Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Annoyed at people ranting about charity shops

360 replies

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 10/11/2023 16:10

This is one those threads that’s a release of frustration. So apologies for it being so boring.

AIBU for getting pissed off at seeing people moaning constantly about charity shops and their pricing? It’s driving me insane.

Most people’s objections seem to be based on….

  • Charity shops should be cheap…because they’re a charity ain’t they
  • I could buy that stuff cheaper elsewhere.
  • people give them things for free then they make loads of money from it.

Now am I loosing my god damn mind or do people not understand the point of charity shops is to FUCKING RAISE MONEY. So of course they want to raise as much money as possible. Of course people donate stuff for free….because they donate it so the charity can make money from it!! If you think you can get it cheaper elsewhere then bloody do it….if the shop is that over priced it’ll close down won’t it.

Been tipped over the edge by a shitty TikTok video someone made slating a local
hospice charity shop for selling their items for “too much”. The video has so many shitty comments under it….all apparently oblivious to the fact the shop exists to raise as much money as possible to support those with life limiting illnesses not so Barbara and Jeff can get a cheap table.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Stroopwaffels · 11/11/2023 12:12

I hear what you're saying @ichundich but then you'd get people moaning that they were spending money on posters and flyers which isn't going to the cause. It's not really needed - all that is needed is for either people to use their words and ASK "can you take electricals" or "I have a bag of underwear/socks, can you take that" rather than just dumping and running. Or asking themselves whether they would be prepared to pass their donations on to a friend, neighbour, relative. If they wouldn't because it's too old, worn, broken, why would you expect other people to buy it?

Storage is a massive issue for many charity shops - we already store Christmas stuff to be sold in November/December and just don't have the space to store other stuff for different occasions or seasons. And if you pay for a storage unit, you're back to the criticisms that you are frittering away money.

ichundich · 11/11/2023 11:59

Charity shops could give out guidelines about what can be donated and the condition things must be in. They could have posters and leaflets with these in their shop, on the website, Facebook etc. I would happily buy school uniform from a charity shop if I knew about it; have you thought about advertising that you are having a uniform sale / considered storing uniform until June / July / August when people are most likely to buy it?

senua · 11/11/2023 11:50

FKATondelayo · 11/11/2023 11:32

You agree that low income people have been priced out of charity shops? That's what most critics of the OP on here are saying.

Yeah, they have been gentrified.

FKATondelayo · 11/11/2023 11:32

Stroopwaffels · 11/11/2023 09:57

Why is that @FKATondelayo ? Are you labouring under the misconception that nobody would ever choose to shop in a charity shop if they can afford to shop elsewhere? That they are for the "poor" or "misfortunate" people? 🙄

You agree that low income people have been priced out of charity shops? That's what most critics of the OP on here are saying.

43ontherocksporfavor · 11/11/2023 11:32

I love a charity shop. I have a very good one that is managed so well and clothes are organised by colour and then size. Feels like a boutique
and prices reflect the brand .

senua · 11/11/2023 11:28

I think that Charity shops may be on their way out because the world has changed. Clothes used to be quality but expensive so if you could get them cheaper it was great; now clothes are too-cheap fast-fashion. Women used to be SAH and have time for volunteering; now most people work. Society used to operate on goodwill where people would donate their excess and shops would sell at discounted prices; now people either bin stuff or try to sell it on the internet, people won't volunteer, customers realise that chazzers aren't what they used to be (thanks Mary Portas) and so customers have become as hard-nosed as the charities (hence threads like these).
They've had their day. They might be having a current post-covid, Cost of Living bounceback in sales but when the good times return they will struggle massively.

Stroopwaffels · 11/11/2023 11:13

@Ragwort is right about the school uniform. I used to volunteer in Oxfam, who have a long-standing link with M&S. Every few months we'd get boxes of stock from one of the big local stores. Stuff which hadn't sold in the sales but also customer returns, or things like a pack which should have 4 pairs of socks and only had 3. We had lots of schoolwear around October/November one year, all brand new with tags - trousers, cardigans, single shirts, socks, gym shoes, the lot. I think we put the trousers and cardigans out at £3, the shirts were £1. We sold hardly any. Partly because the sizing was random, we didn't have the range of sizes you would expect in a "normal" shop, partly because in October/November people have bought their uniform for the year, partly because of weird attitudes about charity shops being either disgustingly unhygienic, or for the "poor people".

Missedmytoe · 11/11/2023 10:59

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 10/11/2023 16:16

With regard to the pricing, it makes no sense when a charity shop prices a used/second hand item at, or above the price it sells for when new. There is also an argument for saying that, if a charity shop prices items too high, they won’t sell, and so the stock in the shop doesn’t change, which makes them less attractive to customers - if it’s always the same stuff, people will stop going in.

But if they price things cheaply, and get fast turnover of their stock, people will keep on coming in, to see what is new - so the argument is that lowering the price and increasing the turnover, actually makes more money for the charity shop.

I also think that charity shops have two aims - making money for the charity, of course, but also providing people who don’t have much money the opportunity to buy things they need, but otherwise couldn’t afford.

Much of that comes down to management. I volunteer in a well-run one. We could do with more people as at this time of year, the volume of donations steps up, (and will peak by mid-January) and we can't process it quickly enough.

We have different departments, all headed up by volunteers: homewares, textiles, furniture, music, toys and clothing. Everything has to be sorted.

Damaged and broken goods are binned. We can't sell electrical as we don't have anyone who can PAT test but people still give us those..

Standard stuff from supermarkets
/Primark etc. is priced below their rate. Any more valuable items are researched and priced at between half and two thirds retail proce.

People regularly complain about the prices. I've taken to showing them the current retail price for the items. If they say they can buy it elsewhere cheaper, I wish them good luck.

Agree with you that people are unaware of how much the shops do, and their purpose. Wages for managers are shit too.

sleepwouldbenice · 11/11/2023 10:47

LadyGaGasPokerFace · 10/11/2023 21:18

I can see the argument, but selling Primark, H&M et al clothes for more than anyone would pay the original price for is complete bat shit. They need a quick turnaround, I’m not surprised some charity shops are drowning under clothes/books/items donated when the prices are stupid. It’s the turnaround of the stock that stops them. If you’re charging stupid prices, no one buys, therefore you have a backlog of new stock. It’s not really that difficult.

Partly correct. They should probably have ragged the stock instead.
Putting loads of too cheap stock out takes time space and money.

sleepwouldbenice · 11/11/2023 10:43

MaisyAndTallulah · 11/11/2023 03:44

I think you are being unreasonable, yes.

Charity shops have become elitist and that's ugly. What about poor people needing to buy 2nd hand clothes? Only someone completely out of touch could imagine that this is OK. God the ignorant are boring.

You're right that your ignorance is boring. Chairtiy shops are there to make money for the charity

ichundich · 11/11/2023 10:40

Stroopwaffels · 11/11/2023 10:31

It's not the criticism that bothers us volunteers, people criticise all sorts of things for all sorts of reasons.

It's the general feeling that the charity sector runs on the goodwill of well-meaning but a bit thick volunteers, who can't recognise decent brands, think it's reasonable to price "bobbled Primark" for £20, and who wouldn't know what stock rotation meant if it came up and slapped them. And that everyone on Mumsnet, even if they have never shopped in a charity shop let alone volunteered, could do it all SO much better.

Where on this thread are people saying that charity shop workers don't have a clue about brands?

greengreengrass25 · 11/11/2023 10:39

Ragwort · 11/11/2023 09:25

I feel like a broken record commenting on these threads ... and it's interesting how much so many mumsnetters seem to know about the organisation and running of charity shops yet proclaim they 'never' shop in them. Hmm
Of course there are some badly run charity shops ... but plenty are making money for the charity they support.
Its been shown over and over again that price is not the only factor why goods don't sell ... on the back of this thread (which repeats itself at least every month) I have done £1 rails, 'name your own price days' and even offered stuff for free just to get rid of it ... lots of stuff still just won't move. We get brand new generic school uniform from a well known High Street retailer .. it doesn't even sell at £1 for a brand new pair of grey/black school trousers or skirt.
In our town we run regular 'free cycle events' ... nothing to do with charity shops but open to everyone .. take what you want ... no money is asked for and no questions .... we still end up with more 'stock' than we start with ...
The problem is that we are now a throw away society.

Interesting post😀

Why doesn't the uniform sell?

Stroopwaffels · 11/11/2023 10:31

It's not the criticism that bothers us volunteers, people criticise all sorts of things for all sorts of reasons.

It's the general feeling that the charity sector runs on the goodwill of well-meaning but a bit thick volunteers, who can't recognise decent brands, think it's reasonable to price "bobbled Primark" for £20, and who wouldn't know what stock rotation meant if it came up and slapped them. And that everyone on Mumsnet, even if they have never shopped in a charity shop let alone volunteered, could do it all SO much better.

SideBob · 11/11/2023 10:22

theresnolimits · 11/11/2023 09:25

I must have missed the people at the door of the charity shop forcing me to buy that £3 bobbly Primark t shirt. Generally if it’s too expensive or poor condition, I just …move on.

When I go into Jigsaw, pick up a £125 jumper that I can’t afford, I just put it back and walk out. That is surely the retail experience? And yet those stores are only making money for their shareholders, they don’t have the excuse of maximising profit for a charity. Where’s the outrage they aren’t cheaper to allow poorer folks to buy?

And out of interest, I have a friend who has a nice sideline in scouring charity shops for designer and reselling on ebay/vinted. If you price lower there’s no guarantee you are helping the right people.

None of use say we buy overpriced bobbly jumpers, it's just an observation. Life would be pretty boring if we weren't allowed to talk about anything.

SideBob · 11/11/2023 10:20

Stroopwaffels · 10/11/2023 21:58

https://www.charityjob.co.uk/jobs/retail

whole board of jobs for all the experts.

So upon any criticise anything if you're not prepared to work in that area? Too funny.

Don't like club cards? Go and be Tesco's CEO.

Don't like how the police handle certain aspects of policing? Well here you go, they're hiring.

Just be an MP if you disagree with them so much!

MereDintofPandiculation · 11/11/2023 10:09

Now am I loosing my god damn mind or do people not understand the point of charity shops is to FUCKING RAISE MONEY. So of course they want to raise as much money as possible This is a change from 30 years or so ago. At one time, they did raise money, but they did so by selling stuff to people who couldn't afford to buy new. So there was an element of charity in the pricing too. Then it became chic to hunt for bargains in charity shops, and people shopped there who could perfectly afford to buy elsewhere, and so we have the current model. But lots of people can remember when they were deliberately cheap so that the less well off could afford stuff.

ichundich · 11/11/2023 10:05

Stroopwaffels · 11/11/2023 09:57

Why is that @FKATondelayo ? Are you labouring under the misconception that nobody would ever choose to shop in a charity shop if they can afford to shop elsewhere? That they are for the "poor" or "misfortunate" people? 🙄

Exactly. What is so bad about people using charity shops to buy stock that they are selling on more expensively? Like no one has ever made money from house clearances or flea markets or unwanted gifts. If the sole aim of charity shops is indeed to raise money they shouldn't care who buys from them, whether they are 'poor' or not.

Stroopwaffels · 11/11/2023 09:57

Why is that @FKATondelayo ? Are you labouring under the misconception that nobody would ever choose to shop in a charity shop if they can afford to shop elsewhere? That they are for the "poor" or "misfortunate" people? 🙄

FKATondelayo · 11/11/2023 09:45

Saying 'sales are up in charity shops proves that their pricing strategy is a success!' is like saying 'food banks are more popular than ever proving how delicious and nutritious the food is'.

theresnolimits · 11/11/2023 09:25

I must have missed the people at the door of the charity shop forcing me to buy that £3 bobbly Primark t shirt. Generally if it’s too expensive or poor condition, I just …move on.

When I go into Jigsaw, pick up a £125 jumper that I can’t afford, I just put it back and walk out. That is surely the retail experience? And yet those stores are only making money for their shareholders, they don’t have the excuse of maximising profit for a charity. Where’s the outrage they aren’t cheaper to allow poorer folks to buy?

And out of interest, I have a friend who has a nice sideline in scouring charity shops for designer and reselling on ebay/vinted. If you price lower there’s no guarantee you are helping the right people.

Ragwort · 11/11/2023 09:25

I feel like a broken record commenting on these threads ... and it's interesting how much so many mumsnetters seem to know about the organisation and running of charity shops yet proclaim they 'never' shop in them. Hmm
Of course there are some badly run charity shops ... but plenty are making money for the charity they support.
Its been shown over and over again that price is not the only factor why goods don't sell ... on the back of this thread (which repeats itself at least every month) I have done £1 rails, 'name your own price days' and even offered stuff for free just to get rid of it ... lots of stuff still just won't move. We get brand new generic school uniform from a well known High Street retailer .. it doesn't even sell at £1 for a brand new pair of grey/black school trousers or skirt.
In our town we run regular 'free cycle events' ... nothing to do with charity shops but open to everyone .. take what you want ... no money is asked for and no questions .... we still end up with more 'stock' than we start with ...
The problem is that we are now a throw away society.

ichundich · 11/11/2023 09:03

The fact that these threads come up so often shows that the current pricing strategy is pissing off (and driving away) customers. Charity shop sales might be up on last year, but we also have a CoL crisis at the moment. Aldi and Primark sales are also up. Charity ratepayers are granted a mandatory 80 per cent relief from non-domestic rates where the property is wholly or mainly used for charitable purposes by that charity or by that charity and other charities.

Stroopwaffels · 11/11/2023 09:01

Agree waste reduction centres, repair shops etc are a great concept. But that's a different sort of model from the charity shop at the moment.

Any volunteer will know that a high percentage of what we're given is just not sellable AT ALL. Chipped mugs, empty DVD boxes, VHS cassettes, single socks, shoes with the soles hanging off. And obsolete things like photo albums, cassette tapes are dififcult to shift, CDs and DVDs rapidly going the same way. Not everything CAN be recycled or has a value as a second-hand item. Lots of things are only fit for the bin.

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 11/11/2023 08:49

Spirro · 10/11/2023 21:30

I actually think charity shops are supposed to form part of a social contract. It’s not just about raising money. It’s also about recycling, and providing second hand items at an affordable price to people who can’t afford to pay new prices. If they price items too high it violates the part of the contract about supporting those who are less fortunate.

I think a previous poster mentioned a model in another country where they have more charity shops whose explicit aim is reduction of waste, reusing of items and providing affordable items. I do think there is space for more of that type of charity shops, maybe run by charities or social groups whose aims are linked to reducing waste and/or providing affordable items especially for people in need. local to me with have some free “repair shops” and I guess it’s similar to that:

I do think that is a very different and separate thing to a charity shops aimed soley at raising as much profit as possible for their own charity. As someone else has said charities have to show they are actually raising money towards their stated aims.

OP posts:
Dowhadiddydiddydum · 11/11/2023 08:41

Thanks to the most recent posters who have knowledge and experience about the actual working of charity shops. I think many people don’t understand how much goes in to running a charity shop and how much income they can make for their charities. I can’t remember the exact amount but I remember hearing that during covid, because of shop closures, Barnardo’s income was a lot less than predicted (by millions I think).

OP posts: