Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Annoyed at people ranting about charity shops

360 replies

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 10/11/2023 16:10

This is one those threads that’s a release of frustration. So apologies for it being so boring.

AIBU for getting pissed off at seeing people moaning constantly about charity shops and their pricing? It’s driving me insane.

Most people’s objections seem to be based on….

  • Charity shops should be cheap…because they’re a charity ain’t they
  • I could buy that stuff cheaper elsewhere.
  • people give them things for free then they make loads of money from it.

Now am I loosing my god damn mind or do people not understand the point of charity shops is to FUCKING RAISE MONEY. So of course they want to raise as much money as possible. Of course people donate stuff for free….because they donate it so the charity can make money from it!! If you think you can get it cheaper elsewhere then bloody do it….if the shop is that over priced it’ll close down won’t it.

Been tipped over the edge by a shitty TikTok video someone made slating a local
hospice charity shop for selling their items for “too much”. The video has so many shitty comments under it….all apparently oblivious to the fact the shop exists to raise as much money as possible to support those with life limiting illnesses not so Barbara and Jeff can get a cheap table.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Teder · 11/11/2023 19:00

YABU in that it’s probably location dependent. Charity shop after charity shop has closed down near me.

I volunteer for a learning disability charity who had lots of shops and I noticed they were often over priced. Eventually, all the shops bar 1 or 2 closed down. It was really sad for the people who volunteered in them - most of them people with learning disabilities who otherwise were not included in society.

cakewench · 11/11/2023 18:23

I mean, I've never taken to social media to complain about the pricing in charity shops, but now that you've brought it up: we have one locally which prices ambitiously rather than sensibly. I get that they'd like to make money (obviously) and we're happy to support them but we're also not going to pay well over the odds for an item if we can get it cheaper elsewhere.

I'm thinking in particular about a large book (think coffee table style book) which my young DS was interested in. They had it at £25 - £30 or so. It was old but not 'collectable' old. We checked online and many of them were available for single digit prices. I think we ended up with a copy for £5 or so.

They had that book in the window for months. It's probably still in there, somewhere 😄

KirstenBlest · 11/11/2023 18:19

@booksandbrooks , the ones near me either look like jumble sales or are more like boutiques. The finds are in the jumbly ones. There are rails packed full of Primark, Shein, Missguided and Boohoo, but look carefully and you'll find 'what -would-monty-don-wear' brands often in great condition for less than £5.

The boutiquey ones have less crap, less stock but although the stock is on the whole better, the absolute finds aren't there. Some of them have things like Barbour or Seasalt coats in good condition for about £60, but they're not going to make me buy it on the off-chance it might be a good un. When I find something I genuinely like and want and it fits, I'll pay.

Buying something because it 'has something about it' for <£5 and finding that it has a RRP of £150 or something is brilliant.

booksandbrooks · 11/11/2023 17:54

I dislike the way a lot of them have become boutiquey style.was stock, thoughtfully arranged, clothes by colour etc. it may look better but it doesn't make for a better experience. Two of my favourites have gone that way. One used to look like a jumble sale but be absolutely heaving with loads of stuff cheap- meld range charging and a few pricier bits. They emptied it, had very little stock all pricier items a fair bit of over pricing imo. Looked at lot smarter but was always empty of customers too. A year of that and they've just closed down. Four of the other charity shops on that road are still buys and there's a shelter which I don't bother with much as it went the same long before. It's not just about the prices, it's the curation and lack of stock.

MereDintofPandiculation · 11/11/2023 17:35

Whiskerson · 11/11/2023 12:15

But why do you think there was "an element of charity in the pricing"? Their aim has always been to raise money for that charity. Why else would they bother going to the trouble of setting up a chain of shops? If they were indeed more affordable 30 years ago, the obvious explanation would be that "pile them high, sell them cheap" was thought to be the most effective pricing strategy at the time. We can speculate all day about whether they would actually raise more money by selling cheap or not, but the fact remains that charities have always aimed to raise money for themselves, not to miss out on potential income by prioritising the welfare of the local poor.

Similarly, some charities ask for small donations ("just £2 can help..."), others go straight in with an ask for £50 knowing that fewer people can afford this. This has nothing to do with wanting to help the general public save money, it's purely to do with what they think will raise the most money. It's the individuals responsibility to manage their own finances.

Maybe. Could just be things had to be priced lower because it was a matter of shame to buy clothes from there (I'm probably going back more than 30 years here), so the pool of purchasers was smaller. And the goods on sale weren't always of high quality - it was more "could someone get some use out of this?" rather than "could I imagine paying good money for this?"

Seymour5 · 11/11/2023 16:38

@SprogTakesAQuarry whilst I agree that we should all be able to afford to clothe ourselves, a change of government won’t help everyone. Work with people on limited incomes, and you’ll see wide variations in spending, with necessities quite far down some lists of priorities.

You’re right of course about the purpose of charities.

SprogTakesAQuarry · 11/11/2023 16:21

How is it the responsibility of charity shops to clothe the poorest people in our country?

Thats our responsibility as a society, it’s got sweet FA to do with a local hospice charity, or the British Heart Foundation.

Everyone in our country should be able to afford to dress themselves and their families. That this isn’t the case had nothing to do charity shops, and everything to do with the fact that we have voted in right wing governments for many years.

The trustees of every charity have a responsibility to make sure income is maximised to meet their specific aims. It’s nonsense to suggest that they should ignore these obligations.

VimtoVimto · 11/11/2023 16:17

I started volunteering at a charity shop earlier in the year and was amazed at how much goes on behind the scenes. I did realised donations had to be sorted but not at the sheer quantity that is put in the rag bins due to being stained, in holes or threadbare.

I also find the vast majority of people who complain about pricing are resellers. Some people will advise us that we have underpriced or overpriced collectibles which we pass on to the manager (in the space of two hours we were once told a camera was underpriced and overpriced by two separate men). There is one lady in particular who comes in regularly and makes loud comments that we don’t know what we are doing with regards to pricing but generally buys something and another who always tries to barter whatever the item.

The other thing that has surprised me is how often I am attracted to an item on the rails thinking it is Fatface or White Stuff to find out it’s actually Sainsburys Tu. Anything I buy is at the price on the rails.

Seymour5 · 11/11/2023 14:06

Missedmytoe · 11/11/2023 10:59

Much of that comes down to management. I volunteer in a well-run one. We could do with more people as at this time of year, the volume of donations steps up, (and will peak by mid-January) and we can't process it quickly enough.

We have different departments, all headed up by volunteers: homewares, textiles, furniture, music, toys and clothing. Everything has to be sorted.

Damaged and broken goods are binned. We can't sell electrical as we don't have anyone who can PAT test but people still give us those..

Standard stuff from supermarkets
/Primark etc. is priced below their rate. Any more valuable items are researched and priced at between half and two thirds retail proce.

People regularly complain about the prices. I've taken to showing them the current retail price for the items. If they say they can buy it elsewhere cheaper, I wish them good luck.

Agree with you that people are unaware of how much the shops do, and their purpose. Wages for managers are shit too.

I volunteer too and I think we all could do with more volunteers. None of the staff are overpaid, and they put in extra time for nothing. I was in this morning, it was very busy as per usual. If items are overpriced, they don’t sell.

As you say, damaged and broken goods are binned. It begs the question why they are donated in the first place? We pay for our bins to be emptied, sadly they are regularly full!

Stroopwaffels · 11/11/2023 13:22

Also in response to the "just advertise you have got it" - can't remember about M&S, but lots of brands make corporate donations which come with strings. Oxfam got stuff from Ted Baker pre-pandemic. The contract stated we were not allowed to advertise that fact on social media or posters in store, we were not allowed to put items in the window, we were not allowed to have more than 3/4 items on the shop floor at any one time. Zara donation was similar - can't account for more than X% of what you have out, can't put it in the window, can't mention it in advertising.

The brands are worried that if word gets round that the local Oxfam/red Cross/BHF is stuffed with BNWT M&S or Zara, it will affect sales in their main shops. There are also all sorts of rules about cutting through tags or writing on them with sharpie so that the CFers can't buy stuff in a charity shop and take it back to M&S/Zara/Ted Baker for a refund.

LimeCheesecake · 11/11/2023 13:13

Yep these posters complaining about charity shop prices - what they mean is they want a bargain, not that they can’t afford the prices.

if you want to buy a t shirt for £2, go to primark or the supermarket. No one on a low budget now needs to rely on charity shops anymore now we all have access to very cheap clothing.

so the “social function” of charity shops of the location to go to for super cheap clothing for those with a very limited budget has pretty much ended with the rise of the cheap supermarket/primark clothing option.

Charity shops are now a place if you go to if you want to get something unique, something good quality for fast fashion prices, something recycled if you care about environmental impact of fashion.

KirstenBlest · 11/11/2023 13:10

have you thought about advertising that you are having a uniform sale / considered storing uniform until June / July / August when people are most likely to buy it?

Where are they supposed to store it?
When you have a clear out and donate to a charity shop, do you think about when they will sell it? I'd have thought that people clear out at the end of a season, so outgrown school uniform would be donated in June, not August.

Stroopwaffels · 11/11/2023 13:04

This wasn't even second hand @greengreengrass25 ! It was brand new with all the labels and had literally just arrived from the same M&S store where people are prepared to pay £10+ for a pair of trousers and £15 for a pack of school shirts.

I got a few things of the right size for my kids, one of my sons was a super skinny boy so age 14 long length trousers fitted him until he was 16 or 17. Also we had an issue once that they sent us a lot of red school cardigans/jumpers and none of the local schools have that colour, they are all blue/black/grey/green. But I do think that there is a large number of people who wouldn't ever dream of buying anything in a charity shop, tagged or not, and others who think that they should leave clothing in case a "poor person" comes along.

greengreengrass25 · 11/11/2023 13:00

Stroopwaffels · 11/11/2023 11:13

@Ragwort is right about the school uniform. I used to volunteer in Oxfam, who have a long-standing link with M&S. Every few months we'd get boxes of stock from one of the big local stores. Stuff which hadn't sold in the sales but also customer returns, or things like a pack which should have 4 pairs of socks and only had 3. We had lots of schoolwear around October/November one year, all brand new with tags - trousers, cardigans, single shirts, socks, gym shoes, the lot. I think we put the trousers and cardigans out at £3, the shirts were £1. We sold hardly any. Partly because the sizing was random, we didn't have the range of sizes you would expect in a "normal" shop, partly because in October/November people have bought their uniform for the year, partly because of weird attitudes about charity shops being either disgustingly unhygienic, or for the "poor people".

It's quite bizarre

I used to buy uniform 2nd hand for mine at times as did my dm for me and we were very mc.

ShanghaiDiva · 11/11/2023 12:55

ichundich · 11/11/2023 11:59

Charity shops could give out guidelines about what can be donated and the condition things must be in. They could have posters and leaflets with these in their shop, on the website, Facebook etc. I would happily buy school uniform from a charity shop if I knew about it; have you thought about advertising that you are having a uniform sale / considered storing uniform until June / July / August when people are most likely to buy it?

We do!

43ontherocksporfavor · 11/11/2023 12:49

Not to me @KirstenBlest as I only look through the colours that suit me. I don’t do pink, yellow, purple so saves me time.

KirstenBlest · 11/11/2023 12:39

clothes are organised by colour and then size.

Clothes organised by colour are IMO off-putting. I'm far less likely to rummage through a rack of clothes if they're the same colour.
If they're sorted by type of garment, then by size, then by colour that's much better.

LuvSmallDogs · 11/11/2023 12:32

One of the charity shops near me was giving out free coats last year and also had a special Xmas present evening - tickets for it were given out to kids by their school. There was juice and biscuits for the kids and colouring for them to do so the parents could sneak the toys they were buying (many brand new and in boxes) to the till and into big bags.

We had a rough year last year, that charity shop made Xmas feasible. We're not rich now, but can afford things that are cheap but new (such as "compatible with Lego, but not Lego" sets instead of actual Lego).

kaka79 · 11/11/2023 12:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Stroopwaffels · 11/11/2023 12:28

Prices everywhere have gone up. Interested in why charity shops are immune from this.

BitofaStramash · 11/11/2023 12:27

AutumnNamechange · 11/11/2023 12:20

I see what you are saying, but prices in charity shops have gone up a huge amount since covid, while the people buying from them have not had similar increases in their income. More people I know are turning to Vinted rather than charity shops now - and I'm sure this is having a knock on effect for charity shops where people are no longer donating their decent stuff as they know there will be people willing to pay them for it on vinted as charity shops are unaffordable for a lot of people now.

Actually charity shops are booming.

tfn.scot/news/shop-takings-continue-to-soar-as-charities-report-increasing-demand

www.civilsociety.co.uk/news/uk-charity-shops-generated-75bn-of-social-value-last-year-finds-report.html

AutumnNamechange · 11/11/2023 12:20

I see what you are saying, but prices in charity shops have gone up a huge amount since covid, while the people buying from them have not had similar increases in their income. More people I know are turning to Vinted rather than charity shops now - and I'm sure this is having a knock on effect for charity shops where people are no longer donating their decent stuff as they know there will be people willing to pay them for it on vinted as charity shops are unaffordable for a lot of people now.

kaka79 · 11/11/2023 12:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Missedmytoe · 11/11/2023 12:15

@ichundich most shops do have that info on their websites. As for school uniform, its not standard necessarily that it's donated- many schools now have their own second hand shops run by parents associations, etc.
If the shop is lucky enough to have volunteers that can 'do' social media, they can use (for example) Instagram to show the sort of thing that they take.
All comes down to resources and management again.

Whiskerson · 11/11/2023 12:15

MereDintofPandiculation · 11/11/2023 10:09

Now am I loosing my god damn mind or do people not understand the point of charity shops is to FUCKING RAISE MONEY. So of course they want to raise as much money as possible This is a change from 30 years or so ago. At one time, they did raise money, but they did so by selling stuff to people who couldn't afford to buy new. So there was an element of charity in the pricing too. Then it became chic to hunt for bargains in charity shops, and people shopped there who could perfectly afford to buy elsewhere, and so we have the current model. But lots of people can remember when they were deliberately cheap so that the less well off could afford stuff.

But why do you think there was "an element of charity in the pricing"? Their aim has always been to raise money for that charity. Why else would they bother going to the trouble of setting up a chain of shops? If they were indeed more affordable 30 years ago, the obvious explanation would be that "pile them high, sell them cheap" was thought to be the most effective pricing strategy at the time. We can speculate all day about whether they would actually raise more money by selling cheap or not, but the fact remains that charities have always aimed to raise money for themselves, not to miss out on potential income by prioritising the welfare of the local poor.

Similarly, some charities ask for small donations ("just £2 can help..."), others go straight in with an ask for £50 knowing that fewer people can afford this. This has nothing to do with wanting to help the general public save money, it's purely to do with what they think will raise the most money. It's the individuals responsibility to manage their own finances.