Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find my MIL just so intrusive and possessive?

85 replies

LoveattheWaterCooler · 10/11/2023 12:14

MIL has, from day 1 had a possessive chip on her shoulder. It's really hard to explain, there's been so many small things over the years that I can't really remember, but when I first met DH, she made a huge deal of telling me that SHE'D decorated and picked all the decor/ sofas etc for the house he was then living in. I was like, okay great, not sure why you're telling me this or why it matters? When I moved into that house a couple of years into our relationship, she made it clear she wasn't happy and I can't explain it, but when she came to visit, she'd make all these petty, possessive remarks about things.

We bought a house together, 4 years after we met. She lives 3 hours away and would make a big thing of messaging saying she was going to come and visit and DH could just leave keys out for her to make herself at home (we were both at work) there was no question of her just arriving after we'd got home from work. I'd get home and she'd have rearranged things in the living room and would be asking me what the thank you card in the hallway was for etc.

We have 2 dogs and she acts so possessive and entitled over them, when she visits no one else is allowed to walk them (she knows walking the dogs is my favourite thing and whilst I do invite her on some dog walks, tbh some of the time I want to use walking the dogs as an excuse to get away from her for an hour) She cottoned onto the fact I enjoy the peace and quiet and excuse to get away from her for an hour, so now she jumps out of bed at 6.30 when she's here to dash downstairs and walk them before anyone else is up (they don't have a morning walk with us, they just get an hour and half's walk at some point in the day when we have time) she does the same again in the afternoon, stands up and announces that she's going to walk the dogs and practically runs to get their leads. Doesn't ask if it's okay, just does it. We once asked her not to walk them and she threw an almighty strop, said we were being cruel for not allowing her to walk the dogs (it was once, they'd both caught something off the field the day before and had been throwing up all night) she was their granny and entitled to walk them?! WTF?!

She came to stay at the weekend and said her and FIL would be with us at midday, we had a party to go with the kids until 2pm so asked if she could arrive about 2.30/3. She said no, they wanted to get to us for lunchtime and to just leave a key out and they'd make themselves at home. I said to DH I wasn't really comfortable with this, why couldn't they just arrive when we asked. He agreed but he said he wanted to pick his battles with his mum so would just leave the key out.

When we got home, I asked who wanted a drink and went to walk to the kettle, MIL jumped up and said 'I'll make the teas' I said, no it's fine, they're guests I'm happy to make the drinks to which she huffily said 'This is MY grandchildren and Son's home, I'm entitled to make a drink.' I snapped back I know it was, but it's my home too and I'm also entitled to make a drink. It was so awkward after that. On the Sunday it was my dad's birthday so I scarpered over to my parent's whilst DH took the kids out with PIL and it was great to get a break.

This morning I go on Facebook and see my MIL has joined our village community page and is commenting on someone's post?! WTF, she lives 3 hours away, why on earth has she joined our community page? I know why, because she's desperate to prove that our life is also HER life and that SHE practically lives here too (when she doesn't).

It's like a power struggle every time we see her and I'm so over it, AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LoveattheWaterCooler · 11/11/2023 19:09

PictureOfFlorianTray · 11/11/2023 16:24

Quite true @pikkumyy77

Your MIL's very presence in your home is one large battle.

How long can anyone carry on playing games like pretending to love scrubbing toilets or cleaning ovens ?

There needs to be boundaries and your husband needs to be proactive here.

Also, as others have said, do not leave keys anywhere.

You’re right! As much as the suggestions of pretending to love hoovering etc have made me giggle, one she’d cotton on straight away and two, I just can’t be arsed with constant games in my home. Why can’t she just be bloody normal?!

I’m having a word with DH as this can’t continue. The silly thing is, she moans that she doesn’t see us enough, yet she has no idea that we’d see her MORE if it wasn’t for all the crap she pulls.

OP posts:
PictureOfFlorianTray · 11/11/2023 16:24

Quite true @pikkumyy77

Your MIL's very presence in your home is one large battle.

How long can anyone carry on playing games like pretending to love scrubbing toilets or cleaning ovens ?

There needs to be boundaries and your husband needs to be proactive here.

Also, as others have said, do not leave keys anywhere.

pikkumyy77 · 11/11/2023 15:11

When people tell me to pick my battles I do: Siege of Leningrad? Alesia? Battle for Algiers? Lets pick something bloody and miserable but which I win. Just because you choose your battle doesn’t mean you never engage.

RedDoughnut · 11/11/2023 08:29

What is she like with your DC?

From her attitude to the dogs I'm surprised you didn't mention how she is with children.

I agree with you though she sounds annoying but perhaps not unbearable.

montysma1 · 11/11/2023 00:52

Can you not just walk the dogs if you want whether she has walked them or not?

starfishmummy · 11/11/2023 00:40

Can't you play into it?
MIL - it's time for a cuppa - I'll have 1 sugar

My mil has "rules" about when tea or coffee can be drunk, she'd probably tell me I couldn't have one as kts too near to lunch, dinner, random time in the middle of the day. She doesn't drink tea or coffee herself, but is never far away from a bottle of something luminous blue and sugary.

Mnetcurious · 11/11/2023 00:25

She sounds awful, yanbu at all. I would absolutely be putting my foot down about the leaving the key and the dog walking, completely unreasonable! Which battles is your dh picking exactly? I’d be explaining that leaving a key and walking the dogs are non-negotiable boundaries for you and either he’ll have to tell her or you will. Either by addressing it when she first arrives or in advance, I would be saying something like “I really don’t want to miss out on walking the dogs whilst you’re here so please don’t expect to take them for walks, I will be doing that. It’s really important for my mental health to have that window of time in the day in the fresh air with just me and the dogs. I’m sure you understand that we’re all different people with different ways of doing things and different boundaries, and this is one of mine”. If she protests, just repeat until she gets the message. Even just “it’s nothing personal towards you, this is the way I do things, just as you do things the way you like them in your own home”.

AndWordsWhen · 11/11/2023 00:06

No MIL - only I can load the dishwasher correctly.
MIL - please don't hoover, I'm very particular about how it's done.
DH likes his shirts ironed a certain way - please don't touch them.

Then sit back and enjoy yourself.

SheSaidHummingbird · 10/11/2023 23:02

@LoveattheWaterCooler You must let her know how much you love doing the washing up, scrubbing the shower, cleaning the oven.... well, all of the worst chores. And you'd be so sad if anyone were to take away your utter delight at doing those jobs.

StarShipControl · 10/11/2023 22:56

@LoveattheWaterCooler in that case I'm thinking you start doing the opposite... 'MIL would you mind walking the dogs for me tomorrow morning so that I can have some time free to (insert something exciting / she couldn't resist etc)' 😜

Yes I agree with this. Keep telling her what a wonderful guest she is for doing these things so you can have time to relax. Then go off by yourself and tell her how peaceful and relaxing it is going for a walk by yourself.

SeaToSki · 10/11/2023 22:18

Is there anything you would rather not do, like loading the dishwasher or taking out the bins? You could mess with her by saying you like doing those jobs and see if you can palm them off on her.

Also if you want DH to sit up and take a bit more notice of what is happening, think of a job that he likes doing and tell MIL you like that job, so then she ends up messing with DH

LoveattheWaterCooler · 10/11/2023 22:05

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 10/11/2023 21:22

She's awful

There is no way in hell my mum would expect to let herself into my brothers home and no way that my SIL would allow it if she did. You are allowed to have boundaries to your own HOME! Can you imagine if you two did the same to her?

Please sort this out before you have children (if you plan to)

We have 2 DC. She’s awful and possessive over those too, but that’s a whole other thread.

I’m loving these suggestions, in particular the photos/ cushions of the dogs for Christmas 😂

OP posts:
herbetta · 10/11/2023 22:02

LoveattheWaterCooler · 10/11/2023 19:27

Yes, you’ve absolutely hit the nail on the head. It’s exactly the problem, she’s so sly and that’s what maddens me the most. How can I complain about her walking the dogs, without sounding petty? She was never overly bothered about walking the dogs, until I stupidly let slip that I love walking the dogs, it’s my quiet time and around the same time, they were ill and so we asked her not to walk them. It’s like all of a sudden she thought ‘well if she can walk them, I need to be able to walk them, I’m just as entitled to.’

In fact everything she does is sly, all of it. The leaving the key out, the going through my cards, the joining the Facebook page, none of it is awful in certain context’s (as PP have pointed out) but in the context of her I know there’s hidden meanings and agendas behind all of it but if I object to any of it, I look like a petty cow.

@LoveattheWaterCooler in that case I'm thinking you start doing the opposite... 'MIL would you mind walking the dogs for me tomorrow morning so that I can have some time free to (insert something exciting / she couldn't resist etc)' 😜

disappearingfish · 10/11/2023 21:26

My SIL has similar tendencies towards her sons and DILs. I actually suspect some kind of neurodiversity. She's incapable of reading a room and blurts out the most inappropriate comments that make everyone cringe.

She's much better if you tell her straight that she's annoying/rude.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 10/11/2023 21:22

She's awful

There is no way in hell my mum would expect to let herself into my brothers home and no way that my SIL would allow it if she did. You are allowed to have boundaries to your own HOME! Can you imagine if you two did the same to her?

Please sort this out before you have children (if you plan to)

Yetmorebeanstocount · 10/11/2023 21:00

Santaiswashinghissleigh · 10/11/2023 20:40

As naff as it sounds book yourself a spa day or trip away with a friend. After all she has it all covered for you doesn't she? Not sure how you find a sap like your dh attractive.. Maybe suggest if he doesn't man up his dm will be having him back as an early Christmas present..? And for Christmas get her loads of things with your ddogs faces printed on. You can get cushions and jumpers and all sorts!

Love the doggie-themed Xmas gifts idea!

Darby3785 · 10/11/2023 20:59

Good grief! There is no way I would put up with that from my MIL at all!

She seems to think she has ownership over your DH and children, like she thinks they are her property and that enables her to do as she likes! I think it comes from a place of insecurity, she can't stand not being the main woman in her sons life and needs to be this.

No wonder you have had enough!

Your DH needs to stand up to it, otherwise you are going to wake up and she will have moved in overnight!

GrumpyPanda · 10/11/2023 20:54

Regarding the cards, back in my parents' uni days a friend of theirs and his gf had an issue with the friend's landlady snooping around his mail. The gf took to writing open postcards with this statement slipped into the middle of the text: "Dear Mrs X, what follows isn't intended for you." Maybe a useful suggestion to some of your friends and relatives?

Humbugg · 10/11/2023 20:49

Personally I’d let her crack on with making tea, walking dogs, household chores of your choosing. If she’s around you may as well get something useful out of her to offset her awfulness.

the moving of living room stuff would Fck me right off

BMrs · 10/11/2023 20:45

Look up covert narcissist. My MIL is one too

Yetmorebeanstocount · 10/11/2023 20:40

As pervious poster said, be very grateful to her whilst you keep mentioning her status as 'guest'. Let her 'help' and do jobs for you, act as if you are lady of the house and she is the maid. It will infuriate her.

'So lovely of you to offer to make the tea when you are the guest.'

'You are such a great guest to take our dogs out for us when you are visiting.'

When she has rearranged things: ' thanks so much for tidying, you are such a helpful guest'.

etc.

And change the locks - she may well have already taken a copy of the key..

Santaiswashinghissleigh · 10/11/2023 20:40

As naff as it sounds book yourself a spa day or trip away with a friend. After all she has it all covered for you doesn't she? Not sure how you find a sap like your dh attractive.. Maybe suggest if he doesn't man up his dm will be having him back as an early Christmas present..? And for Christmas get her loads of things with your ddogs faces printed on. You can get cushions and jumpers and all sorts!

pickledandpuzzled · 10/11/2023 20:35

Ah, you’re doing it wrong. She wants a power struggle- drop the rope and spoil her fun!

Thank her for walking the dogs- it’s great to not worry about it and gives you some peace and quiet as well!

Let her knock herself out making tea- ooh lovely, such a treat for someone else to make it. Two sugars please Oh and DH likes it really strong these days!

kill her with kindness!

TheCatterall · 10/11/2023 20:34

Stop leaving the key out - for safety reasons you understand of course… they can find a cafe until you get home.

If she pushes back insisting that’s what needs to happen’ just befuddle her with a ‘no thank you MIL, not doing that, look forward to seeing you on Friday at x time…’

just keep standing your ground.

christ Id be stealth sneaking the dogs into my bedroom each night so I can run away with them in the morning and just leave the DH with everyone to deal with for the day.

can you also get random friends to send you congratulations cards and all manner of random messages inside them… but vague ones so she has no idea what’s going on.

MyAnacondaMight · 10/11/2023 20:31

Maybe the dog will have a sore paw, or imaginary thorn etc., next time and unable to be walked. Then you’re just taking the leads upstairs “just in case” she doesn’t remember the next morning. If she asks, she’s already in the wrong for ignoring you re their health needs.

Let her make the tea, but send it back for being wrong. Or ask her for a latte, using the new milk steamer (that she doesn’t know how to use).

Forget to leave the key out. Or leave the wrong keys. Or a freshly cut copy that don’t work and you had forgot to test them.

Leave some paperwork around re emigration to Australia. Really wind her up. If she asks, deny all knowledge.

Swipe left for the next trending thread