Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel down about a judgemental mother?

66 replies

Katielottierose947 · 11/11/2023 10:30

Hiya I’m 25 years old and in a long term happy relationship

I was out for a coffee yesterday with a couple of my girlfriends and another lady had tagged along (she was friends with my friends) everything was fine and we were chatting and then children got brought up. Both my friends that were there have children and also the new lady I’d just met let’s call her Lucy ( not her real name)
Lucy is in her early 30’s with 2 children.

Lucy asked ‘When are you going to have kids then?’ I replied that me and my boyfriend have decided we actually don’t want children and that even though we’ve thought a lot about it it’s still the decision we’ve come to. Lucy proceeded to say ‘ I wouldn’t feel like a proper woman if I hadn’t of had children to be honest, I mean it’s a bit selfish! ’ she laughed and then she made her eyes go wide like she was in shock . I laughed nervously back. And saw my two friends wince.

My friends saved me from the awkward silence that arose. I didn’t want any confrontation. When I went home that afternoon I felt a bit down thinking should I want children, am I a normal woman? I’ve seen loose women discuss this in their show before so I know I’m not alone I think it was Vicky Pattinson?

Why are woman called selfish for NOT wanting children? Am I being unreasonable to be upset by this comment ? Has anyone been in a similar situation before ?

thanks sweeties 😊

OP posts:
daliesque · 11/11/2023 10:57

Although at 25 you might change your mind

Yes, but she also might not.
25 is perfectly old enough to make a decision to either want kids or not.

MyCircumference · 11/11/2023 10:57

very ignorant of her

daliesque · 11/11/2023 10:56

She's talking crap, and as a childfree woman myself I can tell you that you've got about 15 years where you will get the same crap from many people who can't think past their own life choices.

Just ignore.

Come and join us on the board for mn without children.

Teaandscone · 11/11/2023 10:54

What are you, then, OP; imaginary?

greengreengrass25 · 11/11/2023 10:50

So horrible and tactless of her

You may have been trying for a baby for all she knew so she shouldn't be making these sort of comments to anyone

Janieforever · 11/11/2023 10:50

The word selfish is very telling here op.it means she is struggling and thinks you don’t want kids so you can have an easier or better life.

shes envious. I see this a lot on here. Women being bitchy about other women If they think they have chosen an easier path than them. Or trying to convince them to do something they did , as they suffered. odd but simply tells you more about them than they wish you to know.

so let it go, it’s not about you , it’s about her feelings about her own choices.

PaperDoIIs · 11/11/2023 10:46

Tbh even if you wanted kids , it was stupid to ask when you're only 25.
Then she compounded that stupidity with her next comments. The thing is.. you can't fix stupid.

At least she's not an actual friend or someone you'll be likely to see much of , it at all, again. So fuck her and what she thinks.

hettie · 11/11/2023 10:46

Christ, how utterly fucking tedious that people are still subjected to this crap. Talk about internalised gender stereotypes.
I used to get the 'you're so selfish' bollocks and 'not very womanly' (wtf!) Oh and the patronising 'you'll change your mind'. As it happens I did but that was largely due to a DH who was also prepared to give a big fuck u to the patriarchy and step in to be 'mothering and domestic' in equal measure.
My come back to the 'you're selfish' was always to inquire to whom was I being selfish? Selfish to the world (pretty sure the global population doesn't need my kids?). UK for denying them future workers (cause that makes it sounds like you want me to be a birthing machine for a capitalist society)? My partner (his decision too). My unconceived child.. ? That last one always got them.
I would tell them quite clearly that my very thoughtful decision was the opposite of selfish. That selfish would be bringing a child into the world with out too much thought, not really assessing whether you had the emotional, relationship and financial resources to do a good job and then being a bit crap at it and making the kids life a bit crap. I would say that I'd really thought about it and that the time commitment that it needed wasn't possible for me, nor did I want it. And thankfully I had a choice.
That and a hard stare usually shut them up.
Sorry you're experiencing this. I really really wish more people thought a lot more about becoming parents as it would stop so much misery and and struggle. I commend you for making your choice for whatever reasons you have because you've made an active choice.

ZenNudist · 11/11/2023 10:44

She's a dick.

Although at 25 you might change your mind

eurotravel · 11/11/2023 10:41

God what a nightmare woman. Ignore her and avoid ever seeing again. She's probably jealous deep down & hates it

Brexile · 11/11/2023 10:37

What a cow. Obviously insecure and thinks that anyone else's different circumstances/ lifestyle are an implicit criticism of hers, hence she has to put the boot in first. Idiot.

Heyisforhorses · 11/11/2023 10:36

Apparently you're not complete unless you have kids, that was in a fiction book im reading and even reading it I thought it was bullshit!! I have kids but I also know women who don't and don't want them and I understand that. Weare all still normal women with different mindsets. To judge someone for not having children is really unkind, even asking the question without knowing a reason is out of line.

You have made your choice, you aren't wrong, it's what you want in your life so don't mind anyone else.

KnackeredBack · 11/11/2023 10:34

Not at all unreasonable to ignore entirely and hopefully your reaction will make her think twice about saying exactly what's on her mind again. I'm sure we've all put our foot in it at times, but that's a fairly impressive one.

It never ceases to amaze me as to what people think is reasonable to verbalise out loud.

Almondmum · 11/11/2023 10:34

She just sounds like an absolute thicko to be honest. The idea that not having kids is selfish is moronic. Why anyone would say shit like that to someone they've just been introduced to is beyond me. Its a shame she's chosen to reproduce really.

Lammveg · 11/11/2023 10:34

YANBU to not want kids, it's not selfish (in fact it's probably more selfish to want kids)

But YABU to be down about it! She's just some stupid woman who had a stupid opinion.

FatFilledTrottyPuss · 11/11/2023 10:33

God she sounds awful. There’s absolutely nothing wrong in not wanting children and it’s certainly not selfish! Selfish would be having children you didn’t want because you felt you ought to and not being cut out for parenting.