Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think GPs should be able to check medication availability

342 replies

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 10:11

I'm absolutely fed up of ordering medication to turn up at the pharmacy to be told the manufacturer is out of stock.

If they have access to the system why isn't the GP checking this and prescribing the alternative? Surely machine learning/AI would help here or are the systems not integrated?

I mean in the whole era of technical progression why are we running between Boots and the GP to get things re-prescribed?

For context this has happened with my HRT, my DD14 ADHD medication, antibiotics etc etc over the last three months.

AIBU to expect an integrated supply approach to prescriptions?

OP posts:
jeaux90 · 17/11/2023 07:48

Hameth · 16/11/2023 18:06

I run a GP practice. The GPs dont have access to information about stock. They have to follow guidelines (first line choice) and then local systems have their own prescribing policies and after that they are forced to consider the cheapest option, They are responsible for choosing medications that will make you better not for ensuring a chemist (an independent business) can supply it.

When it comes to stock, there are several issues. Some like Boots cut costs by only ordering by request so you have to go back again. The government wont always refund the full cost so when they tell you its out of stock, it might just be they wont dispense it because it costs them money.

We get a list of 100 drugs with supply problems every week via email - how can anyone cope with that. Brexit (both supply and regulatory issues) is still ongoing. We have massive shortage of HRT and the morphine used in end of life, for example.

Good insights thanks. I think the thing I find interesting is there are lists of low/no availability but these are not used well because they are lists. No GP will have time to cross reference.

It could be easily automated using ML etc to flag against prescriptions though, which is the point of the thread. There is a way to technically solve these issues. When I say technical I mean via software and machine learning.

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 16/11/2023 21:33

Badbadbunny · 16/11/2023 18:52

Well, yes, obviously, but it's still a very expensive drug, however much discount the NHS has negotiated. His consultant is the one who said it costs over £1k per tablet, and I presume she knows what she's doing!! It's hardly going to be a few pounds per tablet is it??

This website suggests the US price is $13k for 3 tablets!! https://www.drugs.com/price-guide/ninlaro

Edited

But look at something like Humira. The NHS was not paying the US full price for it - mainly because Abbvie wanted it to come into the market here. Still cost around ten grand a year - just not the 96 thousand dollars a year per person (not counting loading phase) it would cost at US list price.

Then biosimilars came along and it was repriced at just over three and a half grand per year charged to the NHS.

I doubt the NHS pays anything like the US price for anything.

coffeeaddict77 · 16/11/2023 19:01

Badbadbunny · 16/11/2023 18:52

Well, yes, obviously, but it's still a very expensive drug, however much discount the NHS has negotiated. His consultant is the one who said it costs over £1k per tablet, and I presume she knows what she's doing!! It's hardly going to be a few pounds per tablet is it??

This website suggests the US price is $13k for 3 tablets!! https://www.drugs.com/price-guide/ninlaro

Edited

The consultant won't know the cost the NHS is paying actually. They will be talking about the list price too.
No, it won't be a few pounds per tablet if the list price is over 1K per tablet although the discount could be huge. It depends on how often the tablet needs to be taken and how effective if it. If it was once a year and cured cancer, for example they could charge 1K easily but if 1 per day and not so effective, if could be a fraction. NICE decide how much the NHS will pay and won't recommend if the drug costs over the threshold.

Badbadbunny · 16/11/2023 18:52

coffeeaddict77 · 16/11/2023 18:48

That is the "list price" which is the official price the company charge for the tablets (and probably do in the US). The NHS will be paying a lot less though and the actual cost will be kept secret (as stated the discount is commercial and in confidence).

Well, yes, obviously, but it's still a very expensive drug, however much discount the NHS has negotiated. His consultant is the one who said it costs over £1k per tablet, and I presume she knows what she's doing!! It's hardly going to be a few pounds per tablet is it??

This website suggests the US price is $13k for 3 tablets!! https://www.drugs.com/price-guide/ninlaro

coffeeaddict77 · 16/11/2023 18:48

Badbadbunny · 16/11/2023 18:34

Ixazomib (Ninlaro). Part of standard treatment for Multiple Myeloma. Alongside Revlimid which costs a few hundred per tablet (which they also over-prescribe!).

Per NHS webpage "The list price is £6,336 per pack of 3 capsules"

https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ta870/documents/final-appraisal-determination-document#:~:text=2.3%20The%20list%20price%20is,online%2C%20accessed%20November%202022).

Edited

That is the "list price" which is the official price the company charge for the tablets (and probably do in the US). The NHS will be paying a lot less though and the actual cost will be kept secret (as stated the discount is commercial and in confidence).

Badbadbunny · 16/11/2023 18:34

coffeeaddict77 · 16/11/2023 18:10

It is very uncommon for one tablet to cost that much, including cancer drugs. Which one are you talking about btw?

Ixazomib (Ninlaro). Part of standard treatment for Multiple Myeloma. Alongside Revlimid which costs a few hundred per tablet (which they also over-prescribe!).

Per NHS webpage "The list price is £6,336 per pack of 3 capsules"

https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/ta870/documents/final-appraisal-determination-document#:~:text=2.3%20The%20list%20price%20is,online%2C%20accessed%20November%202022).

Eskimal · 16/11/2023 18:16

I haven’t read all the responses so I hope somebody has responded that manufacturers do have the ability to update the dm+d if they so wish. GP surgeries may be slow to run updates, though.
GPs are already overworked and the NHS overstretched, so they can’t be expected to know everything.
Sometimes the error is a change of pack size etc
Or there can be issues at one of the three big distributors: AAH, alliance or phoenix.
Pharma is big business so they may even restrict things in some markets if they can direct supply elsewhere for strategic reasons.

plenty of things that affect availability beyond the GPS control.

coffeeaddict77 · 16/11/2023 18:10

notmorezoom · 16/11/2023 18:01

Not uncommon for cancer drugs

It is very uncommon for one tablet to cost that much, including cancer drugs. Which one are you talking about btw?

Hameth · 16/11/2023 18:06

I run a GP practice. The GPs dont have access to information about stock. They have to follow guidelines (first line choice) and then local systems have their own prescribing policies and after that they are forced to consider the cheapest option, They are responsible for choosing medications that will make you better not for ensuring a chemist (an independent business) can supply it.

When it comes to stock, there are several issues. Some like Boots cut costs by only ordering by request so you have to go back again. The government wont always refund the full cost so when they tell you its out of stock, it might just be they wont dispense it because it costs them money.

We get a list of 100 drugs with supply problems every week via email - how can anyone cope with that. Brexit (both supply and regulatory issues) is still ongoing. We have massive shortage of HRT and the morphine used in end of life, for example.

notmorezoom · 16/11/2023 18:01

coffeeaddict77 · 16/11/2023 17:30

I can't think of any drug that costs £1k per tablet. I think you are mistaken.

Not uncommon for cancer drugs

coffeeaddict77 · 16/11/2023 17:30

Badbadbunny · 16/11/2023 16:58

@melj1213

The amount of medicine wasted by that one person was about £3k worth, all in, from the last couple of years. That's £3k that the NHS paid for medicine that was never going to be used, and potentially meant that someone else who actually neededthe medication, and would take it, was left short/waiting and that's just one person, multiply that by how many others who are doing the same and the NHS would save millions on waste alone.

I've no doubt that some people lazily tick all the boxes. BUT, from my experience, the GP surgery admin/receptionists can also be lazy and tick all the boxes when the repeat request was only for selected items. Likewise, if the pharmacy manage the repeats, they can sometimes tick all the boxes when only selected items have been asked for by the patient - after all, they make more profit by dispensing more, don't they! Certainly happened to us many times.

Worse is my OH's cancer drug package which apparently can't be changed, not even by the oncologist, so every month he gets drugs worth thousands that he doesn't need and doesn't take! Every consultant appointment he mentions it, but they just shrug it off as though it's not important. One of the drugs is over £1k per tablet - he gets issued 3 each month but only takes 2. He's asked them not to issue it for a couple of months so he can use up some of his stock, but they won't do it as apparently it's "too hard" to keep changing the monthly drugs package!

Edited

I can't think of any drug that costs £1k per tablet. I think you are mistaken.

Badbadbunny · 16/11/2023 16:58

@melj1213

The amount of medicine wasted by that one person was about £3k worth, all in, from the last couple of years. That's £3k that the NHS paid for medicine that was never going to be used, and potentially meant that someone else who actually neededthe medication, and would take it, was left short/waiting and that's just one person, multiply that by how many others who are doing the same and the NHS would save millions on waste alone.

I've no doubt that some people lazily tick all the boxes. BUT, from my experience, the GP surgery admin/receptionists can also be lazy and tick all the boxes when the repeat request was only for selected items. Likewise, if the pharmacy manage the repeats, they can sometimes tick all the boxes when only selected items have been asked for by the patient - after all, they make more profit by dispensing more, don't they! Certainly happened to us many times.

Worse is my OH's cancer drug package which apparently can't be changed, not even by the oncologist, so every month he gets drugs worth thousands that he doesn't need and doesn't take! Every consultant appointment he mentions it, but they just shrug it off as though it's not important. One of the drugs is over £1k per tablet - he gets issued 3 each month but only takes 2. He's asked them not to issue it for a couple of months so he can use up some of his stock, but they won't do it as apparently it's "too hard" to keep changing the monthly drugs package!

UndertheCedartree · 16/11/2023 11:32

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 11:47

You are just making my case for me here. In my industry we have to have background checks etc too. It's still 20 days.

Do people have to have certain vaccinations in your industry?

JustCheckingforMe · 16/11/2023 10:23

There is a huge difference between what the HCPs are saying happens and what actual patents are experiencing. I was standing at the counter showing the dispensing assistant (in the chemist) the 2 items in the bag that I hadn't ordered and asking about one I had ordered that was missing. The lady behind me in the queue, who was earwigging, said she was a gp receptionist and it must be my fault for ordering the wrong drugs. It is gaslighting and it is infuriating.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 15/11/2023 20:25

How about you just don't collect the prescriptions until you need them then, regardless of when the pharmacy makes them up for you?

Tried that once because I had three weeks' left and had a bunch of long days at work where I'd be nowhere near the Pharmacy between 8am and 10pm.

'You didn't collect after a week so we sent the prescription back to the GP. You'll have to make an appointment to see them to get another prescription now'.

I didn't have a message to say that it was waiting for me, either.

rasellagirl · 15/11/2023 20:21

Boots online stock checker is very helpful

RosesAndHellebores · 15/11/2023 20:11

Nice bit of ageism there @melj1213 . I suppose it doesn't apply to pregnant women or those on universal credit? I'm over 60. I don't waste mine or any institution's funds. I do however take exception at the NHS and its constituent parts that perpetually waste the money with which I and millions of others fund it.

@C8H10N4O2 well said.

C8H10N4O2 · 15/11/2023 17:31

melj1213 · 15/11/2023 16:33

Oh I have not doubt that that was the case, and you can't control what people do with their meds once we dispense them but I have to say that the vast majority of "wasted" medication is returned by over 60s who do not pay for prescriptions, where they just keep reordering things they don't need or won't take. Perhaps it's because they don't see the cost of the waste since their prescriptions are free so they don't realise just how much money is lost for every medication they take without using?

You never get someone just ordering meds they are never going to use when they have to pay for their prescriptions at £9.65 per item, in fact I often get people who pay for prescriptions come to pick them up and ask us to take items off because they don't need it and don't want to pay for it, or where the item dispensed is cheaper to just buy OTC - for example there was a 30yo prescribed 56 ferrous sulphate tablets at a cost of £9.65 for the prescription charge ... You can buy a bottle of 60 of the exact same thing OTC for £3.10 so she opted to pay £3.10 instead of £9.65, but why didn't the GP just tell her to buy them in the first place?

The amount of medicine wasted by that one person was about £3k worth, all in, from the last couple of years. That's £3k that the NHS paid for medicine that was never going to be used, and potentially meant that someone else who actually needed the medication, and would take it, was left short/waiting and that's just one person, multiply that by how many others who are doing the same and the NHS would save millions on waste alone.

Oh come on, patients are often encouraged to tick the box for automated prescription management by both pharmacists and GP practices which encourages build up of drugs, especially in older and more vulnerable patients who will often assume the doctor/pharmacist knows best.

These threads always go the same way. Multiple posters self describing as part of the system - be it as medics, pharmacists or admin all "explain" how it works, all explain something different because there are massive variations depending on where, when and who you are. There are variations in what should happen and actual practice.

The net result is the same though - somehow its always the patients in the wrong. The system is just dysfunctional if it creates so much waste and so many problems for patients and staff alike.

Nobody is winning here on any side of the situation and blaming problems on stupid patients isn't going to fix anything, its just going to perpetuate waste and problems for all parties.

JustCheckingforMe · 15/11/2023 17:25

I am really careful to only order the repeats I actually need. I still get items I didn't order and not the ones I did order. It all seems very disorganised. Even if I carefully open the bag on the counter in the pharmacy, they cannot take anything back. I wish I could get it organised to get 56 days worth of everything, all on the same day, but it seems impossible. My consultant has just prescribed a new painkiller and I am trying to figure out how to co- ordinate things so I don't end up with another repeat date.

melj1213 · 15/11/2023 16:33

coffeeaddict77 · 15/11/2023 12:32

She presumably didn't want her GP to know that she wasn't taking the medicines. It is difficult to prevent that.

Oh I have not doubt that that was the case, and you can't control what people do with their meds once we dispense them but I have to say that the vast majority of "wasted" medication is returned by over 60s who do not pay for prescriptions, where they just keep reordering things they don't need or won't take. Perhaps it's because they don't see the cost of the waste since their prescriptions are free so they don't realise just how much money is lost for every medication they take without using?

You never get someone just ordering meds they are never going to use when they have to pay for their prescriptions at £9.65 per item, in fact I often get people who pay for prescriptions come to pick them up and ask us to take items off because they don't need it and don't want to pay for it, or where the item dispensed is cheaper to just buy OTC - for example there was a 30yo prescribed 56 ferrous sulphate tablets at a cost of £9.65 for the prescription charge ... You can buy a bottle of 60 of the exact same thing OTC for £3.10 so she opted to pay £3.10 instead of £9.65, but why didn't the GP just tell her to buy them in the first place?

The amount of medicine wasted by that one person was about £3k worth, all in, from the last couple of years. That's £3k that the NHS paid for medicine that was never going to be used, and potentially meant that someone else who actually needed the medication, and would take it, was left short/waiting and that's just one person, multiply that by how many others who are doing the same and the NHS would save millions on waste alone.

JustCheckingforMe · 15/11/2023 12:59

Riverlee · 15/11/2023 12:08

Pharmacists dispense the prescription that’s sent to them. They don’t usually deviate. If they’re not happy with the dose, they should speak to the gp first.

This isn't the pharmacist in the chemist. This is a phamacist in the surgery who will create the prescription and send it to the dispensing chemist up the road. I dont think the gp is involved.

coffeeaddict77 · 15/11/2023 12:32

melj1213 · 15/11/2023 10:58

And yet people still do it by requesting prescriptions for things they no longer take, knowing they will not take it. It always shocks me when people bring items back from elderly relatives who have passed away/gone into a care or nursing home, at the sheer volume of items especially when it's the same thing that has been dispensed again and again but never actually taken.

One lady came in a few weeks ago with three Tesco bags for life full of medication for disposal that they had removed from her elderly aunt's house when she went into a care home. There were hundreds of boxes of the same item, diligently dispensed on a 2 monthly basis (based on the dates on the dispensing stickers) going back 2.5 years, none of which had been opened but all of which had to be destroyed. This lady was not on repeat dispensing but was just requesting all of the medications on her repeat request list every 2 months, like clockwork, but then only taking 2/3 out of the 7 medications she requested ... She actively had to request those medications from her GP, yet knew she wasn't taking them, which not only wasted the items but also wasted the GP and pharmacy's time processing and fulfilling prescriptions she was never going to use.

She presumably didn't want her GP to know that she wasn't taking the medicines. It is difficult to prevent that.

Riverlee · 15/11/2023 12:08

JustCheckingforMe · 15/11/2023 07:51

I got my phone call (from the practice pharmacist) to negotiate my prescription and managed to get an agreement for the required amount. I will have to see what is in the bag when I get there.
I am on vagifem pessaries and my gynae told me that I can use 3 per week because my symptoms were so severe. This is written in my notes.
The (male) pharmacist has decided I can't have sufficient for that so is only giving me enough for 2 per week.
I have never met this person and I am not comfortable going into the detail of my problems. Luckily I can probably buy a box of Gina now that it is available OTC. It is yet another thing to have to work around.

Pharmacists dispense the prescription that’s sent to them. They don’t usually deviate. If they’re not happy with the dose, they should speak to the gp first.

melj1213 · 15/11/2023 11:56

RosesAndHellebores · 15/11/2023 11:07

@melj1213 because the oharmacy has a notice up saying that if prescriptions are not collected within 7 days they will be sent back. I imagine there will then be a massive Ball ache getting it sorted again with more work for the GP.

It isn't my job to make the system work but it is a reasonable expectation that it does work and works efficiently. So much time is being wasted.

I imagine the issue of the three bags above related to an elderly lady who didn't understand what she was doing. A prime example of where a F2F appointment with a proactive GP would have helped.

They don't send them back to the GP though so they will not need to do anything, they send them back to "The Spine" which is essentially the Cloud for prescriptions. You "imagine" there to be a lot more problems than there actually are because you have no idea how the system works and are basing your opinions of the entire system based on, what sounds like, one very dysfunctional pharmacy.

This just means that the prescription is undispensed from that specific pharmacy and returned to the system so any other pharmacy can dispense it if they want.

So if your pharmacy returns things after 7days then all that would happen is that after a week the prescription goes back the Spine and they undispense the physical item in their store but the prescription is still available for either them, or any other pharmacy, to re-dispense at any point before it expires 6 months after issue.

RosesAndHellebores · 15/11/2023 11:07

@melj1213 because the oharmacy has a notice up saying that if prescriptions are not collected within 7 days they will be sent back. I imagine there will then be a massive Ball ache getting it sorted again with more work for the GP.

It isn't my job to make the system work but it is a reasonable expectation that it does work and works efficiently. So much time is being wasted.

I imagine the issue of the three bags above related to an elderly lady who didn't understand what she was doing. A prime example of where a F2F appointment with a proactive GP would have helped.