Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To deliver a lesson in table manners?

310 replies

Mannersdomatter · 09/11/2023 07:18

My partners child is 12 and just started high school (year 7).

I realised last week that she doesn’t know how to use cutlery. We went to a very nice expensive restaurant and she ate her entire meal, including broccoli, with her fingers. She was holding broccoli in her fist like a banana/lollipop and biting it.

later on I asked her to use her cutlery and she had it in the wrong hands and was totally
clueless how to hold it.

in addition to this she lies down at the table, sits on her phone, spills food down herself, chews with her mouth open and is generally lacking in table manners.

I work in education and have children myself and I am astonished at how immature she is. She behaves more like a 6/7 year old. She is clearly bright, but speaks in a very baby voice and asks the most silly questions for her age. I worry she’ll be targeted at school by bullies.

WIBU to say to my partner I won’t eat out with them again until he teaches her how to use cutlery? I don’t feel it’s my place to pull her up on her table manners (although I have done several times).

I just realised I sound like my mother! 😂

OP posts:
museumum · 09/11/2023 09:47

Ffs! It is not ableist or bigoted to teach your children social conventions around eating!!!!
If it emerges that she is left handed or dyspraxic then that needs to be accommodated (obviously). Nobody is suggesting the girl is beaten, only that she is given life skills that will allow her to blend in with society (if she chooses). If she can use cutlery but chooses not to as an adult that’s her decision but as a child our responsibility is to impart those skills.

regularmumnotacoolmum · 09/11/2023 09:46

Mannersdomatter · 09/11/2023 07:38

It is widely accepted that if you’re right handed you hold your knife in your right hand and fork in left. If you’re left handed then you would swap around.

Sorry but I don't agree with this. Lots of people eat with their right hand due to religious reasons. The rest is bad manners but cutlery in the wrong hand is a ridiculous thing to pick at.

notacooldad · 09/11/2023 09:45

You would be surprised at how many children that age can't use a knife and fork. I work with kids and we eat out often as a group. I noticed it the other year when one 12 year old was just using a fork and just shovelling food in her mouth. I asked her to use a knife and fork and she didn't have a clue. Once you notice things once you see it all the time then.
A lot of the families I work with have many take aways (burgers, pizzas) and these are all finger foods.
Also many famils dont have a dining table and some children have got used to laying out on the floor watch tv or gaming while they eat.
At work we often have children complaining when they are adjed to sit at the table for their meal and think they should be allowed to eat in the gaming chair while playing fortnite.

Hereforthebunfights · 09/11/2023 09:45

GrumpyPanda · 09/11/2023 09:34

So dyspraxia accounts for the baby voice, sitting on her phone/inability to sit at all, and chewing with wide open mouth? Goodness me.

Seems like a whole group of posters are massively projecting while failing to read. That and the customary AIBU hyena-like pile-on. Which is a shame because this child clearly needs help.

Actually yes, dyspraxia could account for all those things. (Which doesn't mean that's what's going on here nessasarily)

10HailMarys · 09/11/2023 09:44

She behaves more like a 6/7 year old

I’d say this is the actual problem, rather than just the cutlery. There’s something wrong if she consistently behaves like a six-year-old.

Either she actually does have some significant SEN, or she has been badly neglected, or she has deliberately started behaving like a baby, either for attention or because she’s been traumatised by something.

Itsnotchristmasyet · 09/11/2023 09:43

Ju1ieAndrews · 09/11/2023 09:23

So you've chosen to be with a man who has such bad parenting skills, that strangers would assume his NT DD has SEN when she's out in public.

How do you find this attractive?

Do you not see that he is negligent as a father?

Worst still, you're wondering if you should raise it, because it seems he doesn't notice &/or care that he's letting his child down by not teaching them basic skills.

Does he genuinely not think any effort is required with parenting, or is he just incredibly lazy?

I completely agree.

OP has actually said she doesn’t think the girl has SEN and so therefore she thinks it’s simply bad parenting - how she finds this attractive is beyond me!

SoftSheen · 09/11/2023 09:40

IME most left handed people (we have several in our family) still hold the fork in their left and the knife in their right. That said, I don't think most people would care if someone needed to hold them the other way round. The point is to be able to eat neatly and tidily without disturbing other people, something that a 12 year old (assuming so significant SN) should be able to do.

BeckhamSeven · 09/11/2023 09:40

If my daughter's school is anything to go by, yes she will get picked on if she can't eat sat at a table. My friends got hauled in for a meeting with the head of year when their child couldn't sit at a table and use a knife and fork. They found it "hilarious" but the unfortunate truth was that their daughter was being picked on because it was frankly gross. You need to understand why she hasn't be shown how to sit at a table properly, especially at the age of 12!

chocolatefiends · 09/11/2023 09:37

Above post was meant to quote this post:

It is widely accepted that if you’re right handed you hold your knife in your right hand and fork in left. If you’re left handed then you would swap around.

Avatartar · 09/11/2023 09:37

Depends on priorities/ circumstances when being brought up - if for instance tv dinners and no dining table, it’s likely that she’s never had the chance to sit down at a table with cutlery to have a meal, rather than refuel while doing something else. Sit them both down, tell them in your house/going for a meal manners are really important as is thinking about food and having a conversation rather than absent mindlessly eating while distracted by tv/ phones etc

chocolatefiends · 09/11/2023 09:36

No it isn't. I am right handed but I eat the way that has, in the past, being consdiered 'left handed' because that makes more sense to me.

Everything else you have said sounds like there is a problem and someone needs to help her.

But if you insist that she eat the 'right way' for her handedness you could mess with her brain development. I can't believe you're a teacher and you don't know this!

GrumpyPanda · 09/11/2023 09:34

Hereforthebunfights · 09/11/2023 08:17

Dyspraxia

So dyspraxia accounts for the baby voice, sitting on her phone/inability to sit at all, and chewing with wide open mouth? Goodness me.

Seems like a whole group of posters are massively projecting while failing to read. That and the customary AIBU hyena-like pile-on. Which is a shame because this child clearly needs help.

boamorte · 09/11/2023 09:34

People can hold cutlery in whatever hands they please

You sound very controlling

onlyoneoftheregimentinstep · 09/11/2023 09:30

Shadowsindarkplaces · 09/11/2023 07:41

Pick up plate, put on floor, saying eat properly or on the floor like an animal. At 12 ,no additional needs. She is aware and making a choice. probably for attention

What a horrible thing to suggest. Irrespective of her lack of manners nothing excuses humiliating a twelve year old.

Haydenn · 09/11/2023 09:30

Rather than giving her a lesson could you just ignore the fact that it annoys you and come up with a fun game of sorts. Are there any fun films things like princess diaries or pride and prejudice or Emma that you could spend some time watching and then have your own dinner party or we’ve even done murder mystery games where we all dress up. Make the table manners part of a character so you can teach her but it is fun and a bit ridiculous rather than embarrassing.

”Please do pass the port round”

EmmaOvary · 09/11/2023 09:29

I am right handed and hold my knife in my left hand. Who cares?

SleepingStandingUp · 09/11/2023 09:27

Mannersdomatter · 09/11/2023 07:38

It is widely accepted that if you’re right handed you hold your knife in your right hand and fork in left. If you’re left handed then you would swap around.

This isn't a hill I'd die on.

The bigger issue is surely that she doesn't even pick it up? What kind of food do you have at home where it's never bothered you she uses her hands only?

TheBirdintheCave · 09/11/2023 09:26

@Vegemiteandhoneyontoast It's fascinating how differently brains work :) I'm technically right handed though do a lot of things with my left hand and eat with my knife in the left and fork in the right.

Gerrataere · 09/11/2023 09:25

Cupcakemum79 · 09/11/2023 09:14

I'll quote you here: This is so ignorant. Just because you may vaguely know some children with SEN, really doesn’t mean you know everyone’s capabilities and every type of disability.

So yes you did literally say I vaguely knew them.
I've also never said that you or other SEN parents don't put in the effort, on the contrary even, I know it can take a lot of effort.

Apologies, I did mean vaguely in a general context from what you quoted but yes I did use the word. However that wouldn’t be ‘ignorant’, simply an oversight.

My point remains that unless you have parented children with additional needs yourself, your opinion about what can and cannot be taught/learned simply isn’t relevant. SEN parents hear enough from the ‘well I know someone and they manage it’ train of thought, it’s never taken on board. Honestly in the kindest way, SEN parents don’t care for the passing opinions of those who dont have a clue (even if they think they do).

Anyway, the thread is being derailed here. I absolutely wouldn’t dismiss that the daughter has ASD traits. It presents differently in girls. As as they reach puberty, becoming evidently more immature than their peers is often a key sign. But as others say, it may well be neglect from parents as well. Does she have siblings and how do they behave if so?

Willyoujustbequiet · 09/11/2023 09:24

Mirabai · 09/11/2023 08:48

It’s inextricably part of the wider issue that she can’t use cutlery at all. So she either has SEN issues or has been neglected.

And I’m a poc so you fuck off with your racism analogy. (See - sometimes offence can be caused without intention?)

I couid say fuck off back but I'm more mature than that.

I'm mixed race so crack on.

Bonjovispjs · 09/11/2023 09:24

I'm another one who is right handed, but eat with my fork in my right hand and knife in my left. Its not the wrong hands, its whats comfortable for me and loads of other people going by this thread. It shouldn't bother other people that we do that. All your other points I agree with and need sorting.

Ju1ieAndrews · 09/11/2023 09:23

So you've chosen to be with a man who has such bad parenting skills, that strangers would assume his NT DD has SEN when she's out in public.

How do you find this attractive?

Do you not see that he is negligent as a father?

Worst still, you're wondering if you should raise it, because it seems he doesn't notice &/or care that he's letting his child down by not teaching them basic skills.

Does he genuinely not think any effort is required with parenting, or is he just incredibly lazy?

Vegemiteandhoneyontoast · 09/11/2023 09:22

@TheBirdintheCave to be honest, I can't remember if I was taught that way or it was just comfortable. Eating the 'right handed' way is comfortable, though. Unless it's with a spoon.

TheBirdintheCave · 09/11/2023 09:18

@Vegemiteandhoneyontoast Interesting. Is this because it's what was comfortable for you naturally though or because someone told you that was the 'right' way to eat? My brother is also left handed and eats the 'right handed' way but no one taught him to do it like that, he just finds it comfortable.

Cupcakemum79 · 09/11/2023 09:14

Gerrataere · 09/11/2023 09:09

I didn’t say you ‘vaguely’ knew them, I said you knew them by association. That doesn’t give you a valid insight into individual SEN and development of social or coordination skills.

But their parnets taught them nonetheless which sometimes took a lot of effort.

Good for them, but that doesn’t mean those of us with SEN children who have tried to implicate these expected social manners and not yet managed to achieve it have not put in ‘a lot of effort’. Im sure you don’t mean to come over as both patronising and a tad ignorant but your very limited insight doesn’t give for a balanced view here.

I'll quote you here: This is so ignorant. Just because you may vaguely know some children with SEN, really doesn’t mean you know everyone’s capabilities and every type of disability.

So yes you did literally say I vaguely knew them.
I've also never said that you or other SEN parents don't put in the effort, on the contrary even, I know it can take a lot of effort.