Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Advice - Dog or no dog?

42 replies

CocoC · 11/11/2023 12:26

Looking for some advice here.
We are considering getting a dog - husband is keen, as are DC (age 12,10,8) but I am very nervous about the logistics.
We live in London, and both work from the office 3 days a week and often go abroad to see family for holidays (so dog couldn’t come) - and of course weekends are filled with kids activities (football, swimming etc).

Husband and I both love dogs. The dog would absolutely get walked morning and evening, and would get a dog walker for the days we are in the office, so my concern is not about the dog welfare - but about mine.
I was desperate to have a dog when I was a child, but I am not sure I want one now as I worry it will massively restrict our freedom and I will end up really resenting that - and that it will be yet another thing to feel guilty about. Another ball and chain (not to mention money drain with dog walkers etc) just when the children are finally getting more independent.

Has anyone else been in this position, and have any advice? Or has anyone got a dog and regretted it?

many thanks!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mysa74 · 11/11/2023 14:43

I have 2 married friends in our friendship group who both debated getting their own family dogs, both with similar concerns. They both started off with the borrow my dog app, then both decided to try fostering. One family loved the experience so much they decided fostering dogs was the way to go, they still had the ability to go on holiday and enjoyed the range of dogs they fostered, the other fell in love with the foster dog and adopted it...

Lizzieregina · 11/11/2023 14:08

We got a puppy when my kids were similar ages to yours and had a very similar lifestyle, including family abroad.

We loved every minute with him and have zero regrets.

However! I really really wanted him and did the lions share of the dog work. You don’t sound like you’re fully on board, so for that reason, I’m voting no dog.

OrlandointheWilderness · 11/11/2023 14:04

I think no dog. We have 3, they are working dogs and are actually a far more demanding part of life than our 12 year old children what with endless walking, training, feeding, hoovering and days out working them.
We adore them but I don't think they would be right for you.

LlynTegid · 11/11/2023 13:59

You have doubts, that is enough reason to say no dog.

margotrose · 11/11/2023 13:56

The main thing to consider is what if you end up with a dog who is anxious, or reactive, or can't be left for as long as you'd like because they have separation anxiety?

Basically, you need to plan for the worst case scenario. We have a beagle with separation anxiety - he's five and it's only recently that we've been able to leave him alone for an hour without him freaking out completely. Luckily we have family who have him while we work, but if we didn't, we'd be utterly fucked.

stardust25609 · 11/11/2023 13:49

If you get the right dog they could certainly cope with this. We have 2 greyhounds and they'd be fine with the schedule, as they only need 2 30 minute walks a day and sleep a lot (built for speed not endurance). I think getting a rescue also makes you feel less bad about working when having a dog because they're better off than in kennels, and you can find an adult you know suits your lifestyle (ie doesn't have separation anxiety so is happy to be left alone when you go to kids activities). However it will definitely restrict your freedom and money, and add more responsibilities to your routine. I'd look into cost of dog walkers in your area, and dog food etc, and they will need to go to a home boarder or kennels when you're abroad (ours enjoy this as they go to a greyhound only place but this adds extra money to any holiday obviously) and we need to make sure there is free space before we book anything. I think it's then an individual decision on whether it's worth it to you.

SweetFemaleAttitude · 11/11/2023 13:36

Yes. We have a dog and if I could go back in time, I wouldn't have one.

Don't get me wrong. I absolutely love her and wouldn't be without her now, but it does massively restrict your ability to be spontaneous.

Your life kind of revolves around making sure their needs are met.

Making sure they aren't on their own for more than 4hrs max, wanting to go places where you can't take the dog and people are reluctant to dog sit, even though when you say you're getting a dog, they're all 'oh we will have her if you need her looking after', absolute bollocks lol.

As I say, wouldn't be without her now, but we won't be getting another when her time is up.

Createausername1970 · 11/11/2023 13:35

We have a dog, love her to bits, will be terribly sad when she is no longer with us. But I am not sure I would have another one.

As everyone has said, any plans have to revolve around the dog. Holidays can't be booked until we sort out her arrangements. I don't want to take her with us as then our holiday revolves around the dog and we can't go out for the day.

Insurance is expensive, as is her hypoallergenic food. All in, she probably cost us around £140 a month. That's getting on for £15k over her life time. Don't begrudge it, but it's a consideration.

Pinkpinkpink15 · 11/11/2023 13:34

@CocoC

you will be the one most impacted by getting a dog.

you dont 'really really really' want a dog right now. It's generally a 15 year commitment YOU don't want to make. Don't let them cajole or guilt you into it.

ita total change of lifestyle & a massive commitment

another poster is correct too, they need YOU a lot too, not just adequate walks & supervision.

Boomboomboomboom · 11/11/2023 13:34

Don't do it.
100% regret mine and I love walking and running with him but they're such a tie - holidays and going out are more difficult.
Never rely on kids and husband either to walk!

atthebottomofthehill · 11/11/2023 13:34

No dog. IMO the only people who should have dogs are essentially farmers.

Strictlymad · 11/11/2023 13:34

We bought a ‘lockdown pet’ for our then only child- a Guinea pig. Don’t get me wrong she’s lovely but it’s an extra consideration going away, vets, this year I have spent a considerable time in hospital and it’s been an extra stress. I do regret it. And she’s a rodent….. a dog is 100x worse!

Caroparo52 · 11/11/2023 13:33

Everyone wants a dog until reality hits and dog needs walking or feeding or walking again. In the rain.
You know YOU will be responsible as whole family magically too busy and you won't let the dog down as the guilt will be unbearable.
Soooo if you realistically have 2 hours free a day then yes.
Otherwise N.O.
A dog is for life not 5 minutes petting.
We have dogs and adore them
but I WFH and dogs are type who like 20 minute pootles not 90 minutes full on run about.
It is hard work. But reward is unlimited.
Sounds not for you imo.

lljkk · 11/11/2023 13:31

Yes Dog, adult not puppy though. You don't sound any busier than anyone else I know who successfully has a happy dog in their lives.

SiennaMillar · 11/11/2023 13:31

Another financial consideration is health insurance and vets trips (also, this is a time consideration as you may need to take a day off work to go). Our dog was only about one year old, went into the garden, sniffed up a grass seed and £500 later it was removed by the vet under GA! Another £2000 due to recurring UTIs. Both v common problems in dogs. She’s also allergic to poultry and only tolerates a raw frozen diet, so that’s £3 a day in food, plus the purchase of a new freezer. £75 a month on insurance. She can’t be left alone for more than 3-4 hours, so we can only go to dog friendly restaurants/hotels/ friends/family.

PuttingDownRoots · 11/11/2023 13:30

The main reason we don't heave a dog (or indeed any pet) is because our lifestyle wouldn't be fair on them.

Animals deserve proper care, time and attention.

AffIt · 11/11/2023 13:29

Gently, no dog.

I grew up with dogs (and cats and horses - we had a lot of animals!) and dogs are brilliant, but they are incredibly consuming and your life just sounds too busy at the moment.

There will inevitably be people coming along who'll say 'oh, my dogs come everywhere and they're fine', but they're NOT bloody fine: dogs are pack animals and happiest in 'their' space with 'their' people, not being endlessly dragged around shops and pubs and walked by a myriad of strangers.

That's not to say 'no dog EVER', things will probably settle down in a few years and you'll have more bandwidth for a pooch.

Milknosugarta · 11/11/2023 13:29

Definitely don't. You will end up doing most of the work, and you will resent it. I speak from experience.

margotrose · 11/11/2023 13:25

We live in London, and both work from the office 3 days a week

What will happen to the dog while you work? Many dogs couldn't be left for a full working day with just a walker coming in at lunchtime, and a puppy certainly couldn't cope with it. You could pay for daycare but it's expensive and certainly doesn't suit every dog.

often go abroad to see family for holidays (so dog couldn’t come)

Are you willing to add hundreds of pounds to your holiday costs to pay for kennels, or a sitter, or a home boarder?

and of course weekends are filled with kids activities (football, swimming etc).

So what happens to the dog when you have to get up early for activities or your kids are wanting to send the day somewhere that isn't dog friendly?

Husband and I both love dogs. The dog would absolutely get walked morning and evening, and would get a dog walker for the days we are in the office, so my concern is not about the dog welfare - but about mine.

You should be concerned about welfare, being brutally honest. Dogs need so much more than three walks a day, they need your time and company too.

rookiemere · 11/11/2023 13:22

Don't get a dog. Join borrowmydoggy and borrow someone else's.
DS 17 is going to uni next year ( fingers crossed) but no spontaneous trips abroad for us because of the dog DH insisted on getting 5 years ago ( and now regrets). Rookiedog is lovely and well looked after, but yes absolutely has to be considered in all plans including work promotions and travel.

MercyIsEliminated · 11/11/2023 13:21

Having a dog will certainly restrict your freedom and spontaneity to some degree. If you’re not prepared for that (and it sounds like you’re not) don’t get a dog. I think you are approaching the issue very sensibly. Unfortunately, far too many people follow their hearts rather than their heads in such situations. And then they end up with dogs that they don’t really have time or energy to train properly. Or the dog ends up stuck in a crate for hours at a time.

I absolutely adore my dog. But it’s true that factoring in a dog’s needs can make a busy family life more challenging. For me it’s worth the complications. But if you’re not 100% on board, it’s probably wise not to add a dog to your household now.

Faithtort · 11/11/2023 13:04

I would say no don’t get a dog. We got our dog when our children were little and I wasn’t working. She’s 8 now and she’s happy with one walk a day and then just lying around the house and is no bother. She comes with us at the weekends to our childrens sporting activities and fits in well with our life but I put loads of time into her training when she was a puppy. I can’t imagine having a new dog now with our busy lives. We also have family that are happy to have her when we’re on holiday.

Nochoiceleft · 11/11/2023 13:03

I have a dog. She’s a rescue. She’s an absolute star and happy to snooze the day away. There is always someone at home and we holiday in cottages where we can take her with us.
But everything we do has to take her into consideration. We can’t just disappear out for the day. We can’t just book a holiday or short trip abroad. We can’t leave her in the cottage alone when we are away so pubs and meals out have to be dog friendly. She hates being in the car, it completely stresses her out so that limits where we can take her to walk her. I also find that I get very stressed worrying about doing the right thing for her. That is totally my issue but it stills adds to my general levels of stress.

Mindymomo · 11/11/2023 13:02

When you think about getting a dog, unfortunately you don’t take it in that this will be your life for 10/15 years, people stop inviting you to their houses because you have to bring your dog, you cannot go to friends houses that have cats and then there’s problems with holidays. We always presumed that we could leave our dog with our adult sons, but in reality it wouldn’t work and we don’t think we could go away without our dog.

margotrose · 11/11/2023 13:02

Definitely don't get a dog.