Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Allowing ex-colleague/friend to collect our child

379 replies

MrPrickley · 10/11/2023 11:51

My DW is currently on holiday with her friends. I’m responsible for all child related situations for two weeks.
Yesterday DC (5) fell ill at school, she was fine before going but by 10.30 was throwing up. I was about to go into a client meeting. They are important clients who wouldn’t take a cancellation at such short notice well, I was on the opposite side of the city to my child’s school, 15 minutes until the meeting so notime to hand all the relevant information over to anyone else.
I have a friend/ex-colleague who lives 20 minutes from us. She has her own child and has met ours before, at Christmas events or other casual meet ups. My wife hasn’t met her, not sure why really, it’s just never come up and we were married before I met her. I knew she worked from home on Thursdays, so I called her, asked if she could do me a favour. I called the school back let them know, gave friend the password and the school her full name, the school said they’d ask for the password and photo ID before letting my DC go.
All fine, finished my meeting two hours later, was at friends door an hour after that. DC was fine, she had been snuggled on friends sofa, with the cat, been sick a few more times and my friend had sourced some PJs from a neighbour.
Told DW when she called in the evening. She lost her head, how dear I send our child with someone she doesn’t know. Why didn’t I call her mother (who lives 45 minutes away and doesn’t have a key to our house?!), why didn’t I call her friend (who I don’t have the number for), why didn’t I just leave work and so on. She knows of this person and like I said my DC has met her before.
Now I’m apparently having an affair with this friend and that’s why I called her? I wouldn’t have time for an affair if I bloody wanted one and I love my wife dearly, couldn’t imagine cheating on her?!!!
She’s in a strop now and won’t answer my calls, thinks DC will be traumatised.

AIBU to think I was right in calling my friend and DC is fine so what’s the issue?? I’ve taken today off with her and if I hadn’t of been about to go into a meeting I’d have got her myself.

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 10/11/2023 21:17

Blondeshavemorefun · 10/11/2023 15:06

This

Several times you meet a month and dc met but wife hasn't

Because the wife doesn't want to. Os he made to force her?

Autiebibliophile · 10/11/2023 21:27

It sounds like you need a better back up plan for long term.friend your child doesn't really know isn't really suitable fora sick child. You should have left work and collected the child. But your decision and the child is fine.

Skyisbluegrassisgreen · 10/11/2023 21:39

She had a stomach bug - she wasn’t in intensive care in hospital, get a grip.

Fionaville · 10/11/2023 21:41

I can't believe the comments on this thread! If the roles were reversed and the dad had gone on a lads holiday for two weeks, then criticised the mum for how she'd dealt with the sick child situation, the comments would be mostly 'Leave the bastard!
The mum has trusted the dad with 100% child care for two weeks, knowing hes in work, while she's on holiday! Quite frankly, it's got fuck all to do with her how it was dealt with. If she's such a precious parent, then she shouldn't leave them for a girls holiday! I'd say the same if it was mum or dad away.

LylaLee · 10/11/2023 21:44

Things that strike me:
(1) You've instructed your office to not interrupt a multi million pound meeting. Fine. But (a) you had no adult available for an emergency. What if the child had fallen and broken her arm? Had an allergic reaction. What was your plan for such eventualities?

(i) you should have informed your sister that, 'heads up, my phone is off for a meeting, you're the emergency contact between 12 and 1.'

(b) You say you have no support network. BUT you are in a high paying role (in charge of multi millions) then you pay for support. You pay for 'on call' childminders to be available to you. It's expensive. But, you either pay in money or pay in your child being in a jumbled situation.

(iii) 45 mins for your parents to get there. That's how long it would take me to get to my kid's school. Telling the school someone will be there in 45 mins is normal.

(2) Your wife doesn't like this friend. You don't cut off contact. Fine. But you're so close that you chat on your morning commute? Weird.

(3)This issue is a symptom of a bigger issue. Your wife not trusting your female friendships. Either you pay for relationship counseling, or this festers and you pay for divorce lawyers.

(4) You don't seem to be understanding the wifework comments. Yes, you do the lion's share of driving the kids around, etc. Good. But think about this. Do you know any men who WFH? Why didn't you ask any of them? Why default to a female friend?

tennesseewhiskey1 · 10/11/2023 21:51

I don’t see the issue myself BUT you’re going to get roasted on here OP. I do think you and wife need to sit and discuss the dynamics going forward tho. I suppose I could see both sides - if she is totally insecure then this would be an issue - but I also see that it might be used as a control thing over you.

mummyh2016 · 10/11/2023 22:08

Fionaville · 10/11/2023 21:41

I can't believe the comments on this thread! If the roles were reversed and the dad had gone on a lads holiday for two weeks, then criticised the mum for how she'd dealt with the sick child situation, the comments would be mostly 'Leave the bastard!
The mum has trusted the dad with 100% child care for two weeks, knowing hes in work, while she's on holiday! Quite frankly, it's got fuck all to do with her how it was dealt with. If she's such a precious parent, then she shouldn't leave them for a girls holiday! I'd say the same if it was mum or dad away.

This 100%.
Men are hated on here OP I honestly wouldn't waste your time arguing.

PeppermintPatty10 · 10/11/2023 22:38

OP did the right thing. Reading the first post I can't get past the fact that a mum of three including a wee five year old would go away on a holiday for two weeks, leaving the dad to do all the childcare and work full time?!

steff13 · 10/11/2023 22:53

AnneElliott · 10/11/2023 21:09

Well yes socialising separately is one thing but actually never having met a friend of the other partner is strange in my view.

She's had the opportunity to meet the friend in his chosen not to. So maybe it is weird in your view but it's weird on the wife's behalf not the OP's.

Findinganewme · 11/11/2023 00:12

Something doesn’t add up.

your friend sounds like more of an acquaintance, especially given that your own wife has never met her and how is it that your child has met her? given the non-close friendship, it’s quite surprising that your friend would drop what she’s doing to look after your poorly child, at the risk of the sickness bug (if that’s what it was) being spread within her own home.

secondly, this stuff about you not being able to get out of meeting. I get that the meeting was important, but family emergencies happen. If a person has a call that their loved one is (God forbid) in a car accident, let’s say, would an employer say, ‘no, you can’t go’. I’m so glad that your daughter is fine. You wouldn’t have known that at the time that you had the call from school however and neither would your employer. Doesn’t make sense that they’d say no..what happened to duty of care?

why didn’t you and your wife have an agreement about these things before she left? Your daughter is only 5, and at that age kids do get sick as their immune system is still developing. The agreement on contingency planning in light of sickness, seems like an obvious thing to do. From what you are saying, she would have ‘assumed’ that her mother would step in. Her mother is of course the grandmother and someone who your daughter presumably has a bond with? Someone who would know your daughters signs of wellness, sadness, or flags?

looks like there’s more going on here.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/11/2023 01:34

PeppermintPatty10 · 10/11/2023 22:38

OP did the right thing. Reading the first post I can't get past the fact that a mum of three including a wee five year old would go away on a holiday for two weeks, leaving the dad to do all the childcare and work full time?!

You appear to have missed the memo about the fact that, on MN, mums can do no wrong.

So it's absolutely fine for this woman to swan off on holiday with her mates, leaving her DH to juggle young children and a demanding job for a couple of weeks, but it is absolutely unacceptable for him to make arrangements with a trusted friend for her to provide emergency care for his dd for a couple of hours while he attends a very important meeting.

Clearly, mum is the devoted and responsible parent in this situation, and dad is just taking the piss. How dare he make his own judgement about how best to handle the situation instead of figuring out what his absent wife would want!

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/11/2023 01:55

Findinganewme · 11/11/2023 00:12

Something doesn’t add up.

your friend sounds like more of an acquaintance, especially given that your own wife has never met her and how is it that your child has met her? given the non-close friendship, it’s quite surprising that your friend would drop what she’s doing to look after your poorly child, at the risk of the sickness bug (if that’s what it was) being spread within her own home.

secondly, this stuff about you not being able to get out of meeting. I get that the meeting was important, but family emergencies happen. If a person has a call that their loved one is (God forbid) in a car accident, let’s say, would an employer say, ‘no, you can’t go’. I’m so glad that your daughter is fine. You wouldn’t have known that at the time that you had the call from school however and neither would your employer. Doesn’t make sense that they’d say no..what happened to duty of care?

why didn’t you and your wife have an agreement about these things before she left? Your daughter is only 5, and at that age kids do get sick as their immune system is still developing. The agreement on contingency planning in light of sickness, seems like an obvious thing to do. From what you are saying, she would have ‘assumed’ that her mother would step in. Her mother is of course the grandmother and someone who your daughter presumably has a bond with? Someone who would know your daughters signs of wellness, sadness, or flags?

looks like there’s more going on here.

Why doesn't it add up?

I don't think the friend sounds like a casual acquaintance. The OP said he used to work with her and saw her daily for 5 years. He now meets up with her around once a month and has helped her with stuff when she has needed it. His kids have met her on several occasions. For whatever reason, his wife hasn't. I don't think that's that big a deal. I have a very close friend who I have known for over 10 years, met through work originally and stayed in touch. We help each other out with all sorts of stuff, but my DH has barely ever spoken to her. There are various reasons for this but none of them are sinister!!

If the friend hadn't been able to help, and the OP had been unable to make other arrangements, then obviously, he'd have had no choice but to sack off the meeting and collect his dd, but obviously the consequences of this would have been potentially disastrous for his employer and it might have put him in a very precarious position. It makes perfect sense to put alternative arrangements in place of possible, so that's what he did. Perhaps, given that they worked together previously, he knew that his friend would understand the significance of the meeting and why he needed to ask.

And yes, it might well be that the mum assumed that her mum could be the emergency contact, but she left the OP in charge of looking after the children, and he determined that the friend was a better option, a)because she was closer and b)because MIL didn't have a key to their house. And given that he the one left in charge, her assumptions are irrelevant - it wasn't her decision.

Of course, she could have prepared much better for this kind of scenario before going away, e.g. by giving her mum a key to the house, by giving her DH a list of "acceptable" emergency contacts and by talking about what she wanted him to do in an emergency. The fact is, she didn't do those things, so she can't complain now about the fact that her DH selected another perfectly reasonable solution to the problem that he faced.

If you insist on being in control of every single decision relating to your children, then it's up to you to stick around and put the work in. If you want the other parent to step up so that you can enjoy a bit of freedom every now and then, then you have to trust them to handle things in their own way. As long as the kids are safe and happy, then you really have no right to dictate how the other parent chooses to do stuff, because their approach is just as valid as yours.

Mumto2kids86 · 11/11/2023 02:36

I only thought these ridiculous situations happened in movies. What kind of client meeting takes priority over a poorly 5 year old. Your child was collected by a near-stranger! Also seems odd that your wife would go on holiday for two weeks without you all too but hey ho 🤣

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 11/11/2023 08:47

Mumto2kids86 · 11/11/2023 02:36

I only thought these ridiculous situations happened in movies. What kind of client meeting takes priority over a poorly 5 year old. Your child was collected by a near-stranger! Also seems odd that your wife would go on holiday for two weeks without you all too but hey ho 🤣

What kind of meeting takes priority? The OP has already explained this... the kind of meeting where his company would very likely lose their most important client if the meeting was cancelled at short notice. The kind of meeting where nobody else could step in at such short notice to cover because there wouldn't be enough time to brief them. The kind of meeting for which the OP has said that his boss would not authorise a sudden absence, meaning that he would risk a disciplinary.

Also, the child had met the friend more than once, so no, she wasn't a stranger. And his dd had a tummy bug, so it isn't as if she was seriously ill. Why would the OP risk major consequences for his employer - and potentially his employment - when he had another perfectly satisfactory solution?

Years ago, when I was around 8, I was poorly while my mum was away looking after a dying parent. My dad was supposed to teach a course to a bunch of managers who had paid to attend. There was nobody who could cover him, so he left me in the care a friend/work contact that I had never actually met. She was totally lovely and I was not scarred by the experience in the slightest. All this handwringing about children with ordinary childhood illnesses needing to be with a parent is nonsense. Yes, ideally they will be cared for by a parent and we were lucky that DH and I were always able to do that for our dd, but sometimes it isn't possible and the children will fine if someone else looks after them instead.

As for the mum going on holiday for a couple of weeks...no, I wouldn't have done that personally, but everyone is different and everyone's situation is different. Perhaps she needed a break?

backtowinter · 11/11/2023 09:53

Mumto2kids86 · 11/11/2023 02:36

I only thought these ridiculous situations happened in movies. What kind of client meeting takes priority over a poorly 5 year old. Your child was collected by a near-stranger! Also seems odd that your wife would go on holiday for two weeks without you all too but hey ho 🤣

I've been in plenty of situations where I can't just drop everything and leave work.

Paying a mortgage to keep a roof over DCs' heads was as important as a cuddle

FrenchandSaunders · 11/11/2023 09:55

What happened years ago before mobiles when a child was sick. School would ring the house phone and if parents were out the kid would sit in the sick bay. Not ideal if you feel rough but they all survived! The idea that you have to drop everything and run to the school is bizarre!

A lot of jobs won’t allow that!

FrenchandSaunders · 11/11/2023 09:56

When my kids were small I worked an hour away by train from school and DH had a similar journey by car

IhearyouClemFandango · 11/11/2023 10:06

I don't know, I'm getting a vibe, maybe she does too. Lots of little criticisms and snark about the wife creeping in.

I think it was an odd choice. I wouldn't go off on one about it, but would think it odd. Especially in the context of your wife already not liking her.

ElaineMBenes · 11/11/2023 10:22

What kind of client meeting takes priority over a poorly 5 year old.

You can't use your imagination?

I can think of 2 or 3 occasions this week where I wouldn't have been able to leave work at the drop of a hat. These include teaching commitments and students having travelled significant distances to attend and a visit from a delegation from China who has specifically stopped off at my university on the way to the airport to meet with me.

Life or death .... then yeah you leave. Having experienced getting 'that call' which changes your life forever I guess my perspective changed. A minor illness and a trusted person available is no big deal.

OrlandointheWilderness · 11/11/2023 10:37

@MrPrickley you are fighting an unwinnable battle here. This is MN - you are a man. That is plenty for you to be torn to shreds.

Sometimes in life you absolutely cannot drop everything immediately. The child was moderately unwell and collected by a responsible adult and kept safe. There is absolutely no issue here. When I was small I was the child who threw up at school and an friend of my mum took me to hers because my mum couldn't leave work - we were desperately poor and she was a self employed cleaner. I lived, mum kept her clients and we weren't left in the crap.

Yes our children are the most important things in our lives, but this modern way of 100% putting them right above everything else the entire time is not practical or healthy. Kids have to fit in with life, yes in a very safe way but still!

WrongSwanson · 11/11/2023 10:44

countvoncount · 10/11/2023 13:39

This has gone from the OP saying he adored his wife in the first post....to this mysterious friend sounding more and more appealing by the minute

Wife doesn't work much
Wife won't allow friends
Wife doesn't seem wifey

Friend super caring
Friend is lovely
Friend is wifey

Nah.....nothing wrong with asking a pal to pick your kid up in extreme circumstances, but there's more to this than meets the eye

Agreed

Lochness1975 · 11/11/2023 11:01

Haven't read the full thread but if I was Mrs Prickley I’d be send flowers to say thank you to your friend. Some meetings just have to go ahead.

Ilovecakey · 11/11/2023 11:10

When I was a child if I was sick I would have hated to have to be picked up by someone I barely knew. I only wanted my mum

ElaineMBenes · 11/11/2023 11:28

Ilovecakey · 11/11/2023 11:10

When I was a child if I was sick I would have hated to have to be picked up by someone I barely knew. I only wanted my mum

But mum wouldn't have been collecting anyway.....

billy1966 · 11/11/2023 11:55

I think you did the best you could in a very difficult situation.

Whilst some will say just forgo the meeting, the reality and blow back is real and I can imagine you not wanting to do that.

Some years ago when mine were in primary I got a desperate call from friend whose sisters child was sick and neither the mother nor my friend were able to collect.

She asked was there any way I could collect the child and drop to her mother who didn't drive.
I lived 3 minutes away.

I was able to do it, so did it.
The mother was so grateful and appreciative.
I had never met her child but did have one in a different year, so was known to the school.

Unfortunately sometimes people need to ask for help from someone when they are really stuck.

When my children were small I had weekend nights away, but a girls holiday leaving my husband to juggle it all with work would not have been something I would consider.

The only women that I have heard do this had parents on tap to take over.

You were in charge, you did the best you could.