Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Allowing ex-colleague/friend to collect our child

379 replies

MrPrickley · 10/11/2023 11:51

My DW is currently on holiday with her friends. I’m responsible for all child related situations for two weeks.
Yesterday DC (5) fell ill at school, she was fine before going but by 10.30 was throwing up. I was about to go into a client meeting. They are important clients who wouldn’t take a cancellation at such short notice well, I was on the opposite side of the city to my child’s school, 15 minutes until the meeting so notime to hand all the relevant information over to anyone else.
I have a friend/ex-colleague who lives 20 minutes from us. She has her own child and has met ours before, at Christmas events or other casual meet ups. My wife hasn’t met her, not sure why really, it’s just never come up and we were married before I met her. I knew she worked from home on Thursdays, so I called her, asked if she could do me a favour. I called the school back let them know, gave friend the password and the school her full name, the school said they’d ask for the password and photo ID before letting my DC go.
All fine, finished my meeting two hours later, was at friends door an hour after that. DC was fine, she had been snuggled on friends sofa, with the cat, been sick a few more times and my friend had sourced some PJs from a neighbour.
Told DW when she called in the evening. She lost her head, how dear I send our child with someone she doesn’t know. Why didn’t I call her mother (who lives 45 minutes away and doesn’t have a key to our house?!), why didn’t I call her friend (who I don’t have the number for), why didn’t I just leave work and so on. She knows of this person and like I said my DC has met her before.
Now I’m apparently having an affair with this friend and that’s why I called her? I wouldn’t have time for an affair if I bloody wanted one and I love my wife dearly, couldn’t imagine cheating on her?!!!
She’s in a strop now and won’t answer my calls, thinks DC will be traumatised.

AIBU to think I was right in calling my friend and DC is fine so what’s the issue?? I’ve taken today off with her and if I hadn’t of been about to go into a meeting I’d have got her myself.

OP posts:
Minglingpringle · 13/11/2023 14:49

rainbowboymama · 13/11/2023 11:14

Work would NEVER come before my sick child, and if my manager/client couldn’t understand that then I would absolutely be looking for another job. There is literally no job in the world that I would put before my sick child.

I would also never ever expect an ex-colleague or even a friend, to collect my vomiting child from school either. I also know that unwell children want their parents, not someone they’ve met a handful of times. My children would be distraught if someone they didn’t know particularly well was picking them up, especially when poorly.

At the age of 5 too, I really feel like this is definitely too young of an age to be arranging for this lady to collect them from school when unwell.

I would be upset like your wife. The affair accusations are just because she’s so angry and riled up though I’m sure, she will probably apologise for that accusation once this isn’t so fresh!

Maybe not all children would be as distraught as yours.

Maybe your children would be distraught because you’ve transmitted your own anxiety to them.

Pezdeoro41 · 13/11/2023 14:24

Pezdeoro41 · 13/11/2023 14:23

I think OP is getting an unfairly hard time on this point. He could have potentially lost his job over this - how would losing his income have benefited his child? As a single parent and sole breadwinner I feel this tension a lot and while the majority of times I would absolutely walk straight out and get my kid, there are times when the stakes are so high that you just can’t. One vomiting bug versus your whole career in a cost of living crisis? That’s not prioritising work, it’s prioritising supporting your family.

OP I think you did totally the right thing, well done for thinking on your feet in a real jam and successfully navigating your way out of a crisis!

Ps I am also a woman.

Pezdeoro41 · 13/11/2023 14:23

Jellycatspyjamas · 10/11/2023 12:14

It wasn’t an option to walk away from the meeting. If I’d asked my manager he would have said no

You know women have to navigate this stuff all the time, sometimes your child just needs to be your first priority.

I think OP is getting an unfairly hard time on this point. He could have potentially lost his job over this - how would losing his income have benefited his child? As a single parent and sole breadwinner I feel this tension a lot and while the majority of times I would absolutely walk straight out and get my kid, there are times when the stakes are so high that you just can’t. One vomiting bug versus your whole career in a cost of living crisis? That’s not prioritising work, it’s prioritising supporting your family.

OP I think you did totally the right thing, well done for thinking on your feet in a real jam and successfully navigating your way out of a crisis!

Whiteday · 13/11/2023 12:32

rainbowboymama · 13/11/2023 12:19

@uckedfaypuay agreed, thank you for opening my eyes. I am just an (un)fulfilled SAHM with no other life, so thank you for educating me and seeing this from another viewpoint. I come from sub-standard social and learning conditions, so of course, now so do my children. So thank you again, for opening my eyes to how the other half live and bring up their children. That’s also not sarcasm, I know things can be interpreted incorrectly when just reading a post/response!

This isn't true but you are looking at being employed and bringing in most of the family money through rose tinted glasses. You are making it sound like the man in question should've left his employment immediately, risking his job, therefore the security of his family. You think that's a sensible option? Really?

We'd all like to say "I'm leaving" because something wasn't up to our personal wants, but when you're bringing in money that provides for everyone, then you can't just do that?

Would you expect to go on holiday, your DH need to navigate this situation and you come back and he tells you he is now out of a job? Remember, this was a stomach bug, not life threatening.

MrsB74 · 13/11/2023 12:29

You didn’t do anything wrong - it was an emergency and you asked a friend to help - probably time to introduce your wife to the friend though!

I asked a friend (school mum) to look after one of my dc when she had chicken pox as I had an important appointment - don’t think my DH had met her at that point.

it’s because it’s a woman! It’s a bit rich for her to criticise when she is on holiday though. You were in charge and had to make a quick decision. Some work meetings are very difficult to miss without repercussions.

rainbowboymama · 13/11/2023 12:19

@uckedfaypuay agreed, thank you for opening my eyes. I am just an (un)fulfilled SAHM with no other life, so thank you for educating me and seeing this from another viewpoint. I come from sub-standard social and learning conditions, so of course, now so do my children. So thank you again, for opening my eyes to how the other half live and bring up their children. That’s also not sarcasm, I know things can be interpreted incorrectly when just reading a post/response!

uckedfaypuay · 13/11/2023 12:04

@rainbowboymama You clearly feel 100% fulfilled by being a mother, and it sounds like career is less of a priority for you, and that's genuinely a great thing! But that's a very personal calling and life choice.

Maybe someone chooses a well-paid career, so they can send their child to Montessori or Steiner or some lovely programme their child loves and beams delightedly about 99% of the time... Versus being 100% available for a mildly sick child in sub-standard social and learning conditions.

Or maybe, less optionally, the particular position and career someone has built a track record in – and perhaps even promotion they're banking on – pays the entire family's necessary bills and expenses. Sure, you can wait and hop around for the perfect job which gives you latitude all the time, in the same industry with commensurate pay, but that probably doesn't exist. Even if you start your own business, there are clients you can't afford to lose if you want the groceries and mortgage paid for.

Or maybe, even if finances aren't at stake, someone simply values their competency and contribution in litigation, medicine, education, policy, business negotiation, etc. Maybe they're even just a fledgling freelance interior designer or event planner who takes pride in delivering projects on time.

And of course, that person is the one to help and serve you and your child. My friends are not going to tell you "oops, I know your child's septic condition is deteriorating rapidly, and you might lose your child by sunset, but my Little Timmy has got the sniffles". I'm not going to tell someone I can't defend them in court today for that reason. My family members (no, not Rishi 😂) aren't going to ask for the entire country's Budget announcement date to be delayed on account of Little Timmy's minor cold. The event planner isn't going to ghost you on the day of your DC's birthday party. These are perhaps rather niche examples but at every level of society, this is how the earth keeps spinning, how your child gets their needs met on time on a daily basis.

Of course if your child is very ill or it's a lax period at work, go. But if it's just them catching yet another bug going round, and there's a trusted familiar adult there to give them some Calpol and watch them fall asleep immediately, and you can be there in a few hours, you don't have to rush to their side as if they're literally dying from some terrible disease.

Whiteday · 13/11/2023 11:45

rainbowboymama · 13/11/2023 11:42

@BurnoutGP I did just say in a reply to somebody else, that I do realise that there are actually jobs such as yours/surgeons etc. where I realise this wouldn’t be possible! So I retract my generalisation that no job should come first and apologies for this! However, I do not think this is the case for the OP, it seems like he just didn’t want to upset a client. That’s how I read it anyway.

And lose the company a very valuable contract that would mean financial hardship for them, maybe even redundancies?

Whiteday · 13/11/2023 11:43

rainbowboymama · 13/11/2023 11:26

@Whiteday I think if it means losing your job, the company is being completely unreasonable! As annoying as it must be when employees have to take time off to look after their unwell children, it’s what needs to happen sometimes. Unless the role is that of a surgeon or the like, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to allow them to leave to collect their vomiting child from school.

They definitely should’ve discussed scenarios such as this before she went on a lovely jolly, and I agreed that the affair accusations are not ok!

They may be unreasonable, I agree the DH should resign immediately, give no notice, walk away and then I'm sure the issue of a two week holiday for the DM won't be an issue for a while!

Don't be ridiculous, his job is very important, to maintain a roof over the families head

It's not his employer that's the issue!

rainbowboymama · 13/11/2023 11:42

@BurnoutGP I did just say in a reply to somebody else, that I do realise that there are actually jobs such as yours/surgeons etc. where I realise this wouldn’t be possible! So I retract my generalisation that no job should come first and apologies for this! However, I do not think this is the case for the OP, it seems like he just didn’t want to upset a client. That’s how I read it anyway.

uckedfaypuay · 13/11/2023 11:41

@rainbowboymama it may not mean losing your job (though children of a certain age get sick about 20x a year, so it might). But it might factor strongly into your overall career prospects or the cold hard sum of your annual bonus (which your family is relying on), especially if it's something time sensitive like a client case or big deal you're handling.

CurlewKate · 13/11/2023 11:39

@rainbowboymama "Work would NEVER come before my sick child, and if my manager/client couldn’t understand that then I would absolutely be looking for another job. There is literally no job in the world that I would put before my sick child."

Oh don't be silly.

BurnoutGP · 13/11/2023 11:35

rainbowboymama · 13/11/2023 11:14

Work would NEVER come before my sick child, and if my manager/client couldn’t understand that then I would absolutely be looking for another job. There is literally no job in the world that I would put before my sick child.

I would also never ever expect an ex-colleague or even a friend, to collect my vomiting child from school either. I also know that unwell children want their parents, not someone they’ve met a handful of times. My children would be distraught if someone they didn’t know particularly well was picking them up, especially when poorly.

At the age of 5 too, I really feel like this is definitely too young of an age to be arranging for this lady to collect them from school when unwell.

I would be upset like your wife. The affair accusations are just because she’s so angry and riled up though I’m sure, she will probably apologise for that accusation once this isn’t so fresh!

Just staggering. Next time my child is ill, ill just cancel my 30 patients booked for the day. I'm sure they'll be super understanding just like you would be right.
I'm a GP BTW you know those that are really difficult to get appts with...

rainbowboymama · 13/11/2023 11:26

@Whiteday I think if it means losing your job, the company is being completely unreasonable! As annoying as it must be when employees have to take time off to look after their unwell children, it’s what needs to happen sometimes. Unless the role is that of a surgeon or the like, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to allow them to leave to collect their vomiting child from school.

They definitely should’ve discussed scenarios such as this before she went on a lovely jolly, and I agreed that the affair accusations are not ok!

ElaineMBenes · 13/11/2023 11:24

Work would NEVER come before my sick child, and if my manager/client couldn’t understand that then I would absolutely be looking for another job. There is literally no job in the world that I would put before my sick child.

If only it were that simple!
My child is my priority and that includes being able to provide for them financially.

Whiteday · 13/11/2023 11:20

rainbowboymama · 13/11/2023 11:14

Work would NEVER come before my sick child, and if my manager/client couldn’t understand that then I would absolutely be looking for another job. There is literally no job in the world that I would put before my sick child.

I would also never ever expect an ex-colleague or even a friend, to collect my vomiting child from school either. I also know that unwell children want their parents, not someone they’ve met a handful of times. My children would be distraught if someone they didn’t know particularly well was picking them up, especially when poorly.

At the age of 5 too, I really feel like this is definitely too young of an age to be arranging for this lady to collect them from school when unwell.

I would be upset like your wife. The affair accusations are just because she’s so angry and riled up though I’m sure, she will probably apologise for that accusation once this isn’t so fresh!

Do you think if it meant not being able to provide for your child you may reconsider? The OP is a full time worker, the DM works two days a week

So if he loses his job, she only works two days a week, what then?

Perhaps, the DW should've considered the situation before her holiday?

And being angry whilst dictating what her needs are and accusing him of an affair and then ignoring calls is ridiculous. Maybe he should ignore the calls if she wants to speak to the children?

rainbowboymama · 13/11/2023 11:14

Work would NEVER come before my sick child, and if my manager/client couldn’t understand that then I would absolutely be looking for another job. There is literally no job in the world that I would put before my sick child.

I would also never ever expect an ex-colleague or even a friend, to collect my vomiting child from school either. I also know that unwell children want their parents, not someone they’ve met a handful of times. My children would be distraught if someone they didn’t know particularly well was picking them up, especially when poorly.

At the age of 5 too, I really feel like this is definitely too young of an age to be arranging for this lady to collect them from school when unwell.

I would be upset like your wife. The affair accusations are just because she’s so angry and riled up though I’m sure, she will probably apologise for that accusation once this isn’t so fresh!

Velvetdragon13 · 13/11/2023 10:40

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 12/11/2023 23:36

This is such a ridiculous post. The OP's wife went on holiday for 2 weeks, leaving him in charge. He doesn't need to get her permission to leave the kids with a trusted friend, who wasn't actually a stranger to the kids at all. It's interesting that you think the DW's friend would have been an acceptable option, even though the OP has clearly stated that the kids know his friend just as well as they know his wife's friend.

Do you really ring up your husband to get his authorisation on every single little parenting decision that you make? Or is it only male parents who are required to seek approval from their wives about how to parent their children?

It's amazing how many people clearly still see the mum as the default parent who has the right to call all the shots... even when she has pissed off on holiday leaving dad in charge.

"Do you really ring up your husband to get his authorisation on every single little parenting decision that you make?"

Is what you're doing something you normally do? No.

Is what you're doing different from normal? Then yes!

It's called keeping your spouse or partner in the loop!

TimetoPour · 13/11/2023 09:59

I’m not sure what other people are reading.

Your friend is NOT a stranger to your child and you have known her for a number of years.
She was the closest adult that you trust and knew was available.
She is a parent herself and capable of caring for a sick child.
Your child was happy to be there.
You collected your child as soon as possible.

Your wife is on a 2 week jolly up with the people who would normally be your support network.
She has no reason to dislike this woman other than her own insecurities and jealousy.
She would have been ok if it was one of HER friends that collected the child so her problem is not the fact that you personally didn’t go.

If the situation was reversed and Dad was on holiday, complaining about Mum’s choice of childcare, everyone would be hitting the roof. You handled a difficult situation in the best way possible. Not everyone can just walk out of a job- teachers, surgeons- people who are dealing with major financial contracts that will crumble a company and in turn other people’s jobs and livelihoods.

randomchap · 13/11/2023 09:23

It is rather telling that people critising are changing the narrative to suit their opinion. Op states friend who's met the child multiple times, then the critics are calling her a stranger.

Sometimes you just cannot get out of work without serious consequences. Op got his child out of school, to a safe place, with a person they know, to be cared for. There's nothing wrong with that.

@MrPrickley is your wife responding to you again now?

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 13/11/2023 09:08

You've done nothing wrong, a situation arose and you dealt with it. Your kid was safe and looked after. Your wife is just in a strop because its a female friend you called.

I was once asked to pick up the kid of someone I do martial arts with. Never met the child, but she was sick, he was at work over an hour away and his wife was in surgery (she's a surgeon) so could hardly just disappear. My friend was trying to get home, but trains were running late and it was just a disaster. I was a SAHM at the time and my kids went to the same school and I was his desperate option.

Needless to say, his child survived being collected by me, she lounged on the sofa under our "sick blanket" as my kids call it, and my friend and his wife were extremely grateful I dealt with their puking child for them.

I would do the same for anyone I knew, in that situation and I know I have friends who would do the same for me.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/11/2023 07:07

uckedfaypuay · 13/11/2023 00:23

You'd be surprised. I have friends who are surgeons and no, firstly there usually isn't a nice locum system in place, secondly surgeons have their own specialties and skillsets. In most if not all cases, I'm sure my friends would go on with their life-saving duties if their child has a minor bug.

I'm all for flexible working, and being a present parent. But that's when it's warranted. You can't live and breathe for your child to this extent. Well, you can, but accept that as a personal decision rather than impose it on everyone else.

It sounds from this thread like many SAHMs (or people working only at low levels because of their DC) don't have a grasp of how the real world works. The funny thing is that the real world works to serve and sustain them and their oh-so-important DC – to offer them the services they need on a timely basis (and would no doubt throw a strop about if DC couldn't get access ASAP), and their DH the employment and salary he needs – precisely because people don't drop everything and go running home the moment their child has a cold.

Edited

Can you imagine the outrage if teachers were constantly popping off to pick up their slightly poorly children?

Whiteday · 13/11/2023 06:06

@MrPrickley if your wife is that concerned about who picks up her children, then she should not swan off on two week holidays leaving you in this position!

Kattiekat · 13/11/2023 06:00

So your additional posts say you are the main drop off / collect parent. Who usually leaves work to collect child. There have even been instances when child is unwell and you have left work because your wife was unwilling to leave a lunch with her friend.

in an ideal world we would all leave work every time but in this instance it would have caused you major work tissues and had repercussions for you and so you asked this person.

well your wife will have to get over it.

Ask your friend and their partner if she has one, out for a drink with your self and your wife to say thank you and so they can meet up. Then at least she can put a face to the name.

and next time she goes in holiday factor in your important meetings that you can not leave work for. Let your wife know. If she is unable to find a suitable emergency contact for while she is away, then she can’t go. Give your mother in law a spare key for emergencies if she doesn’t mind helping out.

Having said all that tbh I wouldn’t have liked it either but what’s done is done a lesson would have been learnt on my part.

Whiteday · 13/11/2023 05:59

@CrappyBarbara so everyday you ensure one of you is not doing something they can't leave?