Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not seeing the positives in the changes to the area I’m from

31 replies

Cricklely · 10/11/2023 10:34

So,
I grew up just out of the central area of a city. It was a nice area, big park, small touristy area, then houses. There was some social housing, busy high street with useful shops etc. Good schools.
We moved when I was about 17, now 44.
DH and I moved back to the city last year having lived abroad. By chance we became friends with someone who lives in the area I grew up. Initially I thought they didn’t seem the type to live there, they are creatives but making good money.
We went over for lunch not long ago and after DH and I strolled around the area. It’s changed so much.
The high street is now filled with overly priced independent shops and coffee shops. There are only a handful of chain stores (M&S, Co-op, Boots, Sainsbury’s local and Tesco express). Everything else is independent and a Quick Look in a few overpriced, there are cocktail bars where pubs used to be etc.
The main through road now has a bus lane and cycle lanes which has made traffic awful quite frankly.
There must have been some investment into the high street as it’s all nicely painted and hanging baskets of flowers but it’s not useful. I couldn’t afford to shop there with any frequency.
The schools seem to have gone progressive, no uniform, teachers first names, child led etc. not a traditional education by any means.
House prices have shot up faster than most other parts of the city etc.
I got chatting to some old friends, apparently it now attracts those on 6+ figure incomes, especially the “Champagne Socialist”.
I had a look and the schools have very few pupils qualifying for free schools meals now (less than 10% closer to 5%), so what’s happened to the social housing?
They had to leave as they weren’t just priced out of buying a house/renting one. But with the closer big supermarket being an M&S, terrible traffic thanks to bus and cycle lanes and lots of other amenities gone (banks, clothes shops etc.) it no longer fit their lifestyle.
Our friends who now live there are the definition of champagne socialist, make ridiculous amounts each year, go on several expensive holidays and everything else but very left wing. They think it’s a positive, but of course they do, it now suits their life?!
AIBU to think these are necessarily positive changes?

OP posts:
Greatbigfluffytrousers · 10/11/2023 13:49

I know what you mean. I remember being in a shop many years ago and a woman was complaining to the shop keeper thst the area was going to the dogs because the “useful” shops were closing and coffee shops taking their place. I think the alternative is the useful shops close and nothing takes their place though.

BitOutOfPractice · 10/11/2023 13:47

Lefties are allowed holiday as well you know 🙄

if you loved the town before and it was so in keeping with you and your lifestyle, why did you move away?

no area stays the same. Ever. You sound very bitter op

MotherWol · 10/11/2023 13:41

It might not seem like a positive change to you, but clearly it's popular with the people who live there. Places change, surely you weren't expecting it to have the same shops as 30 years ago? A high street with thriving independent shops, bus and bike lanes and nice cafes sounds lovely to me, but everyone's different.

Fieldofbrokenpromises · 10/11/2023 13:39

YABU

Wotsitfappe · 10/11/2023 13:28

Yeah gentrification has lots of problems. This can't be a new phoneom to you though?

I think while people doing well are partly responsible (and I wish I was doing that well!) they will have been priced out if other areas. So I think really it's our economic and social system which is a problem and you should be looking to blame, if you are blaming. Rather than being bitter at your friends. And it does sound a bit like you are, with your use of phrase champagne socialist.

What are you looking for them to do or change to make them proper socialists? What do you think that looks like? I genuinely wonder as I feel we are all lacking power to change our political system.

divinededacende · 10/11/2023 13:13

I don't think the changes themselves are inherently positive or negative. It sounds like texbook gentrification. Areas tend to mold into the characteristics of the people living there so the changes obviously suit the general demographic of the area.

I get it though, it's never nice to see an area you have a connection with change beyond recognition. Gentrification doesn't suit everyone and people end up being priced out of areas they have deep roots in. It's happening in so many parts of Glasgow and people on the lower end of working class are being pushed further and further away from the city. I'm lucky that my area is close to the city centre and has great transport links everywhere. The fact it's on the main route towards Ibrox Stadium makes it pretty gentrification proof. I shat myself when an artisan coffee shop opened up around the corner 5 years ago but it never went beyond that 🤣.

I have to say, I do love to see areas full of independent shops, cafes and restaurants. I just can't afford to live in them.