Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Annoyed at people ranting about charity shops

360 replies

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 10/11/2023 16:10

This is one those threads that’s a release of frustration. So apologies for it being so boring.

AIBU for getting pissed off at seeing people moaning constantly about charity shops and their pricing? It’s driving me insane.

Most people’s objections seem to be based on….

  • Charity shops should be cheap…because they’re a charity ain’t they
  • I could buy that stuff cheaper elsewhere.
  • people give them things for free then they make loads of money from it.

Now am I loosing my god damn mind or do people not understand the point of charity shops is to FUCKING RAISE MONEY. So of course they want to raise as much money as possible. Of course people donate stuff for free….because they donate it so the charity can make money from it!! If you think you can get it cheaper elsewhere then bloody do it….if the shop is that over priced it’ll close down won’t it.

Been tipped over the edge by a shitty TikTok video someone made slating a local
hospice charity shop for selling their items for “too much”. The video has so many shitty comments under it….all apparently oblivious to the fact the shop exists to raise as much money as possible to support those with life limiting illnesses not so Barbara and Jeff can get a cheap table.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Violahastings · 10/11/2023 16:58

some of the TikTok videos have shown pretty ridiculous pricing though and items like kids shoes with holes in them for £4 :/ surely you would be better just making a donation for the same amount.

I get the aim is to raise money for charity but surely that means pricing items at amounts people are willing to pay, who wants to buy a faded bobbly Primark t-shirt for £6.50

MrsCarson · 10/11/2023 16:58

To make more money they need to move the stock in and out quickly it keeps people coming in regularly. Stack 'em high and sell 'em low. They get loads of donations and some places throw decent stuff in to the sell by the lb to get rid of the overstock. Or even in the dumpster.

Ballsbaill · 10/11/2023 16:57

Charity shops are scoring an own goal by charging high prices when new is cheaper.

KitchenGard · 10/11/2023 16:57

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 10/11/2023 16:16

With regard to the pricing, it makes no sense when a charity shop prices a used/second hand item at, or above the price it sells for when new. There is also an argument for saying that, if a charity shop prices items too high, they won’t sell, and so the stock in the shop doesn’t change, which makes them less attractive to customers - if it’s always the same stuff, people will stop going in.

But if they price things cheaply, and get fast turnover of their stock, people will keep on coming in, to see what is new - so the argument is that lowering the price and increasing the turnover, actually makes more money for the charity shop.

I also think that charity shops have two aims - making money for the charity, of course, but also providing people who don’t have much money the opportunity to buy things they need, but otherwise couldn’t afford.

Some points, charity shops usually set a price then either date or use a code, then if x item has not sold by eg week 3 they get reduced.

The issue of selling an item more than you could buy it at eg Tesco's, you could then argue why do Asda sell x item for x when Tesco's is selling it cheaper, or why buy x item at Argos when eBay's has it cheaper, just because one is selling the items cheaper else where then its unto the customers to shop around rather than undercutting the "New" price elsewhere.

Borth · 10/11/2023 16:57

YABU for being on TikTok

mondaytosunday · 10/11/2023 16:56

I don't think charity shops should be charging £4.99 for a second hand Tesco t-shirt. Or £14.99 for a cotton skirt that looked like someone dug it out of their grandmothers closet. Those items were cheaper when sold new.
Yes charity shop should be cheap to encourage purchasers. As you say there are cheap NEW alternatives out there so who would buy second hand if it wasn't? Most are staffed by volunteers and items are donated. And some things they sell are grim.
My 18 year old daughter loves an afternoon checking the shops out - but they need to have a high turnover otherwise she won't go back. She's prepared to pay for good items but not for tat.

dottypencilcase · 10/11/2023 16:54

Actually I do know what you're getting at. I was at another charity shop last week and was shocked to hear a woman haggling the price of a collectors item and just not giving up! She was literally begging for £1 off the £35 the item was listed at. When the manager explained the item was listed for £20 more on eBay and was welcome to buy it from there instead, she then tried to get some free packaging materials (bubble wrap/a small box, etc. ) as she wanted to send the item abroad and was worried it would be damaged in transit! Some people are just dickheads.

BitofaStramash · 10/11/2023 16:50

HomeschoolMum88 · 10/11/2023 16:37

Disagree entirely. My mother had literally no money when raising me so she relied on second hand shops for all our clothing, homeware etc. Items weee priced for those in need. The prices today are ridiculous and are out of reach for those who truly need it.

Edited

I am sorry about your situation but that is the role of clothing banks, not charity shops.

Charity shops do not exist to clothe those in need of cheap clothes. They exists to raise funds for the charity. If they can do both that is great but that is not their purpose.

kaka79 · 10/11/2023 16:50

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ShanghaiDiva · 10/11/2023 16:50

ime as a volunteer one of the key issues is quality of donations: fast fashion quality is atrocious and doesn’t sell even at very low prices.

dottypencilcase · 10/11/2023 16:48

I don't know what you're on about OP. I'm in London and went in to drop off DCs toys and games yesterday and found 3 new (with tags) M&S bras in my size for £2.99- I bought 3! And I also found two new dresses from Masai and Sahara for £10 and £18! I'm chuffed to bits! There are some shops locally that sell bobbly, stained tat for £5+ but no one buys it. I'll tell you what's missing from charity shops locally though- some good ol' fashioned bric-a-brack! Nowhere has anything worth buying anymore :(

DuploTrain · 10/11/2023 16:48

You are correct that there’s a lot of misconception about the purpose of charity shops - I’ve seen lots of comments on mumsnet along the lines of “I don’t buy from charity shops because I’d be stopping someone who is poor from accessing the clothes”.

Completely ridiculous… if you’re poor you’re probably working long hours and need to buy clothes quickly and cheaply. Primark or vinted would be much more efficient. You probably don’t have the leisure time to browse around charity shops and find one pair of child’s trousers at a time.

And as has been mentioned, that’s not the purpose of charity shops.

ShanghaiDiva · 10/11/2023 16:47

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 10/11/2023 16:40

I’m not sure why, when I was annoyed by responses on other formats, I didn’t realise starting this thread would also annoy the crap out of me😂.

Clearly I’m just on my own planet with my thought.

For the record though for the repeated “it doesn’t mean you can criticise charity shops” comments (and the random link to Jimmy Saville), I’m not saying you cannot criticise them. I’m saying a lot of people don’t seem to realise most run to make money and pricing/marketing is based on an actual strategy.

There’s a charity shop bashing thread on here every other week.
Based on the comments nearly every shop sells a bobbly primark jumper for £8, the staff get all the good stuff for tuppence and the managers are clueless.

BitofaStramash · 10/11/2023 16:47

Agree with you OP.

People making these kind of criticisms are either ignorant or stupid or both.

Anotherparkingthread · 10/11/2023 16:46

The 'it will close down if it doesn't make any money' rehtoric only works for businesses being run as such. Instead what you will see is charity shops that are subsidized by other forms of donation or takings from shops in more affluent areas. I would not be happy to know my donation of cash, money left in a will, or fundraiser money was being added to the pot and then used to prop up the lease of a rental unit on the other side of the country that was run at loss or limping along.
Also charity shops used to exist in two way relationship, people who grew up with little money (myself included) would shop there as a means to an end, because it was very reasonably priced in comparison to new. Anybody with enough money to buy new wouldn't. So maintaining low prices that are cheaper than Primark and other fast fashion was better for the environment, low income households and the charity. Expecting people to buy second hand when they can get the same items new in Primark, or very cheaply from places like eBay, vinted and Facebook marketplace, is never going to work. People on low income won't shop at a charity shop just to support the charity, and will go (quite sensibly) where they can get more, better quality items for their money.

kaka79 · 10/11/2023 16:45

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

theresnolimits · 10/11/2023 16:44

I don’t recognise the Primark top at higher than new model but if I did see that, I’d just ignore it.

I love a charity shop mainly for the recycling element. So much fast fashion which is binned after a few wears. In a charity shop I can give a garment or toy or book a new life.

I actually also appreciate the accessibility ~ in our town so many retail outlets have closed and I hate online shopping and returns. Charity shops allow the browse and buy model.

I don’t mind £15 for a Boden dress or £25 for a Mint Velvet coat ( both recent buys). I’m not looking for bargain basement, I’m looking for recycling, convenience and the ability to buy locally and support a local charity. And I frequently donate too. I think it’s a great model and long may it continue.

LakeTiticaca · 10/11/2023 16:43

Charity shops sometimes get new items donated free from companies and these products tend to be vastly over priced.
Our local Barnardos had some nice new ceramic pots donated and priced quite expensive. Months later they are still sitting on the shelf.
Maybe if they reduced them to a more realistic price they would sell.
Bearing in mind they get all their stock donated free 😉

Pipistrellus · 10/11/2023 16:43

It's the choice of the charity shop how they price their stock.

It's my choice not to bother looking anymore when it's the same stuff that hasn't shifted week in week out. It's my choice not to donate to shops that (imo) overprice and fail to shift stock as I want my donations to find a new home and actually be used by someone.

decionsdecisions62 · 10/11/2023 16:43

Although my daughter bought a skirt from a charity shop last week that actually cost more than it did when it was in Primark new!

Just saying 🤷‍♀️

warriorofhopelessness · 10/11/2023 16:42

Boredandborder · 10/11/2023 16:34

Where I live, they definitely have become overpriced, I so agree with pp about Primark stuff, which I've seen on sale at prices higher than the original store price. Also just because it's Boden or similar, doesn't mean it's worth £20 when it's ten years old and tatty.

What used to be my favourite charity shop refuses donations for half of the week because their storage is full. Maybe if they priced items realistically they'd have a faster or higher turnover. I don't think that just because they're charity shops mean they owe us as customers, any favours, but a sense check of sold prices on Vinted might be an eye opener for their managers.

I think this is true. There are 3 charity shops near me, one overprices, so £30 for a 10 year wool cardigan, one is reasonable but not very exciting, one is staffed by a lovely manager who prices things reasonably and you can still pick up a bargain. That’s the one I use most and the one I also donate to.

orchardsquare · 10/11/2023 16:41

Lots of charity shops in our town have closed down. They did exactly what other posters are saying - bobbly old fleeces, Primark t shirts, etc for about the same price as they cost new. Also you'd see the same things on the racks all the time and when I donated good quality stuff I never saw it out. We have a Salvation Army that always seems busy and that has fair prices.

DogInATent · 10/11/2023 16:41

But charity shops run like any other shop.
Yes. They but special dispensation with rates and most of their staff are volunteers so their costs are massively lower than other shops. But just like other shops, even with the special favours they get over other High St shops, they will go bust if they can't run as a business - and that includes realistic pricing.

My experience with charity shops is that 49% is well-priced, 49% is way over priced because someone's far too much of an optimist/way out of touch with the rest of the High Street, and 2% is way under-priced because they don't know what they're selling. I've had some great bargains hunting for the 2%, and some good chuckles at the ridiculously over-priced tat.

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 10/11/2023 16:40

I’m not sure why, when I was annoyed by responses on other formats, I didn’t realise starting this thread would also annoy the crap out of me😂.

Clearly I’m just on my own planet with my thought.

For the record though for the repeated “it doesn’t mean you can criticise charity shops” comments (and the random link to Jimmy Saville), I’m not saying you cannot criticise them. I’m saying a lot of people don’t seem to realise most run to make money and pricing/marketing is based on an actual strategy.

OP posts:
KirstenBlest · 10/11/2023 16:39

@JFDIYOLO , I saw something similar in a local charity shop. Someone who looked a bit like they had some issues (homeless, I think) came into the shop and the manager gave them a coat without asking for money. Shop was Scope.

Swipe left for the next trending thread