Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get niece & nephew Christmas presents this year?

210 replies

fudgelover1 · 10/11/2023 21:30

I always buy my niece and nephew Christmas presents, and I usually buy like 3/4 parents as their birthdays are in December so it's a joint present.

However last year they never said thank you and the parents didn't say anything either.

I never get any presents back of my sister and BIL.

This year I don't feel like buying my niece and nephew anything for Christmas just because I dont find them appreciative or grateful.

My nephew was chucking the toys on the floor that I brought him last year.

They are 8 and 13.

Am I being unreasonable to not buy them anything this year?

OP posts:
LaurieStrode · 11/11/2023 01:20

KatBurglar · 10/11/2023 21:40

The thank yous should come from their parents. I gather you don't have children yourself, OP?

If you have kids and sister and BIL don't buy for them, YANBU to stop buying gifts.

If you don't have children, YABU to punish your niece and nephew for not being brought up with manners.

Oh hogwash. It's not punishing them. They won't notice the difference.

Nip it in the bud and stop the pointless merchandise train, OP.

fudgelover1 · 11/11/2023 01:05

RocketIceLollie · 11/11/2023 00:53

Christmas is for children essentially. If you are looking for a thank you then perhaps give the gifts to the children yourself rather than leave them to open a few days later on Christmas Day so they remember to say thank you when they receive the gift to open there and then rather than being forgotten in the pile of presents from various people.

I see the children on Christmas Day as we all go round to my parents.

OP posts:
Pemba · 11/11/2023 01:02

The OP does give them the gifts then and there and I think they open them right away, as it is Christmas Day? That's how I read it.

Incredible that these kids don't know to just say 'thanks', and haven't been taught by their parents. They are apparently more than capable of speaking up and asking if there are more presents, and requesting what they want though. Amazing bad manners. I don't blame the eight year old so much but it's not as though they are tiny pre-schoolers. Terrible parenting.

OP you have been very generous and your relatives have taken that for granted. I would just stop now, you are perfectly justified.

RocketIceLollie · 11/11/2023 00:53

Christmas is for children essentially. If you are looking for a thank you then perhaps give the gifts to the children yourself rather than leave them to open a few days later on Christmas Day so they remember to say thank you when they receive the gift to open there and then rather than being forgotten in the pile of presents from various people.

fudgelover1 · 11/11/2023 00:52

Banana1979 · 11/11/2023 00:33

at age 8 unless they have your number how can they say thank you
that’s for the parents to say
Unless did they did not say thank you when u handed them the presents
did you actually hand over the presents to them or did you take them in a bag and tell the parents to give the gifts as that makes a difference
sometimes I’m irked when people expect and extra thank you after I’ve opened a gift when I already said thanks when receiving it it’s like people want two thank yous and that’s not what gifting is about.
maybe call your sibling and say the kids have never said thank you -and if there is an issue with the gifts your giving that way you can inform her you don’t get a thank you without being confrontational .

We always celebrate Christmas at my parents.

I will hand the presents over in a gift bag and they have never said a thank you.

They will unwrap the presents and still not say a simple thanks, instead I get asked for more presents.

I guess it does seem harsh just stopping buying them presents all together, the selection box with £5 is a good idea though.

OP posts:
mondaytosunday · 11/11/2023 00:44

I used to buy presents for my cousins kids who lived abroad. I didn't have kids for the first few years but when I did I never got any presents back, but that's not why I bought them. Then one year my cousin wrote to me at Easter and said she knew I had sent them gifts at Christmas, but that they had so many she couldn't remember what they were but thanks.
Never sent them gifts again.

fudgelover1 · 11/11/2023 00:33

caringcarer · 11/11/2023 00:29

I think the DC have been brought up badly by their parents. My sister's always gift to my 2 DGS's who are only 8 and 5 and the boys always send a thank you letter they write themselves to my sister's. Before they could write they drew a picture and put a thank you stamp on it. I've seen them stuck up on my sister's fridge.

@caringcarer

Yes 100% it is a result of the parenting as the parents have no manners themselves.

OP posts:
Banana1979 · 11/11/2023 00:33

at age 8 unless they have your number how can they say thank you
that’s for the parents to say
Unless did they did not say thank you when u handed them the presents
did you actually hand over the presents to them or did you take them in a bag and tell the parents to give the gifts as that makes a difference
sometimes I’m irked when people expect and extra thank you after I’ve opened a gift when I already said thanks when receiving it it’s like people want two thank yous and that’s not what gifting is about.
maybe call your sibling and say the kids have never said thank you -and if there is an issue with the gifts your giving that way you can inform her you don’t get a thank you without being confrontational .

caringcarer · 11/11/2023 00:29

I think the DC have been brought up badly by their parents. My sister's always gift to my 2 DGS's who are only 8 and 5 and the boys always send a thank you letter they write themselves to my sister's. Before they could write they drew a picture and put a thank you stamp on it. I've seen them stuck up on my sister's fridge.

momtoboys · 11/11/2023 00:29

vincettenoir · 10/11/2023 21:37

They are small kids who can’t emotionally regulate yet. I think YABU to be so precious about last year. But I guess it’s your money and it’s up to you.

Oh, that is ridiculous.

caringcarer · 11/11/2023 00:24

LimboNovember · 10/11/2023 21:42

Children do throw toys around.
Can you give a 10 in card each?
It's not nice your care and generosity have been talent for granted.
However I wouldn't punish the dc.. I would just reduce and give money in card. Children love money in card.

Yes, I'd do this. All kids like cash. When they grow up they will remember you bought them things. I saw my now adult nephew when I attended a funeral earlier in the year. I chatted to him for a while and one of his sons was getting bored and wanting attention, he turned to his young son and said stop being rude, Aunty X was always very kind to me when I was a child. I want to speak with her now. It made me swallow a lump in my throat that he remembered.

Rosesandstars · 11/11/2023 00:22

I would probably just decide on a £10 budget per niece/nephew OR get them each a selection box and stick a £10 note to it?

You could ask your sister and brother-in-law whether you are 'all not doing presents again this year?', if they don't buy you anything!

Inyournewdress · 11/11/2023 00:20

If anyone says anything I’d just say I was cutting back this year as expenses mount up and you often get the feeling that some of things you give ‘people’ are not really enjoyed or wasted money.

Inyournewdress · 11/11/2023 00:18

I think I would buy the children one small gift each for birthday and one each for Christmas, again very small. Maybe some Xmas chocs each.

I wouldn’t make a sudden cut off in giving but I wouldn’t spend much. That would feel easiest to me but it’s ok to stop if you prefer of course.

They absolutely should have been more grateful and appreciative. But at the same time I think you’d be less bothered by that if you’d not spent so much.

Tbry · 11/11/2023 00:16

I am in similar situations with our nieces and nephews, well we are same on both sides. But we are not going to stop giving to the children and then be accused of being something or other.

If there’s a birthday each and a Christmas gift (my family all seem to have birthdays before and after Xmas too so I can relate), you need to spend less.

so for example birthday one sort Xmas the other
book and £5 or a booktoken
chocs, sweets or selection box with £5

Or just a £5 gift so mini set of toiletries, fluffy socks, hot choc and a mug that sort of thing.

If you can get birthday down to £10 each xmas £5 will be £30 for both rather than a £100.

And no definitely do not give a family joint gift as then the adults also get something and don’t give to you.

See how that goes for this year and the best of luck I really do know how utterly hurtful it is.

Goldbar · 11/11/2023 00:11

fudgelover1 · 10/11/2023 23:59

@ReadingSoManyThreads

They both have December birthdays and it's not like I buy them one present each I buy them several each for birthday and Christmas.

The birthdays are literally a few days before Christmas.

I dont think its being unreasonable seeing as I dont get anything of the parents for mine.

YWNBU so long as you wrapped some presents in Christmas wrapping paper and some presents in birthday wrapping paper.

Personally, I think you need to separate out the parents and the kids. I'd definitely stop giving to your sister and BIL, but the children are separate people. With admittedly shit manners that they've learnt from their parents. They may learn some good manners eventually from non-parental influences and may, far into the future, tell you that actually they loved receiving presents from you and this was a highlight for them.

fudgelover1 · 10/11/2023 23:59

ReadingSoManyThreads · 10/11/2023 23:52

YANBU, however, you were BU for previously buying them "joint birthday/Christmas" presents. Why do people think it's ok to do that?

@ReadingSoManyThreads

They both have December birthdays and it's not like I buy them one present each I buy them several each for birthday and Christmas.

The birthdays are literally a few days before Christmas.

I dont think its being unreasonable seeing as I dont get anything of the parents for mine.

OP posts:
ReadingSoManyThreads · 10/11/2023 23:52

YANBU, however, you were BU for previously buying them "joint birthday/Christmas" presents. Why do people think it's ok to do that?

Goldbar · 10/11/2023 23:48

I'd be tempted to give the 13yo a Costa voucher and the 8yo a shed-load of sugar (maybe a massive jar of jelly beans). And nothing for the adults.

Maray1967 · 10/11/2023 23:42

wellerhugs5 · 10/11/2023 23:32

We have the annual writing thank you card forced sessions with the kids DD 10 and DS 8. They don't want to do it. Every year.
I make them anyway and explain why it's so important to say thank you.
It's an effort each year, but it's worth it, a polite thank you is always so gratefully received.
I also hated writing my thank you cards when I was a kid - it was just childhood laziness more than anything!

Same here. Now mine text, but I make sure they’ve done it!

wellerhugs5 · 10/11/2023 23:32

We have the annual writing thank you card forced sessions with the kids DD 10 and DS 8. They don't want to do it. Every year.
I make them anyway and explain why it's so important to say thank you.
It's an effort each year, but it's worth it, a polite thank you is always so gratefully received.
I also hated writing my thank you cards when I was a kid - it was just childhood laziness more than anything!

Sundaefraise · 10/11/2023 23:20

converseandjeans · 10/11/2023 21:54

YANBU to be fed up - but honestly it's the parent's fault. We force ours to write notes to say thank you - but I think it's rare nowadays & a bit old fashioned.

Maybe just give them £10 & a selection box?

I think this is what i would do as I wouldn’t want to make a big deal of it, but certainly wouldn’t want to spend too much or give the present buying any head space.

FrostieBoabby · 10/11/2023 23:20

If you see them on Xmas day I would give them both a token gift like a small selection box or chocolate orange. Otherwise I wouldn't bother at all.

I stopped giving to my siblings kids presents when it dawned on me I never got any acknowledgement and even my 'big' bdays went by without even a text so none of them give a monkeys about me.

As a child, we had an elderly spinster great aunt who always bought us a gift and my Mum always gave her a present from all us kids (not comparing OP to an elderly spinster btw, the memory just poppped into my mind!)

saraclara · 10/11/2023 23:14

The thank yous should come from their parents. I gather you don't have children yourself, OP?

WTF? I do have children and I have grandchildren. And absolutely the thank you should come from the children. These kids are 8 and 13! My kids said thank you (nudged by me where necessary) from the moment they could say the word. My little granddaughters the same. Their parents will then add an 'oh that's lovely, thank you' of their own where appropriate.

Vinrouge4 · 10/11/2023 23:13

vincettenoir · 10/11/2023 21:37

They are small kids who can’t emotionally regulate yet. I think YABU to be so precious about last year. But I guess it’s your money and it’s up to you.

They are 8 and 13. Hardly small kids.