Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not seeing the positives in the changes to the area I’m from

31 replies

Cricklely · 10/11/2023 10:34

So,
I grew up just out of the central area of a city. It was a nice area, big park, small touristy area, then houses. There was some social housing, busy high street with useful shops etc. Good schools.
We moved when I was about 17, now 44.
DH and I moved back to the city last year having lived abroad. By chance we became friends with someone who lives in the area I grew up. Initially I thought they didn’t seem the type to live there, they are creatives but making good money.
We went over for lunch not long ago and after DH and I strolled around the area. It’s changed so much.
The high street is now filled with overly priced independent shops and coffee shops. There are only a handful of chain stores (M&S, Co-op, Boots, Sainsbury’s local and Tesco express). Everything else is independent and a Quick Look in a few overpriced, there are cocktail bars where pubs used to be etc.
The main through road now has a bus lane and cycle lanes which has made traffic awful quite frankly.
There must have been some investment into the high street as it’s all nicely painted and hanging baskets of flowers but it’s not useful. I couldn’t afford to shop there with any frequency.
The schools seem to have gone progressive, no uniform, teachers first names, child led etc. not a traditional education by any means.
House prices have shot up faster than most other parts of the city etc.
I got chatting to some old friends, apparently it now attracts those on 6+ figure incomes, especially the “Champagne Socialist”.
I had a look and the schools have very few pupils qualifying for free schools meals now (less than 10% closer to 5%), so what’s happened to the social housing?
They had to leave as they weren’t just priced out of buying a house/renting one. But with the closer big supermarket being an M&S, terrible traffic thanks to bus and cycle lanes and lots of other amenities gone (banks, clothes shops etc.) it no longer fit their lifestyle.
Our friends who now live there are the definition of champagne socialist, make ridiculous amounts each year, go on several expensive holidays and everything else but very left wing. They think it’s a positive, but of course they do, it now suits their life?!
AIBU to think these are necessarily positive changes?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EmmaEmerald · 10/11/2023 16:38

I get it OP

But banks are closing everywhere

I'm back in the place I grew up and the nightmare of cycle lanes hasn't arrived yet but it's creeping up, we're just outside it

The only supermarket being M&S though, yikes.

Nothing against independent shops though.

Schools, I don't know about. Generally I'm pleased the area doesn't feel like a PC nightmare...yet.

I got annoyed with a former contact who questioned my move saying "will you be okay? It's not very diverse". I think she means skin colour....I'm not white,
I grew up here and I'm happy with the diversity but she's only looking at it one way.

I did point this out to her and she went quiet.

the social housing has vanished from my previous area of London, they all got pushed out. Awful. We were on TV doing local demos in fact, but no luck.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 10/11/2023 16:28

The fact it's on the main route towards Ibrox Stadium makes it pretty gentrification proof.

HA!

I remember when I moved from Whitechapel to Walthamstow 25 years ago, I thought "Well it's a bit shabby and far out of town, but at least prices will never go nuts here. Limiting factors."

Nowhere is gentrification proof.

Crikeyalmighty · 10/11/2023 16:25

@LimeCheesecake very well put. I gave some friends who live in a very working class town in Lancashire. They like a nice wine bar and tapas as much as the rest of us liberal metropolitan elite. Fashions in retail and hospitality have changed.

Wotsitfappe · 10/11/2023 16:23

Interesting the op hasn't been back

LimeCheesecake · 10/11/2023 16:12

OP - the alternative to the small expensive independent shops (plus M&S food) isn’t the high street of your youth, it’s boarded up shops, charity shops, hairdressers and if you are lucky a pound shop, unlucky, a few betting shops. The high street in small areas of cities is dying unless it can find a way to cater to wealthy locals. The costs of running a physical shop are too high in comparison to a website and delivery or big supermarkets. Your friends are right, it is nice they have shops that are doing well. The alternative is grim.

pubs are shutting nationally. In nice areas with people who like to go out, some are able to reinvent themselves into cocktail bars or mid-price restaurants. But going down the pub has gone out of fashion. Not just in middle class areas.

And finally if you are in your 40s and moved away in your teens, the social housing would already have started to move to privately owned - perhaps you were too young to realise. It could be the council has kept ownership, but in a city, those social housing renters are more likely to use the bus and cycle lanes and very much appreciate the traffic calming. And like most people on a budget now, buy most of their items online or from larger and cheaper supermarkets further out of town.

dumpkin · 10/11/2023 16:06

I hate the term champagne socialist. The idea that you can’t be truly left leaning and have a high income is ridiculous. Not everyone with a high income is interested in a small government society with a “pull yourself up by your bootstraps” attitude.

Champagne socialism doesn’t mean the above though does it?

One of my relatives is a classic champagne socialist. Works in an investment bank, obviously not on paye (less tax) & is a landlord of a fair few properties. Paid 1.5m to live in tiny catchment of excellent state school but super judgey of private schools (he went to one). Also loves a bit of coke, he’s such a cliche it’s unreal.

CuriousGeorge80 · 10/11/2023 15:45

I suspect most people find the changes to their childhood life hard to accept - so you are blinkered, and I understand that.

But you should also consider why you spending time with people you clearly don’t like.

And it’s perfectly possible to earn well and be left leaning without being a twat, by the way.

CuriousGeorge80 · 10/11/2023 15:45

I suspect most people find the changes to their childhood life hard to accept - so you are blinkered, and I understand that.

But you should also consider why you spending time with people you clearly don’t like.

And it’s perfectly possible to earn well and be left leaning without being a twat, by the way.

HerculesMulligan · 10/11/2023 15:34

I think Roy Keane would tell you that they eat prawn sandwiches, wouldn't he?

Araminta1003 · 10/11/2023 15:30

“I don't want to be a liberal metropolitan elite, though - I don't like the food. I was HAPPY as a champagne socialist!”

Does a champagne socialist eat? If so, what?!

Araminta1003 · 10/11/2023 15:28

I think you need to urgently find out if the buses are aiming for zero emissions! Like in many European cities and London.

“In central London, all double-deck buses will be hybrid by 2019 and all single-deck buses will emit zero exhaust emissions by 2020. By 2037 at the latest, all 9,200 buses across London will be zero emission.”

APocketOfGooseFood · 10/11/2023 15:09

High streets are dying because shopping habits have shifted to primarily online, and so many chain retailers have gone out of business. The alternative to the sort of shops you seem to dislike is streets lined with empty retail units, which then become wastelands which attract antisocial behaviour, and investment in town centres ends completely. The regeneration of our high streets must happen through diversification and fundamental changes to what they offer, or they will die completely. You have to give people a reason still to visit high streets - leisure and mixed use, bringing empty upper floors back into use as homes so that there are people coming and going in the day and in the evening, are tried and tested measures to regenerate town centres. Providing sustainable transport options through making buses and bikes easier and quicker than private cars increases the success of high streets, rather than diminishing it.

You are feeling nostalgic for your childhood, and probably have a rose tinted view of how things were then, when you were happy in that place. But times change and the building blocks of sustainable places are no longer the things which worked when you were young.

Araminta1003 · 10/11/2023 15:06

“Our friends who now live there are the definition of champagne socialist, make ridiculous amounts each year, go on several expensive holidays and everything else but very left wing”

Presumably they have to hand over almost half the amount they earn in tax?
People cycling and paying tax and going on camping holidays and the odd holiday to Reims in their electric vehicle/on the train are not the problem! People like that are the norm in Scandinavian countries, hence why their societies function better. Kids there don’t wear uniform either. Dressing kids up like mini City workers when many adults don’t even do it is old fashioned. If the schools can be run and be successful like that, lucky them! Wish our local schools could get away with that.

And what is wrong with local small businesses thriving?

Champagne is a form of local craft specific to an area of France. What is the problem?

Coffeerum · 10/11/2023 15:04

I hate the term champagne socialist. The idea that you can’t be truly left leaning and have a high income is ridiculous. Not everyone with a high income is interested in a small government society with a “pull yourself up by your bootstraps” attitude.

PonyPatter44 · 10/11/2023 14:59

I don't want to be a liberal metropolitan elite, though - I don't like the food. I was HAPPY as a champagne socialist!

BitOutOfPractice · 10/11/2023 14:51

The liberal metropolitan elite wokerati you mean!

HerculesMulligan · 10/11/2023 14:39

Champagne socialists are very 1990s, OP. We're the liberal metropolitan elite now.

Crikeyalmighty · 10/11/2023 14:20

Sounds good to me. !! What's the issue? I'm left of centre and like nice areas, holidays and wine. Just means I would like plenty of others to like and afford them too

BitOutOfPractice · 10/11/2023 14:20

PonyPatter44 · 10/11/2023 13:50

I am a socialist and I LOVE champagne. Misses point of thread

Champagne for everyone @PonyPatter44 I’m sure Marx said that! 😂

I think the op thinks only people living in penuary are allowed to want a better quality of life for everyone 🤷‍♀️

meeercat7 · 10/11/2023 14:08

It sounds nice. Where is it?

dumpkin · 10/11/2023 13:56

It’s just gentrification, pros & cons. Can certainly change the feel of an area.

user1471447924 · 10/11/2023 13:54

You sound a bit jealous you can’t afford to live there.

CompaniesHouse · 10/11/2023 13:52

Your friends don’t sound like socialists?! I think you just mean they are well off and also liberal. No problem with that is there?

also, not sure what your problem is with schools being progressive.

maybe just don’t visit there again, I don’t think it’s good for your mental health.

ScholesPanda · 10/11/2023 13:50

Why do so many people on Mumsnet spend time with 'friends' they clearly dislike?

PonyPatter44 · 10/11/2023 13:50

I am a socialist and I LOVE champagne. Misses point of thread

Swipe left for the next trending thread