Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our first house purchase should be our forever home?

57 replies

heydorothy · 11/11/2023 14:16

There’s hardly any flats available near where we live. I know 20 years ago-10 years ago even, it made sense for people to buy small and build lots of equity then move up the ladder to somewhere bigger etc. It just doesn’t seem practical now.

House prices are stagnating now but obviously still very high. I wouldn’t say they’re gaining value like before at all. We have our deposit but renting currently as it is cheaper to do so while interest rates are sky high. When we do move, we’ll have our first DC to think about too.

AIBU to look for no less than a 3 bed / buy as big as we can afford to? I am neurodivergent and moving frequently causes me stress and it would be nice to just put down roots somewhere that feels permanent enough. We could buy a two bed but then we would likely have to move again, fork out for another set of legal fees and stamp duty.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
StepUpSlowly · 11/11/2023 23:09

I think most people think that way, OP, so I don’t think you are unreasonable, it’s more that most people can’t afford to buy their forever home from the get go otherwise most would.

Personally, I own a 3-bedroom place, but my main criteria buying it was that I wanted to either be mortgage-free or have a mortgage I could easily pay back and ideally quickly (honestly I dislike debt and so the idea of a 30 year mortgage that would be dependent on me always earning similar amounts, just made me really uncomfortable). Thankfully, I bought in a place where housing is fairly affordable and where buying a 3 bedroom place could actually be cheaper than buying a 1-bedroom or 2-bedroom (it’s not London. But think of the cost of buying a 2-bedroom flat in central London vs 3 bedroom in London Zone 3 or 4. Except in my case it would be the choice between buying a studio on the sea front vs a 3 bedroom place 2 miles away. So I am still central just not sea front.) I bought a 3-bedroom because it it did make sense for me to get the “most out of my budget” but if a 3 bedroom had costed double the price and forced me to get an important mortgage I wouldn’t have done it and picked whatever led to the least debt tbh.

And yet, I bought it knowing it’s not my forever home. I love my new place, but I have no doubt that my needs in 10 years or even 5 will be very different to now, I move a lot and like to change and I know what I was able to afford here (a big place for a decent price) I definitely won’t get in a city like say, London. And so I do know that a change would mean likely, in my case “downsizing” (personally I don’t intend to have 3 kids so I couldn’t even picture having the need to ever upsize and get 4 or 5 bedroom house so it’s not even something I am considering.)

So yes, weirdly enough I could see myself moving to “New York” and live in a one-bedroom apartment in 5 years time, and not blink twice. Space wasn’t my criteria when buying, it was price. I have no mortgage and so it now mean I can save up most of what I earn to get a next property if I chose to. I think to me that’s a lot more valuable than overstretching myself space wise and price wise and then spend the next 2 decades living pennies to pennies. I personally would rather be a bit cramped but financially comfortable than have the space and nice house but worry about losing it until the last repayment. But personally I have also never been that attached to havinv the best house. I come from a poor background so having a decent bed and roof over my head is great in and and by itself. I don’t crave a fancy house and I cannot phantom spending close to a million on a place ever. EVER. I wouldn’t even be able to enjoy it knowing how much and how long it would take to repay.

So I think it’s fair to buy your dream home if you can but I would still be wary of overstretching yourself. I think the extra space might not always be worth the stress.

Motheranddaughter · 11/11/2023 21:59

We totally maxed out to buy 4 bedroom in good area with excellent schools
DC now at Uni, we will watch and wait and sell at the top of the market on basis we will sell out at best price and will then move on

manyofyou · 11/11/2023 21:48

How much of a deposit do you have? I’m saving for a house at the moment. Currently live with parents. I would deff think moving into your ‘forever’ home if you could would be ideal as I would also hate to move again (not even don’t the process once yet but have heard it’s bloody exhausting and stressful). But that is me, and I am very sensitive to stress lol! Go for it if you can. But only if you can afford it, as the stress you will save from moving will likely multiply ten fold if you are living in a house you can’t really afford or have to sacrifice so much for merely to live in it xx

FuzzyPenguin · 11/11/2023 21:25

I have never intentionally bought a house as a stepping stone to the next one and always went into it as my “forever home”. But my needs have changed which has caused me to to need to move. I have been in this house for 5 years and love it, I have no plans to move but who knows what might happen down the line.

Beachwalker66 · 11/11/2023 21:19

Interest rates are certainly not Sky high. They are still fairly low.

Aside from that, I am reminded of the saying “when people make plans, God laughs.”

Just buy the best you can, allowing for the chance rates might rise or something else could cause difficulties. It’s quite a privilege to be able to buy your forever home as a FTB but if you can afford it, good luck to you.

OliveToboogie · 11/11/2023 20:54

After exh and I had our DD we moved to a 2 bedroom terrace in quiet cul du sac. We then had our ds. Were lucky enough to be able to add an extra bedroom. When we split I bought him out. Dd has moved out and Ds will eventually. I will never leave my wee house. I have great neighbours, 10 mins from station and local shopping centre. It is quiet and overlooks a park. Have my own private back garden. It's my wee bolt hole x

cestlavielife · 11/11/2023 20:33

You cannot control everythjng in life. Buywhat makes sense for , the next 5, 10 years. Biggest you cqn afford in the location you want... But you might find in 7 you need to move for some reason.

FloofCloud · 11/11/2023 18:42

I'd say do what you can to make your life easiest. I also hate moving, only bought twice (I'm 51 first house bought in 2001). When our kids got a bit older we ended up remodelling our house because I didn't want to move, Both kids ND and probably DH too. We're all looking forward to move somewhere else as our forever home when they've finished college (about 7-8 years probably) and then we all want to relocate to the countryside - currently in a lovely desirable area but it's busy ... we want quiet

Peccary · 11/11/2023 18:42

Husband and I have moved a lot and were mid 30s when we bought, we went straight for a family home. Not sure if it's forever but if we moved it would be likely because we are relocating

Dogdaywoes · 11/11/2023 18:27

Buy the best house you can afford.

People don't buy small and move up because it's the done thing, they buy what they can afford.

Do you have the deposit for a more expensive house? Can you afford the larger mortgage?

sunnydayhereandnow · 11/11/2023 18:25

If the question is partly a financial decision, it's worth doing some calculations. Remember that there are two ways in which you "move up" the ladder as a homeowner: a big chunk of your mortgage is actually returning to you and paying off your loan, and house prices consistently increase in the medium to long term. This means that generally you end up with a tidy lump sum in your hand when you sell and are looking to put a deposit on your next place. Yes moving costs money but generally nothing like as much as what you got back by paying your mortgage and house price rises. I'm on my 3rd place, it cost nearly three times the purchase price of my first, but I was able to put down a deposit pretty much equal to the price of my first flat (which I bought in the 2000s on a 95% mortgage!) simply through paying back my mortgage and house price increases. And I wasn't even particularly lucky with the housing market - at both times I bought when house prices were high. Probably the best "investment" I made was to buy places that were well within my budget then overpay the mortgage.

PictureOfFlorianTray · 11/11/2023 18:23

In the 60s many couples moved into either parents' Bose in order to save for a deposit.
It's nothing new.

The late 70s/early 80s saw couples buying their first homes straight away ... for many.

The demand of women, and rightly so, meant that women's salaries were included in the mortgage applications.
The downside of this was that higher spending power meant higher mortgages which resulted in higher prices.

Now women want to stay at home for a lot longer, but house prices are still unreachable.

There needs to be a massive sea change.

SquashPenguin · 11/11/2023 18:19

We bought a 5 bed because we could afford it and we loved the house and loved the street. It was a great price and we are very happy here. I have moved 18 times between uni and moving around for work. I am never moving again. We are gradually doing the house up to our taste and enjoying the process. My partner was messed around by his buyer to such an extent that we never want to put another house on the market.

Chlorinara · 11/11/2023 18:17

We bought the cheapest house around with a 3rd bedroom. The 3rd bedroom was ridiculously tiny, it needed a lot of work, and the area wasn't the best but these compromises were what made it affordable.

Financially and practically it actually would have been better to get a "better" 2 bed. The amount of work we had to put in didn't really pay back when we ended up having to sell soon after anyway. For me having that 3rd bedroom brought with it a sense of security that I really valued so it was worth it, but for a lot of people it probably wouldn't have been the right decision.

Reigateforever · 11/11/2023 18:16

Buy as big as you can without overstretching your money, look back in history at how the bank rate went up. Since my first ‘forever’ home I have moved countries 3 times, I would never have imagined that then but nothing can be guaranteed.

dumpkin · 11/11/2023 18:14

Anyone with any financial sense leverages themselves up the ladder until they get what they want.

Nonsense, for many the ladder doesn’t really exist anymore. Stamp duty costs are a big factor

Daphnis156 · 11/11/2023 18:11

You are probably not able to make the decision now on a so called forever home.
Time and events will decide for you.

AlltheFs · 11/11/2023 18:07

Anyone with any financial sense leverages themselves up the ladder until they get what they want.
Buying a forever home as your first purchase is a fairly daft notion for most people.

Pipsquiggle · 11/11/2023 18:05

The house we are currently in is a long term buy - at least 15 years.
We had to consider primary and secondary schools plus links to London.
OP what life stage are you at? Do you have DC? Will you need to factor schools or commuting?

Dacadactyl · 11/11/2023 18:01

Our first house was a 3 bed. I wouldn't have bought a 2 bed either. I wouldn't necessarily think your first house should be your forever home, but I'd look for a 3 bed minimum if I could afford it. You won't outgrow it if you have 2 kids.

Pickingmyselfup · 11/11/2023 17:57

Buy the biggest you can providing you can afford the potential increases in interest.

We bought a 3 bed detached and whilst we always thought we would go bigger it's looking unlikely. We have enough room for the 4 of us and we always planned to have 2 kids. It's not quite big enough downstairs in an ideal world but it's manageable. We are going to look into an extension too which will be a lot cheaper than moving if we are approved.

I think had we gone for a 2 bed we would still be in the position of not being able to buy bigger and we would be massively struggling for space in the long run.

RandomUsernameHere · 11/11/2023 17:41

Most people can't afford to buy a 3 bed house as their first home, but of course YANBU if you can afford it and want to do so.

Spendonsend · 11/11/2023 17:33

Buy the biggest/best you can afford.

Stamp duty, moving fees, decorating to your taste, changing furniture to fit new shapes all costs lots.

Tiredbehyondbelief · 11/11/2023 17:29

You can try getting a flat with the potential to convert the loft. These flats are rare

Echobelly · 11/11/2023 17:27

I don't know about forever home, but certainly going for a big as you can afford in an area you are happy with is always s good principle.