Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Visiting in-laws who have a dangerous dog..wwyd

436 replies

Kerrieanne85 · 10/11/2023 19:04

Advice please/how would you word this???

Firstly I want to state I have a Fantastic relationship with in-laws, absolutely love my MIL and FIL.

They've invited us over to their house for FIL's birthday next weekend. They live about 2 hours away so we only see each other every couple of months.

We're looking forward to seeing them and our two DC aged 9 & 6 can't wait to see their grandparents.

Here's the thing, they are currently housing a "dangerous dog". The dog belonged to their daughter (my SIL)....she never trained the dog properly, is super hyper, doesn't take order from owners, the dog has bitten other cousins when they visited SIL, the dog attacked SIL's boyfriends leg so badly leading him to be on crutches for 7 weeks. Dog has also bitten FIL that he needed stitches at the hospital on a different occasion. Dog was advised to be put down but SIL couldn't bring herself to go through with it, so they tried to rehome him...no-one wants the dog with its history. MIL also loves the dog to bits and can't bring herself to have him put down. Now SIL has a 9 month old baby they have given the dog to MIL and FIL.

The dog is now taking medication 3 times a day to 'calm him down'. MIL says the dog has been fine with just the two of them in the house and she gives him medication.

Hubby doesn't like to see his parents with the dog there as we're all not comfortable with him. I told hubby to speak to his dad regarding possibly having the dog elsewhere when we visit with our young children. He doesn't want to cause an atmosphere as it's his step-mum and she's absolutely besotted with this dog and she can get quite defensive about the issue when it's been brought up in the past.

How would you ask her about the dogs whereabouts when we visit next week. She can have this 'it's my house, my way' attitude sometimes.

Before anyone says host them at our house. We always host them at our house when we see them mainly for this reason, this time they want us to go to their house

Thanks for the read

OP posts:
Ramalangadingdong · 10/11/2023 21:13

I would not go. I would host at my place. I would not expose kids to a dangerous dog.

Ragwort · 10/11/2023 21:13

I can't believe you are just pussy Grin footing around with conciliatory messages when your ILs have a dog that has bitten people so badly that they were on crutches for 7 weeks !! Why are you being so soft?

All you need to say is 'as previously discussed we will not be visiting your home whilst dog is still living with you'.

Why are you so afraid of offending them?

ilovesushi · 10/11/2023 21:12

No way can you have your children in the same house as that dog. Nope, no, no way jose.

BrimfulOfMash · 10/11/2023 21:10

“Hi FIL and MIL, really looking forward to seeing you, obviously we can’t bring the children into the house with Dog present so please let us know that he is taken care of elsewhere, Thank you xx”

And if you arrive and dog is present, leave.

Can’t imagine a worse situation: dog frightened with so many strangers in the house for the party, ILs busy and distracted with hosting so not keeping tabs on him, excited kids letting him out of a closed room…

You can’t be guilt tripped or held to ransom by your MIL’s irrational (and dangerous) behaviour.

Ricco12 · 10/11/2023 21:10

Any experienced and responsible owner of a bull breed would have that dog PTS. I’m a SBT owner and the damage that dog could do is catastrophic. You MIL is an idiot. With the issues around XL bullies and the DDA the last think our breed needs is an owner who thinks it’s acceptable to give a SBT who has attacked people. SBT are lovely dogs but as with any breed you do get ones with temperament flaws and if a dog bites it should be PTD especially a powerful dog like a Stafford . Sorry but good relationship or not I would be telling this woman she is a complete idiot who clearly has no clue what she is dealing with. People like this shouldn’t own dogs.

seeyounexttuesluv · 10/11/2023 21:07

If she loves your kids she wouldn't suggest you coming over with that dog around them. I would never forgive myself for letting anything happen to my grandkids. I have a terrier who can be nippy moron when over excited, but he's small and easily put behind a stairgate. No way would allow him to mix and bite anyone and injure them.

RedToothBrush · 10/11/2023 21:06

The dog has a history of harming people AND YOU ARE STILL CONSIDERING GOING?

Just no.

They won't get the message until either you say no or someone is very seriously injured.

This isn't a choice. Or at least it shouldn't be.

Kerrieanne85 · 10/11/2023 21:06

This is what I've said, I've written

"Evening mama, thank you for inviting us to papa's 70th Birthday, we're all looking forward to seeing him and you. I know this is something we've spoken about numerous times, but we cannot come if Zorro is still there. There has been too many serious incidents with him and although you have mentioned that he has calmed down with you and papa, we are all not comfortable being around him. We'd love to come but if Zorro is still around then we'll have to arrange another time when you can stay with us. What are your plans for Zorro on the day?

OP posts:
bumtrumpet · 10/11/2023 21:05

Just say no. You know this dog has a bite history. If you take your DC into that environment and they're bitten, some of that blame lies with you! Just say no and meet elsewhere. Who's more important here. Your MIL or your DC?

JanefromLondon1 · 10/11/2023 21:04

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

feelingalittlehorse · 10/11/2023 21:02

Realistically, this situation isn’t fair on anyone. The children are being put in harms way, and clearly this dog is anxious (hence the medication) and therefore showing nervous aggression. Putting that dog out of their comfort zone by having visitors is both totally irresponsible, and terribly unfair on the dog.
I have an extremely boisterous, 42kg labrador. He’s friendly as anything, but do I let him socialise with my friends young children? No. Because he may knock them over and injure them. It’s part of being a responsible dog owner.

As a moot point, I adore my dogs to the moon and back. If any of them ever showed any aggression to someone, I’d have them euthanised without question.

nibblessquibbles · 10/11/2023 21:02

How about

HI MIL looking forward to seeing you. I hear that doggy is behaving better but probably best for all that we don't take any risks. So suggest that the dog is left outside for the day or could he be kept in a room and I'll make sure kids are kept out of that room. Of course if you have a better solution then just let me know! Looking forward to see you love dil

itsalongwaybackfromsorry · 10/11/2023 21:01

Kerrieanne85 · 10/11/2023 20:21

Just to answer a few questions on the replies:

  • I wasn't asking whether we should go or not. I wanted advice on how to tell MIL the dog needs to be away from the house if we do go. She is ALWAYS in tears and has had full on emotional breakdowns in the past where we have spoken about this. She says she loves the dog so much it breaks her heart to have him put down but she knows she needs to do it.
  • it's a pedigree Staffordshire Terrier
  • the reason they want us at their house this time is because they just finished a house extension and are also inviting family from abroad to come to his 70th birthday

Tears and 'full on emotional breakdowns' are her weapon of choice.

Clearly.

You need to ignore her weaponizing of her tears.

Be blunt. "We can't visit if the dog will be there. He's unpredictable and dangerous. Everyone knows it. And we will not put ourselves or our children in harm's way. Let us know when the dog will be kenneled elsewhere so we can plan."

Badgrief · 10/11/2023 21:00

I would point out to MiL that it is unfair on the dog for it to have to be around young children and other unknown visitors, when it is already known to be reactive (friendlier word than aggressive). Medication three times a day sounds quite extreme, it's not just a little calming.

So the dog needs to be somewhere else (probably kennels if any will take it) while they celebrate FiL's birthday, for its own wellbeing. Long term, the fact that it's owner (your SiL) will not have it in the same house as her child, shows it is not living its best life.

Rosebel · 10/11/2023 21:00

My brothers dog snapped at my DS when he was about a month old. DS is 3 now and hasn't met the dog since.
My brother says I'm overreacting and dog is safe. I don't care. I'd rather be safe than sorry.
In your case I'd stay at a B&B and met in laws away from the house and be clear that they don't bring the dog with them.
MIL sounds incredibly selfish. The dog needs to be put to sleep for it's own good as well as everyone else's safety. Cant believe she's putting a dog before her grandchildren.

Hippobot · 10/11/2023 20:59

If it bites someone else not only will the dog be put down but your in-laws will be prosecuted for having a dangerously out of control dog (and knowingly too!). Is your SMIL aware that she would be fined and possibly jailed?

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 10/11/2023 20:59

I agree that regardless of what she says she's doing with the dog, it won't really be good enough.

Doors can be opened accidentally, baby gates just make whatever is behind them seem appealing to children over toddler age, eventually the dog will need to be let out so it can toilet.

A bite risk dog isn't going to do well in a boarding kennels so thats not going to be an option.

I would just say that you are very sorry, you'll not be able to attend FIL birthday but hopefully you can make it up to them by going to X restaurant with them on such and such a date.

Daisy4569 · 10/11/2023 20:58

Looking forward to seeing you next weekend. I know that is now medicated and doing much better but obviously having extra people in the house (especially children) is likely to add extra stress to the situation. Just checking that there is a plan to keep and children apart so we can all relax and enjoy the day

BloodandGlitter · 10/11/2023 20:58

Someone should have a chat with them about making an appointment for behavioural euthanasia with the bite history the dog is too unpredicatable to rehome and rescues don't have the time for the amount of care and training it would take.

NotSorryForTheReality · 10/11/2023 20:57

@Caerulea

I’m not disagreeing 100% this can happen down to the breed but every dog has its own personality, my staffy was 100% good with all people/children not so much other dogs (however was never off leash or allowed close enough to do anything…and more than once needed to have her held close to make sure she couldn’t get near the “friendly” dog)…., rotty was good with people and dogs, the German shepherd bitch had “family” who she was very protective over but again wasn’t allowed even close to the opportunity to be reactive…, though the dog shepherd was really friendly with all people and kids (not dogs).

They all have their own personality that needs to be dealt with accordingly and that’s the owner’s responsibility.

Maraa · 10/11/2023 20:56

Don’t go. I’d rather put up with abit of a situation or argument with her than regretting the visit for the rest of my life

Readingallnight · 10/11/2023 20:53

ttcat37 · 10/11/2023 20:49

Where does it say that? I can see in the post that she calls it a dangerous dog, can’t see OP calling it a dangerous breed

I see the mix up.
Idontlikealdi was I think referring to a previous and recent ( to theirs ) post.

OhwhyOY · 10/11/2023 20:52

I wouldn't go, the chances of them properly locking the dog away or sending it off elsewhere are very low IMO. I was worried already when you said about the biting, when you said it was a staffie given their jaw strength etc I would not be taking my children anywhere near it.

In fact I'd be considering calling someone (I don't know who the relevant authorities are but assume police?) to report the fact that this dog has bitten all these people. Hopefully that might force their hand - it's not fair on the dog either to live its life locked away. And I would tell them that I wanted to help them do the right thing as I knew it would be painful for them to do it themselves and this way it removes the decision from them. This is obviously a bit of a nuclear option though, if you want a gentler one you have a few good suggestions in the thread. I'd say we can't visit if the dog is there, much as we'd love to, and if you get crying/guilt trip I'd just say I agree it's a devastating situation but not as devastating as if the dog mauled one of the children. Please do the right thing by everyone a d have it pts.

Pipsquiggle · 10/11/2023 20:51

ttcat37 · 10/11/2023 20:30

It sounds like a familiar issue that’s already been spoken about so I don’t think you need to labour the point. Say something like “I know we’ve talked about it before but I just wanted to make sure that dog is going to be staying elsewhere whilst we’re there. Obviously we can’t visit if he’s at the house”

Something like this is what needs to be said.

LavendersBlueeee · 10/11/2023 20:51

Not worth the risk. You’d never forgive yourself.