Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He said yes then asked for more time

289 replies

excuseme678 · 10/11/2023 10:53

After several years I decided to take the bull by the horns and I asked my partner what he thought of us booking a registry office for a year's time from now. We don't have the money for a big wedding and I'm honestly happy with a registry office.
Age isn't on my side unfortunately.
He said 'yes that could be good'. I asked him several times, are you sure? I don't want to pressure you, are you certain?' He said yes.
I was crying tears of joy, I asked him if I should tell my family and his etc. And he said yes.
We were hugging and I was so happy, I didn't know if this day would ever come.
I said to him one last time, as long as you're certain you're ready, you can have time to think about it if you want.
He said 'actually, can I have time to think about it?'
I said yes that's fine, and asked him to tell me next week.
I'm actually not sure how to feel now, he already knew I wanted to get married and I'm scared he said yes because it's what I wanted to hear. What do people think, I'm just really not sure what he'll say. I feel embarrassed tbh.

OP posts:
waitholdup · 10/11/2023 12:38

Notwhatyouwanttohear · 10/11/2023 11:27

Why on earth would you ask a man to marry you.

If they want to marry you they will ask.

Forcing him into something he is not ready for is a recipe for disaster

Anyone can ask anyone to marry them, we're not in the 1950s anymore.

But when they don't want to get married, and you do, then thats not going to work out

coxesorangepippin · 10/11/2023 12:37

Flogging a dead horse here op

Move on

And him out

VWdieselnightmare · 10/11/2023 12:33

OP, I lived with a nice man for three years in my early 30s. We'd both said, when we first met and again, six months into the relationship when we moved in together, that we wanted children. The first couple of years we focussed on careers and fun, but I knew my biological clock was ticking a bit louder and when he didn't raise the issue of starting a family and marriage I did what you did and proposed that we move to the next stage — making it legal and having children. His response was 'Yes, let's — but I really need to focus on my career for the next 18 months. But after that, yes.'

Soon after that I was offered a very good job opportunity in the US and, knowing that we had 18 months before getting down to marriage and children I took it. Our relationship survived about six months. He didn't seem that bothered about saving it.

Two years after we split up I moved back to London and went to an art exhibition where someone we both knew had some work on display. He was there with his absolutely gorgeous wife (seven years younger than me) and she was holding their baby. Mutual friends had tactfully 'forgotten' to let me know that within three months of splitting up with me he'd met her and they were married and pregnant within the year.

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 10/11/2023 12:33

You asked him several times - perhaps because he didn't give a response that showed real enthusiasum for marrying you. You know him well. Your instinct was probably sound.

He seems happy with the way things are but doesn't want to make this relationship his only option. He is still waiting for the woman of his dreams OP.

Blinkityblonk · 10/11/2023 12:32

I wouldn't want to wait a year in my mid thirties, having been together for a few years. By then you pretty much know which way you want to jump. Wait the week, hear what he has to say, and I'd be very offended if it were anything other than yes and as soon as possible. Another year is time you don't have to be messing around with your biological clock waiting for him given you would need to dump him, move out, date, find someone else and start trying, if you think of it like that it is a waste of a year when he 's faffing, because he can't say the actual truth.

Yalta · 10/11/2023 12:28

Those who said he changed his mind because you asked a few times are being silly. Men aren't some timid forrest creature you can scare off by asking them something several times

Must admit to being very wary of people who ask the same question over and over after I have answered them
I assume my answer wasn’t what they wanted to hear so change it

MumblesParty · 10/11/2023 12:27

Helenahandkart · 10/11/2023 11:23

I waited and waited for a proposal that never came, and watched my childbearing years evaporate. Now I’m 50 and childless.
Tell him straight, you need to move the relationship on and start trying to conceive with a man who is fully committed to you. And if that isn’t him then you need to find someone else.
I started trying to conceive at 36. It was too late for me.

Read this post over and over OP. I’ve been on MN for 20 years and I’ve watched this play out time and again. Men procrastinate, women wait patiently, and then it’s too late. Quite often the man goes off with a younger woman, gets married almost immediately, and goes on to have kids, while the former girlfriend is left wondering what the hell happened.
Don’t let that be you OP.

You need to have a serious and honest talk with him, and don’t take any bullshit.

LifeExperience · 10/11/2023 12:27

I'm sorry, OP, but he doesn't want to marry you.

Ponderingwindow · 10/11/2023 12:26

@MargotBamborough

you wrote this up so well. I agree. If you get to stage 3, it’s because he doesn’t want to marry you.

I’ve been in stage 3. Even convinced the man we should marry. A few years and one very expensive divorce later I luckily got my relationship with DH. DH could not wait to marry me.

CleansUpButWouldPreferNotTo · 10/11/2023 12:25

Better he said now that he wants more time rather than yes and you told everyone and then he got cold feet. What Rory McIlroy did to Caroline Wozniacki was just cruel, after a long public relationship and engagement, he called it off the day after the wedding invites went out!!!!

Sorry for you OP but think it's time to cut your losses.

GentlemansRelish · 10/11/2023 12:24

MargotBamborough · 10/11/2023 11:13

Mumsnet is an odd place.

If @excuseme678 had posted, "I've been with my DP for X years and I was hoping he would have proposed by now especially since I am approaching my mid 30s and I want children, what should I do?" you can guarantee people would say, "Why do you need to wait for a man to propose? It's 2023. Use your words. Tell him you want to get married and book a registry office. It doesn't have to cost thousands, you can do it for £200."

Then someone posts saying she's tried to do exactly that and she's "weird" and "odd" and "putting him on the spot".

Of course you need to put him on the spot. You need to know whether he wants to invest in a long term future and have children with you while your ovaries still work.

YANBU.

I think that's perfectly reasonable.

The only thing I think the OP did at all wrong was asking him several times in the immediate aftermath of her proposal whether he was sure.

If someone had proposed and I'd said yes, I wouldn't the person continually asking for reassurance that I really meant it immediately afterwards, and offering me 'time'. Especially if I were, as the OP's partner clearly is, just marrying because the other person wanted to. That in no way necessarily means he doesn't love her or see a future with her -- I had absolutely no desire to get married, though I loved and was fully committed to me longterm partner. I only got married because he really wanted to. That doesn't make me a bad person.

Wills · 10/11/2023 12:24

My husband would have loved to have just bumbled along, but after 6 years together I told him either do something to keep me or I'm off. It took him a couple of months to get his head around it but he proposed. We married 2 years later and celebrated our 25th wedding anniversary this year.

lovemelongtime · 10/11/2023 12:22

It is totally possible to be committed without being married and to live happily with children while not married. I guess you need to work out whether its the idea of marriage itself that he doesnt want (my husband really wasnt bothered about getting married for years) - but if he shows committment to you in other ways dont make this a deal breaker.

Mari9999 · 10/11/2023 12:21

@excuseme678
A date won't protect you.. The trip to the Registry office or a church is the only absolute certainty.

Maybe, he just isn't ready to be married. Only you can decide what your priorities are. Don't give him a ultimatum date, instead give yourself the date. Know how long you are willing to stay without marriage if that is your line in the sand. Boundaries are put in place for you.

I think sometimes we forget that all of the issues and weariness that couples experience in marriage also happen when living together. The clock does not wait for marriage to start ticking. Sometimes, the attraction and excitement is over before the actual marriage ever takes place.

RantyAnty · 10/11/2023 12:21

You mentioned being a people pleaser. Is he one too towards you? Often times there is a giver and a taker in a relationship like this.

I don't think I'd even kick the can down the road for another year for a registry wedding. Book it first available date.

Those who said he changed his mind because you asked a few times are being silly. Men aren't some timid forrest creature you can scare off by asking them something several times.

What is your living situation? Renting, owning, your place?

I'd be starting to make arrangements to move out after the first of the year. You don't need to be on a permanent audition or probation period for the role of wife with anyone.

Nomnomnom66 · 10/11/2023 12:21

@Helenahandkart I'm sorry that happened to you.

AnnieRegent · 10/11/2023 12:20

MargotBamborough · 10/11/2023 11:28

I agree with much of this.

Having kids was very important to me so if I had found myself in my late 30s, in a relationship with someone who was a bit lukewarm but willing to be talked into having kids with me, I'd probably have done it on the basis that it was most likely my last chance saloon for having kids. I'd rather have taken the risk of ending up a single parent than not having kids at all.

But if I had more time on my side, say if I was still in my early 30s, I'd want someone who was going to say an enthusiastic yes to spending his life with me. And who was willing for that to include marriage if that was important to me.

I never had to figure out how important marriage was to me because it turned out it was more important to my husband.

Good post. Whenever threads like these appear, people tell the poster to dump the boyfriend and find someone else, as if that's easy to do in your mid-30s. Of course it's not impossible, but a lot of people write as if it's a guarantee. Sometimes the options are more likely to be persuade this man to have kids/use a sperm donor/remain childless. Not to mention the pain of breaking up with someone you love.

OP - no advice but am sending sympathy. Many of my friends are/have been in this situation and it sucks!

Xmasbaby11 · 10/11/2023 12:20

I think you've done well OP - you have given him a clear deadline.

He may not give the answer you hope, so be prepared for that and decide if you are going to split in that case. Any answer other that yes, let's book it, I would see as the end. Let's face it, it's either yes or no at this stage. He may be happy bumbling along but you aren't, and 3 years is ample time to feel sure, especially in your thirties.

TheDogsMother · 10/11/2023 12:19

Notwhatyouwanttohear · 10/11/2023 11:27

Why on earth would you ask a man to marry you.

If they want to marry you they will ask.

Forcing him into something he is not ready for is a recipe for disaster

What ?? This isn't the 1950s. Why should a woman wait to be proposed to. Just discuss it together like adults and agree next steps.

acpk55 · 10/11/2023 12:19

I'm actually not sure how to feel now, he already knew I wanted to get married and I'm scared he said yes because it's what I wanted to hear

does he want to get married ( to you ? ), does he actually want kids , are these things that you want

LifeInAHamsterWheel · 10/11/2023 12:16

I honestly believe if men want to marry, they will. My own DH (we're married 20 years now) needed a push but I knew it was on the cards. As soon as I brought it up it was full steam ahead. But now that you've done that, for him to still be hesitant tells me he's not interested. I'm sorry but you need to put yourself first and if marriage is really important to you then leave him Flowers

Onethingatatime23 · 10/11/2023 12:15

You have done the right thing, OP.

He tells you next week and you take it from there.

SwingTheMonkey · 10/11/2023 12:15

tara66 · 10/11/2023 12:12

Just book the date for a marriage at your local Registry Office and tell him. You will then know if he fails to turn up on the day. He has not actually said ''no'' yet.

Oh my god, excellent advice!

Bundle him into the boot of your car on the day, blindfolded, hands tied behind his back and with a sock in his mouth. He’s not said no until he’s managed to scream it through the sock! Good luck op!

fulawitt · 10/11/2023 12:14

Me think there is a book in the Bible with a woman asking a man to marry her. Ruth ? This is old. Absolutely appropriate. If it was good 2000 years ago I don't understand what is shocking about it today.

MargotBamborough · 10/11/2023 12:14

crispcreambun · 10/11/2023 11:55

What’s this sexist assumption that a man will ask before a woman even thinks about it? Are us females too fucking slow and braindead for the quick witted clever men or something? And it’s rather at odds with the (also sexist) idea that all women have been dreaming of their wedding since childhood.

I don't think it is a sexist assumption, it is what I have observed in reality.

Most women who would like to get married are not actually sitting around reading wedding magazines and dropping heavy hints about what kind of diamonds they like, they are getting on with their lives. Unless they are already over a certain age and want marriage and then children, in which case they might be thinking about it a little bit more, particularly in terms of whether marriage and kids with their current partner is on the cards.

Most men who are actually enthusiastic about getting married will ask the woman before she gets to the point where she feels she needs to bring the subject up. And in most cases they will have discussed it together anyway so only the timing of the proposal comes as a surprise.

I think the way I see it is this. For all women who want to get married, the time in their relationship before they get engaged is at one of three stages.

Stage 1: It's still early on in the relationship, even if the woman is willing to propose to the man she is unlikely to do so because it's still pretty new and she knows most people would think of her as crazy for proposing at that stage.

Stage 2: They've been together for a while, it would be considered a perfectly normal time to get engaged, but equally, they haven't been together for so long that not being engaged yet is weird.

Stage 3: They've been together for ages and she would like them to be engaged already but they're not.

In my experience if a man is enthusiastic about getting married then either he will ask the question or they will just naturally discuss getting married and decide to do it in either Stage 1 or Stage 2, and Stage 3 will never happen.

Stage 3 is where men who don't really want to get married hang out.