Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Annoyed at people ranting about charity shops

360 replies

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 10/11/2023 16:10

This is one those threads that’s a release of frustration. So apologies for it being so boring.

AIBU for getting pissed off at seeing people moaning constantly about charity shops and their pricing? It’s driving me insane.

Most people’s objections seem to be based on….

  • Charity shops should be cheap…because they’re a charity ain’t they
  • I could buy that stuff cheaper elsewhere.
  • people give them things for free then they make loads of money from it.

Now am I loosing my god damn mind or do people not understand the point of charity shops is to FUCKING RAISE MONEY. So of course they want to raise as much money as possible. Of course people donate stuff for free….because they donate it so the charity can make money from it!! If you think you can get it cheaper elsewhere then bloody do it….if the shop is that over priced it’ll close down won’t it.

Been tipped over the edge by a shitty TikTok video someone made slating a local
hospice charity shop for selling their items for “too much”. The video has so many shitty comments under it….all apparently oblivious to the fact the shop exists to raise as much money as possible to support those with life limiting illnesses not so Barbara and Jeff can get a cheap table.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Ibizabar · 10/11/2023 19:04

The most popular and very busy Charity Shop in my city sells everything for under a fiver. Most things are priced around 3 quid. I suspect it makes more money than the ones that have more expensive prices.

Itsnamechange · 10/11/2023 19:04

To be honest I have no idea how the charity shops near me still operate. The clothes are almost always tatty, cheap brands that they're selling for almost close to retail price. People want to support charities but not at the cost of filling their home with worn looking, overpriced rubbish.
Perhaps with the rise of fast fashion and places like vinted, where you can get like new, fashionable clothes very cheap, the model just doesn't work anymore?

FKATondelayo · 10/11/2023 19:03

That we have such a big charity sector in this country is not a sign of success but of failure. We have privatised essential services (child safeguarding, medical research, hospices etc) and called it charity. And now we aren't even allowed to criticise their strategies or their employees.

TheaBrandt · 10/11/2023 19:03

Hmm the owners do make money. My friends Dh looked into our local charity shops finances the owners were taking out a decent whack. The volunteers realised and left.

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 10/11/2023 19:02

We have this thread over and over again, and people always argue about whether a charity shop's purpose is to provide cheap items to locals.

I think that's all a red herring.

The real issue is why do donors choose to give their goods to charity shops?

Some of them are just using the charity shop as a bin. Some are donating to charity shops because they care about that cause specifically, and they want the charity to make as much money as possible.

But some are choosing to donate excellent goods that they themselves could sell on ebay, because they think donating it all to a charity shop means it will be bought by someone too skint to buy new or to bid on ebay.

So naturally those donors feel aggrieved if they feel a shop overcharges.

Rosscameasdoody · 10/11/2023 19:01

As per previous posters. Our local charity shops are pricing goods only pennies below what you can buy new. You have to ask yourself what’s best for the charities - reasonably price second hand goods that sell, making money for the charity, or stuff that sits unsold on the shelves for months because it’s overpriced.

Gazelda · 10/11/2023 19:01

What an incredibly insulting post @FKATondelayo. I imagine that you have absolutely no idea of the breadth of skills and compassion the many thousands of charity workers (and volunteers) provide to society. How sad life would be if we were all in it for the profit we make and the tax we pay.

Stroopwaffels · 10/11/2023 18:59

Agree pretty much with everything you said, @Dowhadiddydiddydum. I have been a charity shop volunteer for about 10 years, first for Oxfam, now for Save the Children and I am sick to the back teeth of threads on here from people who are not volunteers moaning that:

the shops are too expensive
only stock bobbled Primark t-shirts for £30
the staff are basically a bit thick and wouldn't recognise a brand if it slapped them
all the "good stuff" whatever that means is stolen by volunteers
none of the shops make any money

ChocolateCinderToffee · 10/11/2023 18:58

@FKATondelayo would you like to provide us with some evidence for your comments, or are you simply airing your own biased and uneducated opinions?

FKATondelayo · 10/11/2023 18:55

BitofaStramash · 10/11/2023 18:31

Do you have any clue how much directors in charities are paid?

There are tens of thousands of charities in the UK and the vast majority of directors are paid below market rates and could earn a lot more doing something else.

There are a small number of charities where directors are paid larger sums of money. These are very large charities with turnovers of £300-£400 million who employ thousands of people often in multiple countries.

It is a good thing to employ highly qualified and experienced and well paid individuals who know what they are doing to run these multi million pound international organisations which are often involved in literally life and death operations.

Personally I would much rather these brilliant and talented people* who would make so much more in the for-profit sector would do just that. Generate profit, grow the economy and pay taxes - so we don't have the need for 'charities' - which 70% of the time are barely regulated job creation enterprises for otherwise unemployable graduates.

ShanghaiDiva · 10/11/2023 18:52

SideBob · 10/11/2023 18:47

If you donated x item you generally would want the item to make as much as possible eg the ebay side of the business, so why is it a bad thing to not want them to raise as much as possible ?

It's dishonest to try and fleece people by charging more than the price of brand new, or overpricing damaged/low quality stuff.

The fact that it's in the name of charity doesn't make it better. They get this stuff for free. There's no need to use these kind of tactics.

But asking a higher price for a branded product eg Seasalt dress is not fleecing people. Many people who donate where I volunteer are keen to point out that their donation is worth x and want us to get a good price for it. We have sold never worn seasalt coats for £60. New they cost £180 so £60 is a good price imo. If you don’t want to pay £60 for a donated coat we have many others starting at £7/8.

Cheesecakefiend · 10/11/2023 18:51

I think it’s annoying finding Primark t shirts for £5 when the charity shop has (rightfully so) kept aside valuable items of clothing to sell on e bay. It just feels like the shop is trying to taking the piss a bit. Surely no one is buying these tatty t shirts for a fiver? Our charity shops are a laughing stock in our town as they only have overpriced tat but are given cheap rent by our council so will never go bust.

Pleaseme · 10/11/2023 18:49

RedRobyn2021 · 10/11/2023 18:32

This

I’d agree with this. I donate my stuff and my time to my local thrift store which does a lot of community based stuff. Free kids wellies, free kids coats, free school uniform rail. Stack it high sell it cheap and fast. Generally make 1-2k a week for various local good causes.

Charity shops seem really uncompetitive now. I went on vinted the other day and bought a lovely new with tags monsoon dress for £12 in my size. It’s all shien/ primark asda stuff at my local charity shop for the same price if not more. They’ve not been accepting new stock for ages.

Books are the same I pick them up at the supermarket which has a donate 50p honesty bucket. The £2/£3 for paperback seems really expensive in comparison.

The amount charity shops actually make for charities is dwarfed by legacy gifts. I do wonder if by putting people off giving their stuff/ time / money they will find that over the longer term legacy gifts reduce.

weirdoboelady · 10/11/2023 18:49

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 10/11/2023 16:16

With regard to the pricing, it makes no sense when a charity shop prices a used/second hand item at, or above the price it sells for when new. There is also an argument for saying that, if a charity shop prices items too high, they won’t sell, and so the stock in the shop doesn’t change, which makes them less attractive to customers - if it’s always the same stuff, people will stop going in.

But if they price things cheaply, and get fast turnover of their stock, people will keep on coming in, to see what is new - so the argument is that lowering the price and increasing the turnover, actually makes more money for the charity shop.

I also think that charity shops have two aims - making money for the charity, of course, but also providing people who don’t have much money the opportunity to buy things they need, but otherwise couldn’t afford.

They absolutely DO NOT have two aims. They exist to make money for the charity. There are many ways in which they may have other benefits, including

  • they may provide volunteering or employment experience for their benficiaries
  • they may 'accidentally' benefit local people in need.

Be very clear, if a charity's registered purpose is not the relief of poverty, they have an ABSOLUTE RESPONSIBILITY to raise the most money they can from donations. Otherwise they are breaking the law. And if their charitable object is to fund a school in India, they should not be deliberately benefitting the local populace in x-town, UK.

Of course their volunteers sometimes get pricing spectacularly wrong. But the entitlement of local people, who feel charity shops are there to provide them with cheap prices and subsidised good, is simply wrong (99% of the time. The other 1% of the time the people wanting these bargains will, indeed, be the people they are constituted to help.)

SideBob · 10/11/2023 18:48

There are plenty of things I don't buy every day, from every shop, because they are not worth it to me, but presumably there is a market for them at that price point -

A used jam jar for £3 is worth nothing to anyone

ShanghaiDiva · 10/11/2023 18:47

@KnottyKnitting
I am a volunteer and I have never seen the price higher than tag scenario that so many posters on mumsnet mention. Pricing mistakes do get made eg items which are damaged and damage has not been noticed (we reduce or ask for a token donation) but where items are new with tags I have never seen this happen in the shop I volunteer in.

SideBob · 10/11/2023 18:47

If you donated x item you generally would want the item to make as much as possible eg the ebay side of the business, so why is it a bad thing to not want them to raise as much as possible ?

It's dishonest to try and fleece people by charging more than the price of brand new, or overpricing damaged/low quality stuff.

The fact that it's in the name of charity doesn't make it better. They get this stuff for free. There's no need to use these kind of tactics.

User0000009 · 10/11/2023 18:47

greengreengrass25 · 10/11/2023 18:34

@User0000009

I get that and I don't need to shop there but it would be good if there was a balance for those on low incomes who really need some clothing

Of course x

MadKittenWoman · 10/11/2023 18:47

Starlightstarbright2 · 10/11/2023 18:33

I don’t moan about them anymore . I simply don’t shop in them anymore .

if you want my other thing of things that put me off was the colour grouping rails ..

Colour grouping makes the items look more curated and expensive. I've actually complained when favourite charity shops have tried moving to grouping by size- it looks like a jumble sale. I Iive in and shop in 'naice' areas, and the best charity shops order by colour AND size. They are there to make money for charity, not to sell things cheap. I've bought designer pieces for upwards of £80-£100. Any shops selling bobbly Primark will just get left with stock or go out of business.

KitchenGard · 10/11/2023 18:45

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

i wonder if this would be more accurate you could get eg 2x - 5x the sale value from using ebay as the potential for more customers is eg in 1000,s vs however many they have in the store over x weeks when the item is on sale.

KnottyKnitting · 10/11/2023 18:44

I sort of get what you are saying but sometimes the pricing is just ridiculous.

I saw items in a local Sense shop recently which were new tagged items from primark. They were priced higher than they were available new in the store!

I could understand a good quality brand in good condition being priced fairly high ( my DDs love charity shops and have found some really great deals on expensive brands) but someone needs to have a bit of common sense with poor quality items!

kaka79 · 10/11/2023 18:41

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Gazelda · 10/11/2023 18:41

Mnetcurious · 10/11/2023 18:31

Charity shops have all the same costs as any other retailer, except for the stock.
@Gazelda

You do know that other retailers have to pay their staff (charity shop staff are mostly volunteers) and don’t get the 80% discount on rates that charity shops do?

You're right, of course. My mistake.

However my point still stands. The cash taken at the till obviously makes the shop worth keeping open. It would be an incredibly irresponsible Trustee Board who kept an unprofitable shop open.

And as I said, the social impact that charity shops provide is incredible. Volunteering opportunities (growing confidence, skills, reducing isolation etc). Eco benefits. A sense of 'giving back' that staff, volunteers and customers all feel. A community space where people feel welcome (alright, I accept there are a rare few unwelcoming shop staff/volunteer). Cause awareness. Event and activity promotion. Filling up empty retail units to prevent the death of a high street. And so much more. £7.35 worth of social value for each £1 invested.

Mnetcurious · 10/11/2023 18:41

KitchenGard · 10/11/2023 18:33

i would like proof on your 80% assertation as most charities i know get no way near that amount of reduced rates

A quick google will help you. It’s also in the article someone else has linked in this thread.

suitsyoumissus · 10/11/2023 18:40

I think you might be a little bit unreasonable. I've volunteered in a charity shop and some of the comments about over-pricing are fair. The shops are following a policy - but a basic Primark top is never going to be worth £4/£5. A White Stuff tunic might be worth £15 if in good nick, but if the fabric is showing signs of age then it isn't. On the other end of the scale - an immaculate pair of Irregular Choice shoe with the box for £10, even though I pointed out what they sell for on EBay.
I think most charity shops would end up taking more money if they piled them high and sold them cheap. We would clear the shop within a couple of days when there was a sale on, and take much more money than usual.