Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Allowing ex-colleague/friend to collect our child

379 replies

MrPrickley · 10/11/2023 11:51

My DW is currently on holiday with her friends. I’m responsible for all child related situations for two weeks.
Yesterday DC (5) fell ill at school, she was fine before going but by 10.30 was throwing up. I was about to go into a client meeting. They are important clients who wouldn’t take a cancellation at such short notice well, I was on the opposite side of the city to my child’s school, 15 minutes until the meeting so notime to hand all the relevant information over to anyone else.
I have a friend/ex-colleague who lives 20 minutes from us. She has her own child and has met ours before, at Christmas events or other casual meet ups. My wife hasn’t met her, not sure why really, it’s just never come up and we were married before I met her. I knew she worked from home on Thursdays, so I called her, asked if she could do me a favour. I called the school back let them know, gave friend the password and the school her full name, the school said they’d ask for the password and photo ID before letting my DC go.
All fine, finished my meeting two hours later, was at friends door an hour after that. DC was fine, she had been snuggled on friends sofa, with the cat, been sick a few more times and my friend had sourced some PJs from a neighbour.
Told DW when she called in the evening. She lost her head, how dear I send our child with someone she doesn’t know. Why didn’t I call her mother (who lives 45 minutes away and doesn’t have a key to our house?!), why didn’t I call her friend (who I don’t have the number for), why didn’t I just leave work and so on. She knows of this person and like I said my DC has met her before.
Now I’m apparently having an affair with this friend and that’s why I called her? I wouldn’t have time for an affair if I bloody wanted one and I love my wife dearly, couldn’t imagine cheating on her?!!!
She’s in a strop now and won’t answer my calls, thinks DC will be traumatised.

AIBU to think I was right in calling my friend and DC is fine so what’s the issue?? I’ve taken today off with her and if I hadn’t of been about to go into a meeting I’d have got her myself.

OP posts:
rainbowunicorn · 10/11/2023 17:56

Cupcakekiller · 10/11/2023 16:26

If a child is ill, they need to be with their parents or other family members. You could have left your work- you weren't miles away or performing a life saving operation.

No, they really don't. They just need to be with someone that can keep them safe and comfortable.

Pumpkinpie1 · 10/11/2023 17:32

Wife left child for a fortnights holiday …. Could never imagine doing that
Wife is ridiculous

Blondeshavemorefun · 10/11/2023 17:22

Takes a good friend to look after a throwing up 5/6yr esp when meant to be working from home

So if she is such a good friend she needs to meet your wife

I think we all find it weird that you've know friend for years - lives local - has met your children many times

But not your wife

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 10/11/2023 16:34

Cupcakekiller · 10/11/2023 16:26

If a child is ill, they need to be with their parents or other family members. You could have left your work- you weren't miles away or performing a life saving operation.

I think the OP knows his own child better than you do? His dd was fine - safe and happy. And really, it's for him to judge the impact of whether or not he was able to leave the meeting.

If parents have very strong feelings about their children only being cared for by close family members, then that's absolutely fine, but then they probably need to accept that they won't then have the flexibility to be able to go off on holiday for a couple of weeks without their children.

BurnoutGP · 10/11/2023 16:30

Cupcakekiller · 10/11/2023 16:26

If a child is ill, they need to be with their parents or other family members. You could have left your work- you weren't miles away or performing a life saving operation.

You do know that not all families are 1) perfect lovely supportive and available and 2) local. At that some jobs for both sexes cannot be dropped instantly. Your comment is frankly ridiculous.

Cupcakekiller · 10/11/2023 16:26

If a child is ill, they need to be with their parents or other family members. You could have left your work- you weren't miles away or performing a life saving operation.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 10/11/2023 16:14

Conkersinautumn · 10/11/2023 15:54

Child emergency isn't something where you 'ask' it's a fact, your responsibility (child) way trumps your responsibility to someone else's business. Of course your wife is furious, you're priorities are fucked up.

So the OP makes arrangements with a trusted friend for a few hours so that he can attend an essential work meeting while his dd is safely cared for. Meanwhile, the wife is away for a couple of weeks having fun with her friends.

And you think it's his priorities that are fucked up?

There is no way that a mother would get the same responses if her husband was on holiday she asked a friend to help her out in this way, and her husband had then complained about it. The double standards on here are truly shocking.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 10/11/2023 16:04

Lots of ridiculous responses here.

You did nothing wrong, OP. Your wife chose to leave you in charge of parenting while she went off on holiday. You made your own judgement about how to handle a difficult situation and you asked a trusted friend for help. Your dd was safe and happy.

There is literally no issue. Your wife has no business behaving like a control freak when she has chosen to leave you in charge for 2 weeks.

nadine90 · 10/11/2023 16:02

I’m never the type to say “if the sexes were reversed…” but in this case I will. If you were away and wife had asked a female friend to collect I doubt people would be flaming her for it. It’s not ideal to have anyone else collect a poorly child but sometimes these things happen. You made a decision based on knowing this friend for years and your instinct was correct as your child was well looked after. I have friends I’ve known for less time who I would trust with my children too. Your wife’s issue is jealousy, pure and simple, and you are right not to pander to that. Men and women can be friends and she needs to grow up. If she would meet her and her husband, it sounds like you could all be good friends but she is being very childish about it.

Feellikeafailurenow · 10/11/2023 15:55

FrenchandSaunders · 10/11/2023 11:56

You're doing all the childcare related stuff for two weeks, your DW is on holiday. So these decisions fall to you, not her. If she's that particular about things she shouldn't go away.

This

Conkersinautumn · 10/11/2023 15:54

Child emergency isn't something where you 'ask' it's a fact, your responsibility (child) way trumps your responsibility to someone else's business. Of course your wife is furious, you're priorities are fucked up.

AliMonkey · 10/11/2023 15:52

OP, what you did was perfectly reasonable. And I don’t really think your DW can complain when in past she’s made you leave work to pick up sick child rather than her leaving her ladies lunch. In fact given her working hours and that you have Sat with kids on own, why on earth are you doing majority of school runs, unless it’s a practical reason like you having the only car and school not being walking distance?

I can’t believe all the comments here about your work always coming first when it’s clear that’s not the case given you left straight after your meeting to pick DC up and do most school runs. Fewer would think you were in the wrong if you were female - so many just assume that all men are bad parents which you clearly are not.

I am also shocked by comments that DC would always want family (any family, not just parents) in preference to friends. Why does blood trump friendship? I have several friends who would be much better choice than some family members.

It’s great that you have a friend willing to pick up vomiting child (would be low down on the list of favours I’d be willing to do!) and that your DC was so happy there. Friends like that are worth keeping, whatever your DW says.

Nonplusultra · 10/11/2023 15:45

I think my mind would jump to affair too because I’d wonder why a woman would be willing to collect someone else’s vomitting child and bring them into their house.
I’m generally a very helpful sort of person, but I draw the line at letting vomitting bugs through the door.

That’s a huge favour.

BlueEyedPeanut · 10/11/2023 15:40

You did fine. Your child was sick - not dying - and NOT with a stranger despite what people keep dramatically claiming 🙄. It's a very mummy-martyr thing to completely drop everything for the children, even when there are alternative options available, and fuck the long-term consequences of walking out of your job etc.

Mumof2teens79 · 10/11/2023 15:39

I get that some meetings are important but I would probably have done a shorter meeting and got to school as soon as I could.
It is quite odd that you have a friend your wife has met but your daughter has.
And meeting a couple of times to me doesn't say your daughter knows her well enough to go her when she is sick.

I would not have done this myself, and would be less happy if DH had done it, whether a male or a female if I had never met them and DC didn't know them really well.

You need to make sure as a family you have back up plans for this. Grandparents need keys and passwords, and you both need contact numbers for good friends you agree can be called to help out.
And if one person knows they are unavailable/away the other parent needs to be prepared to drop everything.

2023forme · 10/11/2023 15:38

CuriousGeorge80 · 10/11/2023 15:23

Honestly OP I think what you did was fine in the circumstances. Your wife is jealous. I guarantee she would have zero issue asking her own friend you hadn’t met. As would many of the people criticising you on here.

It amazes me how many people genuinely seem to not understand the concept of a work meeting that you can’t cancel other than for an absolute total emergency (eg death, hospital).

This 👆. Ok so child was poorly but it’s not like she was having brain surgery. A few hours with a caring adult the child has previously met is absolutely fine.

for those saying they’d never put work before the child - that’s all well and good if your work is flexible enough to facilitate this. But not everyone has a job like that - I can imagine many scenarios where the parent can’t just up and leave work the instant a problem with their DC crops up.

so @MrPrickley i think your DW is being very unreasonable. If I were her, I’d be wanting to send your friend a small thank you gift.

TokyoGhoul · 10/11/2023 15:33

FilthyforFirth · 10/11/2023 15:28

Wow how weirdly personal. No I wouldnt be away from my primary age children for two weeks.

Two wrongs dont make a right though.

You said you would be livid.
I was just expanding on the situation for the expressed lividness?

One 'wrong' is responsible for the second 'wrong' and then critical of it.

Also the second 'wrong' worked out fine.

While the first 'wrong' is still selfishly sunning herself being 'livid'.

FilthyforFirth · 10/11/2023 15:28

TokyoGhoul · 10/11/2023 15:23

Would you be livid from your sun lounger?

Livid with the decision the parent working full time and looking after 3 kids made while you were lounging?

Hopefully your rage would awaken you to what a lazy arse unreasonable twat you are so you'd get straight on the next plane home to help?

Wow how weirdly personal. No I wouldnt be away from my primary age children for two weeks.

Two wrongs dont make a right though.

Passerillage · 10/11/2023 15:23

I don't really see a massive problem. If the sexes were reversed, and the husband was away on a lads' holiday, and the wife going into an important "don't miss this if you value your next promotion" client meeting, and she called an old colleague to collect the vommy child and then picked her up a couple of hours later, it would scarcely even warrant telling the husband-on-holiday about.

In fact if she then posted about the husband being angry about it on here, people would be calling her husband controlling and unreasonable for trying to micromanage her from his holiday.

I'm mostly surprised the friend agreed to pick up a vommy child, because I would REALLY hesitate to, in case I ended up getting the same call from my own kids' school 48 hours later, but maybe she felt put on the spot a bit.

CuriousGeorge80 · 10/11/2023 15:23

Honestly OP I think what you did was fine in the circumstances. Your wife is jealous. I guarantee she would have zero issue asking her own friend you hadn’t met. As would many of the people criticising you on here.

It amazes me how many people genuinely seem to not understand the concept of a work meeting that you can’t cancel other than for an absolute total emergency (eg death, hospital).

TokyoGhoul · 10/11/2023 15:23

FilthyforFirth · 10/11/2023 15:13

Yabu. I would read DH the riot act if he ever did this. But he wouldnt as our children come first, especially a sick one over work.

A grandparent 45 mins away is preferable to a loose friend closer by in my opinion.

I wouldnt assume affair but I would be livid nonetheless.

Would you be livid from your sun lounger?

Livid with the decision the parent working full time and looking after 3 kids made while you were lounging?

Hopefully your rage would awaken you to what a lazy arse unreasonable twat you are so you'd get straight on the next plane home to help?

ElaineMBenes · 10/11/2023 15:19

If I have something I know I absolutely should not miss at work then I will arrange to have my backup people in the sidelines.

Every single time?

Op what you did was fine. I've collected friends kids from school in an emergency and vice versa. It's no big deal and just what you'd do for a friend.

sonjadog · 10/11/2023 15:19

I don't think you did anything wrong per se, but you knew your wife would be very upset and jealous before you contacted this friend and yet you did it anyway. So you brought this one on yourself. You should have contacted the grandparents.

Your wife sounds shit, btw. Possessive, controlling, lazy and selfish.

TokyoGhoul · 10/11/2023 15:19

If I were you OP I'd be saying to my wife:

Get back home now.

I cannot take full responsibility for work and child care while you laze about criticising me for doing it wrong.

No more 2 week girls holidays as we have kids to care for, and we obviously need to address this distrust issue we've been avoiding.

Your issue here isn't your DD and the om
Vomiting that's all resolved.

Your issue is a lazy arse wife, unrealistic expectations, and a weird dynamic around your friendships and your wife.

Ponoka7 · 10/11/2023 15:18

Ideally it would be family, but the GM doesn't seem to want to, or be particularly close. I think that you should have asked her, or now see if she l'd be available going forward. If not, your friend is a suitable replacement, given family were away with your wife. Some people are lovely and some seem lovely but aren't. You can't tell. That's how sexual abuse by family and friends happen. Then there's trusting someone to make the call that a hospital run is needed. Your wife really should meet her.