Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for not wanting my baby to view my partner’s ex’s Mum as ‘Nanny’?

171 replies

fellinlovewithawar · 09/11/2023 14:09

My partner and I are expecting our first child together at the beginning of next year. He already has two children and maintains a good relationship with his ex, as well as her family. I’ve met the majority of them (always in a setting such as a party, or with the kids about), and they’ve all been incredibly welcoming. With that said, there are times I struggle with the dynamic. This is very much a ‘me’ issue, but sometimes I feel like I don’t really belong in the setup. This is something I’m working through, and I support the co-parenting relationship as much as I can, but I just don’t feel comfortable right now establishing a relationship with the rest of the family.

My partner has expressed that he’d like us to meet up with her family separately eventually (outside of family gatherings) and when we’ve spoken about a wedding in the future, he’s told me he wants them all to be there. He doesn’t have much of a relationship with his own family and views his ex’s Mum as his own parent. She’s always been supportive of him, and I would never want him to lose that, nor the relationship he’s built with the rest of the family. He wasn’t the initiator in the breakdown of his last relationship, and it doesn’t feel fair for him to suffer because of it. However, when it comes to conversations around our son, I’m finding it really hard to accept this. The main sticking point is that I can only see his ex’s Mum as exactly that. He said he wants her to be one of the first people to meet our baby. When I’ve spoken about my own Mum babysitting, he’s suggested that we could always ask her instead. When we’ve spoken about returning to work and I’ve considered spending a couple of days at my parents to WFH, he’s suggested I could go over there as an alternative. He’s also said our son will be calling her ‘Nanny’.

We spoke at length, and I explained why I felt the way I did, and didn’t feel it was fair that he’s made that decision on viewing her as ‘Nanny’ without talking it through with me first. He understood, but I think this all really upset him. I can see his point of view, but something about our son being integrated into his ex’s family just makes me uncomfortable. I’m happy for him to meet her, to go over to play when we bring the other children, but I cant get past the idea of him calling her his ‘Nanny’.

I need to know AITAH for feeling uncomfortable and telling him I don’t want this? I don’t know if I’m not fully understanding his viewpoint and if I should just push through the way I’m feeling.

OP posts:
Lisapop1 · 10/11/2023 12:48

In normal circumstances I'd say that seems weird but it seems like she really means something to him. If you can get over the fact that it's the ex's mum and as long as she is lovely and welcoming to you I'd go with it. I know it's a big ask on your part but just see how it's goes.

AuntieStella · 10/11/2023 11:53

The snag with that view @Jellytot1234 is that he has accepted them as his family. OP cannot reject that for him, and would be very unwise to try.

And that means they are part of the lives of all three of his DC.

Jellytot1234 · 10/11/2023 11:50

I understand why people think this is “nice” but I completely think it’s reasonable to not want her to be so involved so much. It almost feels like you’re being forced to accept your partners ex’s parents as your own family for your child and whilst being kind and civil is a wonderful thing; I would feel like this is a huge overstep and boundary line. Your partners upbringing/ lacking family life of his own is not for you to sacrifice your own family feelings. I wouldn’t want my child to refer to my ex’s parents as “nanny” either. There’s being kind and accepting of others for the sake of the children and then there’s just being weird.

ladycarlotta · 10/11/2023 10:49

I think you need to accept that they are his family. The ex wife thing obviously is quite unusual but you may need to work on putting your issues with that aside, because limiting the relationship your partner has with a supportive mother-type figure is not really going to go your way. Similarly creating that divide between your baby and his siblings will create unnecessary tension and perhaps resentment.
There are a lot of ways to be divorced and his sounds like quite a positive one. I can fully understand your discomfort but I think maybe it's something both you and your partner need to properly communicate over, each respecting how the other feels in order to come to a compromise that will actually work. There's no use in you telling him he's weird and needs to change, and him telling you you're uptight and need to change. It's a huge grey area and you both need to hear one another. If it were me, though, I think I'd far rather this family culture of love and acceptance, than one of animosity. My parents were very uncomfortably divorced and it's still a total pain for me as their child 20+ years on. If the children in this scenario are being spared that, then it's brilliant.

ManchesterLu · 10/11/2023 10:41

Maddy70 · 09/11/2023 14:37

I understand him wanting her ti be called nanny. If his other children call her that you don't want your own child feeling "different"

Yeah I'm inclined to agree with this. There are so many people on here whose own relatives can't be bothered with their kids, so if this lady wants to be 'Nanny', and is already a good nanny to your DP's kids, I'd be inclined to go with it.

littleburn · 10/11/2023 10:28

Your DP sees her as his substitute mum, so I think I'd not be so bothered about your child calling her 'nanny'. What would bother me more is the examples you give of him actively trying to prioritise his 'mum' over your DM, but I'd feel like that regardless of whether she's his 'real mum' or not.

Bigger picture, does his ex have a new partner? If not, is there an element of him being kept in the son-in-law role by her family because that's what everyone's used to and no one else has stepped that role yet? I can imagine that, even with the best intentions, this closeness will lessen over time if/when her daughter has a new partner.

MinnieL · 10/11/2023 10:24

It’s a no from me

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 10/11/2023 10:13

The young children of a friend of a dd, not remotely related to us - always call my dh Grandpa, presumably because they’ve heard it from our own Gdcs.

Dh has never objected in the slightest. He is perfectly happy with it.

Lastnightschips · 10/11/2023 10:11

My ex stepmother is Grandma Diane to my kids, they benefit from having a loving extra ‘grandparent’.

Fifthtimelucky · 10/11/2023 10:00

I understand how you feel about this but the telling thing to me is that your partner sees his ex's mum as his, and doesn't have a good relationship with his own.

My husband's ex wife was in a similar situation. After she and my husband divorced, she stayed in close contact with his mother for 40 years (until the latter died). She called her "Mum" and all her children called her "Granny", although only one of them was my husband's. In turn, my mother in law treated her as her daughter and treated all the children as her grandchildren.

I agree with those who say that the more loving adults there are in a a child's life the better.

I also agree with using a different name for "biological" grandparents. That might happen naturally if the real grandmothers don't want to be known as "Nanny". My children called both of their grandmothers "Granny", but they called my father's wife "Granny Mary" (not her real name).

Miamonthly · 10/11/2023 09:41

PramPusherCentral · 09/11/2023 14:29

The more people there are to love and care for my child, the better.

I would go with the above sentiment.

Babies and motherhood are a LOT of work and here you have a woman who is grandmother to your step children and is willing to treat your child on a par with them.

This is preferable to your child being excluded, not taken on trips or given gifts and so forth, always the odd one out.

If your husband has a pseudo mother-son relationship with this woman filling in for a lack of biological familial support I think you should respect it and crack on.

Otherwise you run the risk of alienating your husband and causing issues where your child is seen as ‘other’.

If you want a clean slate where partners are dissociated from ex’s family then you should have gone for a man without children.

To be blunt you aren’t going to understand any of this truly until you become a parent yourself and have a newborn to look after.

You are really very lucky to have the offer of more support and love for the baby, and harmony and acceptance where there are two family camps.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 10/11/2023 09:30

If you find it uncomfortable your partner should respect your wishes. I’m not sure what to think. I’ve grown up with step grandparents though, they were always called by first names but were treated as grandparents. I’m not going to lie and say relations with both were great because there were some issues which were ironed out when we came along, maybe that’s why they and my DM preferred their first names rather than Nanny eg Ivy.

My step grandmother did paid childcare when we were older too.

McQueensMuse · 10/11/2023 09:25

My exh's Mum is a diamond and I always say that I got custody of her in the divorce.

She is a fantastic nana with my two older DC and I've since had a third child with my new partner and she straight away treated him as her own grandchild.

I love it, So does my partner.
The more people that love your DC the better and it would be horrible for the smallest DC to be left out.

HMW1906 · 10/11/2023 09:20

Chances are if the older siblings are calling her granny around the baby then the baby will likely copy that anyway. That happened with my nephews younger half siblings, they all call my parents nan and grandad just because they initially copied their older brother. My parents didn’t mind so it stuck. My parents used to have the younger siblings round for tea with my nephew (the oldest are mid/late teens now so don’t come often anymore) and they still baby sits the youngest occasionally if ex SIL is struggling for child care.

It does sound like they are basically his family as he doesn’t really have much to do with his own family so I’d probably let it go.

DisquietintheRanks · 10/11/2023 09:12

Do you really want your child to feel like the odd one out when you are with his siblings and their family? The one that doesn't belong? OK then.

NewFriendlyLadybird · 10/11/2023 09:11

I can’t see the name ‘Nanny’ as a sticking point — it’s not actually any more meaningful than aunty or any other child-friendly relational name. And if the other children already call her that, it makes absolute sense. The only thing I would not agree with is her being considered ahead of your own mother, but you can control that.

CoffeeCup14 · 10/11/2023 09:05

I can understand your feelings and I think they are a reasonable way to feel. I think it's worth keeping an open mind about what you choose to do. Also, how you feel now with an unborn baby is not how you will feel with a toddler or a five-year-old or a teenager.

I have two children with my ex. At his house they have two step-siblings and a half-sibling. They also have contact and a relationship with their step-siblings' half siblings (my ex's second wife'ex-husband remarried and had more children...).

The divorce and his remarriage was very difficult for me. But I can see benefits to my children of being integrated into their family at their dad's house, and their step-siblings' family. Blended/mixed families can be difficult and anything which increases cohesion is valuable.

I would hope your partner can understand how you feel and allow you to go at your own pace. You might benefit from exploring what it is about this which worries you to help understand your feelings. But I think it coupd be beneficial to the children to do this, and even if you don't like it, you can get used to it.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 10/11/2023 09:00

I don’t think it’d bother me too much - my own DM would never have been called ‘Nanny’ anyway and love never comes amiss. But once the child was older I’d make sure they knew what is meant by ‘grandmother’ and who really was one of those.

Dontcallmescarface · 10/11/2023 08:48

When I’ve spoken about my own Mum babysitting, he’s suggested that we could always ask her instead. When we’ve spoken about returning to work and I’ve considered spending a couple of days at my parents to WFH, he’s suggested I could go over there as an alternative. He’s also said our son will be calling her ‘Nanny’

This makes me feel a little uneasy. Why is he suggesting you put his ex MiL above your DM when it comes to babysitting "duties"? Yes, ask exMiL if your DM isn't available but to suggest asking the non-bio "nanny" instead makes me question why he wants to lessen your family's involvement in your Dc's life. TBF I could be reading more into it than there is but, as I said, it just doesn't sit right with me.

CurlewKate · 10/11/2023 08:40

A child can't have too many people who love them.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 10/11/2023 08:35

Chlorinara · 09/11/2023 14:50

So your son's half siblings already call her Nanny. I think extending that to include him is nice and a pretty natural thing to do. Would something like Nanny Jane be an acceptable compromise? That would give a bit of flexibility to morph into either Nanny or Jane as he gets older.

I wonder if it might help to unpick the issues a bit. Wanting her to provide weekly childcare for your baby is a completely separate thing to your son seeing her on birthdays and Christmas and calling her by the same name as his half siblings use.

^^
This. Nanny is not the hill to die on here. If your own mum wants to be called Nanny then exMil Nanny becomes Nanny Jane

Even the nicest ex MiL is going to baulk at providing free childcare to a grandchild who is not her own while you WFH in HER house. Bless him. I’m sure he’ll at some ping realise this is barking if you keep laughing at him.

5128gap · 10/11/2023 08:32

Not U to feel a bit disconcerted, because its an unusual situation. But provided you don't think its a way of hanging on to his ex herself, then you'd be U to act on your feelings.
Sounds to me like this woman is a positive presence in his life and could be the same for your child, and its not right for you to stand in the way of that.

NewLevelsOfTiredness · 10/11/2023 08:26

My Stepdaughters' dad and his family have been fantastically accepting of my daughter. Like wise my parents have treated my stepdaughters as family.

I won't say I don't sometimes find it a little odd but there is simply no doubt that both my SDs and my daughter benefit from getting as much family and love as they can. It also makes them feel more like 'full sisters' than 'half sisters.' My wife and I have chatted a lot with her ex about that and we're all on board with it. My little girl adores him but I never feel like my role as dad is threatened at all by it.

So yeah it is weird. But I'm looking at three kids that mean the world to me and seeing without doubt that it's best for them.

AuntieStella · 10/11/2023 08:25

She can have a motherly relationship with him but does that mean automatic rights to your child?

OP isn't talking about her child though.

She's talking about their child, and her/his existing siblings and family relations

gannett · 10/11/2023 08:22

Some horribly small-minded posts on this thread.

Family isn't just about blood and biology. For a lot of people, especially those whose biological family have let them down, they end up with more of a chosen family, and this can come in any form. Friends, friends' families and yes, very often exes' families. This isn't "enmeshment" or "weird" or any of the derogatory terms used on this thread. It's the realisation that good people who genuinely care about you are to be treasured wherever you find them - and that you can find them outside of the traditional blood relative setup.

The more love and care in your child's life the better. It's equally valuable whether it comes from her biological grandmother or from a non-related "nanny" or "auntie". Quibbling over what she's called just strikes me as trying to impose some sort of weird hierarchy on the situation - as if you want to make it clear that she's lesser in status. Don't do that, it's gross behaviour.

Describing her as "partner's ex's mum" may be factual but it's clear you haven't got your head round the idea that she is, to all intents and purposes, an actual maternal figure to him.