Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

He said yes then asked for more time

289 replies

excuseme678 · 10/11/2023 10:53

After several years I decided to take the bull by the horns and I asked my partner what he thought of us booking a registry office for a year's time from now. We don't have the money for a big wedding and I'm honestly happy with a registry office.
Age isn't on my side unfortunately.
He said 'yes that could be good'. I asked him several times, are you sure? I don't want to pressure you, are you certain?' He said yes.
I was crying tears of joy, I asked him if I should tell my family and his etc. And he said yes.
We were hugging and I was so happy, I didn't know if this day would ever come.
I said to him one last time, as long as you're certain you're ready, you can have time to think about it if you want.
He said 'actually, can I have time to think about it?'
I said yes that's fine, and asked him to tell me next week.
I'm actually not sure how to feel now, he already knew I wanted to get married and I'm scared he said yes because it's what I wanted to hear. What do people think, I'm just really not sure what he'll say. I feel embarrassed tbh.

OP posts:
JollyJunee · 10/11/2023 13:13

OP, you’ve been together for 3 years. Live together. You want children. If he isn’t sure then move on. However, it’s perfectly fine to say I want to get married, tell me now whether you’re in or out? If he doesn’t know/needs more time/thinks it’s too soon just move on. It’s not being pushy, or forcing him to marry out. It’s forcing him to make a decision. A decision that you need the answer to.

Good luck.

JobMatch3000 · 10/11/2023 13:12

Surely he's agreed to marry you. He can't back down on that. When you chat next week it's just to confirm the venue, day of the week and time. Sit down together with your laptop and credit card and get it booked!

Frenchtoastandoj · 10/11/2023 13:11

It’s not really about marriage , he isn’t committed to you . He isn’t willing to tie himself to you . It’s not that unusual , lots of men do this and lots of women are in the same position as you .

By all means wait the week , but be aware that you may be about to waste another year.

I’ve just seen a friends son do this to a gorgeous young lady . I think she deserves better - as do you .

Goodluckanddontfitup · 10/11/2023 13:10

I really think a deeper conversation is needed here. A yes or no to marriage doesn’t answer the questions about what the future looks like. Plenty of people never marry for their own reasons but have a fully committed relationships and raise children together, marriage isn’t for everyone and it doesn’t mean that a family isn’t possible. Equally, marriage doesn’t necessarily mean children will follow, some may want to marry but not have kids. These are the conversations that need to take place as sensitive and awkward as they may feel. After 3 years together you should be able to speak about this and really need to do so rather than just staking your future on assumptions you make about what the answer to this one question means.

plantingandpotting · 10/11/2023 13:07

There'll be someone out there for you who doesn't need to take a second to think about it.

Please don't have children with someone who is clearly a total commitmentphobe.

'yeah could be good' is the most limp lukewarm response to what was essentially an earnest marriage proposal.

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 10/11/2023 13:07

I'm all for thinking over important life decisions and not leaping into things carelessly only to regret them later...

However, why would one week more make a difference to him?

This isn't sudden and out of the blue and being asked by a stranger. He has had plenty of time to consider whether he does or does not want marriage to you (or at all).

minipie · 10/11/2023 13:06

Do you even know he wants children (and soon)?

Because I can see him being flaky about that too and that’s much more time critical.

Eggandcresssandwich · 10/11/2023 13:03

OP unfortunately he doesn’t want to marry you but isn’t brave enough to say that outright. Maybe he is not ‘into’ the idea of marriage or maybe he’s not sure enough about the relationship yet, hard to tell without knowing more about what conversations you’ve both had about it in the past. But it doesn’t really matter the reason, if you want to get married he’s not the one, you wouldn’t want to marry someone who needed a week to decide, you want to marry someone who cannot wait to be your husband.

porridgeisbae · 10/11/2023 13:03

If he says no, I think you should dump him. You probably should dump him anyway and move on to someone who really wants to marry you.

JFDIYOLO · 10/11/2023 13:00

Do you have a fertility thief here, OP? A man who'll string you along with the marriage mirage and the maybe baby until it really is too late for you?

And don't have a baby with a man who won't marry you.

Mrsttcno1 · 10/11/2023 13:00

OP haven’t you just posted about this yesterday/day before, under a different username?

If he’s not sure and needs a week to think, why would you want to marry him? Marriage should be because both of you really want it, and are ready, not because you want it and he agrees to try and placate you temporarily. With regards to your age and fertility, I’m sure it was your post the other day, and as you were told on there you cannot force or coerce him into having a child. If a child is important/a deal breaker to you, and you feel time isn’t on your side, then the answer is for you to leave and find someone else, not for you to push him into a wedding in the hope that afterwards you can push him into a baby.

Nonplusultra · 10/11/2023 13:00

Well done for asking @excuseme678

I have to say that when my dh proposed, it came out of the blue for me, and I said yes because I couldn’t bear to say no to him. I really did need to take time to think about it.

I didn’t want to ruin his big moment, and I thought I could think it through later, and if it was going to be a no, I’d let him down gently. It wasn’t easy to think surrounded by well wishers and wedding planners.

It wasn’t a no, I loved the bones of him. We’re happily married a long time now. But it took me a while to get used to the idea. I actually think it’s an eminently sensible thing to take a few days and consider the future.

And I’d strongly urge you to do the same. If he’s not saying yes now, what are you going to do? And are you sure that you want to marry him. Use these few days to get your head straight too.

It’s a huge decision- throw kids in the mix, and getting married is one of the biggest financial decisions of your life. One that has the potential to plunge you into poverty. It’s not something to take lightly and we really shouldn’t pretend that giddy romanticism has any place in the decision making.

I wouldn’t assume the worst just yet. But I would hold firmly to the deadline you’ve set - don’t give away your power waiting for him to come back, or make a grand gesture or whatever. “So, it’s been a week…?” is a good opener.

I hope you get the answer (and the future) that you deserve.

ElleCapitaine · 10/11/2023 12:57

Notwhatyouwanttohear · 10/11/2023 11:27

Why on earth would you ask a man to marry you.

If they want to marry you they will ask.

Forcing him into something he is not ready for is a recipe for disaster

You’d ask a man to marry you because you want to get married and life is too short so sit about like a drip waiting for laid back Bob to get his act together. Also, if he says no, it means you don’t have to waste any more time or money on him.

Shade17 · 10/11/2023 12:55

He’s just not that into you. If he wanted to marry you he’d jump at the chance.

AnneLovesGilbert · 10/11/2023 12:54

Mylovelygreendress · 10/11/2023 12:02

Years ago one of my friends had been with a guy for several years and was desperate to get married and have children but he kept saying he wasn’t ready .
When she hit 32 and he was 34 she tried giving him an ultimatum. He then agreed to get engaged the following year . It didn’t happen . At age 35 he still wasn’t ready so she walked away absolutely broken hearted .
Within 18months he was married to someone else ( younger) and expecting a baby . My friend never did get married or have children .

It’s a common tale. I’m so sorry for your friend.

AFieldGuideToTrees · 10/11/2023 12:53

excuseme678 · 10/11/2023 11:46

I can see that he loves and is attached to me, he says he misses me etc. And I know breaking up would really hurt him. I guess I am a people pleaser and always want to put him first.

Actions are what you want, not words.

My ex husband told me he loved me every day. I don't actually now believe he ever did.

So he might be saying all sorts of things, what's he actually doing that shows he loves you and wants to have a long, fulfilling life with you?

Obimumkinobi · 10/11/2023 12:53

A proposal/decision to get married doesn't have to be OTT romantic or a big gesture but it does need to be sincere and "right" for both people. Without overthinking it or trying to please anyone else but yourself, does this situation feel right for you?

If the story of your "engagement" was retold in speech at your wedding? Would your friends and family think it was sweet or have a giggle with you, or would they be concerned for your future happiness?

Solongtoshort · 10/11/2023 12:53

There are three outcomes to this, yes,no and my way.

I think you need to think about what you’re going to say in a weeks time, you have gathered everyone’s opinion and he has said give me a week and you feel hurt.

In one weeks time if he says, ok let’s book for a years time, you are going to have to spend a year wondering and a lifetime knowing he had to think about if he wants to settle for you (because that’s what it sounds like).

If he says no don’t do it, your going to have to leave him. There’s no shame in being heartbroken even if you have finished the relationship.

The only thing that would swing this for me would be if within a week he proposed to you and said why wait l have booked it for us, l just wanted to be the one proposing which let’s face it could be the reason there’s a 33% of this.

Bite the bullet tonight and say look l’m not waiting a week, save yourself the anguish of the next week.

Good luck

Pipsquiggle · 10/11/2023 12:51

Have you had the children chat yet?
Does he know that fertility drops off a cliff for women in their mid 30s?

The only reason I say that is that my DH didn't realise.
We'd been together for 5 years. I was 32 and said if he didn't want DC then we need to split up. He genuinely didn't realise about fertility in women - I showed him graphs etc. He proposed to me 2 weeks later.
Got married the next year, had first DC 18 months later.

TBH, having DC was more important to me than getting married but I knew he would want to be married first.

You need to be crystal clear about what you want.

Pjmasksonrepeat · 10/11/2023 12:48

It's hard op. Give him that week but also take that time yourself to try and imagine different scenarios and what you would do if he doesnt want to marry.

My sister proposed to her partner after years being togther and he just laughed and said marriage wasn't important. It hurt her but she wanted to stay with him and did. He didn't really want marriage or kids after always saying maybe. Now in her 50s she regrets missing out on kids.

Another couple I know were togther for years and she gave him an ultimatum so he proposed. They divorced a year later.

Other couples I know never got married but have kids and are totally committed to each other.

Every couple is so different but try to evaluate your relationship. Make sure you want the same things in life whilst it's not too late. Good luck as I know decisions like this can be so hard.

samestyle · 10/11/2023 12:47

He doesn't want to but doesn't want to say no, why would you want to if he isn't gushing over the idea. Several years is plenty long enough to know than to fob you off another week, don't keep waiting if he still doesn't know after a week.

Rara12 · 10/11/2023 12:47

My experience reflects many others' - 10 years with someone who was constantly finding reasons as to why we couldn't get married, he did finally propose (after about 8 years) and I had to postpone the "wedding" twice (including cancelling venues, bought a dress etc, very embarassing and painful)... Eventually things happened and I left him. I have no doubt he loved me and never meant to hurt me, but for his own issues/reasons he didn't genuinely truly want marriage or children with me. I am so glad that we didn't have children together.

Single for 2 years after, at 34 started thinking about sperm donors/egg freezing. Just before 35 met the One, you just absolutely truly know. Engaged almost a year to the day of meeting each other, he can't wait to marry me (and never wanted to be married before). Oh and we're about to have a baby in a few weeks.

It's your life story, you're writing it. Just chimed in to add to all the posters saying he doesn't truly want to marry you. That's not a reflection of you, it's just who he is. Now is a good time to start thinking about breaking up and getting ready for the future you want.

All the best!

mrsmartins85 · 10/11/2023 12:44

Personally I don’t really understand the grand proposal thing no matter which partner proposes. Marriage and kids is something I think a couple should have discussed at length from the beginning, particularly if they are of a certain age when they meet. If it isn’t a natural evolution of the relationship (unless they have agreed it’s just not for them) and is something that makes the person asking nervous because they might say no, that should be a major red flag.

Women often feel if they’ve invested time and all that goes with it into a relationship that they can’t risk giving it up (like throwing good money after bad!). I’ve been there. Luckily I was early 30s but I wasted a whopping 10 years.

The way I got out was allowing myself to really imagine how devastated I’d feel losing the future I imagined. The resentment and anger actually helped a ton to feel the loss of the relationship less intensely. I look back with relief.

crochetmonkey74 · 10/11/2023 12:44

Ive been here Op and wasted 7 years, He doesn't want to- get out while you can still have kids with someone else

Rewis · 10/11/2023 12:40

Did you previously have a discussion about marriage and kids and the timeliness? If the timeline has gone without any discussion then he's not wanting marriage and kids with you.

If you've never actually talked about it. The time is now. You just need to decide if you're ready to walk away if your desires don't match

Swipe left for the next trending thread