Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think GPs should be able to check medication availability

342 replies

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 10:11

I'm absolutely fed up of ordering medication to turn up at the pharmacy to be told the manufacturer is out of stock.

If they have access to the system why isn't the GP checking this and prescribing the alternative? Surely machine learning/AI would help here or are the systems not integrated?

I mean in the whole era of technical progression why are we running between Boots and the GP to get things re-prescribed?

For context this has happened with my HRT, my DD14 ADHD medication, antibiotics etc etc over the last three months.

AIBU to expect an integrated supply approach to prescriptions?

OP posts:
jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 11:59

@Peablockfeathers pharmaceutical companies don't own all the pharmaceutical research companies but they have a federated way of working.

Just like manufacturing does.

Technically I'd like to understand why there isn't more efficiency when I see way more efficient ways of working in different sectors.

Is this just funding and lack of will to change. I think it probably is.

OP posts:
Didoreththeterf · 12/11/2023 11:57

The problem really isn't with NHS IT systems.
The problem is with the supply of the medication.

I presume it is because of Covid and/or Brexit, but its only over the last few years that commonly used medications have been increasingly unavailable.

Investment in publicly owned manufacture of generic pharmaceuticals to ensure continuity of supply would be a more effective solution than fannying about with IT systems to track the shortages.

Sceptre86 · 12/11/2023 11:54

Your understanding of pharmacy is poor. GPS do receive lists of medication that is out of stock longterm. Other shortages can change almost daily. @BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn has explained it really well.

Peablockfeathers · 12/11/2023 11:54

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 11:39

@Peablockfeathers

You don't need to integrate all systems they just need to federate or share data points.

Ask yourself why other industries are way more efficient.

We have this weird need to get protective about the NHS I too want to see it thrive but the way it operates is a waste. It creates stress, not just for the users but for the employees too.

My pharmacist is lovely, he's exhausted and could barely talk yesterday. It's a mess.

GP surgeries and pharmacies aren't run by the NHS is the glaring point you're missing.

CormorantStrikesBack · 12/11/2023 11:54

I mean I guess the govt could buy all the pharmacies if they wanted and make them all nhs. But seeing as the govt are going in the opposite direction and privatisation of various nhs depts and services I can’t see it happening

melj1213 · 12/11/2023 11:52

ExtraOnions · 12/11/2023 11:18

Our surgery has an in-house pharmacy. It’s hopeless

You’ll get what you need less than half the time .. the suppliers have it, they just don’t have any “in stock” and needs to be ordered in for the next day. This isn’t just a one off .. I was there last week where someone needed the medicine urgently for her brother who had terminal cancer, told her it would be next day (hopefully), she made a bit of a fuss .. and (surprise surprise) they found some round the back.

The whole place is filled with bags waiting to go out, and still seems to run on paper

This clearly shows a total lack of understanding of how pharmacies work.

Pharmacies cannot hold infinite amounts of infinite supplies of infinite medications that could possibly be prescribed on any given day "just in case".

Therefore we hold larger amounts of stock of the most common lines - amitriptyline, atorvastatin, amoxicillin, flucloxacillin, bisoprolol, omeprazole, penicillin, prednisolone, metformin, co-codamol, naproxen etc - and smaller amounts of other drugs we use often but not necessarily daily to ensure that we aren't wasting it (eg due to it expiring before it gets dispensed) but even on "fast line" items there can be a rush on them at certain times so we just don't have the stock that day but, unless it's a Saturday, the pharmacy I work in gets daily deliveries whereby as long as we order an item before 7pm it will be with us by 5pm the following day.

I work in a pharmacy within a supermarket, in the evenings (after 5pm) and at weekends there is only us and another supermarket pharmacy on the other side of town who are open, so we get every prescription from the OOH centre and/or everyone coming in after work or on Saturday with a paper prescription because it is most convenient. Unfortunately if we only have 20 boxes of flucloxacillin and 21 people are prescribed it at the OOH centre, the last person either has to go elsewhere or wait until the following day when our next delivery will arrive. We can't just magic medicine up from nowhere, we aren't pharmacists from the 19th Century who mixed up their own concoctions on site.

In the case of the person in your example, it might be that they didn't have anything sitting on the shelf but they had an item that had been dispensed for someone else but they made the decision that her need was greater and/or hedged their bets that the other person wouldn't come in for the medication that day (either due to the time or because it had been sitting waiting to be collected for a few days/weeks/months) and essentially took it off the other person to give to her. This is not best practice and sometimes even palliative care medication isn't time critical and can wait 24hrs but if not then the pharmacist will make an informed decision as to the best course of action to take, which may be taking medication from one person to give to another because they are physically there at the moment.

Of course the pharmacy is filled with bags and runs on paper - we get hundreds of electronic prescriptions sent to us each day to fulfil (as well as the walk ins, referrals, private prescriptions, online doctor orders etc) and we have to print out the prescription, put it in a basket with the items we have physically taken off the shelves as per the prescription, dispense them on the computer system, have a dispenser check the information on the sticker matches the item it is being attached to and then have the item checked by the pharmacist before they sign off to hand out. If someone isn't waiting to collect it there and then we have to file them away for collection and the easiest way to do so is to put it on a numbered shelf and then write the number on the prescription and file it away until someone comes to collect it. There's no way we could do this if every prescription was only available on a screen as opposed to a physical piece of paper that we can take to each location and can only be in one person's possession at any one time.

We also need there to be a physical prescription (or token) as prescriptions are legal documents so we have to have them for the items to be checked off and for the patient to fill in the back of with their exemption/payment and signature. We also have to physically send prescriptions to the NHS at the end of the month so we can be paid correctly for the items we have dispensed.

CormorantStrikesBack · 12/11/2023 11:52

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 11:47

You are just making my case for me here. In my industry we have to have background checks etc too. It's still 20 days.

But the NHS doesn’t do the checks themselves. It’s the DBS service. Which is not controlled by the NHS. So either your industry isn’t doing DBS checks as their background check(so won’t be as thorough) , or it takes longer than 20 days (on average).

the hold up with the dbs checks is normally at the police force vetting stage. So maybe they should be quicker. 🤷🏻‍♀️. But then they don’t get enough funding to employ more dbs check staff. But it’s not the nhs fault.

as for the original question. All the pharmacies are private companies. Lots of different firms. The GP doesn’t have access to their stock control.

Chersfrozenface · 12/11/2023 11:48

Do you think supermarkets, medical research, logistics work like this? No, they don't.

Supermarket logistics work on the basis of separate chains.

If your local Asda doesn:t have Heinz beans in stock, its system can't tell you whether the Tesco up the road has them.

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 11:47

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 12/11/2023 11:44

For a new employee in the NHS to actually be able to work from offer to being on site. 6 months.

In my industry its 20 days.

The NHS could be faster, but I doubt you're comparing like with like. Many NHS employees will be on 3-month notice contracts. Many need DBS checks, health checks, vaccination checks - if they don't already have up to date Hep B, for example, the vaccination schedule for that alone is considerably over 20 days.

You are just making my case for me here. In my industry we have to have background checks etc too. It's still 20 days.

OP posts:
jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 11:46

NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/11/2023 11:42

I wouldn't particularly like AI getting within a country mile of prescriptions. It would go from a stock check to making prescribing decisions (and refusals) without a trained human's involvement.

No. It was just mean the alert is sent to the GO as they approve so they can intervene and make an alternative prescription rather than us running between pharmacy and GP.

How do you think fraud alerts are created in banking? It's AI/ML and been around for years.

OP posts:
BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 12/11/2023 11:44

For a new employee in the NHS to actually be able to work from offer to being on site. 6 months.

In my industry its 20 days.

The NHS could be faster, but I doubt you're comparing like with like. Many NHS employees will be on 3-month notice contracts. Many need DBS checks, health checks, vaccination checks - if they don't already have up to date Hep B, for example, the vaccination schedule for that alone is considerably over 20 days.

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 11:44

@Musicaltheatremum wow!! That's shocking. I mean it's an indication of how mad it is when I got excited about automatic transmission of prescriptions where I live.

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 12/11/2023 11:42

I wouldn't particularly like AI getting within a country mile of prescriptions. It would go from a stock check to making prescribing decisions (and refusals) without a trained human's involvement.

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 11:42

GRex · 12/11/2023 11:38

It isn't practical to integrate stock across all privately owned pharmacies. In spring my GP warned me a particular antibiotic may be out of stock, and asked what pharmacy I use, then said he'd have admin check stock and he would put through the prescription for whatever it was the pharmacy had, so wait until after X time to pick up. A time before that when something ran out the pharmacy checked systems and said we could collect from X place or ask the GP to issue Y, we decided to just collect from the other place. Stocks running out aren't ideal, but it happens, best thing is to just stay calm and ask for help from the pharmacist and GP to find you some solution that will work.

I'm sorry but this is not a solution.

This is a sticking plaster.

Other industries are way more efficient.

We need to stop making excuses. The government need to invest in a better more federated way of working across the NHS, GPs and pharmacies.

Do you think supermarkets, medical research, logistics work like this? No, they don't.

OP posts:
OddBoots · 12/11/2023 11:40

I get the whole GPs and pharmacy being outside of the NHS but if there are alerts about national shortages (rather than local stock) then there MUST be a way for that info to be added to Spine (as we have learned it is called) so the GP can see that when they click on the medication to prescribe it.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 12/11/2023 11:40

You’ll get what you need less than half the time .. the suppliers have it, they just don’t have any “in stock” and needs to be ordered in for the next day.

Have you any idea how many thousands of medicines there are? All in multiple.doses and formulations and pack sizes? Many with short shelf lives. They cannot possibly keep everything in stock all the time just in case it's needed.

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 11:39

@Peablockfeathers

You don't need to integrate all systems they just need to federate or share data points.

Ask yourself why other industries are way more efficient.

We have this weird need to get protective about the NHS I too want to see it thrive but the way it operates is a waste. It creates stress, not just for the users but for the employees too.

My pharmacist is lovely, he's exhausted and could barely talk yesterday. It's a mess.

OP posts:
GRex · 12/11/2023 11:38

It isn't practical to integrate stock across all privately owned pharmacies. In spring my GP warned me a particular antibiotic may be out of stock, and asked what pharmacy I use, then said he'd have admin check stock and he would put through the prescription for whatever it was the pharmacy had, so wait until after X time to pick up. A time before that when something ran out the pharmacy checked systems and said we could collect from X place or ask the GP to issue Y, we decided to just collect from the other place. Stocks running out aren't ideal, but it happens, best thing is to just stay calm and ask for help from the pharmacist and GP to find you some solution that will work.

Musicaltheatremum · 12/11/2023 11:38

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 11:29

So many people on here having a hard time with this, I'm so sorry!

Yes I've written to my MP about it, but he's an idiot with absolutely no profile.

I'm coming at this from 25 years in the tech industry. It is absolutely resolvable they just chose not to.

I will give you a different view on this, it takes on average the NHS about 80 days to onboard a new employee often its a lot more, often 120 days. That's 20 ish working days a month. So 6 months. For a new employee in the NHS to actually be able to work from offer to being on site. 6 months.

In my industry its 20 days.

It's just another reflection on just how inefficient it is.

All this inefficiency impacts us every single day and I'm sick of it.

No political party will fix this, they never have.

Couldn't agree more. I've just retired from general practice. In Scotland we don't even have electronic transfer of scripts to the pharmacy so gas to be collected. The infrastructure is there but the government (SNP) isn't switching it on. Even COVID didn't improve things. It's a disaster

Peablockfeathers · 12/11/2023 11:32

Ironically I'm not sure it's others failing to grasp this. NHS IT systems are separate to both GP and pharmacy systems, to be fully integrated you'd have to make GP surgeries and pharmacies part of the NHS (not private businesses contracted out). I don't think anyone is going to argue about how efficient the systems are, nor that it would be nice and make life easier if this could happen; but people are explaining why it can't (save for serious serious investment and fundamental changes to how the services are all run).

jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 11:31

Peablockfeathers · 12/11/2023 11:26

But even if something was in stock on an imaginary system, someone else could go in with their prescription and deplete it. If pharmacies were state owned along with GPs then sure something could be put in place. The real issue is the affect of (mainly) Brexit which is leading to chronic shortages.

It's not just Brexit. I just gave a different process/example.

It's the NHS systems and the lack of integration. Disgraceful.

OP posts:
jeaux90 · 12/11/2023 11:29

So many people on here having a hard time with this, I'm so sorry!

Yes I've written to my MP about it, but he's an idiot with absolutely no profile.

I'm coming at this from 25 years in the tech industry. It is absolutely resolvable they just chose not to.

I will give you a different view on this, it takes on average the NHS about 80 days to onboard a new employee often its a lot more, often 120 days. That's 20 ish working days a month. So 6 months. For a new employee in the NHS to actually be able to work from offer to being on site. 6 months.

In my industry its 20 days.

It's just another reflection on just how inefficient it is.

All this inefficiency impacts us every single day and I'm sick of it.

No political party will fix this, they never have.

OP posts:
Peablockfeathers · 12/11/2023 11:26

But even if something was in stock on an imaginary system, someone else could go in with their prescription and deplete it. If pharmacies were state owned along with GPs then sure something could be put in place. The real issue is the affect of (mainly) Brexit which is leading to chronic shortages.

coffeeaddict77 · 12/11/2023 11:22

They do often get alerts on their system if the manufacturer states that there is a national shortage but Pharmacies are not part of the nhs so there is no way a GP it system will have access to individual pharmacy computers.

IrresponsiblyCertainAboutSexualDimorphism · 12/11/2023 11:21

Coyoacan · 12/11/2023 11:19

Does anyone know why the manufacturers cannot seem to provide much demanded medicines?

Brexit. Also knock on effects of COVID (and in one case an earthquake I think) on manufacturers of the raw ingredients in India, China and other places.