Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Allowing ex-colleague/friend to collect our child

379 replies

MrPrickley · 10/11/2023 11:51

My DW is currently on holiday with her friends. I’m responsible for all child related situations for two weeks.
Yesterday DC (5) fell ill at school, she was fine before going but by 10.30 was throwing up. I was about to go into a client meeting. They are important clients who wouldn’t take a cancellation at such short notice well, I was on the opposite side of the city to my child’s school, 15 minutes until the meeting so notime to hand all the relevant information over to anyone else.
I have a friend/ex-colleague who lives 20 minutes from us. She has her own child and has met ours before, at Christmas events or other casual meet ups. My wife hasn’t met her, not sure why really, it’s just never come up and we were married before I met her. I knew she worked from home on Thursdays, so I called her, asked if she could do me a favour. I called the school back let them know, gave friend the password and the school her full name, the school said they’d ask for the password and photo ID before letting my DC go.
All fine, finished my meeting two hours later, was at friends door an hour after that. DC was fine, she had been snuggled on friends sofa, with the cat, been sick a few more times and my friend had sourced some PJs from a neighbour.
Told DW when she called in the evening. She lost her head, how dear I send our child with someone she doesn’t know. Why didn’t I call her mother (who lives 45 minutes away and doesn’t have a key to our house?!), why didn’t I call her friend (who I don’t have the number for), why didn’t I just leave work and so on. She knows of this person and like I said my DC has met her before.
Now I’m apparently having an affair with this friend and that’s why I called her? I wouldn’t have time for an affair if I bloody wanted one and I love my wife dearly, couldn’t imagine cheating on her?!!!
She’s in a strop now and won’t answer my calls, thinks DC will be traumatised.

AIBU to think I was right in calling my friend and DC is fine so what’s the issue?? I’ve taken today off with her and if I hadn’t of been about to go into a meeting I’d have got her myself.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 16/11/2023 12:58

Velvetdragon13 · 16/11/2023 09:41

You didn't read the entire post, did you?

Are you supportive of dumping your kids with people your other doesn't know and not keeping your other in the loop, leaving them to "find out"? Nothing is more suspicious than something happening and wondering why you were not informed - and that is the entire point.

@OP if you don't want insight on your problem, don't post it online.

If you choose to go away for 2 weeks and leave your other half in charge of the kids, then it's reasonable to assume that you trust them enough to make sensible judgements about the children. You don't need to be informed in real time about each and every tiny decision made.

The OP told his wife that evening about the perfectly acceptable arrangements that he had put in place to ensure that their child was appropriately cared for while he attended a very important work meeting. There is literally nothing to be suspicious about.

If you don't trust your partner to look after your kids appropriately, then that's your call... you may have good reason for this, for all I know. However, if you do feel that you're unable to trust your partner, I'm guessing that you wouldn't go away on holiday for 2 weeks, leaving him in sole charge of the children?

Whiteday · 16/11/2023 12:35

@Velvetdragon13 have you read the OP, it clearly states he told DW, she didn't "find out", he told her when she called in the evening?

Was he supposed to contact her every step of the way, whilst receiving calls from the school and arranging emergency childcare? Make another few calls to his DW, for her to approve his parenting decisions from her sun-bed?

He didn't dump his child, he arranged cover around his work requirements.

Velvetdragon13 · 16/11/2023 09:41

CurlewKate · 12/11/2023 23:14

@Velvetdragon13 "Did you call your DW before making arrangements with your ex colleague/friend?"
Why should he? He was duty parent. It was his call.

You didn't read the entire post, did you?

Are you supportive of dumping your kids with people your other doesn't know and not keeping your other in the loop, leaving them to "find out"? Nothing is more suspicious than something happening and wondering why you were not informed - and that is the entire point.

@OP if you don't want insight on your problem, don't post it online.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/11/2023 12:51

Spinet · 14/11/2023 12:37

I don't need to 'justify my existence' to you or anyone else! Unless you think work= existence??

Personally, I don't think you need to justify your existence to anyone.

But I think you do think that you need to justify your position, otherwise you wouldn't feel the need to make pompous and frankly stupid statements about how, as a SAHM, you take pedagogy and social development seriously while implying that others view these things as an "afterthought".

I'm sorry to break it to you, but being a SAHP doesn't make you a superior parent. Your kids won't turn out happier or more successful because of it. If that arrangement works well for you and your family, then crack on...no judgement here.

However, I will judge the pathetic attempts to pretend that you're somehow taking your parenting responsibilities more seriously than those who WOH. They just make you look ignorant and insecure about your own choices.

ElaineMBenes · 14/11/2023 12:39

I'm a firm believer in people doing what they think best without slagging off other people's best or calling it sub-standard.

Except that's essentially what you did.......intentional or not 🤷‍♀️

Spinet · 14/11/2023 12:37

I don't need to 'justify my existence' to you or anyone else! Unless you think work= existence??

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/11/2023 12:30

Whiteday · 14/11/2023 12:22

Yes I think that's exactly what's being said!

It's actually rather sad that some people feel under such pressure to justify their existence with pompous nonsense like this.

Spinet · 14/11/2023 12:29

No. I was just rejecting the idea that being a SAHP provides sub-standard social and learning conditions. I was referring particularly to what that poster said in the same passive-aggressive tone they used. If you want to take offence you can, just as I took offence at that post, but it won't get anybody anywhere. I'm a firm believer in people doing what they think best without slagging off other people's best or calling it sub-standard.

Whiteday · 14/11/2023 12:22

ElaineMBenes · 14/11/2023 12:14

But then I, like many SAHPs, take pedagogy and social development seriously and don't look at it as an after-thought to outsource.

Are you suggesting that parents that work don't take this seriously?

Yes I think that's exactly what's being said!

ElaineMBenes · 14/11/2023 12:14

But then I, like many SAHPs, take pedagogy and social development seriously and don't look at it as an after-thought to outsource.

Are you suggesting that parents that work don't take this seriously?

Whiteday · 14/11/2023 12:08

Spinet · 14/11/2023 11:25

Some people know that their kids would have sub-standard social and learning conditions if they were a SAHP. Good on them for recognising that they don't have the skills to deal with their kids day in day out!

My kids definitely benefited from having a SAHP. But then I, like many SAHPs, take pedagogy and social development seriously and don't look at it as an after-thought to outsource. (As an aside I have done the background work on Steiner schools and would never send my kid to one, lovely and hippy as they seem on the surface).

Do you home school? Or do you outsource that?

Spinet · 14/11/2023 11:25

Some people know that their kids would have sub-standard social and learning conditions if they were a SAHP. Good on them for recognising that they don't have the skills to deal with their kids day in day out!

My kids definitely benefited from having a SAHP. But then I, like many SAHPs, take pedagogy and social development seriously and don't look at it as an after-thought to outsource. (As an aside I have done the background work on Steiner schools and would never send my kid to one, lovely and hippy as they seem on the surface).

Manthide · 14/11/2023 08:39

uckedfaypuay · 13/11/2023 12:04

@rainbowboymama You clearly feel 100% fulfilled by being a mother, and it sounds like career is less of a priority for you, and that's genuinely a great thing! But that's a very personal calling and life choice.

Maybe someone chooses a well-paid career, so they can send their child to Montessori or Steiner or some lovely programme their child loves and beams delightedly about 99% of the time... Versus being 100% available for a mildly sick child in sub-standard social and learning conditions.

Or maybe, less optionally, the particular position and career someone has built a track record in – and perhaps even promotion they're banking on – pays the entire family's necessary bills and expenses. Sure, you can wait and hop around for the perfect job which gives you latitude all the time, in the same industry with commensurate pay, but that probably doesn't exist. Even if you start your own business, there are clients you can't afford to lose if you want the groceries and mortgage paid for.

Or maybe, even if finances aren't at stake, someone simply values their competency and contribution in litigation, medicine, education, policy, business negotiation, etc. Maybe they're even just a fledgling freelance interior designer or event planner who takes pride in delivering projects on time.

And of course, that person is the one to help and serve you and your child. My friends are not going to tell you "oops, I know your child's septic condition is deteriorating rapidly, and you might lose your child by sunset, but my Little Timmy has got the sniffles". I'm not going to tell someone I can't defend them in court today for that reason. My family members (no, not Rishi 😂) aren't going to ask for the entire country's Budget announcement date to be delayed on account of Little Timmy's minor cold. The event planner isn't going to ghost you on the day of your DC's birthday party. These are perhaps rather niche examples but at every level of society, this is how the earth keeps spinning, how your child gets their needs met on time on a daily basis.

Of course if your child is very ill or it's a lax period at work, go. But if it's just them catching yet another bug going round, and there's a trusted familiar adult there to give them some Calpol and watch them fall asleep immediately, and you can be there in a few hours, you don't have to rush to their side as if they're literally dying from some terrible disease.

Wow that's a big jump from SAHM to sub optimal social and learning conditions! I was a SAHM and perhaps it would have been better not to squash 6 people into a 3 bed house and to be able to afford the best clothes etc but all my dc's friends loved visiting ( they all went/ go private) and the eldest two are Cambridge graduates so can't have been all that bad!

Manthide · 14/11/2023 08:18

GabriellaMontez · 10/11/2023 12:07

A casual acquaintance was free to care for your vomiting child at no notice...

I have 4dc and when I was a SAHM I was asked on a couple of occasions to pick up unwell children of acquaintances - and more often to pick up a child when they were stuck in a traffic jam/ train cancelled. Of course I generally had a child of the same age, at the same school but I think a lot of people will help others if asked.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/11/2023 23:52

rainbowboymama · 13/11/2023 11:42

@BurnoutGP I did just say in a reply to somebody else, that I do realise that there are actually jobs such as yours/surgeons etc. where I realise this wouldn’t be possible! So I retract my generalisation that no job should come first and apologies for this! However, I do not think this is the case for the OP, it seems like he just didn’t want to upset a client. That’s how I read it anyway.

Because you obviously have a much better understanding of the OP's job than he does himself?

I think the kind of people who insist that they would never let work get in the way of picking up a child with a minor illness under any circumstances have a)probably never done the kind of work which actually matters to anyone, and b) never had any real financial responsibility for supporting their family.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 13/11/2023 23:42

Velvetdragon13 · 13/11/2023 10:40

"Do you really ring up your husband to get his authorisation on every single little parenting decision that you make?"

Is what you're doing something you normally do? No.

Is what you're doing different from normal? Then yes!

It's called keeping your spouse or partner in the loop!

Gosh, I can't imagine having to live like that. Luckily, dh and I always trusted each other to look after dd and we didn't feel the need to get each other's permission with regard to each and every decision. It would have driven me mad if every last detail of everything had to be negotiated and agreed, but fair enough if that's how you choose to run your lives!

Blondeshavemorefun · 13/11/2023 22:35

I didn't say that at all @AliMonkey

It was a simple question as op said usually wife is at home 3/5 on a Friday but that kids went to after school regardless till op can pick up so I'm guessing 5/6pm usually

I missed the last bit so apologies @MrPrickley

AliMonkey · 13/11/2023 21:50

Blondeshavemorefun · 13/11/2023 20:35

If dd was sick thur she wouid be off Friday due to 48hr sickness policy

So who has dd Friday @MrPrickley

Did you take time off your job ?

@Blondeshavemorefun If you bothered reading to the end of the OP's post, you'll see that @MrPrickley took the Friday off, so stop trying to insinuate that he's either lying or not willing to take time off work when necessary and possible.

Blondeshavemorefun · 13/11/2023 20:35

If dd was sick thur she wouid be off Friday due to 48hr sickness policy

So who has dd Friday @MrPrickley

Did you take time off your job ?

Miaminmoo · 13/11/2023 19:31

In the same vein I can’t believe someone so particular would have gone on holiday and left a 5 year old for 2 weeks and not made a contingency plan beforehand - what if husband got ill too?

uckedfaypuay · 13/11/2023 19:21

rainbowboymama · 13/11/2023 12:19

@uckedfaypuay agreed, thank you for opening my eyes. I am just an (un)fulfilled SAHM with no other life, so thank you for educating me and seeing this from another viewpoint. I come from sub-standard social and learning conditions, so of course, now so do my children. So thank you again, for opening my eyes to how the other half live and bring up their children. That’s also not sarcasm, I know things can be interpreted incorrectly when just reading a post/response!

I know you probably think I'm being passive aggressive by apologising for anything that came across wrongly, but genuinely, even if my tone was a bit patronising, I didn't mean for the content to be interpreted that way.

I genuinely think it's great if someone is fulfilled all the way by something, and makes the active choice to prioritise and optimise that unconditionally (whether it's motherhood, career while being child free, or something else). That person will have no regrets on their deathbed.

All I meant was that it's a very individual thing that can't be forced – whether it's being a shepherd in the Hebrides or Prime Minister of the UK, if you're not drawn to devoting your whole life to being that, it's not something that can be forced. Of course, all parents have to prioritise their DC, but prioritising is different from optimising, i.e. ensuring their absolute maximum comfort and welfare 100% of the time. As an analogy, making sure the DC are always in Business or First Class emotionally, when some days Economy will perfectly suffice. Of course the children who always fly Business/First are very lucky and want for nothing in certain ways, which is fantastic.

As for the substandard social and learning conditions, I was absolutely in no way implying your children have that. If you would rush to their side for every little ailment, your children are probably not short of care and attention, which is lovely!

My whole point was that's clearly a dilemma you're privileged not to face – maybe your children thrive in any school environment, or maybe your DH can fund anything at all, or maybe even the lowest paying jobs in the industry you're qualified in pay very well, or maybe you can afford to be a SAHM or work part time providing round the clock quality conditions instead of having to be a dual income family, etc – but others might have to or perhaps choose to.

Grimupnorth442 · 13/11/2023 18:58

Welcome to mumsnet.....the unrealistic world where most people would leave heir marriage if their partner had a friend of the opposite sex ( or same sex if applicable).
You did what you thought was best in the situation your daughter was poorly with a tummy bug not being blue lighted to hospital from a head injury. She was fine, this would not even energy the realms of my clearly insane brain to be jealous or lose my head over. Some people are bloody odd.

MzHz · 13/11/2023 18:49

I agree with those who say that you managed this perfectly

your wife has issues @MrPrickley and if you’re in charge then you get to decide how best to manage the situation

be very clear with her that you made the best decision and the right one for you/your child and her jealousy is misplaced and ridiculous

Whiteday · 13/11/2023 18:26

RafaFan · 13/11/2023 18:14

@Bellsandthistle Quite. My 6 year old started feeling poorly at school once. School couldn't get hold of me because I was in an exam and had my phone turned off. School then called my husband who could NOT immediately leave work as he's a carpenter and was working on the roof of a house at a point where it was open to the elements. We have no family nearby. He called our neighbour who my daughter knows, but not terribly well. She picked our child up and looked after her for a couple of hours until one of us could get there. Everybody was totally fine with the situation. It was a reasonable solution.

Of course it was! No drama!

RafaFan · 13/11/2023 18:14

@Bellsandthistle Quite. My 6 year old started feeling poorly at school once. School couldn't get hold of me because I was in an exam and had my phone turned off. School then called my husband who could NOT immediately leave work as he's a carpenter and was working on the roof of a house at a point where it was open to the elements. We have no family nearby. He called our neighbour who my daughter knows, but not terribly well. She picked our child up and looked after her for a couple of hours until one of us could get there. Everybody was totally fine with the situation. It was a reasonable solution.