Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not get niece & nephew Christmas presents this year?

210 replies

fudgelover1 · 10/11/2023 21:30

I always buy my niece and nephew Christmas presents, and I usually buy like 3/4 parents as their birthdays are in December so it's a joint present.

However last year they never said thank you and the parents didn't say anything either.

I never get any presents back of my sister and BIL.

This year I don't feel like buying my niece and nephew anything for Christmas just because I dont find them appreciative or grateful.

My nephew was chucking the toys on the floor that I brought him last year.

They are 8 and 13.

Am I being unreasonable to not buy them anything this year?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Catopia · 20/11/2023 20:22

fudgelover1 · 11/11/2023 13:26

It's just not the children that don't say thank you.

I brought my sister and her husband some perfume and aftershave and never got a thank you.

I don't have a close relationship with these set of children, the 13 year old will barely talk and is very hard to start a conversation with her.

My other sister is very grateful and her child will always say thank you and they will get me presents.

I dont want it to be awkward as we all be together on Xmas Day and it will look bad one set of kids getting something and the others nothing.
I think a selection box is a good idea.

I agree with PP saying manners cost nothing and at 13 you would my niece would at least say thank you.

Is there any way you can arrange to see just that sister and daughter e.g. on xmas eve and give them the present 1:1 to make it less awkward?

LaurieStrode · 19/11/2023 00:31

Agree, @LizzBurg

One really wonders what sort of deficient parenting such children have had.

LizzBurg · 18/11/2023 23:06

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 18/11/2023 17:45

You get someone something or do something for them, you get a thank you which tells you they're grateful. You continue doing so as you know they appreciate it.

You don't get a thank you, they throw said presents on the floor, tells you they don't appreciate it, which means you stop doing so, simple!

Same as if it were a partner, colleague, friend.
If not even the parents can acknowledge OP's efforts, it means it's meaningless to them. So why force it on them when they've made it loud and clear it's not appreciated.

Enabling rudeness and being spoilt isn't a good thing either.

Personally if I saw my niece or nephew throwing a gift that I had just given them on the floor as the giver of the gift and also their aunt I’d be having a word with them. It’s hardly the child’s fault if their parents or other family members aren’t teaching them how to behave appropriately.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 18/11/2023 17:45

LizzBurg · 18/11/2023 11:35

If them showing you gratitude is your motivation for getting their gifts then maybe you’re right to stop.

You get someone something or do something for them, you get a thank you which tells you they're grateful. You continue doing so as you know they appreciate it.

You don't get a thank you, they throw said presents on the floor, tells you they don't appreciate it, which means you stop doing so, simple!

Same as if it were a partner, colleague, friend.
If not even the parents can acknowledge OP's efforts, it means it's meaningless to them. So why force it on them when they've made it loud and clear it's not appreciated.

Enabling rudeness and being spoilt isn't a good thing either.

LaurieStrode · 18/11/2023 16:39

LizzBurg · 18/11/2023 11:35

If them showing you gratitude is your motivation for getting their gifts then maybe you’re right to stop.

That's how gift exchanges work among civilized people.

daliesque · 18/11/2023 11:59

MyCircumference · 11/11/2023 08:11

i would change it to a family present, a cinema voucher or something

Personally I wouldn't bother at all. They aren't grateful, they give nothing back and even your parents are telling you to stop giving. So stop.

LizzBurg · 18/11/2023 11:35

If them showing you gratitude is your motivation for getting their gifts then maybe you’re right to stop.

fudgelover1 · 14/11/2023 09:38

Doingmybesteveryday · 14/11/2023 07:56

Absolutely. 13 and 8! I’ve been sending thank you cards after every Christmas and birthday since a very young age. I still do it now and cringe if I haven’t thanked someone or sent it late! No excuses for bad manners. Your sister and BIL should be insisting they do, not allowing her to request expensive perfume. I’d be so embarrassed. Don’t send them anything. Cheeky little brats!

Yes I absolutely agree with you.

I have decided im not going to buy them Christmas/birthday presents again.

I dont even get a box of chocolates/ card of my sister or BIL at Christmas.

On my birthday I got a £2 mug, this was after spending £100 - £150 between the four of them at Christmas.

It wouldnt be so bad if I got a thank you but they dont and manners dont cost anything.

I would just rather donate the money to a cat charity and would make me feel a lot better.

OP posts:
Doingmybesteveryday · 14/11/2023 07:56

Absolutely. 13 and 8! I’ve been sending thank you cards after every Christmas and birthday since a very young age. I still do it now and cringe if I haven’t thanked someone or sent it late! No excuses for bad manners. Your sister and BIL should be insisting they do, not allowing her to request expensive perfume. I’d be so embarrassed. Don’t send them anything. Cheeky little brats!

Toddlerteaplease · 13/11/2023 12:22

vincettenoir · 10/11/2023 21:37

They are small kids who can’t emotionally regulate yet. I think YABU to be so precious about last year. But I guess it’s your money and it’s up to you.

They are 8 & 13. So are old evolution not to be rude.

Barney60 · 13/11/2023 11:35

I would expect 8 and 13 year olds to say thank you for a gift.

This.

fudgelover1 · 13/11/2023 11:06

Sugarfree23 · 13/11/2023 09:09

Op things I'd do.
Cut back on the mum and dad, no expensive gifts for them a token to open - chocolates, biscuits, wine.

The kids. Are the birthdays gifts actually presented as birthdays, ie birthday paper etc? If they aren't then you haven't really given them birthday gifts so I wouldn't start now.
If they are then change of tact, money in a card for birthday.

Christmas cut it back to one gift at a set budget.

My LO has a Christmas birthday too and I sometimes feel he puts ideas down because we are asking him for ideas, and he's going through the Smyth catalogue, not because it's stuff he really wants. 7 lots of people buy for him so there's 14 things before you look at stocking fillers or little extras.
Money for birthday works well so I can take him to shops in summer and choose something

@Sugarfree23

I have decided I wont be bothering with buying them any kind of presents this year.

Im just going to send a WhatsApp message to say that I am not doing presents this year.

I would rather donate some money to a cat rescue charity local to me.

OP posts:
Sugarfree23 · 13/11/2023 09:09

Op things I'd do.
Cut back on the mum and dad, no expensive gifts for them a token to open - chocolates, biscuits, wine.

The kids. Are the birthdays gifts actually presented as birthdays, ie birthday paper etc? If they aren't then you haven't really given them birthday gifts so I wouldn't start now.
If they are then change of tact, money in a card for birthday.

Christmas cut it back to one gift at a set budget.

My LO has a Christmas birthday too and I sometimes feel he puts ideas down because we are asking him for ideas, and he's going through the Smyth catalogue, not because it's stuff he really wants. 7 lots of people buy for him so there's 14 things before you look at stocking fillers or little extras.
Money for birthday works well so I can take him to shops in summer and choose something

Luxell934 · 13/11/2023 08:48

HarrietsweetHarriet · 13/11/2023 07:54

I stopped buying gifts for neices, nephews, great-neices and great-nephews as I never received a thank you. There are so many of them- 15 now- I simply can't afford to do it any more and the lack of acknowledgement had been grating for some time. The crux came when I bought a beautiful hand made hare - think long legs and ears stitched in linen with a beautiful hand made dress and slippers , for great-neice. I asked for some feedback as I thought she'd adore it ...response from mum was 'um, oh,...yeah...well she didn't know what it was, she only likes Peppa Pig'. I gave up after that. Also gave up regular gifting of my homemade preserves, chocs and bakes for same reason. Never got a thank you or a comment that it was delicious. Presumed they didn't like them so I stopped.

Would her lying to you have been more preferable? Would that have made you feel good even if it was a lie? “Oh she absolutely loved it, takes it everywhere with her!!” When the reality is she wasn’t fussed as she is only interested in Peppa Pig right now.

I get the saying thank you part is important, of course it’s just good manners. But some adults on here seem to have a very childish attitude. Oh they didn’t say thank you? so they will be cut of the will at once! And some adults seem very hurt some people don’t actually like these amazing thoughtful, handmade gifts they have put a lot of time, thought and effort into and seem to take it very personally.

If you give someone a gift, there’s a chance they might not be as enthusiastic as you are about it, the only polite thing to do is gush over it and say thank you so much! My own aunt used to buy me China dolls…they were creepy as fuck and I was too old for them, but because I said I loved them and sent a hand written card each year she kept buying me them.

HarrietsweetHarriet · 13/11/2023 07:54

I stopped buying gifts for neices, nephews, great-neices and great-nephews as I never received a thank you. There are so many of them- 15 now- I simply can't afford to do it any more and the lack of acknowledgement had been grating for some time. The crux came when I bought a beautiful hand made hare - think long legs and ears stitched in linen with a beautiful hand made dress and slippers , for great-neice. I asked for some feedback as I thought she'd adore it ...response from mum was 'um, oh,...yeah...well she didn't know what it was, she only likes Peppa Pig'. I gave up after that. Also gave up regular gifting of my homemade preserves, chocs and bakes for same reason. Never got a thank you or a comment that it was delicious. Presumed they didn't like them so I stopped.

Talkinrubbishagain · 13/11/2023 07:40

I stopped buying presents for my grandnephews. We didn’t have much money and many people to buy .
Their parents never acknowledged them. An email or fb message takes no time.
I always get my own children to write a short thankyou card.

Ktime · 13/11/2023 00:19

LavendersBlueeee · 12/11/2023 22:20

Similar for us - BIL has 6 kids and we get them birthday and Christmas gifts every year which goes into the hundreds of pounds. I don’t even know if they get any enjoyment from the gifts as they never mention them after they’ve received them. We just have to guess what they like as we are never given any ideas.
We on the other hand have 1 DC who is younger than theirs and it’s very hit and Miss whether they buy anything for our kid. Sometimes yes at £50, sometimes nothing, sometimes something cheap or shit or that we’ve already got because they never bother to ask.
Dont know that our nieces and nephews should suffer because their parents aren’t great at buying for ours but we honestly paying so much for gifts for their kids and we don’t even know if they appreciate them.

Honestly, just stop. The kids will get gifts from their parents, it’s not your job to bedeck them with gifts.

Save the money for your own poor child who they give shit gifts to!

LaurieStrode · 13/11/2023 00:15

Iloveanicegarden · 12/11/2023 22:45

For years I sought out interesting items for presents, wrapped them imaginatively, Spent quite a lot in total and barely any thanks from any of the 5 children. When they'd got too old for presents I gave money - wrapped up as little gifts on 'money trees' etc

We were thinking of dividing our estate between the 5 of them but since we seem to have dropped off the face of the earth (except at Christmas and birthdays) One younger relative even went as far as saing she 'forgot we were here' (5mins away by car) We are now inclined to leave our estate to charity!

Same here. My estate is now bequeathed to elephant rescue in India and Africa.

Unless i die really old (unlikely) it would have been a life changing amount for four now-adult ingrates. Oh well.

Ceci03 · 13/11/2023 00:05

Definitely don't pander to them with a box of chocolates or a family present. They don't care!!!!! It's nothing to them.

Ceci03 · 13/11/2023 00:04

I'm not buying my niece and nephews of one sister anything this year. Made an effort for
Their birthdays and sent coffee shop
Vouchers and cards. After about 3 weeks I txt my sis asking did they get the cards etc she said she wasn't sure!!!! None of the kids sent a txt or even acknowledged receipt so I'm giving up. I'm the person who ends up hurt. They obviously don't give 2 f*s and don't appreciate it. Probably they get too much. I hate people not saying thank you. Real bug bear. They are 15 so well able to send a quick txt

Celestine70 · 12/11/2023 23:52

I would get them nothing! And I wouldn't feel bad about it. If they actually have the gall to say anything, just tell them that every year they don't seem to care about your presents so you assumed they didn't want them.

justanothermummma · 12/11/2023 23:36

It's not their fault their parents haven't modelled gratitude. Maybe just get them one thing each?

The teenager is perfectly able to say thank you though. Do you see them often?

Maybe organise a family day out with the whole family?

StarDolphins · 12/11/2023 23:15

vincettenoir · 10/11/2023 21:37

They are small kids who can’t emotionally regulate yet. I think YABU to be so precious about last year. But I guess it’s your money and it’s up to you.

8 & 13 small kids?! What would they have been at 4 & 9, babies?

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 12/11/2023 23:12

Iloveanicegarden · 12/11/2023 22:45

For years I sought out interesting items for presents, wrapped them imaginatively, Spent quite a lot in total and barely any thanks from any of the 5 children. When they'd got too old for presents I gave money - wrapped up as little gifts on 'money trees' etc

We were thinking of dividing our estate between the 5 of them but since we seem to have dropped off the face of the earth (except at Christmas and birthdays) One younger relative even went as far as saing she 'forgot we were here' (5mins away by car) We are now inclined to leave our estate to charity!

Even worse when it's your own kids....

Mumblebeeee · 12/11/2023 23:12

Please please please do one of those charity gifts ‘in their name’. Tell them the charity sent a big thank you message which was nice for a change