Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Annoyed at people ranting about charity shops

360 replies

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 10/11/2023 16:10

This is one those threads that’s a release of frustration. So apologies for it being so boring.

AIBU for getting pissed off at seeing people moaning constantly about charity shops and their pricing? It’s driving me insane.

Most people’s objections seem to be based on….

  • Charity shops should be cheap…because they’re a charity ain’t they
  • I could buy that stuff cheaper elsewhere.
  • people give them things for free then they make loads of money from it.

Now am I loosing my god damn mind or do people not understand the point of charity shops is to FUCKING RAISE MONEY. So of course they want to raise as much money as possible. Of course people donate stuff for free….because they donate it so the charity can make money from it!! If you think you can get it cheaper elsewhere then bloody do it….if the shop is that over priced it’ll close down won’t it.

Been tipped over the edge by a shitty TikTok video someone made slating a local
hospice charity shop for selling their items for “too much”. The video has so many shitty comments under it….all apparently oblivious to the fact the shop exists to raise as much money as possible to support those with life limiting illnesses not so Barbara and Jeff can get a cheap table.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Stroopwaffels · 11/11/2023 08:14

For a charity shop to run efficiently, you need people. You need people to sort through the donations, price and steam the good clothing, research the bric a brac online so you're not putting out a gold bangle for £2, stock the shelves, operate the till, go through every item on the shop floor weekly to remove anything that's been there more than 2/3 weeks according to policy. And that's before all the other jobs in running a shop like cashing up, banking, recruiting new volunteers, training them, window displays, reporting figures to head office, dealing with emails, phone calls, social media and so on.

Volunteers are there by choice and in my experience some will pick and choose what they want to do. You've got Joan who only does the books and won't sort other donations, Mary who does the till on a Friday morning and won't ever switch days, and Bill who refuses to go on the till at all. Sue who can't lift anything heavy, Ann who doesn't like using the steamer, Peter who is only interested in cleaning the jewellery. It's not like a normal business where you just draw up a rota and tell people what they're doing. If they don't want to turn up, they don't. There is this perception that we're all standing around twiddling our thumbs doing very little whereas we are snowed under with stuff and not enough people to get it all done. Not enough RELIABLE, adult people who are prepared to come in week in, week out and get stuck in. Well intentioned 14 year olds doing their D of E who want to come 1 hour a week for 12 weeks are a total waste of time. And the manager wastes so much time training people on the till or giving them the health and safety briefing, then they leave.

Most charity shops have one paid member of staff. Many like the one I am currently helping in have nobody paid at all. The one paid member of staff is paid for 35 hours a week - or less if it's a smaller shop. Shop is open 9-5 Monday to Saturday, and maybe 4 hours on a Sunday. That's 52 hours a week. Because of lone working policies most charity shops will insist on 2 able bodied over 18s in the shop at any time.

Like i said, all the experts feel free to come and show us all how they could do it so much better. With limited resources, variable quality/quantity of stock and a volunteer "workforce".

Charity sector sales are way up on last year. Which kind of says people are finding things they are prepared to buy, at a price they are prepared to pay. Despite what some moaners on MN say.

VimtoVimto · 11/11/2023 08:07

Dunnoburt · 11/11/2023 00:38

And don't forget that anything sold is 100% profit!

It’s not 100% profit. The stock may be free but there are overheads both directly attributable to the shop and those attributable to head office.

wannadisc0 · 11/11/2023 08:04

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ShanghaiDiva · 11/11/2023 08:00

Dunnoburt · 11/11/2023 00:38

And don't forget that anything sold is 100% profit!

Of course it isn’t!
salaries, rent, utilities, equipment, rubbish disposal, cleaning supplies…how do you think all this paid for?

Stroopwaffels · 11/11/2023 07:59

Dunnoburt · 11/11/2023 00:38

And don't forget that anything sold is 100% profit!

Well no. That's assuming you have no cost of sales which isn't true. There are so many other costs - heating, light, waste disposal, rent, licence to play music in the shop, cost of labels and other consumables like the wee plastic bits for the pricing gun, telephone line, window cleaning etc etc.

I have posted the link to the charity job board so all the experts who could do it SO much better and make SO much money can apply and show the rest of us dimwitted and thieving volunteers how it's done.

Whiskerson · 11/11/2023 07:54

Do people also think Primark has a moral responsibility to clothe the British poor?

Or do people understand that this is a business model designed to make maximum money?

Charitable objectives are laid out in law. If a charity exists to save the whales, then they must raise money to save the whales. If they can best achieve that by selling "overpriced" clothes to people willing to pay for them, then that is what they must do. They can't write in their annual report "Well, in 2022-3 we basically broke even on our charity shops, so no money for the whales, but on the plus side Pauline from Peckham found a lovely cheap outfit to wear to work!". The Charity Commission would not be impressed, for one.

towriteyoumustlive · 11/11/2023 07:51

Lots of our charity shops now have pricing strategies and it makes some many so expensive! Too expensive.

So people don't buy the stuff.

And now lots of charity shops aren't accepting donations because they're too full. Because... people havent bought stuff. DUH!

So YABU. They should be priced sensibly. A Primark tshirt that cost £3 new should not be £3 in a charity shop!

Our local independent charity shop is amazing!

pleasehelpwi3 · 11/11/2023 07:17

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 10/11/2023 16:16

With regard to the pricing, it makes no sense when a charity shop prices a used/second hand item at, or above the price it sells for when new. There is also an argument for saying that, if a charity shop prices items too high, they won’t sell, and so the stock in the shop doesn’t change, which makes them less attractive to customers - if it’s always the same stuff, people will stop going in.

But if they price things cheaply, and get fast turnover of their stock, people will keep on coming in, to see what is new - so the argument is that lowering the price and increasing the turnover, actually makes more money for the charity shop.

I also think that charity shops have two aims - making money for the charity, of course, but also providing people who don’t have much money the opportunity to buy things they need, but otherwise couldn’t afford.

The last paragraph demonstrates the common but fundamental misunderstanding of the aims of charity shops- their sole aim is to raise as much money for the charity, not providing for people who can't afford things.

MaisyAndTallulah · 11/11/2023 03:44

I think you are being unreasonable, yes.

Charity shops have become elitist and that's ugly. What about poor people needing to buy 2nd hand clothes? Only someone completely out of touch could imagine that this is OK. God the ignorant are boring.

Q2C4 · 11/11/2023 03:43

A lot of posters are talking about the purpose of a charity shop. Each charity has a stated purpose - unless that includes selling affordable items to those in need, there is no obligation on the charity shop to price things cheaply.

Charity shops also have to pay to dispose of a lot of tat that people donate which isn't sellable & really ought to be recycled or binned instead.

Q2C4 · 11/11/2023 03:39

Viviennemary · 10/11/2023 17:00

I disagree. They are far too expensive now. I'm not paying £2.99 for a second hand book that I can get from Amazon new for not much more. It's cheeky.

In that scenario why wouldn't you buy the book from the charity shop? It's still cheaper, not to mention greener. It also puts the money in the hands of a charity rather than Amazon.

sleepwouldbenice · 11/11/2023 01:04

Dunnoburt · 11/11/2023 00:38

And don't forget that anything sold is 100% profit!

There's no purchase cost no but not all staff are volunteers and there is non pay costs, and the cost of getting rid of poor stock
If it's so easy to be profitable why don't you all do it? Anyone can according to a previous poster!

Dunnoburt · 11/11/2023 00:38

And don't forget that anything sold is 100% profit!

sleepwouldbenice · 10/11/2023 23:19

PestilencialCrisis · 10/11/2023 22:08

I think there are many reasons charity shops exist. One is obviously to raise money for charity. Another is so that people who can't afford new can still have stuff. Another is to stop the stuff ending up as landfill. Another is to make people take stock of the things they have and feel good and generous and lucky that they are in a position to donate things to those less fortunate. Another is to give people opportunities to volunteer and/or get work experience/gain confidence/become part of the community. Lots of reasons for charity shops, not just about making money.

Ideally yes realistically no. They would make a loss. That's why some shops shut

sleepwouldbenice · 10/11/2023 23:15

You are totally right, OP

On this thread people want

cheaper prices to support those in need,

use of volunteers but expert pricers

charity shops benefit from cheaper rates but would need to employ more staff and bigger premises to process the volume of goods to sell at lower prices

Complain that cheap stock is doldrums but also complain that poor stock is ragged

You cant please them all! As you say if they get it wrong they go out of business....

Ihadenough22 · 10/11/2023 22:13

I volunteer in a charity shop here in Ireland. We would get a mixture of donations in regards to clothes. Some of our things would be good brand names, some designer and then Penney's/Primark or shein.
Our manager has the staff trained that only items in good condition are put out on the shop floor and the poor quality stuff is recycled. We price stuff according to brand and quality and brand new items sell for more.
In our town there are several charity shops and some of them either put out stuff that poor quality or they are charging to much for items. Our customers will tell us that X shop has poor stock or charging to much for particular items. We have a high turnover of stock and people come to us regularly because they know they get good stuff at a fair price. They will bring or tell their friends as well about us.

Yet we do get some people looking to buy things for half nothing or wanting a discount on say a good branded jacket for 25 euro that in great condition and would have been 100 euro plus when brand new. A charity shop is their to make money for the charity but if they have poor stock or charge high prices they won't sell as much or have the turnover to keep people calling in to see what they have for sale. Also having a good manager and nice staff is a help as well.

Boymum2104 · 10/11/2023 22:10

The pricing is ridiculous though & will therefore put people off if they feel they can get a better deal elsewhere. 1 of my local shops sells branded goods they find on M&M direct for double the price (I overheard 2 of the workers talking about it). Another 1 is right next to a 'choice store' (old season next stuff) they try sell the 'Next' stuff for more than it's up for in Choice. I can't tell if it's genuine desperation for funds for the charity or just workers coming up with whacky ideas and rolling with it.

PestilencialCrisis · 10/11/2023 22:08

I think there are many reasons charity shops exist. One is obviously to raise money for charity. Another is so that people who can't afford new can still have stuff. Another is to stop the stuff ending up as landfill. Another is to make people take stock of the things they have and feel good and generous and lucky that they are in a position to donate things to those less fortunate. Another is to give people opportunities to volunteer and/or get work experience/gain confidence/become part of the community. Lots of reasons for charity shops, not just about making money.

ShanghaiDiva · 10/11/2023 22:08

ConsuelaHammock · 10/11/2023 21:10

What percentage of the money raised in the charity shops for the ‘big’ charities is actually donated to those who are ‘helped’ by the big charities? You sound like you know a lot about them? What percentage is siphoned off by the big bosses?

bhf annual report
https://www.bhf.org.uk/what-we-do/annual-report-2023#:~:text=Did%20you%20know%20that%2080p,donate%20to%20British%20Heart%20Foundation.

Our Annual Report and Accounts 2023

The 2023 annual report details our financial situation, the challenges we've overcome and the lifesaving research we're funding.

https://www.bhf.org.uk/what-we-do/annual-report-2023#:~:text=Did%20you%20know%20that%2080p,donate%20to%20British%20Heart%20Foundation.

Parkermumma07 · 10/11/2023 22:04

So why price it in such a way that it won’t sell. What’s the point in that. Benefits no one!!

Stroopwaffels · 10/11/2023 22:00

PrimalOwl10 · 10/11/2023 21:53

People will vote with their feet especially with the likes of vinted where you can get a bundle of clothes cheap. I stopped donating to charity shops because they over price things. I rather sell it to someone in need on vinted for a fraction of the price.

How do you know you are selling to “someone in need” ?

PrimalOwl10 · 10/11/2023 21:53

People will vote with their feet especially with the likes of vinted where you can get a bundle of clothes cheap. I stopped donating to charity shops because they over price things. I rather sell it to someone in need on vinted for a fraction of the price.

worstdaughter · 10/11/2023 21:53

Re Emmaus - I will never donate to them. They are allegedly a charity that helps homeless people back on their feet. They force their residents to close benefit claims when they come to live there and pay them a pittance. Leaving them without NI contributions for their time there and no way of saving towards more permanent accommodation, not to mention the hassle and disruption to their income making it more difficult to leave once there.

JaceLancs · 10/11/2023 21:39

I work for a charity (small local) we keep thinking about opening a shop to raise funds but feel we can’t compete so do ‘pop ups’ instead - market stalls and sometimes car boots
Personally I also love a bargain and recycling is environmentally friendly so buy as much as I can from charity shops
Truth is they vary so much and it depends on who does the pricing and guidance given
At the end of the day it’s intended to raise as much money as possible for the charity - if they can also help people on limited budgets all the better
I went Xmas shopping today - all from charity shops - also ended up with a dress, 2 jumpers and a pair of shoes
The customers drive the market eventually - I buy very little from one shop which is overpriced - has same goods for weeks on end and frequently is not accepting donations - I donate and buy loads from another one quite close by who is more reasonably priced - had a quicker turnover of stock and has never refused my donations