Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Visiting in-laws who have a dangerous dog..wwyd

436 replies

Kerrieanne85 · 10/11/2023 19:04

Advice please/how would you word this???

Firstly I want to state I have a Fantastic relationship with in-laws, absolutely love my MIL and FIL.

They've invited us over to their house for FIL's birthday next weekend. They live about 2 hours away so we only see each other every couple of months.

We're looking forward to seeing them and our two DC aged 9 & 6 can't wait to see their grandparents.

Here's the thing, they are currently housing a "dangerous dog". The dog belonged to their daughter (my SIL)....she never trained the dog properly, is super hyper, doesn't take order from owners, the dog has bitten other cousins when they visited SIL, the dog attacked SIL's boyfriends leg so badly leading him to be on crutches for 7 weeks. Dog has also bitten FIL that he needed stitches at the hospital on a different occasion. Dog was advised to be put down but SIL couldn't bring herself to go through with it, so they tried to rehome him...no-one wants the dog with its history. MIL also loves the dog to bits and can't bring herself to have him put down. Now SIL has a 9 month old baby they have given the dog to MIL and FIL.

The dog is now taking medication 3 times a day to 'calm him down'. MIL says the dog has been fine with just the two of them in the house and she gives him medication.

Hubby doesn't like to see his parents with the dog there as we're all not comfortable with him. I told hubby to speak to his dad regarding possibly having the dog elsewhere when we visit with our young children. He doesn't want to cause an atmosphere as it's his step-mum and she's absolutely besotted with this dog and she can get quite defensive about the issue when it's been brought up in the past.

How would you ask her about the dogs whereabouts when we visit next week. She can have this 'it's my house, my way' attitude sometimes.

Before anyone says host them at our house. We always host them at our house when we see them mainly for this reason, this time they want us to go to their house

Thanks for the read

OP posts:
Chipsahoyagain · 11/11/2023 18:39

Wow I can't believe they would put a dog over their own dc and gc attending a milestone occasion. Absolutely ridiculous how some people behave over their dogs. This is a dangerous one too. You made the right decision to put the safety of your family first

Kerrieanne85 · 11/11/2023 18:34

Update; had a long chat with MIL and SIL, they understood my concerns and said maybe it's best for us not to come to the 70th party. Zorro is staying for good. No intention of having him put down. If we do go then Zorro would be locked in PIL bedroom. Zorro is now 9 so they will wait for nature to take him when the time comes

We're not going.....they understand and we'll host our own birthday party for FIL another time

OP posts:
Pumpkinpie1 · 11/11/2023 18:30

I wouldn’t risk it
I be honest why I wouldn’t go if asked. I can’t understand anyone who puts a dangerous dog before family and friends

Jenkib · 11/11/2023 18:21

Tell them to crate it and the dog stays in the crate for the duration of your stay !

That is the only terms you will go there !

Ball is in her court then !

SIL sounds rather irresponsible not having it PTS if advised it should be- bitten a child then an adult !

Good luck .

Evan456 · 11/11/2023 18:19

It’s a no brainier!!

Brumbies · 11/11/2023 17:37

RampantIvy · 10/11/2023 19:06

Personally, I wouldn't go.

Neither would I and I'd tell they why!

wasdarknowblond · 11/11/2023 17:34

I had a similar situation a while ago and frankly I was too frightened of the dog to ever visit my aunt’s house. You certainly shouldn’t put your kids anywhere near the dog. I simply don’t get why it’s still around - sad as it is, it should have been euthanised long ago. I’m sorry but your step-mum should be more responsible. If it bites a stranger she could be in serious trouble.

dawngreen · 11/11/2023 16:17

At the end of the day the house is the dogs home. So they need to meet up with you else where. And not be guilt tripped in to inviting ppl there. But you could meet up some where fun for the kids etc.

sollenwir · 11/11/2023 12:47

I wouldn't go, and certainly wouldn't take children there.

PlacidPenelope · 11/11/2023 12:45

Kerrieanne85 · 10/11/2023 21:06

This is what I've said, I've written

"Evening mama, thank you for inviting us to papa's 70th Birthday, we're all looking forward to seeing him and you. I know this is something we've spoken about numerous times, but we cannot come if Zorro is still there. There has been too many serious incidents with him and although you have mentioned that he has calmed down with you and papa, we are all not comfortable being around him. We'd love to come but if Zorro is still around then we'll have to arrange another time when you can stay with us. What are your plans for Zorro on the day?

That's good, @Kerrieanne85. However, if the response is Zorro will be in the house but shut away no way should you still go it would take only one careless moment for one of the many people there to accidentally open the door to where he is and the result would be carnage. Plus you'd be on edge all the time just in case that happened, hardly a fun relaxing event.

I am aware the issues regarding the dog are not the fault of the dog and I feel massively sorry the dog has been let down so badly by your SIL and MIL. The consequences of their actions/inactions are that the dog will have to be put to sleep and that is on them it is their fault entirely.

You have to protect your children and yourself from danger or witnessing something horrific, the line has to be If you want us there the dog has to not be there AT ALL.

AnnieSnap · 11/11/2023 12:38

I have 3 dogs, a large one and 2 Toy Poodles. They all have lovely temperaments. One of my youngest grandsons is scared of dogs, so despite their lovely temperaments, I put them upstairs out of the way (taking them out for a walk as necessary) until they have gone. Your in laws should absolutely put this dog out of the way of visitors.

housingplanningquestion · 11/11/2023 12:26

"Oh I'm so sorry MIL. You know we'd love to come and see you. It's just tricky with the dog. I know he's really unlikely to do anything, I know he's a good dog really, but if something happened I'd never forgive myself. I know it's a million to one, but knowing I knew the risk (because of what happened recently to the cousins and FIL), and took the kids into that risk, and then it happened: how could I explain that to them? What kind of mother would that make me? Sorry if this sounds unnecessarily anxious of me, but I'm sure you understand. Maybe it's a bit like how you are struggling to harm the dog. What shall we do instead? Meet out without the dog? Come to ours?'

Of course she doesn't really deserve all that accommodation, but seeing as that's what you asked for OP. The other thing to consider is if the dog really is being effectively medicated. Could DH pop over and check this out? Otherwise may be an ongoing bone (ha!) of contention.

suitsyoumissus · 11/11/2023 09:37

I think Op agrees, she's sent a message and waiting the response.

Codlingmoths · 11/11/2023 09:31

Kerrieanne85 · 10/11/2023 22:22

Thank you all for your replies. I will call her tomorrow and speak to her properly.

Reason for the advice on wording is because the family have had MANY fall outs (as all families) but SIL has manic depression, hubby doesn't mince his words and is too blunt with things in the past which has caused many fall outs and NC. This is why now he's decided he doesn't want to cause another atmosphere. (He doesn't want to go to their if the dog is there)

Last time they came to our house, we spoke about having Zorro put down. SIL burst into tears and spent 25 minutes in my sons room crying her eyes out. MIL burst into tears and had to calm down in the garden. FIL just sat there watched everything and didn't say a word. SIL's boyfriend got pissed off that she was crying for the dog which caused him to be on crutches.

They then started arguing in Portuguese between them which I don't understand.

I'm not blowing my own trumpet but I'm usually the one who gets them all to start speaking to each other again and be on terms. That's why I wanted advice on the message to MIL

I just don’t see this as a pouring oil on troubled waters situation. I see it as nuclear when my kids lives are being risked. My contribution would be to say Dh is absolutely right, you want us to risk our children’s lives here. You are actively putting your grandchildren’s lives at risk here with that dog and YOU get upset?? We aren’t coming if the dogs there. Ever. Not one time. Not if it’s in 5 years. Dangerous dog in your house, we won’t be. We will be here bringing up our children safely and happily.

Londonrach1 · 11/11/2023 08:22

Stay in hotel near by and see them somewhere without the dog. No way would I be anywhere near the dog...it's bitten before

Nickinoo22 · 11/11/2023 08:19

Notquitegrownup2 · 11/11/2023 07:46

I wouldn't trust her to lock him in another room or to crate him for the day. You would find him appearing nearby with MIL who 'just wanted him to come and say hello, and show you what a good boy he is now . . ." or who hated to hear him whining during the day and wants to just give him a little break from being locked away

.

I think this is exactly how it could go. I am a huge dog lover and have multiple but I wouldn't set foot in the house let alone take a child. Sorry, however fond you are of your ILS you are just going to have to be honest with them.

oakleaffy · 11/11/2023 08:17

Notquitegrownup2 · 11/11/2023 07:46

I wouldn't trust her to lock him in another room or to crate him for the day. You would find him appearing nearby with MIL who 'just wanted him to come and say hello, and show you what a good boy he is now . . ." or who hated to hear him whining during the day and wants to just give him a little break from being locked away

.

This ...
I can see it happening. Or:
Zorro {what a name...lacerating people with it's sword like teeth}
A dangerous dog stressed out even more by it's histrionic owners , it will likely be squealing and crowing and yelping in a weak crate that it isn't trained for, as it will hear the sound of strangers in the house that its thinks it owns...It will be busting out of that crate.

Or raking at the flimsy door with it's hard nails and getting out, and flying at someone causing even more damage to an innocent person.

Nightmare situation.

GabriellaMontez · 11/11/2023 07:59

Your husband and his dad sound like the only sane ones amongst you.

Why the battle to maintain a relationship with these lunatics? It's not a good thing.

clpsmum · 11/11/2023 07:50

nzeire · 10/11/2023 19:12

Don’t go

i would not give a shit how angry or offended anyone was.

it’s an absolute no braineR

And this

clpsmum · 11/11/2023 07:50

FourChimneys · 10/11/2023 19:12

If the dog maimed/killed one of your children how would you explain to the police you knowingly took them to house with an aggressive dog with a history of biting?

You might think your MIL is lovely but she's willing to risk the lives of her grandchildren.

No way on earth would I set foot in that house even without children.

This

Notquitegrownup2 · 11/11/2023 07:46

I wouldn't trust her to lock him in another room or to crate him for the day. You would find him appearing nearby with MIL who 'just wanted him to come and say hello, and show you what a good boy he is now . . ." or who hated to hear him whining during the day and wants to just give him a little break from being locked away

.

BrimfulOfMash · 11/11/2023 07:43

I'm not blowing my own trumpet but I'm usually the one who gets them all to start speaking to each other again and be on terms. That's why I wanted advice on the message to MIL

Tbh OP, I would leave them to it. It isn’t your job to be peacekeeper in DH’s family, or save them from themselves, protect them from the emotional fall out that they cause themselves and those around them. Arguably ‘making it all nice’ just puts off the whole issue of the dog needing to be PTS.

You sent a clear and direct message, stick with calm, polite, firm, and let them take grown up responsibility for their own response. You don’t need to manage their response to your reasonable decisions.

MeridianB · 11/11/2023 07:36

Hibiscrubbed · 11/11/2023 03:43

What sort of fucking maniac would expect children to be in the company of a dog that bit an adult so badly they were on crutches for seven weeks?!

Yes, and 30 mins of sobbing from the MIL and SIL who’ve created the problem while two of the victims look on. These women sound deranged. What are the chances that this situation will go on and on until the next time.

oakleaffy · 11/11/2023 07:33

LaurieStrode · 11/11/2023 07:20

@WiddlinDiddlin

It would have been considerate to put a trigger warning on your post; i for one didn't need that image planted in my mind this morning.

It's possible to discuss OP's dilemma without graphic imagery.

People NEED TO KNOW what certain types of dogs are capable of.
They are too often seen as ''big softy's'' {sic} til they are going crazy at someone.

I had no idea how horrific dog 'bites' could be from strong, powerful types bred to have been bull baiters or dog fighting breeds - yes, all dogs can bite, but a chihuahua hasn't the power to wrench and maul and consume like some breeds/types are capable of doing.

A dog owner was partially consumed by her dangerous dogs at a vets in USA as she exercised them in the vet's yard - no one heard a thing.

These dogs had bitten in the past and were excused.

The vet staff said they were far too aggressive for the staff to manage, and the owner would have to exercise them in the yard - the vet staff weren't wrong.

https://www.star-telegram.com/news/local/crime/article228517434.html

oakleaffy · 11/11/2023 07:22

WiddlinDiddlin · 11/11/2023 01:00

I own dogs, I work with dogs and evaluate bites.

'Breaks the skin' is a level 2 bite. Things don't get serious until we get to Levels 3/3a and above and even then, it is one part of the story, not the whole bloody novel.

It's important to identify accurately what level a bite is, because you might think a 'proper' bite is one deep puncture wound and some scrapes' and the next person might think its like the graphic images I saw last week of a child with the side of their face, neck, and torso ripped away and lower arms consumed and if we're just talking in vague 'you know what I mean' terms, then no, people do not automatically know what other people mean, at all.

I absolutely do know people who have dumped dogs at vets for a 'graze' level 2, where a few incisors have grazed skin causing some red marks. I also know people who have minimised multiple level 5s (keeping in mind that level 6 is Victim Dead)...

Having seen occasional images of particularly Pit bull damage to people, it's absolutely horrific.
I clicked on one in error that was marked NSFL and can't 'un see it' {I wasn't sure what the ''L'' was at that time.

NSFL =not safe for life.

Like they have been come at with a chainsaw with massive lacerations and shredded skin, their face gone, yet they were still alive at the time of the photograph.
The poor man died a few days later, unsurprisingly.

I never thought such things were possible from supposed 'Domesticated dogs'.

Swipe left for the next trending thread