Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To preference a school 35 minutes away?

179 replies

Sallyh87 · 09/11/2023 13:20

Going through the process of filling out school selection forms. The best one is a 35 minute walk away and my DDs best friend from nursery is going to select this one. I can’t drive (disability) but DH can. DH can likely drive her 3 - 4 times a week due to WFH.

So my question

  • is a 35 minute walk too much for a four year old
  • would a closer but not as highly rated school be better
  • Is there any kind of older child pushchair I could use???

Granted, I am sure there is a bus service but I find buses so unreliable.

OP posts:
Westfacing · 10/11/2023 08:39

DS2 walked 25 minutes one way at aged 4 - it's perfectly do-able particularly as you say it will likely be only once or twice a week, plus there are buses.

Doone22 · 10/11/2023 08:36

...everybody's parents and grandparents turning in their graves....

I literally can't comprehend the drivel I'm hearing about how far it is and how it's just too much.

I used to walk further in all weather's at that age because we didn't have cars and buses and if the roads were blocked with snow we'd go cross country instead.

And what's wrong with it making them tired? They're supposed to be!

I'm not telling anyone which school to pick but ffs what's wrong with you all that you can't manage a short stroll?

Abbyant · 10/11/2023 08:30

We live literally a 5 minute walk for my daughter primary and I hate walking with if it’s raining and freezing but atleast I’m home within 15 minutes over an hour would definitely be a no for me.

Doone22 · 10/11/2023 08:28

And this is why we're all fat and unfit. My 90yr old gran walked that every day to the shops.
And cycled 12 miles to work in her younger days

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 10/11/2023 08:15

waterrat · 09/11/2023 13:26

I can give you a golden piece of advice op

You have 7 years or more of primary school and you will massively regret a 35 min walk

Living near primary school means new friends are in the nearby streets. It means you and your child are entering a community. It will be useful on days when you are ill and cant walk your child to school...you can ask friends for Favours. You can organise playdates and pick up swaps easily

Your child will find that walk exhausting in their first years there were times in reception and year 1 we struggled with the 10 min walk home

do not do this ! Also if your local schools are popular put your nearest one first or you may end up with a school nobody else wants

I agree with all of this.
My dc are in Y7 and Y10 now, and walking then to school is a thing of the past. I can not tell you the number of times I’ve thanked the world that their primary school was 5 mins walk away - when I’ve been unwell, when they’re a bit run down, when we’re late, when it’s dark and raining, when it’s snowing, when I’ve needed to pick them up early for any reason, for parents evenings, assemblies, school concerts, sports days; and all their friends are local too. Go local, join the community.

PurBal · 10/11/2023 08:12

Our closest school is 49 minutes walk. So I’m probably biased but I think it’s fine. There’s no bus and because of access you can’t park nearby.

fitnessmummy · 10/11/2023 08:08

What is the actual distance?

My school is just over a mile away and we manage

Belltentdreamer · 10/11/2023 08:03

Good idea on the closer school. And get a scooter not a big kid pushchair

wishingiwas20something · 10/11/2023 08:00

We do a 20 min walk to primary school, I found a scooter the fastest mode of transport for my then 5 year old. However, if it rains or snows we bus or uber. I think the school setting is the most important factor for me.

Mamabear48 · 10/11/2023 07:47

In the long run this will not be viable and remember you’ll have to do it for yours. You’ll probably get rejected anyway due to being out of the school zone

margotrose · 10/11/2023 07:47

Those saying it isn't possible have never done it but loads of kids live more than 30 minites away from their school.

I don't think anyone has said it isn't possible, just that it would be time consuming and miserable in the winter months.

Casperroonie · 10/11/2023 07:47

Based on my own experience, 35 min walk is waaay to long for a 4 Yr old.
In future they'll be wanting to go to clubs etc so you'll have to walk her home after a long day in all weathers or you'll always be asking for favours from other parents.

Unless the other school is terrible there's very little good reason to take her to a school much further away.

Bouncyball23 · 10/11/2023 07:41

When my ds was younger he went to a school with the same distance the walk was absolutely fine in summer but once winter hit it was awful, I swapped schools to a local one and it was the best thing I did.

Cat1313 · 10/11/2023 07:39

My son goes to a school about 30 mins bus/walk away without any issue and his baby brother will eventually go there. My husband doesn't drive but takes the bus half way and walks the rest and has been the past 3 years. I only drive on the days I have off.
It was my old school and I walked the entire route which took about 45 minutes.
There are closer schools but it is a far better school with a bigger intake.
Those saying it isn't possible have never done it but loads of kids live more than 30 minites away from their school.

FlamingoQueen · 10/11/2023 07:38

Have you looked around both schools?
My advice would be to view them both - expensive and shiny is not always best.

margotrose · 10/11/2023 07:29

Your cardiovascular health and health and life expectancy won't regret it at all, in fact the opposite this is one of the healthiest habits you could cultivate. Any NT 4 yr old can walk 35 minutes, they will get used to it.

Of course they can walk 35 minutes but are they going to be happily trotting along next to you after a full day of school in the pissing down rain for weeks on end in winter?

Are they going to want to/be able to walk to school quickly enough in the morning? 35 minute at adult pace can easily be over an hour at a 4yo's pace.

You're not going to be power walking the school run accompanied by a four year old!

IngridMcDonald · 10/11/2023 07:20

I think you've already made your decision. The 35 min away school would also mean you would have to get there for sports days and plays and parents evenings which would also prove awkward as that could mean returning to the school in the evening for example.

MMCQ · 10/11/2023 07:20

Thats more than 2 hours out of your day.
yes your child could walk this but you can’t carry them that far when they are sick. And yes it’s too far in the snow and rain. Choose close by. 15 to 20 mins max or get the bus!

pinkstripeycat · 10/11/2023 07:15

It was a half hour walk to school when I was at primary and lots of people living near me still walk 30-40 mins to primary depending on which school they’ve chosen. Most primary schools in our town are on estates and in villages so no direct buses

Sunandsea26 · 10/11/2023 07:09

waterrat · 09/11/2023 13:26

I can give you a golden piece of advice op

You have 7 years or more of primary school and you will massively regret a 35 min walk

Living near primary school means new friends are in the nearby streets. It means you and your child are entering a community. It will be useful on days when you are ill and cant walk your child to school...you can ask friends for Favours. You can organise playdates and pick up swaps easily

Your child will find that walk exhausting in their first years there were times in reception and year 1 we struggled with the 10 min walk home

do not do this ! Also if your local schools are popular put your nearest one first or you may end up with a school nobody else wants

I would agree with this! My eldest started school in September and we live round the corner and the logistics are such a dream compared to having to drive for nursery. A school a nearby walk makes life so much easier.

C14 · 10/11/2023 06:56

I think there’s so much to be said for picking your local school. Ease of school runs, local friends etc. Go and view all the schools, don’t just go based on ofsted or other people’s opinions, go by how you feel about the school when you’re looking round and take your child. Also don’t pick a school based on where your daughter’s current best friend goes. I guarantee even if they go to the same school they will have new best friends within a few weeks, 4 year olds are fickle like that! It’s not worth walking 35 minutes for trust me. It ALWAYS rains during a school run!

eurochick · 10/11/2023 06:45

I enjoy walking but I'd resent the 1hr10 out of my day twice over. It would also be miserable in sleet, wind where you can't keep a hood or umbrella up, etc. Also, in reception they only usually take a book bag. In a few years they might have a big sports bag and an instrument too. Imagine doing the journey with a cello in tow.

For secondary this sort of journey is fine. For primary I would say it is a chore.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 10/11/2023 06:42

I can give you a golden piece of advice op

You have 7 years or more of primary school and you will massively regret a 35 min walk

Your cardiovascular health and health and life expectancy won't regret it at all, in fact the opposite this is one of the healthiest habits you could cultivate. Any NT 4 yr old can walk 35 minutes, they will get used to it.

glasslightly · 10/11/2023 06:25

No I am not cycling, my DC cycles on the pavement. As I flagged, my situation is a bit different, but as OP says they can also use the car for part of the week at least.

I would also add that until recently it would have been pretty common for kids to walk to school and back - this could easily be 30 minutes from one end of a village to another.

Ontheperiphery79 · 09/11/2023 22:33

Ours is a 30ish min walk and my 5 year old twins have been fine. Scooters have made it easier.