Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get niece & nephew Christmas presents this year?

210 replies

fudgelover1 · 10/11/2023 21:30

I always buy my niece and nephew Christmas presents, and I usually buy like 3/4 parents as their birthdays are in December so it's a joint present.

However last year they never said thank you and the parents didn't say anything either.

I never get any presents back of my sister and BIL.

This year I don't feel like buying my niece and nephew anything for Christmas just because I dont find them appreciative or grateful.

My nephew was chucking the toys on the floor that I brought him last year.

They are 8 and 13.

Am I being unreasonable to not buy them anything this year?

OP posts:
Celticliving · 11/11/2023 08:10

I hand over the gifts. I expect a thank you at that point. If there is none, I gently pull the gift back and say "shall we try that again?". I repeat the process until they realise that I am expecting them to say thanks.

Once the present is opened, if they've not said anything, I will say "Do you like it" or "what do we say now?".

Repeat each and every time. They WILL get it, they might just need a nudge.

There are some funny fish on MN. 8 and 10 too young to say thank you. Utter bollocks. I would expect a 2 year old to say thank you. And it's absolutely down to the kids, not the parents, to say thanks!

Mookie81 · 11/11/2023 08:09

vincettenoir · 10/11/2023 21:37

They are small kids who can’t emotionally regulate yet. I think YABU to be so precious about last year. But I guess it’s your money and it’s up to you.

They're 8 and 13, not 3 year old toddlers.
Stop excusing bad behaviour and bad manners.

Nowstrong · 11/11/2023 08:08

Putting tin hat on. I am old (had to write thank you letters to aunts and uncles, extremely confusing as I still believed in father Xmas) but 1 word comes to my mind.
Spoilt.
Then again, don't know the children or parents, at least a thank you, even at 8, is not too much to expect.

boobot1 · 11/11/2023 07:59

lto2019 · 10/11/2023 22:52

Nope not unreasonable. I have done exactly the same. I bought for one lot and not the others so that put the cat amongst the pigeons - not that the kids knew the others got presents. The first year of no thank you - I let it slide - maybe each parent thought the other had done it. The second year - I was annoyed. The third year - I left presents for one lot of kids and when asked about the others I said - I didn't get a thankyou from either parent for the last two years so haven't bothered buying this year. It takes 2 mins for the parent to send a text with a thankyou, It's not like I expected the kids to write a long arsed thank you letter like I used to have to!

I find the not saying thank you, odd. Surely everyones automatic response to being given a gift is thank you! 🤔

SwirlyWhirls · 11/11/2023 07:53

PestilencialCrisis · 10/11/2023 21:59

Did you send it in the post or give it to them in person? If in person, surely they must've said thank you as it was handed over? Or do you mean they didn't say thank you after opening the present? Or do you mean that they said thank you on the phone/text, but didn't write a thank you card?

The way it would work with my family (at my parents’ house) is that someone would sit by the tree and pass out all the presents. Like “here’s one for X”. So I didn’t pass the presents directly to my nieces. With maybe 8 people in the room, typically 2-3 presents would be being opened at once. My nieces would just quietly open their presents and put them to the side without saying thank you.

LlynTegid · 11/11/2023 07:38

Seems reasonable not to, think you have to assume it will be no presents in the future as well.

LaurieStrode · 11/11/2023 07:33

stayathomer · 11/11/2023 07:17

Nonsense.

Gifts are part of the reciprocal give and take in relationships, a dialogue of sorts. Expecting a response when one has made a kindly and generous gesture is normal. If the "dialogue" is always one-sided and unanswered, why bother?
For the little thrill you feel when you find THAT present, for the excitement in wrapping it, for the littlebuzz you get knowing you have bought someone something! You win some, you lose some, people might not always acknowledge or even like your presents, but there’s a nice feeling in knowing you did something nice for someone and that you tried your best to give them something to make them smile. There’s a whole load of people out there only willing to give if they get, help if they’ve been helped and who are waiting for other people to make the first move just because they shouldn’t have to go first. Very lonely way to live.

How insulting.

Expecting the common social courtesy of thanks doesn't make one a person who "only gives to get."

stayathomer · 11/11/2023 07:21

Ps I’d be shocked if everyone on this thread can hand on heart say every time they were given a gift as a child they reacted the right way when they were given it- didn’t just take and run out, put it down, leave it behind or forget to say thanks for it at least once?!

stayathomer · 11/11/2023 07:17

Nonsense.

Gifts are part of the reciprocal give and take in relationships, a dialogue of sorts. Expecting a response when one has made a kindly and generous gesture is normal. If the "dialogue" is always one-sided and unanswered, why bother?
For the little thrill you feel when you find THAT present, for the excitement in wrapping it, for the littlebuzz you get knowing you have bought someone something! You win some, you lose some, people might not always acknowledge or even like your presents, but there’s a nice feeling in knowing you did something nice for someone and that you tried your best to give them something to make them smile. There’s a whole load of people out there only willing to give if they get, help if they’ve been helped and who are waiting for other people to make the first move just because they shouldn’t have to go first. Very lonely way to live.

CoffeeCantata · 11/11/2023 07:01

I agree with other pps that you would be justified in either not buying presents, or buying a very small token present for these ungrateful children.

Yes, I accept that written thank-yous may be a thing of the past, but a nice, personal text is the very minimum, I think. Of course you say thank you when first opening the present, but it's good to reinforce that with something later. I was always made to write my thank-you letters and although I hated it (all children do) it taught me a lesson about how much the thank-you meant to the person who'd bought me a present (because they'd often tell us so!!). I didn't understand this lesson at the time, but that's true of a lot of things we need to learn as children. Parents need to say 'Trust me, this will matter to Auntie Jill!'

I used to get my children (when they were little) to draw a picture (maybe of the actual present) and just write 'thank you' and the person's name, if they could. This made it a bit more enjoyable and creative for them and brought a smile to the face of the present-giver.

I sometimes feel so depressed by the level of grabby selfishness which we hear about now - on MN particularly! Surely enforcing the idea of a thank-you, oral, written or drawn, is an important lesson for kids - to try to understand the thought that's gone into a gift. The fact that they might think it's boring is absolutely irrelevant. Bits of life are boring, so get over it!

LaurieStrode · 11/11/2023 06:53

PurpleSky09 · 11/11/2023 06:30

Sounds like it's just how they've been brought up. If you can afford a gift for them both I wouldn't stop completely. Why don't you just ask them what they would like and go from there? It's ungrateful and rude not to say thank you but maybe they simply don't like the gifts and being children it will be harder for them to hide their disappointment. If you buy them something they've asked for and hand it to them you can make a point of asking for a thank you!

Otherwise I think you need to speak to your sibling and explain why you're not going to spend so much this year so everyone is aware. Spending £100+ to now buying them a shared box of £5 chocolates is going to go down like a lead balloon and potentially start a row which I'd want to avoid on Christmas Day!

No. Just no.

A) she DID get them what they requested and still received no thanks

B) their parents get no input or advance warning that gifts won't be given this year. Who gives a shit if it's a lead balloon? They certainly haven't concerned themselves with OP's feelings.

Hotchocolatemousse · 11/11/2023 06:47

Don't give them anything, just wrap a large box of biscuits as a family gift. If they query the absence of gifts say you're re-evaluating everything. Mention that little Johnny might be too old for toys because he threw them around last year. So you didn't think he'd appreciate receiving childish toys again this year.

Penguinmouse · 11/11/2023 06:47

I don’t think you’re being unreasonable. I used to write thank you notes at an age younger than them - I can’t believe their parents didn’t prompt with a “say thank you” even if they forgot. I would maybe raise with their parents ahead of Christmas Day so that it’s not awkward on the day but entirely reasonable to say you’ve never been thanked and presents were chucked on the floor last year so you won’t be getting gifts beyond a selection box. That might kick the parents into action and realising how rude they’ve been.

Rocksonabeach · 11/11/2023 06:38

No you aren’t being unreasonable I’m no contact with mine and it’s a relief not to spend £100 s on everybody.

The year before Last Christmas I gave everyone presents and dropped them round and I didn’t get a single text to say thank you. Last year I didn’t do anything and I won’t this year. I do donate to a soup kitchen and help out instead.

piscofrisco · 11/11/2023 06:38

I have this same dilemma except my niece and nephew are 27 and 24 and both working. Im
Not doing it this year after 24 years of not being thanked!

PurpleSky09 · 11/11/2023 06:30

Sounds like it's just how they've been brought up. If you can afford a gift for them both I wouldn't stop completely. Why don't you just ask them what they would like and go from there? It's ungrateful and rude not to say thank you but maybe they simply don't like the gifts and being children it will be harder for them to hide their disappointment. If you buy them something they've asked for and hand it to them you can make a point of asking for a thank you!

Otherwise I think you need to speak to your sibling and explain why you're not going to spend so much this year so everyone is aware. Spending £100+ to now buying them a shared box of £5 chocolates is going to go down like a lead balloon and potentially start a row which I'd want to avoid on Christmas Day!

angsanana · 11/11/2023 06:15

vincettenoir · 10/11/2023 21:37

They are small kids who can’t emotionally regulate yet. I think YABU to be so precious about last year. But I guess it’s your money and it’s up to you.

7 is old enough to not chuck a toy on the floor that doesn't belong on the floor. Writing a thank you card is a faff at that age but a thank you if some sort is just polite eg from the parents. It's not unreasonable not to buy but I get these conversations and decisions can have consequences making you think you wish you'd just bought something to keep the peace! Only you can make that call xx

TolkiensFallow · 11/11/2023 06:10

There are a few things you could do but I think you actually need to address the issue. It’s a bit pass agg to see people or children at Xmas and just not give anything.

You could speak to the parents and let them know you love the kids but you have noticed the lack of manners and find it rude.

You could give the kids presents and if they don’t say thank you then say “have you forgotten to say something/forgotten your manners? I shan’t be buying presents again if you don’t want them” - they are old enough to hear this and they won’t learn if no one teaches them. Their parents clearly aren’t teaching them but it will be a life lesson.

Finally…the joint xmas and birthday thing…I get that you buy several presents. Are the birthday presents wrapped in birthday paper and given ok the actual birthday? It doesn’t sound like it…that is the etiquette though. Having your birthday written off “because it’s so close to Xmas they might as well be combined” is a pet peeve of most people with Xmas birthdays.

LaurieStrode · 11/11/2023 06:09

caringcarer · 11/11/2023 00:29

I think the DC have been brought up badly by their parents. My sister's always gift to my 2 DGS's who are only 8 and 5 and the boys always send a thank you letter they write themselves to my sister's. Before they could write they drew a picture and put a thank you stamp on it. I've seen them stuck up on my sister's fridge.

You're doing a great job of raising such thoughtful and gracious kids!

LaurieStrode · 11/11/2023 06:02

stayathomer · 10/11/2023 23:08

I thought we gave because we saw something people really wanted to have as opposed to receiving back? Yes not great they didn’t respond the right way but you’re being as bad back in another way surely? As someone said a family present instead? A board game is a great one

Nonsense.

Gifts are part of the reciprocal give and take in relationships, a dialogue of sorts. Expecting a response when one has made a kindly and generous gesture is normal. If the "dialogue" is always one-sided and unanswered, why bother?

Drop the rope, OP. If they're taken aback, that's their problem. Thank you notes are NOT a thing of the past.

thehonscupboard · 11/11/2023 04:33

Buy them a set of thank you cards and a pen and stamps.

howdoesyourgardengrowinmay · 11/11/2023 04:15

vincettenoir · 10/11/2023 21:37

They are small kids who can’t emotionally regulate yet. I think YABU to be so precious about last year. But I guess it’s your money and it’s up to you.

At what age do children start to 'emotionally regulate'?

QWERTYoutside · 11/11/2023 02:44

Oh jeez stop, manners are free and gift giving is lovely when people are appreciative, it’s hard to stop at first but it will become the new norm.

MrsClausno27 · 11/11/2023 01:29

I'm mrs Claus and I say stop buying for the entitled little shits.

LaurieStrode · 11/11/2023 01:22

RocketIceLollie · 11/11/2023 00:53

Christmas is for children essentially. If you are looking for a thank you then perhaps give the gifts to the children yourself rather than leave them to open a few days later on Christmas Day so they remember to say thank you when they receive the gift to open there and then rather than being forgotten in the pile of presents from various people.

Christmas is not essentially for children. By far.

We have barely any children in our large extended family and still massively enjoy it.

Grabby little ingrates shouldn't be tolerated.

Swipe left for the next trending thread