Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think GPs should be able to check medication availability

342 replies

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 10:11

I'm absolutely fed up of ordering medication to turn up at the pharmacy to be told the manufacturer is out of stock.

If they have access to the system why isn't the GP checking this and prescribing the alternative? Surely machine learning/AI would help here or are the systems not integrated?

I mean in the whole era of technical progression why are we running between Boots and the GP to get things re-prescribed?

For context this has happened with my HRT, my DD14 ADHD medication, antibiotics etc etc over the last three months.

AIBU to expect an integrated supply approach to prescriptions?

OP posts:
BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 12/11/2023 17:47

you didn't know the manufacturer was out of stock

FFS, how many times does this to be explained? There are dozens of steps between the manufacturer and you holding the dispensed prescription in your hand. And it is not a case of manufacturer has a pile of the things, the individual pharmacy rings them up, and they deliver it the next day.

Supply chains are global. A single medicine might be manufactured in 10 different factories around the globe. Each will have different stock levels. They then send those to wholesalers or shippers, of which there are thousands - again with different stock levels and capacities. At some point a lot of these meds have to go through one or more national borders and customs systems, which can cause unknown delays - for the UK this is a lot worse since Brexit. Then to national wholesalers and distribution warehouses (especially for the chain chemists). Then to individual pharmacies. All of which deal with several different suppliers and multiple GP practices. So if GP prescribes drug A, even if your miracle supply chain data system means they know for absolute certain it is in stock at pharmacy B when they prescribe it, they can't possibly know whether a patient from GP C (who got a prescription days ago but hasn't yet filled it) will snaffle the last box before the first GP's patient gets there.

And if there is a manfacturing problem, GPs already know. As has been explained to you repeatedly.

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 17:47

@melj1213 but that isn't true if it was why do we end up like other posters with medication prescribed that are out of stock with manufacturers? Why?

OP posts:
notmorezoom · 12/11/2023 17:39

As a GP I'd love it if there were one system that I could check for this. But I understand from talking to my pharmacist colleagues that there are various different systems, different suppliers etc. For me to use a system it would have to add no more than 30 seconds to the consultation and be a 'one-click' thing.

IrresponsiblyCertainAboutSexualDimorphism · 12/11/2023 17:37

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 17:30

@Chersfrozenface to the manufacturers so the upwards supply chain.

Even assuming the manufacturers have somehow been persuaded to share their commercially sensitive information with every GP in the land, how would knowing what they have in their goods out warehouse be helpful in understanding
a) what they will have tomorrow
b) what the pharmacies can get hold of by this afternoon?

melj1213 · 12/11/2023 17:34

The point I'm making is at source, you order your normal medication the GP approves it and it gets sent to the pharmacy. You go to the pharmacy they tell you there is a problem with supply from the manufacturer. You then have to go back to the GP for an alternative.

But that "supply issue" might be "We have none in stock and our delivery didn't turn up today because the driver got stuck in traffic due to motorway closures and the next delivery won't be until tomorrow but we have only ordered 20 and due to the delay we now already have 30 prescriptions waiting to be fulfilled so it will be 3 days at least till we can dispense X ... But if you can speak to the GP and get them to change your prescription to Y then we have it in stock and can give you the medication today."

melj1213 · 12/11/2023 17:30

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 17:24

@melj1213 sorry but this is not true all the time is it. Notified of some, not all.

Except it is.

Any SSP as determined by the NHS is passed to everyone including GPs. Any short term or supply chain issues are not notified as they are, as by the nature of their name, short term issues that will be rectified within a short time frame that may even be less than 24hrs, therefore it doesn't require an entire overhaul of NHS contracts and having everyone signed up to a new centralised system that requires every private company in the NHS supply chain to provide their private information to any health authority that requires it ...

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 17:30

@Chersfrozenface to the manufacturers so the upwards supply chain.

OP posts:
jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 17:29

@Chersfrozenface because this isn't about the individual pharmacies it's about the data the GP should have access to from the manufacturer.

Worst case with pharmacies they don't have it in and they get it within a day or so, I mean that's annoying of course.

The point I'm making is at source, you order your normal medication the GP approves it and it gets sent to the pharmacy. You go to the pharmacy they tell you there is a problem with supply from the manufacturer. You then have to go back to the GP for an alternative.

It's the front end process I'm saying should be better. I mean it all should!

OP posts:
justteanbiscuits · 12/11/2023 17:27

AnnaMagnani · 12/11/2023 10:19

Nothing in the NHS is integrated.

Mainly because the public is heavily against having integrated systems.

And the vast majority of pharmacies are private, not NHS.

Chersfrozenface · 12/11/2023 17:26

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 17:11

Missing the point. This is about GPS being able to know when medication is unavailable from the manufacturer, to enable them to give an alternative on the initial prescription.

Whose databases would GPs need access to?

The manufacturers in the UK and abroad? Thd wholesalers? The pharmacy chains, independent pharmacies, supermarket pharmacies?

melj1213 · 12/11/2023 17:26

Chersfrozenface · 12/11/2023 17:22

Unless your disability and/or age means you can't use a phone to call the local pharmacies and say "I have a prescription for MST prolonged release, 20mg do you have any in stock?"

The problem is that some pharmacies hardly ever answer the phone. Such as the one I use regularly. Definitely because they are understaffed and busy coping with taking in and dispensing prescriptions, giving advice, inoculations, drug consumption, packing repeat prescriptions...

This is the issue.

Pharmacies have had so much piled on them, especially during COVID, that we no longer have enough staff to do all of the services required for the people in the pharmacy, never mind answer the phones, and yet we are also supposed to find the time to personally source medications we can't get hold of for patients because they don't want the hassle of dealing with their own medication ...

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 17:24

@melj1213 sorry but this is not true all the time is it. Notified of some, not all.

OP posts:
Chersfrozenface · 12/11/2023 17:22

Unless your disability and/or age means you can't use a phone to call the local pharmacies and say "I have a prescription for MST prolonged release, 20mg do you have any in stock?"

The problem is that some pharmacies hardly ever answer the phone. Such as the one I use regularly. Definitely because they are understaffed and busy coping with taking in and dispensing prescriptions, giving advice, inoculations, drug consumption, packing repeat prescriptions...

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 17:22

@Britneyfan as a GP how much time do you waste having to re do prescriptions because you didn't know the manufacturer was out of stock and the patient has to refer back to you?

OP posts:
TroysMammy · 12/11/2023 17:21

Aortic · 12/11/2023 17:02

Does your son have little patience for perimenopausal women?

It was very difficult when there were shortages. Many women were left going to and fro between pharmacies and GPs as product after product went out of stock. And the onus was on the patient to sort it.

I wouldn’t excuse rudeness. But it seems poor behaviour for your son to turn against middle-aged women desperate to get their HRT.

From the post I read that it's postmenopausal women are the ones that don't have any patience and the lack of medication is the pharmacies fault. Those seeking HRT medication have the poor behaviour.

melj1213 · 12/11/2023 17:21

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 17:11

Missing the point. This is about GPS being able to know when medication is unavailable from the manufacturer, to enable them to give an alternative on the initial prescription.

And you have been repeatedly told that this already exists with SSPs for serious manufacturing shortages.

The problem is you seemingly want to extend this to every shortage ever even if the shortage is "It's 8:58pm, the local OOH has prescribed X drug. We have run out of X drug but have a delivery due at 9am which will contain X so the patient will have to wait 12hrs for the non-urgent and not life saving medication to become available"

IrresponsiblyCertainAboutSexualDimorphism · 12/11/2023 17:19

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 17:11

Missing the point. This is about GPS being able to know when medication is unavailable from the manufacturer, to enable them to give an alternative on the initial prescription.

So your system involves mandating that manufacturers should make available real time data about what stock they have and in which wholesalers?

Who is going to make manufacturers do this?

Britneyfan · 12/11/2023 17:17

You are being so so unreasonable. A prescription is simply a recommendation for a medication. The GP has nothing to do with the pharmacy stock. There are national stock shortages of ADHD medications currently and HRT has had the same issue for ages (and yes at one point it was antibiotics). This is the real problem and where you should be directing your ire. Pressure the government to sort that out. And it’s 100 percent happening because of Brexit (not helped by a sudden unanticipated upsurge in demand for these products). Drug manufacturers often prefer to sell their products to other countries these days as a result of Brexit so we end up with shortages. I’ve spoken with pharmacies about why it’s happening (because as a GP it’s equally frustrating for us when patients are struggling to get their prescriptions filled and calling us about it). This pretty much never happened pre-Brexit.

melj1213 · 12/11/2023 17:16

enchantedsquirrelwood · 12/11/2023 17:04

I don't think it's as easy as you think it is and does show ignorance and a bit of entitlement that some IT company has to spend potentially millions on a whole system, probably one each for Wales, England, Scotland and NI as they're all different, all because you can't be arsed to find medication yourself. That's the issue. No one wants to take any responsibility for their own healthcare

So what happens if you are not in a position to look for your own medicine because you are have a disability or are elderly and wouldn't have the first idea how?

Unless your disability and/or age means you can't use a phone to call the local pharmacies and say "I have a prescription for MST prolonged release, 20mg do you have any in stock?" Then everyone is in a position to look for your own medicine.

It's no different to the time before electronic prescriptions when you could only get a paper prescription from the GP and then had to visit every pharmacy in person and if they didn't have it in stock they would say so and perhaps recommend which pharmacy to try next.

We often get people at our pharmacy counter asking for things like wound dressings, if we don't stock them or we are out of stock and can't get them for a few days but the person needs them immediately then I will always give a list of the other pharmacies nearby that are open but tell them to try ABC pharmacy first because they are the district nurses hub so they often have a larger range of dressings than other places.

Pharmacies will usually try to signpost you to the best option of they can't help but there is no way we can ring round or personally sort out every single person who comes for an item they have run out of and we are out of stock of or we would never get anything else done.

cakeorwine · 12/11/2023 17:11

Ordered prescription.
Went to pharmacy a week or so later.
Told not available.
Did they bother to let me know until I got there?
Did the GP get told?

No.

I had to go to the GP reception and ask for the GP to get an alternative.

This is the 21st century.

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 17:11

rwalker · 12/11/2023 17:07

If all the pharmacy’s were nhs yeah could be done and would be great

but there independent business it would be like expecting Tesco know if Asda had tomatoes

Missing the point. This is about GPS being able to know when medication is unavailable from the manufacturer, to enable them to give an alternative on the initial prescription.

OP posts:
Aortic · 12/11/2023 17:10

I work in the NHS. I am frustrated at the poor IT. I provide secondary care and each of the three acute hospitals I work with has a different electronic patient record system. As it’s in London they are pretty close to each other yet with entirely different systems. Which are of course different to the GP EPR. It’s a nightmare; inefficient and potentially dangerous. I wish we could all use the same system.

I do wonder how a medication database would work though. Tablets are produced by so many different drug companies in this country and abroad. Medications come in so many different formulations. Slow-release, coated, dispersible etc. The same meds might be made by twenty private companies. The manufacturers can be affected by all sorts of things such as lack of product, contamination, local strikes etc. It would require manufacturers to be diligent at updating some kind of private central database continually. There would be no obligation for them to do so so it would be voluntary. Could it work? Possibly. However, it would be absolutely enormous and take coordination internationally.

This is a lot ‘bigger’ than the GP and Boots. However, if if something is out of stock, I think the onus should be on the GP/hospital doctor and local pharmacies to find a solution. But for that to happen there would have to be much more resource given to doctors so they had time to waste on this kind of clinical/admin task. So that is not going to happen.

YouAndMeAndThem · 12/11/2023 17:07

enchantedsquirrelwood · 12/11/2023 17:04

I don't think it's as easy as you think it is and does show ignorance and a bit of entitlement that some IT company has to spend potentially millions on a whole system, probably one each for Wales, England, Scotland and NI as they're all different, all because you can't be arsed to find medication yourself. That's the issue. No one wants to take any responsibility for their own healthcare

So what happens if you are not in a position to look for your own medicine because you are have a disability or are elderly and wouldn't have the first idea how?

If asked, the Pharmacy can help out or family can help but this shouldn't be expected for every patient who is perfectly capable of phoning other pharmacies.

rwalker · 12/11/2023 17:07

If all the pharmacy’s were nhs yeah could be done and would be great

but there independent business it would be like expecting Tesco know if Asda had tomatoes

melj1213 · 12/11/2023 17:07

YouAndMeAndThem · 12/11/2023 16:59

I just don't know who you think will organise this massive undertaking. When the single systems we are all using are already so different and complex, and occasionally inadequate. I don't think it's as easy as you think it is and does show ignorance and a bit of entitlement that some IT company has to spend potentially millions on a whole system, probably one each for Wales, England, Scotland and NI as they're all different, all because you can't be arsed to find medication yourself. That's the issue. No one wants to take any responsibility for their own healthcare.

Not only that but who is paying for it? If the NHS is going to insist on this system then they need to fund it - GPs and pharmacies have systems that work for them based on their needs and requirements and can currently pick and choose whichever suits them.

The systems used by different companies and entities will all be different even within each industry - who is deciding which is more important and standardising things across the board? For example the store I work in does not make up dosset boxes or blister packs so we don't need the dosset box/blister pack settings options to be a big part of our system; the pharmacy down the road is attached to a residential care home so they spend 90% of their day making up dosset boxes and/or blister packs so the need a system that has those settings as the default and easy to navigate ... But if we both have to provide all of our information to the NHS then we need a system we can both use as well as the GPs who need no dispensing information but do need patient record information but they have to be the same system as our inventory levels need to be visible for GPs when prescribing so they can decide who to send the patient to so they can get their prescription immediately based on current stock availability before any other GP can snaffle it all first ...