Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unfair to eldest child?

35 replies

nettle86 · 11/11/2023 15:35

I have dd(8) ds(5) and dd(2). We settled away from my family (think an hour on plane or 8 hour drive and ferry) so now with the 3 kids we only go to my home town once a year (but my parents visit once or twice too).

Last November my best friend back home had a baby and I took both my dd's back for a long weekend. DS didn't want to go and was happy to have a daddy weekend. It was great as bonfire night and my older dd had never seen a big firework display.

This year my ds has asked to go for the weekend as his birthday treat in Jan, he wants to have a sleepover at my dad's (he has a jacuzzi and a puppy lol) and my dad is happy to pay, it's about £100 but that would be a big expense for us with Christmas coming up too. We will be back for his actual birthday.

I'd love to do this, with 3 children and him the middle child he often gets overlooked, 2year old is understandably taking a lot of time and dd1 has had lots of special days out etc over the years. However dd1 is upset and says its not fair as ds had the chance to go last year and turned it down so she should get the choice this year.

For context we did go back home for a fortnight as a family over the summer, my mum is just back from a weekend visit and my dad is coming for Christmas so it's not like she hasn't seen them recently.

I'm feeling guilty about leaving both the girls (I work full time) and her reaction is just making it worse, or should I just give ds the weekend he wants and dd1 will have to accept it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MargaretThursday · 11/11/2023 18:55

If next birthday she wants that, and you'll be happy to do it, then it'll be fine. If you're already doing excuses in your head as to why she can't have it, then I don't think you should do it for him.

But I can see her point. She went with her little 2yo sister. I'll be surprised if most of your concentration wasn't on the 2yo because 2yos need that. Or maybe you say to her "can you help...?"

You certainly can't say because she was at Centre Parks it's fair unless it was only you and her at Centre parks.

One of the issues I've found is that with 3dc the oldest can be left to get on a bit on their own. It's also possible she would have loved to ask for that, but thought that she couldn't because you had the younger two to think about. I've certainly had conversations with my oldest (now an adult) where she had made assumptions that it wasn't possible, so never asked. The younger two (well, the middle one especially) is a ask-for-two-ice-creams-before breakfast type on the basis that if you don't ask, then you don't get.

I also wonder whether the "special days over the years" is before she had siblings, or when they were too young to realise? It's not the same taking the one and only, as leaving some behind.

And also this: You run the risk of creating a situation where DS gets to do single activities with either parent and your DDs get lumped together, they are not the same experience.

I'm one of three, 2 girls and a boy, and me and dsis got lumped together in all sorts despite us being very very different in pretty much everything.
Presents: get the girls something identical/together (if one of us liked it the other generally wasn't interested) and the boy something different.
Take the girls to this together/boy to something different.
The girls can do this job together/not fair to ask the boy to do something on his own.
Most of the time dsis would have preferred what dbro got/did, but it was never given as an option.

Fair certainly isn't always equal, but you need to ask yourself how equal is it actually. Does she ever get time just with you?
And sometimes we can lean ourselves over backwards to make sure it's fair and not notice that actually it's unfair the other way.

UsingChangeofName · 11/11/2023 18:23

5128gap · 11/11/2023 16:25

My rule of thumb would be to never be persuaded out of doing something lovely for one for fear of putting another's nose out of joint. For one thing, it's not good to indulge mean spirited 'it's not fair' thinking (provided you're comfortable you are fair) and for another, it just leads to a whole other problem when one realises the other has been the cause of the nice thing not happening.

Completely agree with this

AllosaurusMum · 11/11/2023 18:23

So you have no intention of taking Dd1 on a special 1:1 trip for her birthday? Just to be clear. It very much seems like you're playing favorites. The centreparcs trip isn't comparable because it was a family trip. Last years trip wasn't for her either. You were going and took the kids with you. Ds just chose not to go. The fact that dd1 had a good time is irrelevant.

UsingChangeofName · 11/11/2023 18:22

ItsADoggieDogWorld · 11/11/2023 16:43

You seem to be worrying more about your daughter complaining with the age old 'it isn't fair'. Why aren't you more worried that your son has asked for this special treat for his birthday. Why should his treat be compromised? Your daughter sounds a bit spoiled tbh. It's his birthday and this is what he's asked for. Just like she got what she asked for for her birthday. When you have several children, sometimes treats are at different times, and children need to learn that.

This is what I was going to say.

Don't teach your dd that she can a) get what she wants and b) spoil things for her brother by wailing "It's not fair". That's just setting everyone up to be miserable for the next 20 years.

saffronsoup · 11/11/2023 16:55

I think it will be hard for her at her age to understand why it is only DS that you want to take away alone on a trip. That you don’t think she deserves the same. It seems that both the holiday park trip and last years trips were with her siblings.

Not everything has to be exactly the same but it does seem you are showing some favouritism in who you enjoy spending time alone with.

ItsADoggieDogWorld · 11/11/2023 16:43

You seem to be worrying more about your daughter complaining with the age old 'it isn't fair'. Why aren't you more worried that your son has asked for this special treat for his birthday. Why should his treat be compromised? Your daughter sounds a bit spoiled tbh. It's his birthday and this is what he's asked for. Just like she got what she asked for for her birthday. When you have several children, sometimes treats are at different times, and children need to learn that.

TomatoSandwiches · 11/11/2023 16:37

@nettle86 I hope she enjoys that, and your son has a great birthday, good luck.

nettle86 · 11/11/2023 16:34

TomatoSandwiches · 11/11/2023 16:27

Can your 2yr old go to someone else so your DD can have 1 on 1 time with her father.
It is hard to balance 3 children's needs and wants, but it sounds like your DD feels there is an unfair balance and I would listen to that, it's all well and good saying she's had lots of special days over the years but of course she would, she's the eldest.
You run the risk of creating a situation where DS gets to do single activities with either parent and your DDs get lumped together, they are not the same experience.

Do you know what I think you might have given me an idea! Tbh I don't think she'd be that impressed with 1:1 with her dad for the weekend (he's sah dad so they get plenty of time) but his parents live close and she'd love a couple of days with them by herself, so I could offer her that.

OP posts:
Britneyfan · 11/11/2023 16:28

I think it’s fine to take DS alone for his birthday as long as you’d do the same for her if that’s what she wants to do in her birthday. She is comparing this trip with the previous one but they’re different things and I think you just have to point that out to her, one was a general family trip and this is his birthday treat. It would be different if you were planning another general family trip and deliberately excluding her.

The other option is to turn this into a general family trip and invite everyone along, using DS’s birthday as the reason/occasion for the trip, but it sounds like that would be currently unaffordable. It is difficult though as I can understand a kid feeling that it’s unfair that one sibling gets to hang out with grandparents and they can’t when they’d like to go too.

TomatoSandwiches · 11/11/2023 16:27

Can your 2yr old go to someone else so your DD can have 1 on 1 time with her father.
It is hard to balance 3 children's needs and wants, but it sounds like your DD feels there is an unfair balance and I would listen to that, it's all well and good saying she's had lots of special days over the years but of course she would, she's the eldest.
You run the risk of creating a situation where DS gets to do single activities with either parent and your DDs get lumped together, they are not the same experience.

5128gap · 11/11/2023 16:25

My rule of thumb would be to never be persuaded out of doing something lovely for one for fear of putting another's nose out of joint. For one thing, it's not good to indulge mean spirited 'it's not fair' thinking (provided you're comfortable you are fair) and for another, it just leads to a whole other problem when one realises the other has been the cause of the nice thing not happening.

nettle86 · 11/11/2023 16:24

Hankunamatata · 11/11/2023 16:20

Will ds mind if dd goes? Do they play together? Do they get on? Is she the type to hog grandparents attention?

They get on well but he has asked for this to be a special trip for him.

With him being only 5 though I could probably convince him bringing dd would be a good idea though.

OP posts:
DisforDarkChocolate · 11/11/2023 16:20

I think if you don't let him have this it won't be fair on him. There is nothing stopping your daughter asking for the same for her birthday?

Hankunamatata · 11/11/2023 16:20

Will ds mind if dd goes? Do they play together? Do they get on? Is she the type to hog grandparents attention?

DinaofCloud9 · 11/11/2023 16:18

It's his birthday treat.

nettle86 · 11/11/2023 16:18

I do think she has a point which is why I'm asking, I had the tickets for the two of us in the basket and decided to post this thread instead.

As to last year it was a very big treat for her. My best friend is also her god mother and she was so excited to see the baby and we had lots of special times.

OP posts:
StarlightLime · 11/11/2023 16:16

nettle86 · 11/11/2023 16:12

Yes of course, although she just had one so will have to wait a while which she's struggling with. She went to build a bear and a "yes day" for her last birthday so perhaps not on the same scale but was very happy with it. I also pointed out to her for her 6th birthday (which what ds will be) we were on holiday in centre parcs.

The whole family were in Centreparcs, presumably? What difference does that make? It was hardly a birthday treat specially for her?

SecondUsername4me · 11/11/2023 16:15

Just take her and ds. Leave the 2yo with dad.

Redditchcycler · 11/11/2023 16:14

nettle86 · 11/11/2023 16:12

Yes of course, although she just had one so will have to wait a while which she's struggling with. She went to build a bear and a "yes day" for her last birthday so perhaps not on the same scale but was very happy with it. I also pointed out to her for her 6th birthday (which what ds will be) we were on holiday in centre parcs.

But a family holiday is not a special treat for her birthday surely ? Unless it was just you and her ?

nettle86 · 11/11/2023 16:12

Yes of course, although she just had one so will have to wait a while which she's struggling with. She went to build a bear and a "yes day" for her last birthday so perhaps not on the same scale but was very happy with it. I also pointed out to her for her 6th birthday (which what ds will be) we were on holiday in centre parcs.

OP posts:
FieldInWhichFucksAreGrownIsBarren · 11/11/2023 16:09

I think she's right, he was offered the opportunity last year and declined -she isn't being offered the chance to turn it down is she? Your son chose not to go, she should get the opportunity to either go or get her own 1:1 trip.

saffronsoup · 11/11/2023 16:08

Last years trip was not a treat for her. You went back to see a friend took your kids. This year you are making this trip a treat for one child but not the others.

I agree with your daughter. This isn’t fair.

SMTWTFS · 11/11/2023 16:06

I agree with your DD. Not fair to just take 1 child. He chose to stay home last year.

Aturtleatemysandwich · 11/11/2023 16:04

Depends - ok she had to share her trip last autumn with her toddler sister, but are the special days out 1:1? Each child should have some 1:1 time, so I don’t think she should go on her brother’s trip but I do think it’s fair to offer her a similar trip for her birthday. And to do the same for the youngest in due course.

UsingChangeofName · 11/11/2023 16:03

Not 100% sure which way the vote is.? I clicked YANBU meaning YANBU to to go.

I think YABU to think it is unfair.

Over the years there will be lots of opportunities presented to one child and not another. As parents you do the best for them at that time and in those circumstances. Being fair to each of them doesn't mean doing or giving the same thing to each of them at the same time.

Last time it was dd1's turn to go. This year it is ds's turn to go.