Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think no good deed goes unpunished

271 replies

caffelattetogo · 09/11/2023 23:58

Please tell me if IABU...

I was asked to run a fundraiser for a group my DC attends. It's a class to teach something I do professionally, and I have done for many years. All good, until it came to setting the ticket price - the treasurer looked on my website and saw how much I usually charge for a session. But this is in a village hall, not the venues I'd usually use, which cost much more to hire. I'd thought we could charge less than I usually do, as the experience won't be the same.
But maybe I was wrong: Tickets went on sale and have sold out.
I said I'd buy the materials and invoice them. No need, says the treasurer, and asks me to send her a list.
The session is on Saturday and the ingredients have arrived - with loads missing and much cheaper quality than I'd usually use. There's no way the food we are making will look or taste the same. I rang tonight and she isn't budging - says my list was too expensive and would eat up their profits. In total, the ingredients I wanted were about 25% of the ticket price. I'm giving my time and equipment for free.
Any other circumstances and I'd walk away, but I feel bad for the people who have bought tickets.
What should I do?

OP posts:
PuttingDownRoots · 11/11/2023 10:29

If they couldn't afford your ingredients, they would have been better asking what you could do within their budget.

Margarine vs butter is one thing...

Squirty cream is definitely not a substitute for clotted cream.

skyeisthelimit · 11/11/2023 10:27

Well Done on standing your ground OP. This is your business and your name on the line, and if you serve up something inferior then people will think that is what you do all the time.

the substitutes are ridiculous, ie squirty cream is in no way a replacement for clotted cream.

Next time, for anything like this, I think that you will need to stand your ground and insist that you buy your own ingredients and bill them, (but give them an idea of the price first).

melj1213 · 11/11/2023 10:24

YANBU and well done for standing your ground, OP

"All they could afford" - then what have they done with all the money people have paid?

They were getting your full session fee from the ticket price (which I assume you usually set to a point which covers your overheads, your time and give you some profit?) without having to pay any overheads beyond ingredients as you were giving your time for free, they own the hall and already pay the bills for heat/light/water etc so surely they could still make a massive profit for the charity whilst providing all of the ingredients you require to do the job properly. It's better to spend 40% of the ticket cost on overheads and 60% profit for the charity (even if they'd have preferred to have 75% profit) than get 0 profit from cancelling the event due to their stubbornness over their budget and end up costing money because they now have to spend time refunding people and are left with ingredients they cannot use.

I would be sure to get out ahead of the news though - post something on social media to make it clear that you wanted to do the session but the committee made it impossible for you to do so.

"It is with great disappointment that I have to announce that my baking class for Skinflint Charity that was due to take place this evening has had to be cancelled.

I was very much looking forward to being able to share the Baked Blueberry Pavlova recipe with you tonight but Skinflint Charity, who insisted on providing the ingredients despite me offering to source them from my usual suppliers to ensure everything was correct, have not provided me with the ingredients I require or have substituted them with inappropriate alternatives that would change the quality and taste of the recipe. After repeated discussions asking them to rectify this situation so that I could ensure you all receive the usual standard of class that I provide they have refused, citing budget constraints.

Had I been made aware of a specific budget I would have adapted my class offering appropriately but at this late stage it is too late to do this and I was left with two options: take the class knowing that we would not be able to produce anything close to the usual standard I expect of my classes or cancel to ensure that people do not waste their time and my professional reputation is not damaged due to the fact you would not be getting the service you paid for despite paying the same ticket price I usually charge

Therefore I made the difficult decision to withdraw from the class as I could not in good conscience allow it to go ahead knowing that the ingredients provided would result in a dish that was nowhere near the standard I would expect to present. I would like to offer my apologies to those who were looking forward to attending this evening as I was, but I am sure you can understand why I have had to take the action I have done and hope to see you in a future class where you will get the service you have paid for.

^Anyone requiring a refund for their ticket should contact Skinflint Charity directly^

Best wishes, OP"

CaveMum · 11/11/2023 10:23

Don’t name names in your statement, rise above it and remain professional. Just refer to being asked to make compromises that you were not prepared to make and the effect it could have on your reputation.

If you make it personal so will they. Remember they go low, you go high.

IncompleteSenten · 11/11/2023 10:20

You should tell them you have kept all communication and if they attempt to blame you in any way you will ensure people know the truth.

Because I would bet all my money and my first born son that they're going to try to claim you've let them down for no reason or you've run off with the money or something.

FlamingoQueen · 11/11/2023 10:19

You have done the right thing. It is the reputation of your business that could take a hit if you’re not careful.
I’ve known a couple of village hall committee members and the power goes to their heads and they always know best! (Obv, I am sure there are some lovely ones out there!).
You have standards - continue to uphold them!

KombuchaKalling · 11/11/2023 10:19

VWdieselnightmare · 11/11/2023 09:27

OH dear, OP, think you just pissed on your chips. No one likes a quitter. 30, 40, 50 people all now feeling annoyed that their night out has been cancelled.

Imagine what they'll be saying now. 'I hear she was such a diva, impossible to work with. It was all about her and her reputation. It all got a bit ridiculous. She was asking for X and Y and Z, which would have cost us far too much to supply. No one around here cooks with X and Y! She knows we're a voluntary organisation but she couldn't be flexible.'

Oooof.

Edited

Maintaining professional standard is hardly pissing on your chips. They sound like a load of cheeky fuckers. I am amused at their arrogance especially the debate about quantities. Poster does it professionally but what does she know 🤷‍♀️

Borth · 11/11/2023 10:15

I’d pull out. The workshop will not be to your usual standard and will reflect badly on you. The treasurer is being grabby and had entire thing.

Penelopepisspot · 11/11/2023 10:14

caffelattetogo · 10/11/2023 19:39

It's things like cheap catering margarine in place of butter, cans of uht squirty cream instead of clotted cream etc. this will taste very different and the cream won't hold its shape.

I’m going to jump to conclusions and assume it’s a cream tea event where you make your own scones first. In which case, if I was given squirty cream in place of clotted cream, I would burn the village hall to the ground.

(I was once given squirty cream in a cream tea in a very posh tea garden. It was very much NOT ACCEPTABLE)

billy1966 · 11/11/2023 10:14

If you do put up a statement on your website, it's important to be specific about the exact issue.

They supplied inferior ingredients which would have resulted in an inferior experience and end product.

Spell the issue out with your regrets.

zingally · 11/11/2023 10:09

Another vote for pulling out. Or at least threatening to, unless more money is provided.

Speaking as someone who also offers a professional service on a self-employed basis, I rely on world of mouth, and my reputation is everything.
People talk, and if the final product is sub-standard, that reflects on you. Even if it's under the umbrella of the hosting club. You want to win over a heap of potential new clients. Not have a load of people walking away feeling slightly cheated.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 11/11/2023 10:06

LAMPS1 · 11/11/2023 10:01

I’m amazed at that response from the committee. The treasurer clearly holds a lot of power and must have been expecting you to contribute not only your time and expertise but also your own cash for the ingredients. So cheeky.

Damage limitation for you now, using your own sm platforms.

“I am sad to have had to pull out of the fund raiser which I happily agreed to do when asked by …….

I was looking forward to this event but am unable to work with the resources provided and know the outcome would therefore be far from successful for all concerned.
Far better for those who bought tickets to request their refund by contacting …………
Thank you for your understanding and my apologies for the inconvenience. I’m sure you will be as disappointed as I am.

An excellent suggestion ...

Puzzledandpissedoff · 11/11/2023 10:05

I think you've made the only decision you could, OP
As mentioned they'll probably slate you for "letting them down", but that'll pass whereas damage to your reputation from offering a lousy product could be harder to overcome

Snoeberry · 11/11/2023 10:03

Well done for standing your ground op.
Ppl on fundraising committees can be awkward sods!

LAMPS1 · 11/11/2023 10:01

I’m amazed at that response from the committee. The treasurer clearly holds a lot of power and must have been expecting you to contribute not only your time and expertise but also your own cash for the ingredients. So cheeky.

Damage limitation for you now, using your own sm platforms.

“I am sad to have had to pull out of the fund raiser which I happily agreed to do when asked by …….

I was looking forward to this event but am unable to work with the resources provided and know the outcome would therefore be far from successful for all concerned.
Far better for those who bought tickets to request their refund by contacting …………
Thank you for your understanding and my apologies for the inconvenience. I’m sure you will be as disappointed as I am.

LakeTiticaca · 11/11/2023 10:00

I once offered a colleague a lift home from work, to save her a 45 minute bus journey. We worked in a supermarket. She said she needed to pick up a couple of items first. I said fine, I'll see you outside in 10 minutes.
After 20 minutes still no sign of her so I went back in to see where she was. She was just approaching the checkout with a trolley packed with a weeks worth of shopping. I was furious.
By that time rush hour traffic was starting to build so I was well over an hour late home from work.
Needless to say she was never offered a lift ever again 🤣

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 11/11/2023 09:59

👏👏👏

suitsyoumissus · 11/11/2023 09:59

WishICouldSmoke · 11/11/2023 08:25

You are right though no good deed goes unpunished. I have a friend who is an amazing artist. I used to think she was difficult as when she does charity / community events she is very particular and controlling over the process. It took me a while to realise that it’s her reputation, livelihood but also a commitment to her art. She will do charity stuff but only in her own way. People have to respect that. She once told me that she won’t be anyone’s “craft bitch”! She is not willing to compromise and hence be punished!

I'm an artist too and really identify with this. I turned down two charity workshops for the same reason. They wouldn't let me order the paints, wanted to buy themselves more cheaply. No matter how many times I explained that if I used the wrong paints the participants wouldn't get the expected results, they just weren't having it.

andweallsingalong · 11/11/2023 09:58

I think you misunderstood - I wouldn't expect sorry or reasonable from the organisers and would never agree to work with them again, but would suck it up as a one of for the good press and marketing.

Then make damn sure for any future similar events with other committees that my contract was tighter.

suitsyoumissus · 11/11/2023 09:55

Good call Op. You can be ready to tell anyone who asks why you pulled out.

Irregardless · 11/11/2023 09:53

@Standingupagainsttheplayers What products do you use?

SomethingFun · 11/11/2023 09:47

I might have misunderstood, but they charged what you normally charge but the venue is free to them and of a lower standard than you normally book, you are giving your time and expertise for free and the only thing they were paying for is the ingredients, which they won’t pay for. And that’s not enough profit for their charity? But you are running a successful business for less profit than this because you pay for better venues and yourself!

I am glad you have told them to do one, margarine and squirty cream in post bake off Britain indeed 😁

Agapornis · 11/11/2023 09:42

I'd absolutely make a public social media statement saying either the full truth, or "unfortunately the wrong ingredients arrived and (charity) is unable to provide the correct ones".

SeamsLegit · 11/11/2023 09:40

What did they respond to THAT?!? Go u OP, and definitely take the advice of PPs, by issuing a statement first!

queenrollo · 11/11/2023 09:38

I would absolutely beat them to the punch by issuing a public statement that you have had to pull out.
If you have all your exchanges in writing then I would keep your powder dry on the whys and wherefores, unless they start tarnishing your reputation in which case I would go public.

I no longer sit on committees or give my time to organisations because this kind of behaviour is rife.