Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel down about a judgemental mother?

66 replies

Katielottierose947 · 11/11/2023 10:30

Hiya I’m 25 years old and in a long term happy relationship

I was out for a coffee yesterday with a couple of my girlfriends and another lady had tagged along (she was friends with my friends) everything was fine and we were chatting and then children got brought up. Both my friends that were there have children and also the new lady I’d just met let’s call her Lucy ( not her real name)
Lucy is in her early 30’s with 2 children.

Lucy asked ‘When are you going to have kids then?’ I replied that me and my boyfriend have decided we actually don’t want children and that even though we’ve thought a lot about it it’s still the decision we’ve come to. Lucy proceeded to say ‘ I wouldn’t feel like a proper woman if I hadn’t of had children to be honest, I mean it’s a bit selfish! ’ she laughed and then she made her eyes go wide like she was in shock . I laughed nervously back. And saw my two friends wince.

My friends saved me from the awkward silence that arose. I didn’t want any confrontation. When I went home that afternoon I felt a bit down thinking should I want children, am I a normal woman? I’ve seen loose women discuss this in their show before so I know I’m not alone I think it was Vicky Pattinson?

Why are woman called selfish for NOT wanting children? Am I being unreasonable to be upset by this comment ? Has anyone been in a similar situation before ?

thanks sweeties 😊

OP posts:
Pizzalover46 · 11/11/2023 12:11

I'm in awe that you didn't hand her arse to her for being so rude to be honest. I'd have been incredibly forthcoming about how rude she is. You aren't "no normal", having children does not mean you are a "proper woman" and you shouldn't ever give someone else the power to make you feel so rubbish about yourself (especially some random woman). Seems like you have a nice couple of friends who helped you out of the situation though and I'd probably ask before meeting them again if Lucy will be there too - and then decline the meet up if she is!

Lavender14 · 11/11/2023 12:07

She sounds like someone I'd have no time for. Infact I'm guessing the fact she has children is her whole identity and we will read about her here as an awful mil later on in life.

There's absolutely nothing wrong in your decision, lots of people are deciding not to have children now. We really debated ttc and we really wanted a child, I think it's more selfish to have children now to be totally truthful.

I'd be spending no more time or thought on her.

AutumnNamechange · 11/11/2023 12:06

Lucy is a twit who obviously has so little else going on in her life that she is defined by her reproductive system. Why anyone would even make comments like that to a 25 year old is beyond me - I don't know anyone in my circle who wanted children at 25, we were too busy building our careers and enjoying life!

Do your friends know how Lucy made you feel? I hope they will not let her tag along next time..

PennyProud · 11/11/2023 12:05

She's rude. I personally would've said that was an unfair statement for her to make. I have a child, I wanted to have children but I completely understand that some people don't want to have children. It's not selfish. If anything it's the opposite. It would be selfish to force yourself to have children that you don't want just to fulfill something you'd consider an obligation

AtrociousCircumstance · 11/11/2023 12:02

She is what is commonly known as a Fucking Idiot. She’s not just entirely wrong, she’s also rude and stupid.

Completely discount her nonsense as quickly you would any other offensive numbskull.

Utterbunkum · 11/11/2023 12:02

I don't have children, past the point where I could now. You have, sadly, in my experience, a long road ahead of you of hearing this. Along with 'you will change your mind' and 'you will regret it'. I didn't and I don't.
If you ask people why they had children, not one of them will say 'I made a personal sacrifice for the sake of the future of mankind'. It is not more altruistic to have a child when it is something that you want.
Women who have children when they don't want them have often been coerced by peer pressure or a partner that does want them. This sort of pressure includes being made to feel you aren't a whole woman if you don't. Never mind what that says about women who want children but can't have them.
It is never having a child for the sake of the child, or for some lofty cause. The fact that childrearing involves sacrifice does not make conception an unselfish act. If you are pressured into it, however appalling that is, you still aren't having the child for the child's sake, or for a cause outside of your immediate situation, which is what absolute selflessness would mean.

EnterFunnyNameHere · 11/11/2023 11:56

There's nothing wrong with choosing to not have kids.

There's also nothing wrong with pushing back at fuckwits who say things like this. You don't need to be rude particularly, but pointing out that saying to someone's face you think they are "selfish" and "not a proper woman" just because they've made different decisions is extremely rude.

I have also been known to point out that they have no idea of my personal circumstances, and maybe they could consider that the person they are quizzing on their fertility choices might have some very upsetting reasons behind not having kids yet.

ownedbymydog · 11/11/2023 11:55

Have a look at tiffany.jmarie on insta, OP, she’s brilliant at highlighting the bollocks that child free people (women, obviously) regularly get hurled at them, and also great with the responses. I do often wonder why people like ‘Lucy’ are so personally bothered by others choices, it’s very strange.

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 11/11/2023 11:55

As someone a bit older than you, I know that is a question you should never ask.
Or indeed answer really. It's no one else's business.
Lucy sounds like a bit of a cow to me.

MrsMiddleMother · 11/11/2023 11:51

Yanbu, don't give this woman any head space. Having children is a completely personal choice and whatever that choice is always be confident in your decision.

Goodnessgraciousmee · 11/11/2023 11:46

She's plain wrong. I have children. Choosing to have them in some respects was the ultimate selfish decision. We had them because we selfishly wanted them. What other reason would be good enough?!

Children are life changing and often bring about rapid and major changes in one's self perception, relationships, life direction, priorities etc (equally, sometimes they don't much - I'd imagine it's hugely personal).

For this reason I think parents often project ideas that because having children has changed who they are, people without children are in some way stunted or less developed.

But it's codswallop because we all have different life stories, different trajectories and we all change and mature in different ways whether we have children or not. Unfortunately, I have encountered as many selfish, immature people who have children as without.

As others have said, sadly you may have to get used to these kinds of comments for the foreseeable and build your own defences against them. Of course you are not wrong to find these horrible, insulting and misogynistic comments very hurtful. It will just be better for you to move into a mindset of seeing this as a failure of intelligence, perspective and empathy on behalf of the other person, rather than a reflection upon your life choices.

SeethroughDress · 11/11/2023 11:42

SugaredCookie · 11/11/2023 11:30

Did this really happen? I just can’t imagine someone being so nosey and brazen to a total stranger.

Of course she’s totally wrong and other people’s fertility choices is none of her business.

I can’t speak for the OP, but based on my own experience of being childfree, it wasn’t that infrequent, usually in the kind of situation the OP describes, friends of friends, people you haven’t met before, in social situations. I mean, there are a lot of dimwits out there.

SugaredCookie · 11/11/2023 11:30

Did this really happen? I just can’t imagine someone being so nosey and brazen to a total stranger.

Of course she’s totally wrong and other people’s fertility choices is none of her business.

dressedforcomfort · 11/11/2023 11:26

What a judgemental cow!

YANBU OP. Your life, your choice. Absolutely none of her business.

StopWastingTimeOnMN · 11/11/2023 11:20

She asked you a rude and probing question, despite the fact that you had only just met. That was the red flag that she was a dickhead.

IMO your only mistake was to [over]share you thoughts with her about whether you want to have children or not - it was none of her business. Grey rock with people like this all the way...

Kayte198999 · 11/11/2023 11:18

I would avoid Lucy in the future. Your friends wincing shows you what they thought of her comments. I don't understand why she thinks it's selfish, that makes no sense at all! I wouldn't be surprised if Lucy is a generally judgemental and unempathetic person. You are not BU to feel down about her comments as they were very rude but just know that this isn't a common way to think – you are great, whole and enough whether you want kids or not

Gnomegnomegnome · 11/11/2023 11:15

Forgot to say, how the hell is it selfish to not want children?

Gnomegnomegnome · 11/11/2023 11:14

She sounds like an insecure dick.

If being a mother is the only thing that she has going for her then good luck to her when they all grow up and leave home.

I wouldn’t want to waste my breath on people like that.

SMTWTFS · 11/11/2023 11:11

NO ONE SHOULD ASK ANYONE WHEN THEY ARE HAVING KIDS! She is a PRICK.

AliasGrape · 11/11/2023 11:06

Urgh, I can’t believe there are still people out there that not only think like this but have no qualms about spouting off about it either.

Having my daughter was a decision I made entirely for me (and my husband of course) to fulfill our own desire to be parents. We work very hard to be good ones, which means having to be selfless quite often in terms of putting her needs first, but that’s our responsibility after the choice we made to bring her into the world - not some sign of our worth as people/ inherent generosity of spirit.

SeethroughDress · 11/11/2023 11:04

eurotravel · 11/11/2023 10:41

God what a nightmare woman. Ignore her and avoid ever seeing again. She's probably jealous deep down & hates it

That’s a silly response. Lucy is clearly a monumental idiot in terms of (a) actually thinking this and (b) being insensitive enough to say it, but ‘she’s just jealous’ is one of those non-things posters invent in all kinds of unlikely situations on zero grounds. Maybe Lucy adores being a parent. Maybe Lucy is one of those limited types who never had the faintest idea what she would do with her life outside of having children. Maybe Lucy has some kind of neurological glitch that means she doesn’t have theory of mind and doesn’t grasp that other people don’t share her (limited) thought processes. Or yes, maybe Lucy is regretting her children.

OP, you are going to need to toughen up about this. These kinds of comments to childfree women aren’t uncommon in exactly the scenario you describe — your friends wouldn’t say anything so dense, but friends of friends sometimes do, or people you meet at parties. (See current thread on the Mners Without Children’ board.) You will go mad if you let it lay an axe to the roots of your being every time.

For what it’s worth, I never wanted children, and would occasionally get those kinds of comment. I’m fine with confrontation, so if I was in the humour I would say something like ‘Gosh, do explain to me why you chose to have children now that there’s reliable contraception’, or ‘Poor you. I can’t imagine feeling my identity as a woman depended on my reproductive capacity’.

Also, I did have a child, by choice, when I was about to turn 40. I remained exactly as ‘selfish’ as I had been before I had him. I’m exactly the same person, but with a child.

JanefromLondon1 · 11/11/2023 11:03

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

Morningtroubles · 11/11/2023 11:03

i voted YABU as you need to stop giving this woman headspace.

it was really rude and insensitive of her to say what she did, but then some people are.

You’ll meet people like this. Be confident in your own choice and have firm but polite replies to shut down the conversation.

ColinFuckingRobinson · 11/11/2023 11:00

There's nothing to be down about. An intolerant woman who can't possibly imagine that people are different made herself look like a dick. That's it. Your friends wincing should tell you how crass she was being.

My DB and SIL have chosen not to have kids and they (she) still gets occasional comments now in their 40's. Some people just seem to take alternative life choices as a personal criticism.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 11/11/2023 10:58

Completely your choice whether or not to have children. I have 2 with a third on the way and they are incredibly hard work. I love them and wouldn’t change anything but having children when you aren’t convinced you want them is never a sensible plan in my opinion.

Next time someone says something so rude to you, call them out on it instead of laughing nervously.