can nurture and women can earn, but ime on average women are more interested in looking after children than men. Do you disagree?

I strongly disagree. I work in a sector that's traditionally male and fortunately have quite a few female colleagues.

I know plenty of women who are assertive, logical etc. Plenty of men who are more 'nurturing'.

We're not animals. Unless socialised into sexism (I'm lucky my parents were progessive) there's no gender to traits.

PlantMum23 · 12/11/2023 22:55

Fluffyowl00 · 12/11/2023 22:41

I think an easy way to solve this would either be to increase child benefit to main caregiver to a useful level, or to reduce tax on women/main caregiver who have children under 12.

That way women can have their own money. It’s so sad to see so many threads where women are begging for childcare money or forced to live on a pittance on SMP. I’m surprised things haven’t changed in the 21st Century, but if they haven’t it’s time to change. 100 years ago men were the breadwinners and gave women ‘pin money’ and it seems in some relationships little has changed.

I think tax should be applied at a household level rather than an individual level. It’s frustrating that someone on £50k with a partner on £10k will pay more tax/ NI (approx £13.5k/year) than two people on £30k (approx £11k/year)

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 22:45

Fluffyowl00 · 12/11/2023 22:41

I think an easy way to solve this would either be to increase child benefit to main caregiver to a useful level, or to reduce tax on women/main caregiver who have children under 12.

That way women can have their own money. It’s so sad to see so many threads where women are begging for childcare money or forced to live on a pittance on SMP. I’m surprised things haven’t changed in the 21st Century, but if they haven’t it’s time to change. 100 years ago men were the breadwinners and gave women ‘pin money’ and it seems in some relationships little has changed.

The issue is that our government won't be able to afford that for a very long time. And also we'd need to somehow stop it being abused, cynical as that sounds.

OP posts:
yellowlane · 12/11/2023 22:43

@willWillSmithsmith my niece said that biology, physics, maths and psychology were the 4 most popular subjects at her school. All girls grammar.

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 22:42

PlantMum23 · 12/11/2023 22:35

Humans are in a -perhaps? - unique situation in where we can make an active choice to delay procreation, or to stop it completely. We are also in an unusual position where our ability to procreate is not entirely dependent on our physical prowess.

In lions for example, the males do vwry little whereas the lionesses do the bulk of the work (both hunting and raising cubs) - it almost feels like weak (human) men would use this kind of argument to excuse their own failings.

In my opinion; things are either evenly split or they aren’t. In our house; things aren’t evenly split. I do more work outside the home; he does more inside the home. Childcare is probably even tbh because after work I like to spend time with them and don’t see it as a “chore” - but while I do that, he cooks and cleans. So although the load is uneven, it’s fair. Id say we both feel like we are getting a good deal; but as is often the case with young children in tow; we both feel we are getting a shit deal.

To clarify, I'm in no way saying that because women are naturally more inclined to nurture they should be predisposed to do so.

I also do think that we're subject to our biology more than we realise. I mean, why do the vast majority of women still want to have children when the world is already hugely overpopulated? I think it's hardwired into us.

OP posts:
Fluffyowl00 · 12/11/2023 22:41

I think an easy way to solve this would either be to increase child benefit to main caregiver to a useful level, or to reduce tax on women/main caregiver who have children under 12.

That way women can have their own money. It’s so sad to see so many threads where women are begging for childcare money or forced to live on a pittance on SMP. I’m surprised things haven’t changed in the 21st Century, but if they haven’t it’s time to change. 100 years ago men were the breadwinners and gave women ‘pin money’ and it seems in some relationships little has changed.

PlantMum23 · 12/11/2023 22:35

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 22:25

Despite doing a lot of things that are extremely far removed from the natural processes (e.g. travelling to the moon) I think humans are still a lot more tied to our biology than we realise.

The 'purpose' of every species is arguably to procreate and perpetuate and that's ultimately what we do pretty much without exception. In fact, scientific discoveries aren't even that unnatural if you look at the innovation that occurs in other species like ants etc. It's really just an extension of exploring our environment.

Humans are in a -perhaps? - unique situation in where we can make an active choice to delay procreation, or to stop it completely. We are also in an unusual position where our ability to procreate is not entirely dependent on our physical prowess.

In lions for example, the males do vwry little whereas the lionesses do the bulk of the work (both hunting and raising cubs) - it almost feels like weak (human) men would use this kind of argument to excuse their own failings.

In my opinion; things are either evenly split or they aren’t. In our house; things aren’t evenly split. I do more work outside the home; he does more inside the home. Childcare is probably even tbh because after work I like to spend time with them and don’t see it as a “chore” - but while I do that, he cooks and cleans. So although the load is uneven, it’s fair. Id say we both feel like we are getting a good deal; but as is often the case with young children in tow; we both feel we are getting a shit deal.

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 22:34

My sister has done extremely well in a science subject and is now pretty senior in imaging tech used by military and security forces. She's the only woman in her team of 40.

OP posts:
CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 22:29

willWillSmithsmith · 12/11/2023 22:26

Are there pressures on girls not to take science subjects? My son’s school was forever trying to encourage the girls to take up stem but they just didn’t want to. My son’s going to be doing engineering at Uni, his female friends from school are doing history and art🤷‍♀️

I'm always reminded of this meme.

Pay equality will be hard to achieve while we continue to prioritise lifestyle
OP posts:
CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 22:27

And animals absolutely do educate their young. In the more intelligent species like dolphins it's quite pronounced and different pods develop and pass down different skills to other pods.

OP posts:
willWillSmithsmith · 12/11/2023 22:26

Bandolina · 12/11/2023 18:19

The thing that makes it clear for me that this is a feminist issue and a constrained choice in a patriarchal society is that even where the woman is the higher earner it is still very often she who goes part time or at least that's what happened to me

There wasn't SPL when I had my DC and if there had been my DH is self employed and would not be eligible

Even though I was the higher earner and financially it would have made sense for him to be the one to stay home we both felt a lot of pressure for it not to be that way. I felt I would have been judged for going back FT and he could not feel worthwhile without working

This was hugely reinforced by everyone around us friends, family and total strangers eg If DH picked up the kids from school he was a saint and such a good dad. If I did it was just what was expected.

Exact same thing with my SIL who earns more than her DH so I think it's not just me.

What about the pressures on girls not to choose science subjects that often lead to more lucrative careers?

Or the pressure to marry someone who earns more than you as a woman and the reverse as a man? I can definitely state that my academic success wasn't an attractive feature to many men and I had boyfriends dump me for doing better than them.

It might look like a 'lifestyle choice' but our choices are constrained by sexual stereotypes you need to look a bit harder.

Are there pressures on girls not to take science subjects? My son’s school was forever trying to encourage the girls to take up stem but they just didn’t want to. My son’s going to be doing engineering at Uni, his female friends from school are doing history and art🤷‍♀️

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 22:25

PlantMum23 · 12/11/2023 22:07

You can’t really equate humans to other animals in this instance though. Animals have no way to better themselves through education, for example. Animals are purely driven by instinct and self preservation (and therefore passing on their genes)

Despite doing a lot of things that are extremely far removed from the natural processes (e.g. travelling to the moon) I think humans are still a lot more tied to our biology than we realise.

The 'purpose' of every species is arguably to procreate and perpetuate and that's ultimately what we do pretty much without exception. In fact, scientific discoveries aren't even that unnatural if you look at the innovation that occurs in other species like ants etc. It's really just an extension of exploring our environment.

OP posts:
CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 22:19

HollyJollyRobin · 12/11/2023 22:10

I really don't think there is a fair way financially for fathers to be involved more than mothers- 2 weeks paternity leave (sometimes not even paid fully) and then they're not entitled to the same as mothers. Why is this? The government really need to look at this. My partner would have loved more time off but we just couldn't afford it.

I'm the higher earner and had nearly a full year off. It was very difficult financially but we made it work. I really did not want to give up any of my time with my child in order for my partner to have extra paternity leave. I don't see why father's aren't also entitled to longer paid paternity leave at the same time as the mother.

If my partner earned more I would definitely want to either reduce my hours or change to a less stressful and lower paid job, in order to have more time with my child. However, I enjoy our lifestyle and want to be able to provide as many opportunities for my child as I can, which wouldn't be possible if I lowered my wage. If we could maintain our lifestyle without me having to work then I would do it in a heartbeat in order to spend all my time with my child.

In terms of the stereotypical roles...I would say we're both guilty here...my partner always does the bins, mows the lawns, sorts the cars out...I tend to do more of the indoor jobs...mainly because I actually enjoy it! It also wouldn't bother me if my partner was a higher earner/if he was the sole earner.

What's influenced this I don't know...society, parents etc...

Interesting topic OP!

I think this post hits at the crux of the issue. There's the concept of what is ideologically fair and then the reality that we have to make things work within the limits of the system we live in (with the knowledge that anything we do will have almost zero impact on the bigger societal picture, but usually significant impact on our own lives).

OP posts:
HollyJollyRobin · 12/11/2023 22:10

I really don't think there is a fair way financially for fathers to be involved more than mothers- 2 weeks paternity leave (sometimes not even paid fully) and then they're not entitled to the same as mothers. Why is this? The government really need to look at this. My partner would have loved more time off but we just couldn't afford it.

I'm the higher earner and had nearly a full year off. It was very difficult financially but we made it work. I really did not want to give up any of my time with my child in order for my partner to have extra paternity leave. I don't see why father's aren't also entitled to longer paid paternity leave at the same time as the mother.

If my partner earned more I would definitely want to either reduce my hours or change to a less stressful and lower paid job, in order to have more time with my child. However, I enjoy our lifestyle and want to be able to provide as many opportunities for my child as I can, which wouldn't be possible if I lowered my wage. If we could maintain our lifestyle without me having to work then I would do it in a heartbeat in order to spend all my time with my child.

In terms of the stereotypical roles...I would say we're both guilty here...my partner always does the bins, mows the lawns, sorts the cars out...I tend to do more of the indoor jobs...mainly because I actually enjoy it! It also wouldn't bother me if my partner was a higher earner/if he was the sole earner.

What's influenced this I don't know...society, parents etc...

Interesting topic OP!

PlantMum23 · 12/11/2023 22:08

MonsieurCrapeau · 12/11/2023 21:59

Men can nurture and women can earn, but ime on average women are more interested in looking after children than men. Do you disagree?

Explore why though.

Or just go down to Smyths and wander around for 20 minutes and there you will find your answer.

PlantMum23 · 12/11/2023 22:07

CaramacFiend · 12/11/2023 21:57

It's often how it is in the animal kingdom though. I do believe females are genuinely more nurturing. Things don't always align with human ideas and ideologies.

You can’t really equate humans to other animals in this instance though. Animals have no way to better themselves through education, for example. Animals are purely driven by instinct and self preservation (and therefore passing on their genes)

SoIRejoined · 12/11/2023 22:06

@CaramacFiend thats because the children are still there after two years, and once they are at school the childcare gets harder.