Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He smokes but won’t stop, we have a baby

106 replies

Pinkiesaurus · 12/11/2023 00:14

My boyfriends smoking has got to me, it never did when it was just us two (I didn’t care about my health probably because I fell for him and knew he smoked it didn’t bother me), but now we have a baby. I’m noticing it way more. He always smokes outside but now with colder weather as soon as he opens back door after smoking I can smell it, I can also smell the smoke off him in bed. I have told him it’s horrible! I know that sounds harsh. But I’m really not liking the smell of fags.

At new year when baby was born he was the one that brought it up he needed to stop smoking, look into but he never did. There has been few times I’ve said to him and reminded him of that he said that. I mention that for babys sake, along with his health. He keeps telling me it’s an addiction!
he has made no effort to try and my mum said he needs to be the one to decide otherwise he’ll do it more (dig heels in)
at the hospital he was encouraged to wash hands after everytime he went out and he still does this before handling baby and takes coat off, but still worry. Am I being unreasonable ? As know there is woman who smoke in pregnancy and vape etc. also probably so many do! (Partners) and maybe even worse things out there!
i just don’t know how I can make him stop or just accept or what to do!

OP posts:
Whiteday · 12/11/2023 19:12

Thepeopleversuswork · 12/11/2023 19:10

@Whiteday

But he didn't and you went ahead and had children with him? Why?

How do you feel about him having the ability to smoke closer to your children now?

Did you have more than one child with him? Did you not think that he hadn't given up with child one, so why bring another into the equation?

I think it's really odd to expect meeting someone and they'll change because you want them to?

Well, shoot me, I made a mistake as a young woman. He promised me when we got married that he'd stop smoking. We were in love and I thought we wanted the same things and I could trust him. He didn't stop, I divorced him (this wasn't the only reason, btw, there were a whole host of unhealthy behaviours but this was one of several dealbreakers). Given where I was, I'm not sure what else I could have done? I took responsibility and took matters into my own hands.

He doesn't have any residence rights with my DD, she resides only with me. She sees him roughly once a month and he never smokes in her presence. No I didn't have another child with him. And no I don't have to apologise for every step of my life to you.

As an aside, people always talk about "smokers" in a very black and white way as if they are condemned to be smokers for life. People always talk about smokers on these threads as if they were heroin addicts who will never quit and you have to just lump it. But the reality is most people do quit. I quit from a 20 a day smoking habit. The vast majority of my contemporaries smoked when we were in our 20s and now almost no-one I know smokes.

You can't always screen out absolutely anything which has the potential to be problematic decades hence. Life isn't like that. You sound a bit like the women on these "My Nigel" threads when someone berates an OP for not having chosen the right man when she was in her 20s.

All you can do is have hard lines which you enforce when it comes to your children and own the decision to remove someone from your life if they don't meet your standards.

Why did you say before we had " kids" plural?

Odd!

Teateaandmoretea · 12/11/2023 19:59

Thepeopleversuswork · 12/11/2023 17:14

@Teateaandmoretea

I'm far from perfect and I have plenty of vices but smoking when you have an asthmatic kid (one who has been hospitalised multiple times for asthma) is bad parenting. There's no grey area there, sorry.

Why are you ‘sorry’?

The pp was basically saying you can’t have kids and smoke. You can. I don’t smoke fwiw, but it doesn’t make you an incapable parent.

Where did the asthma come from? In the eyes of social services the parent would still be ‘good enough’. But you’ve added in the asthma.

Thepeopleversuswork · 12/11/2023 20:12

@Whiteday

Why did you say before we had " kids" plural?

I don't know tbh it was a throwaway line to indicate the period before becoming a mother. I only have one kid.

Thepeopleversuswork · 12/11/2023 20:19

@Teateaandmoretea

The pp was basically saying you can’t have kids and smoke. You can. I don’t smoke fwiw, but it doesn’t make you an incapable parent.

Where did the asthma come from? In the eyes of social services the parent would still be ‘good enough’. But you’ve added in the asthma.

Smoking if you have an asthmatic child is a huge red flag to any medical professionals. My DD has chronic asthma and at every medical appointment I've ever had relating to this a GP or nurse has asked if she exposed to smoke (either primary or second hand). The asthma "journey" has been a total nightmare, it's resulted in hundreds of outpatient appointments and trips to A&E and still not really resolved and every time she has a cold I know I'm possibly facing weeks of medical appointments, trips to A&E etc. I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy and any parent who continued to smoke in this situation would be contributing to a high risk environment for their child and it's unforgivable IMHO.

My ex knew all this, berated me about failing to find solutions to her asthma (it was always my responsibility, see) and still never did anything to stop smoking.

Yes you're correct that this probably wouldn't be sufficient to trigger social services involvement but given how many children live with abusive or neglectful parents because SS don't have the resources to deal with them this is hardly a ringing endorsement.

So yeah I am pretty hardline on this. You have kids, you stop smoking.

Teateaandmoretea · 12/11/2023 20:57

You can be ‘hardline’ on it all you like. But it’s your opinion no more or less. I m sure there’s something that you do that others disagree with.

KaylaDetmer · 13/11/2023 10:49

But it is socially accepted to get pissed?!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page