Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you work in retail (shop floor) have you personally witnessed an increase in thieving?

154 replies

SaturdayGiraffe · 10/11/2023 19:23

Someone just told me there’s conspiracy theories that the shops are lying to raise prices.
I’ve seen one theft this year (as a shopper).
Suppose the AIBU is “To believe that theft has indeed increased.”

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SpaceRaiders · 13/11/2023 11:48

Let’s not pretend this isn’t happening at the top end too. I recently saw a well dressed guy walk into M&S put a large joint in his shopping bag and walk out. I suppose you never really know people’s circumstances but he certainly didn’t look like he was strapped for cash.

On another occasion as I was driving past a bus stop outside Aldi, i saw a group of women being accosted by Lidl security. The security was stacking all their meat onto the pavement. He told them they were banned from the store.

If I see someone stealing food I look the other way, it not my business. Ime you have to be in a pretty low place to steal in the first place. Also the amount of food waste supermarkets dispose is absolutely criminal, when it can be easily distributed to those who need it.

MidnightMeltdown · 13/11/2023 11:37

I grew up in poverty and we somehow managed not to steal. Being poor isn't an excuse. People who do this sort of thing are just filth. They have no morals or dignity.

MidnightMeltdown · 13/11/2023 11:34

@Ilovecakey yeah because people who don't steal are just so stuck up 🙄

NugatoryMatters · 12/11/2023 13:36

None of you stuck up mumsnetters can ever make me feel guilty so you are wasting your time

As I said, there’s a cultural problem in some corners of society. An unrepentant one. That’s why the solutions to it do not lie in policing alone.

But, it must also be remembered, that it’s not everyone in an area/community/income bracket - there are many people in living in pretty desperate poverty who wouldn’t consider buying stolen coats for their kids or buying butter stolen from a food bank. There is nothing ‘stuck up’ about that.

Sadly the people who do buy these things don’t care.

Museum1066 · 12/11/2023 13:03

Its a mix, but also apparently its common that in some big store names its classed as stock shrinkage, as its said that it's also down to staff too. How accurate that it, I'm not sure.

IDontHateRainbows · 12/11/2023 12:58

Moraldilemma84 · 10/11/2023 20:16

Yes it’s awful at the moment.
It’s endless all day long, some grab armfuls of whatever is in reach and run.
Others have detaggers and you find the security tags hidden all round the shop. They know that nothing is going to happen to them if they get caught.
I don’t know what the answer is.

Unless the police think it is worth policing, they will continue. Its effectively decriminalised.

They wouldn't get away with it if it was a burglary of someone's home

Ilovecakey · 12/11/2023 12:56

crazyivy · 12/11/2023 08:06

you are the cause of the problem. You are a fence. You have committed the crime of receiving stolen goods. If your supplier is caught any time in the next couple of years and names you, you will be arrested too

Lol funny cos she don't know my name and I don't know hers. I'm hardly the cause of all shoplifting because a woman once offered me a coat half price and I bought it. She offered it me I never asked and she would clearly still be shoplifting weather I took her up on her offer or not. None of you stuck up mumsnetters can ever make me feel guilty so you are wasting your time. Apart from that I pay for all my stuff but if an opportunity arises why would I turn it down. I'm looking out for my children. The half of the money I saved on the coat can go towards some extra food or presents for my children so as long as they are all happy I could care less what some random stuck up people on the Internet think

ManchesterGirl2 · 12/11/2023 10:13

@Findingmypast good post, that's really eye opening.

SquirrelsStars · 12/11/2023 09:43

No idea if it's increased or not, but 30 years ago I worked in British Home Stores (large department store for those not as ancient as me), and we would regularly have grab and run of whole racks of stuff - usually nice silk nighties, underwear, that sort of thing, obviously just to be sold on. Store also had a full-time security guard walking around and staff all had a system for alerting the guard to suspected shoplifters (3 short rings of the bell). So it wasn't exactly the good old days when this didn't happen! Oh and the post-xmas returns were unbelievable - so many clothes worn once but claiming they hadn't - customers bringing back ripped/dirty children's clothes claiming they were faulty/ripped when bought but had to let kids wear them for the day but still wanted and got refunded.

sep135 · 12/11/2023 09:32

Charity shops near me are more expensive than buying new

Appreciate that Vinted is a recent thing, but there's been decently priced second hand clothes on eBay for years. Or you borrow something off a friend.

Whether or not you're doing the stealing, it's still theft and someone has to pay for the loss.

lap90 · 12/11/2023 09:28

I don't work in retail but have witnessed it myself when in the high street. I've also seen an increase in people not paying transport fares.

sergeantsalt · 12/11/2023 09:27

NugatoryMatters · 11/11/2023 16:39

Charity shops also sell cheap suits, you know.

It’s not a justification.

Charity shops near me are more expensive than buying new

ssd · 12/11/2023 09:22

I work in retail and haven't noticed more shoplifters but im gullible and trust everyone if they look okBlush

Smileycup · 12/11/2023 09:21

This is what happens when inequality becomes ridiculously high. Crime goes up and mental health goes down. It’s been studied. Mental health for all suffers, not just those with the least.

PokeyLaFarge · 12/11/2023 09:11

The people justifying buying stolen goods are the first to complain about the rise in prices, lack of staff, stores closing and rise in insurance premiums!

Findingmypast · 12/11/2023 09:08

My uni (better area) now gets regularly steamed by gangs for computers and other tec. Police know, but don't get involved as the uni won't report it. They've systematically lowered security, opting to shut facilities to students more often, as cost saving. That's lead to even less security and more vandalism, and emboldened the gangs. They're now openly dealing drugs, selling shoplifted goods, publicly telling security to "do one." No ones allowed to complain.
Students complaining about situations are advised to take responsibility for their own security by only being around in main working hours. This has lead to reduced staff in library etc. Student union has no external funding so 'focusses on positivity' and students who speak out are warned about 'bringing the university into disrepute' when they get too loud about it all. 'Broken social contracts' aren't just at the bottom of society.

whiteduvetcover · 12/11/2023 09:07

I also wonder if shoplifters have been emboldened by the many videos on social media of different groups walking into Walmart and Target and just waltzing out with whatever they fancy while the security guards look on? I've seen quite a few of these videos floating about and if you were a dishonest person, I can see how you might be tempted to give it a go.

At the risk of sounding like an old fart (and I'm actually not even that old, ha!!) some people now carry such an air of entitlement they might have actually convinced themselves that it's ok.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 12/11/2023 09:06

hennybeans · 10/11/2023 21:42

The nice branch of Boots in my nearest big city has gotten rid of all their testers and locked all the makeup up in drawers. Ten years ago it was a great place to shop with a lot of high end products. Now I’m going to have to stop referring to it as the nice Boots!

I can’t imagine they would make it so inhospitable if nobody was actually stealing.

Even local small Boots has moved all their No 7 to locked cabinets.

whiteduvetcover · 12/11/2023 08:59

I don't work in retail but I have noticed the staff seem a lot more jumpy so I figure something must be going on.

If I go through self check out with tagged alcohol, they only remove the tag when I've paid and they can see it on the screen. They used to just remove it as soon as the scanner beeped.

I also popped in the other day and admittedly looked like a right scruff! I'd been decorating and had jumped in the shower before popping out but went into shop with wet hair and paint on my joggers - security guard not so discretely followed me round the shop. The guy has got a job to do and I defo wasn't stealing, but that's not something I've encountered before!

Findingmypast · 12/11/2023 08:59

Always been lots of hidden poverty and 'dodgy blokes selling knock off' on the estates, but we used to have a good variety of shops. We lost more and more after the council created red routes, then made local parking expensive and rare.
The middle classes simply drove to better places to shop with parking facilities, removing their money out of the local economy and sealing the fate of the 2 fabric shops, pet shop, plant and flower shop, gift shop, stationary shop, post office, and dry cleaners. All prior to massive increase in visible grab and run.

Those shops got slowly replaced by shops that non car owning locals (aka lower income) might walk to. A large Poundland, a poundworld, 4 betting shops, an amusement arcade, a cash converter, 2 x pawn shops, 2x plastic tat shop, several fried chicken shops.
Council deprived of some parking revenue, reacted by increasing parking wardens and lowering street cleaning. At the same point grab and run was massively increasing, as were pigeons, and crows, more visible druggies, more urine, and more and more security.

Poundland, Poundworld, Cash converter, plastic tat shops and the amusement arcade soon gave up. So much is now boarded up. 'Rough pitches' (2nd hand goods on a blanket) sprung up outside. Some enterprising homeless also come to sell what they can find combined with begging.
Then the fences started turning up with upended bread tray pitches blatantly selling shoplifted goods at a couple of quid cheaper. This is a main thoroughfare with a police station on a turning off it.

Most (not all) of the buyers are visibly down on their luck. Out of date food from 2019 onward sells well in the market. Many are really struggling and it's reflected by what's being sold by fences. It used to be all named brand coffee, laundry gel, Ferrero Rocher etc, but it took hours to sell as most still couldn't afford it, and the fences don't like hanging around too long.

There's still luxury stuff but less, it's now it's mainly gravy granules, biscuits, pet food, tinned meat, fish, and veg, tea, long life milk, sanitary pads, J cloths.
The pitches are continuously restocked by lads on hire bikes while they're there.
Some still tut at it, but 'what can you do' is the main refrain.

crazyivy · 12/11/2023 08:32

nightinorout · 12/11/2023 08:28

@crazyivy what are they selling? I volunteer at my local food bank and we never have lots of brand named products, most of what we have has little to no resale value.

lots of tinned stuff, jam, jars of pickles, breakfast cereal, eggs, bread, butter, cheese, fruit and veg, lots of stuff. I take in homeless people sometimes, and have seen what they bring home from foodbanks and sell on, and also what they buy as ( unwanted!) presents for me from foodbanks too

nightinorout · 12/11/2023 08:28

@crazyivy what are they selling? I volunteer at my local food bank and we never have lots of brand named products, most of what we have has little to no resale value.

nightinorout · 12/11/2023 08:26

@NugatoryMatters I said in my previous post I don't necessarily agree with it, but in such areas shop lifting is at the bottom of the pile of issues police have to deal with and last on the list of what those living there care about.

It wasn't a justification for what's happening, just an explanation that the issue goes much deeper than someone buying stolen goods.

crazyivy · 12/11/2023 08:21

nightinorout · 12/11/2023 08:19

@crazyivy yes of course, the local food bank trolley is where people manage to steal 10+ tubs of lurpack and cathedral city.

Get real!

I am being real. On my estate, people go to food banks, get donations, then come door to door selling them - that happens constantly. The food items still have food back colour coded stickers on them

NugatoryMatters · 12/11/2023 08:20

throughgrittedteeth · 12/11/2023 07:56

Absolutely this. That's what I was getting at with my post too. It's so normalised in some areas. You're more likely to find people who don't want to fund someone's habit rather than worrying about the shops they've stolen from and the breakdown of society.

But this is a huge part of the problem. There clearly are longstanding cultural problems in some areas.

I’m not sure taking the view that it’s just part of the colourful tapestry of life and aren’t MNers silly and naive for thinking it’s bad is a good idea.