Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get niece & nephew Christmas presents this year?

210 replies

fudgelover1 · 10/11/2023 21:30

I always buy my niece and nephew Christmas presents, and I usually buy like 3/4 parents as their birthdays are in December so it's a joint present.

However last year they never said thank you and the parents didn't say anything either.

I never get any presents back of my sister and BIL.

This year I don't feel like buying my niece and nephew anything for Christmas just because I dont find them appreciative or grateful.

My nephew was chucking the toys on the floor that I brought him last year.

They are 8 and 13.

Am I being unreasonable to not buy them anything this year?

OP posts:
Iloveanicegarden · 12/11/2023 22:45

For years I sought out interesting items for presents, wrapped them imaginatively, Spent quite a lot in total and barely any thanks from any of the 5 children. When they'd got too old for presents I gave money - wrapped up as little gifts on 'money trees' etc

We were thinking of dividing our estate between the 5 of them but since we seem to have dropped off the face of the earth (except at Christmas and birthdays) One younger relative even went as far as saing she 'forgot we were here' (5mins away by car) We are now inclined to leave our estate to charity!

LavendersBlueeee · 12/11/2023 22:20

Similar for us - BIL has 6 kids and we get them birthday and Christmas gifts every year which goes into the hundreds of pounds. I don’t even know if they get any enjoyment from the gifts as they never mention them after they’ve received them. We just have to guess what they like as we are never given any ideas.
We on the other hand have 1 DC who is younger than theirs and it’s very hit and Miss whether they buy anything for our kid. Sometimes yes at £50, sometimes nothing, sometimes something cheap or shit or that we’ve already got because they never bother to ask.
Dont know that our nieces and nephews should suffer because their parents aren’t great at buying for ours but we honestly paying so much for gifts for their kids and we don’t even know if they appreciate them.

TerrysNeapolitan · 12/11/2023 22:12

YANBU AT ALL!

Orangeslush · 12/11/2023 22:05

Yanbu I can sympathise. My SIL is a total narcissist, just like my bro. Everything is about them and her kids are entitled brats who never say thank you. I still buy for them reluctantly but wish I could lose that sense of obligation.

Damnedidont · 12/11/2023 22:01

You don't have to treat everyone the same! Please don't punish your polite niece. Don't buy for the ones who are rude and ungrateful. If they query it just calmly say that as they never say thanks or reciprocate you have taken the hint and have stopped embarrassing them with gifts they don't want.

fudgelover1 · 12/11/2023 21:59

Green321 · 12/11/2023 21:10

YANBU at all. They’ve been rude, but probably not the kids fault…

May be worth just thinking about your relationship with them….? Do you want a good relationship with them? What’s going on wrong?

Good question, I have tried to make the effort over the years but have now given up.

Generally I find the kids are very un pleasant and the 13 year old is especially bitchy.

I find it quite difficult to have a conversation with her.

She makes fun out of my other nieces and has a bad attitude with my parents as a result of my BIL bitching about my parents in her presence.

We all do believe it is a result of bad parenting as nobody else's kids are like that in the family.

I dont think I will be bothering anymore as its too draining.

OP posts:
fudgelover1 · 12/11/2023 21:49

EvenBetta · 12/11/2023 20:57

‘My sister and BIL seem completely oblivious to how bad mannered the kids are, even they tell me not to get them any presents or invite them into my home.’

So why do you insist on bringing them in to your home and buying gifts? Confused

Sorry meant to say my parents advise me not to but them presents and invite them into my home.

OP posts:
CWigtownshire · 12/11/2023 21:49

Converseandjeans - you are setting such a good example getting your children to write thank you notes. I always had to and my 2 boys had to. I find it so bad mannered not to thank someone for a gift - whether they like the gift or not! I have given engagement and birthday and Christmas presents and not had a thank you, so rude. And no, I don't think it's up to the parents to say thank you for kids presents, the kids should be brought up with good manners to say thank you themselves from a young age. Makes me sound like a moaning old git, but I'm not really 😀

Ilovecleaning · 12/11/2023 21:20

‘I never get any presents back from brother SIL ‘ - so WHY buy gifts for them??? You are asking to be treated badly. Don’t be such a mug and stop asking to be treated like 💩. I actually sympathise with you tbh. I used to do something similar some years ago until I saw sense. 🌺

Hihellogoodbye · 12/11/2023 21:13

I’m in the same situation with my SIL. She’s a single mum to a 8 year old girl. Always self centred and no matter how much we try she just ignores us and never says even a thank you.

so I’m done with her. Not trying anymore.

this year will be buying for my other sil and her family and my pil

Green321 · 12/11/2023 21:10

YANBU at all. They’ve been rude, but probably not the kids fault…

May be worth just thinking about your relationship with them….? Do you want a good relationship with them? What’s going on wrong?

HalebiHabibti · 12/11/2023 21:07

I didn't make the selection box suggestion but definitely think that it should be completely aligned for everyone. Ie one box of the same brand/type for each family, plus a large 'sharer' bag of M&Ms or something per person under the age of 18. That way you will have given them something individually as well as part of a group gift.

When the polite niece thanks you, make a point of accepting her thanks graciously (ie "thank you lovely, I hope you like them" or similar). Just enough of a response that the lack of thanks from the others is highlighted....

Mamatolittlemonsters · 12/11/2023 21:02

My DC are 2 and 5

If they get a gift in person I always make sure they say thank you when they receive the gift and again once it’s opened (normally with a hug or high five). 5 year old sometimes forgets to say thank you but all I have to say is “have you forgotten something” with either of them and they magically remember. If we don’t see the person when they open it it’s probably because we don’t see them very often. My eldest has problems writing so I always make sure he knows who got him what and I send them a message. If they get money I take a picture of them with what they’ve got to say thank you

sometimes he’s asked my sister if there’s anything else, because normally she’ll get them a few smaller gifts and put them in a gift bag so he doesn’t know when it ends 😂 But she’s actually really good at getting them things and always seems to know what they want

i find it really sad that they don’t buy anything for you. My sister buys for me and the kids for my birthday (not DH because she forgets his birthday every year 😂) and we don’t tend to see her around his birthday. I also tell her not to buy for my birthday or either of us for Christmas. She has no kids and buys for all of us. We’ve managed to whittle it down so she gets us a joint bottle of something for Christmas and we buy her something for both of them to share and something each off the kids while she buys for all of us. It’s not expected in the slightest though and I don’t think she realises the extras we put in (but always thanks us)

i feel your pain over the lack of thanks. My niece and nephew are 5&8 and don’t say thank you at all for gifts (regardless to if we’ve given them in person or not). I don’t know if it’s because my kids always say thank you (or I say thank you on their behalf) I feel like they should know to say thank you or parents should remind them. I could honestly forget to send something and I don’t think they’d notice 😂

EvenBetta · 12/11/2023 20:57

‘My sister and BIL seem completely oblivious to how bad mannered the kids are, even they tell me not to get them any presents or invite them into my home.’

So why do you insist on bringing them in to your home and buying gifts? Confused

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 12/11/2023 20:44

Or even a text, email, WhatsApp, quick call, whatever, to say thank you. Doesn't have to be a handwritten letter, notecard, obvs!

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 12/11/2023 20:27

YANBU but just to say that all the pp saying the parents should thank you obviously the 13 year old should for a requested lovely present, but so should the 8 year old. I get handwritten thank you notes from all my nieces and nephews, and now some greats of each. Usually written themselves obviously guided by parents from the age of 5, no exaggeration. It's lovely seeing how their writing changes as they grow. When they've each reached 10 years old it's a £10 in a card, but col means I now just do birthdays, not Christmas, explained to the parents, no probs, no guilt.
My children were taught by me to write thank you letters, as I was by my mum

prayforthecottransfer · 12/11/2023 20:17

You definitely don't save to buy them anything if you find they're ungrateful.

*their birthdays are in December so it's a joint present
*
Why would you do a joint present for December birthdays? As a person with a December birthday and a mother of a child with a December birthday, this is a copout.

<misses point>

guffaux · 12/11/2023 20:13

For dp's great nephew and niece we gave them gifts as babies/toddlers, gifts with age appropriate money as young children, then money,from 50- going up to 100 as teens- late teens 100 every year-not one thankyou for the past 23 years, from them, or their parents, not even a card for birthday/ Christmas for dp (never mind me) - now the youngest is 18 we are stopping all together- expect it to down like a lead balloon.

fudgelover1 · 12/11/2023 20:07

HalebiHabibti · 12/11/2023 19:19

I'd buy the same gift for everyone to give out in public and individual nice gifts for the people who appreciate them and say thank you (the latter to be given out ahead of time, privately).

Yes 100%.
I was thinking of doing this.

Very good idea.

By selection box do you mean the £2 Cadburys ones or do you mean Roses/ Quality Street/ Heroes?

OP posts:
fudgelover1 · 12/11/2023 20:05

OldPerson · 12/11/2023 19:54

Do you even like your niece and nephew? Do you spend time with them - just you and them? Do you even like your sister? Will you like them more or less in 5 years? If you honestly don't get any value out of spending time with them, then just drift apart. But generally presents are given out of liking another person - not what gratitude you get. Always, always, it's what you get out of spending time with someone. And if you're not getting any joy out of spending time with them - then just ignore them. But it's your decision to walk away from family members. Otherwise just buy them a bar of chocolate and/or promise to take them to the park/ macdonalds/ shopping/ a theme park/ ice-skating/ petting zoo. But don't act like a Diva, that wasn't thanked enough or at all. You need to be a positive influence or no influence at all.

I wouldnt say I dont like my niece and nephew I just find then terribly bad mannered.

Even when they have visited me they will show me no respect, steal things from my home, go in all the cupboards and terrorise my pets.

My nephew in particular is quite aggressive and loves breaking things.

I try and make conversation with the 13 year and and she just looks at me blankly and it is "yes" or "no" answers.

My sister and BIL seem completely oblivious to how bad mannered the kids are, even they tell me not to get them any presents or invite them into my home.

OP posts:
Watchthedoormat · 12/11/2023 19:58

Cinema gift card for the whole family. Surely the parents will say thank you and it won't be so annoying when the DC don't acknowledge their individual gifts.

00100001 · 12/11/2023 19:56

BitofaStramash · 11/11/2023 20:11

They are still just children. 😳

Children who are more than old enough to say thank you when given something...

Even if the little one needed reminding, they should have both thanked their aunty.

Do your kids not say thank you for stuff? Or do you let them not bother because they "still just children"?

OldPerson · 12/11/2023 19:54

Do you even like your niece and nephew? Do you spend time with them - just you and them? Do you even like your sister? Will you like them more or less in 5 years? If you honestly don't get any value out of spending time with them, then just drift apart. But generally presents are given out of liking another person - not what gratitude you get. Always, always, it's what you get out of spending time with someone. And if you're not getting any joy out of spending time with them - then just ignore them. But it's your decision to walk away from family members. Otherwise just buy them a bar of chocolate and/or promise to take them to the park/ macdonalds/ shopping/ a theme park/ ice-skating/ petting zoo. But don't act like a Diva, that wasn't thanked enough or at all. You need to be a positive influence or no influence at all.

RavenhairedRachel · 12/11/2023 19:54

I always used to make an effort with my neices and nephew spending quite a bit ans putting thought into gifts. However when my daughter was born she was the 5th grandchild on her first Christmas my SIL said ' we don't usually get presents for the neices and nephews now, but seeing as it's her first Christmas we'll get her a gift'.I was livid I felt like telling her to stuff it and she didn't have a problem accepting any of our gifts.

Yirk · 12/11/2023 19:42

Young nieces and nephews now only receive a selection box each, I was spending silly money I couldn't afford onnthings they didn't really need or want 🌲

Swipe left for the next trending thread