Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel down about a judgemental mother?

66 replies

Katielottierose947 · 11/11/2023 10:30

Hiya I’m 25 years old and in a long term happy relationship

I was out for a coffee yesterday with a couple of my girlfriends and another lady had tagged along (she was friends with my friends) everything was fine and we were chatting and then children got brought up. Both my friends that were there have children and also the new lady I’d just met let’s call her Lucy ( not her real name)
Lucy is in her early 30’s with 2 children.

Lucy asked ‘When are you going to have kids then?’ I replied that me and my boyfriend have decided we actually don’t want children and that even though we’ve thought a lot about it it’s still the decision we’ve come to. Lucy proceeded to say ‘ I wouldn’t feel like a proper woman if I hadn’t of had children to be honest, I mean it’s a bit selfish! ’ she laughed and then she made her eyes go wide like she was in shock . I laughed nervously back. And saw my two friends wince.

My friends saved me from the awkward silence that arose. I didn’t want any confrontation. When I went home that afternoon I felt a bit down thinking should I want children, am I a normal woman? I’ve seen loose women discuss this in their show before so I know I’m not alone I think it was Vicky Pattinson?

Why are woman called selfish for NOT wanting children? Am I being unreasonable to be upset by this comment ? Has anyone been in a similar situation before ?

thanks sweeties 😊

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bivarb · 11/11/2023 19:05

She's an idiot and very rude.
If it happens again you could act faux surprised and say, "oh no I think it would be selfish to have a child I didn't want just because I feel I'm supposed to. How awful for the unwanted child! Is that the reason you had children??" Then do the wide eye thing.

You could rub all the disposable income and long lies in her face!

I have a child by the way and love being a parent. That doesn't mean everyone would feel that way. My best friend is child free and fabulous.

clarepetal · 11/11/2023 17:14

She's a prick, and it's none of her damned business what you do.

SurvivingNotThriving · 11/11/2023 17:04

Sadly some people are so lacking in imagination (and empathy) that they can't get their heads around the idea that you might want completely different things from them. They Have Figured Out The Correct Way To Live And They Are Always Right. Ignore them - unimaginative people can be quite boring.

Some of my coolest and most awesome friends are child-free through varying degrees of choice. And there's definitely nothing 'lesser' about them.

CoffeeCantata · 11/11/2023 16:44

Awful woman.

The trouble is, sometimes when people are this bad it just knocks the wind out of you and you don't manage to come back at them successfully. Very frustrating. When I've had this level of rudeness/crassness aimed at me, my mouth has gone dry and my brain turns to fog and I've just been unable to get back at them - it's a physical thing, not a 'too timid' thing.

All I can suggest is; rehearse a few good responses to this for future use. If you think ahead, you might manage to put the next idiot in their place.

Iheartpizza · 11/11/2023 15:06

Lucy is a knob who doesn't know how to be tactful.

I have a child. I am no more a 'woman' than you! Go enjoy your fabulous child free life I say!

Ginacake · 11/11/2023 14:02

ZenNudist · 11/11/2023 10:44

She's a dick.

Although at 25 you might change your mind

I'd love to hear your experiences of when you've met women 16-25 who are pregnant or have children and told them they're very young and might change their mind.

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 11/11/2023 13:54

Truth is, some people are just twatty about any life-changing experience they've had: travel, religion, politics, whatever it is, there's a certain kind of person who not only loved their life-changer but can't imagine how anyone's life could be complete without it and can't keep that to themselves.

"I'm glad you've done the right thing for you, Lucy, but if you can't be glad that I've done the right thing for me we should probably talk about something else."

remindersofhim · 11/11/2023 13:33

Another very happy mum here who thinks she's absolutely mental. Ignore her.

honeylulu · 11/11/2023 13:23

What an awful woman. The fact that the other two winced says a lot.

Having children is selfish because guess what, people do it because they want to be parents and satisfy that desire for themselves. (I have kids by the way.) Maybe Lucy kids herself that she's had children in order to contribute their wonderfulness to society and the wider world.

Also I absolutely HATE the notion that a woman isn't a complete and proper woman/person if she isn't a mother. Of course she is. On the contrary it is easy as a mother to feel that is principally what defines you to others and feel like you have lost part of yourself.

All women are people in their own right!

ginasevern · 11/11/2023 13:23

Selfish to whom? Certainly not the planet which is groaning under the weigh of a gazillion humans. She sounds thick, shallow and bad mannered.

Princessfluffy · 11/11/2023 13:06

Maybe ask her if you see her again if she is struggling with motherhood.

heetud · 11/11/2023 13:04

thanks sweeties

Hmm

Hmm.

Passepartoute · 11/11/2023 13:02

What a stunningly stupid woman. With any luck she will soon reach the point when the memory of this conversation makes her go cold with horror at how she has embarrassed herself.

Thankyouthankyoujellybean · 11/11/2023 13:01

Some great responses on here. OP I will add that when people are as monumentally idiotic and rude as this women was, you are entitled to offer a measured, but cold response. Some suggestions:

"Gosh, that was a strong opinion to share! I wonder where it came from? Is everything ok with you?"

"The vast majority of parents are bad at it and should never have had kids." (I don't believe this but it's a great response to someone being a twat)

"I've never met a parent as happy and successful as am." (This will work better when you are a bit older, obviously. My 35yo sister gets good use out of it!)

As a very happy parent of nearly three, I cannot fathom why anyone has an opinion on anyone's choices when it comes to reproduction. It's baffling.

Milknosugarta · 11/11/2023 12:57

I was once asked at a social event by a man I had only just met, if I had children (I was there with DH). When I said no, he jokingly said "why, are you barren?" I was so shocked I couldnt speak. Never forgotten that.

SleepingStandingUp · 11/11/2023 12:42

eurotravel · 11/11/2023 10:41

God what a nightmare woman. Ignore her and avoid ever seeing again. She's probably jealous deep down & hates it

I think lots of women think that's motherhood is what defines them and their lives, and that to not have them therefore makes you lacking. I don't think it's that they secretly hate their kids and regret having them.

SleepingStandingUp · 11/11/2023 12:39

Decisions about your fertility and reproductive SHOULD always be selfish. So yes, it's selfish of you to have kids when other people might want you to or society needs people I'm thirty years time to rub the schools and hospitals but none of that matters as much as what YOU want to do with your body and your life. Moreover, it's selfish of me to have kids when there's so many already alive and we're killing the planet etc. but I still believe that it's a right be selfish on this issue and have them if I want them

The only time, as a possible disclaimer, was if I knew they'd be brought into a life of abuse etc. then obv the woman's rights shouldn't trump everything

Newestname002 · 11/11/2023 12:33

Lammveg · 11/11/2023 10:34

YANBU to not want kids, it's not selfish (in fact it's probably more selfish to want kids)

But YABU to be down about it! She's just some stupid woman who had a stupid opinion.

Yes and yes.

Also don't let other people decisions which either or both you and your partner have properly considered and made to suit yourselves be affected by pushy, intrusive people.

It's none of this rude woman's business whether or not you have children - or anything else for that matter. You also don't need to explain anything to her or anyone else - a statement in response eg "my partner and I have discussed this and decided we don't want children" should be enough. If she presses (as she may) tell her this decision suits you both and you feel no need to discuss it or get approval from anyone else. (Shutting down this sort of attitude works for other things as well). If she gets upset that's her doing - turn to your friends and talk about something else with them. 🌹

Nicole1111 · 11/11/2023 12:28

In the future respond to questions like this with “did you mean to be so rude?”

tsmainsqueeze · 11/11/2023 12:28

She is not worth bothering about.
I'm a mom of 3 my choice , but equally i see just as much satisfaction in remaining child free , it's not selfish -what a stupid comment ! there are more than enough children being produced .
Live your life the way you choose it's no one else's business, no way are you less of a woman but she's crass and thoughtless.

Couch25k · 11/11/2023 12:28

I reckon deep down she’s jealous!

ignore her, she’s trying to do that thing of making herself feel better by saying stupid things out loud. Silly woman!

littlegrebe · 11/11/2023 12:17

I used to work with a woman who thought this and wasn't afraid to say so (she was one of those "tells it like it is" people who thinks being rude is a personality trait). Having thought about it for some time I concluded she must not actually like her children - she was basically saying she had sacrificed her own enjoyment and fulfilment in life to have them. She was a miserable cow to be fair but if she hated it that much why try to pressure everyone else into having children?

Selfish is when you put yourself first and it has a negative effect on someone else, like grabbing the last seat on the train or always leaving the washing up for someone else to do; it's a negative thing because it causes difficulty for someone else. Who are you causing difficulty for by not having children? This isn't the Third Reich, we aren't obliged to have babies for the Motherland.

nutbrownhare15 · 11/11/2023 12:16

She's vile but will be thriving on your silence. Use 'did you mean to be so rude?' next time.

Slidingsocks · 11/11/2023 12:12

Obviously she's a twit, but I've heard this opinion before - that it's selfish to not want children - and I genuinely don't understand the thinking. Is it supposed to be selfish not to want to make the sacrifices involved in being a parent? Or to not want to "do your part" by perpetuating society? Honestly don't get it.

TheUltima · 11/11/2023 12:12

ZenNudist · 11/11/2023 10:44

She's a dick.

Although at 25 you might change your mind

You sound as bad as her with that change your mind comment!

Swipe left for the next trending thread