Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To deliver a lesson in table manners?

310 replies

Mannersdomatter · 09/11/2023 07:18

My partners child is 12 and just started high school (year 7).

I realised last week that she doesn’t know how to use cutlery. We went to a very nice expensive restaurant and she ate her entire meal, including broccoli, with her fingers. She was holding broccoli in her fist like a banana/lollipop and biting it.

later on I asked her to use her cutlery and she had it in the wrong hands and was totally
clueless how to hold it.

in addition to this she lies down at the table, sits on her phone, spills food down herself, chews with her mouth open and is generally lacking in table manners.

I work in education and have children myself and I am astonished at how immature she is. She behaves more like a 6/7 year old. She is clearly bright, but speaks in a very baby voice and asks the most silly questions for her age. I worry she’ll be targeted at school by bullies.

WIBU to say to my partner I won’t eat out with them again until he teaches her how to use cutlery? I don’t feel it’s my place to pull her up on her table manners (although I have done several times).

I just realised I sound like my mother! 😂

OP posts:
CharlotteBog · 09/11/2023 11:39

waterrat · 09/11/2023 11:35

OP you haven't responded to questions about whether this child has potential SEN/ autism/adhd

You say she is 12 but appears a lot younger - you may need to address this properly rather than just pick on the eating.

The OP says in her second post "no disability, no SEN, no reason why she shouldn’t be able to."

TheBirdintheCave · 09/11/2023 11:37

ismu · 09/11/2023 11:32

The reason that there's a convention of right hand for knife and left for fork is actually not about the dominant hand, as both actions require dexterity but not a particular left to right motion that makes it so tricky to use scissors or write for a left hander. It's actually so that when you're sitting at a formal table you're not constantly bashing elbows with your neighbours!
No one is trying to say that people with a disability should conform just for the hell of it, there's actually a social reason for this and nothing to do with left/ right neurological differences.
Maybe we could suggest that people just write on a page however they want, maybe choose left to write or right to left ? Or down the way? Communication with others, who cares ?

I am 37 and have sat at many a crowded dinner table. Never have I once bashed elbows with someone else. How would that even happen? I thought it was bad manners to splay your elbows out when you eat?

And how is this in any way comparable to writing? Which way I choose to eat affects no one but myself.

waterrat · 09/11/2023 11:35

OP you haven't responded to questions about whether this child has potential SEN/ autism/adhd

You say she is 12 but appears a lot younger - you may need to address this properly rather than just pick on the eating.

ismu · 09/11/2023 11:34

Left to RIGHT obviously...Blush

ismu · 09/11/2023 11:32

The reason that there's a convention of right hand for knife and left for fork is actually not about the dominant hand, as both actions require dexterity but not a particular left to right motion that makes it so tricky to use scissors or write for a left hander. It's actually so that when you're sitting at a formal table you're not constantly bashing elbows with your neighbours!
No one is trying to say that people with a disability should conform just for the hell of it, there's actually a social reason for this and nothing to do with left/ right neurological differences.
Maybe we could suggest that people just write on a page however they want, maybe choose left to write or right to left ? Or down the way? Communication with others, who cares ?

Irritatedandfedup · 09/11/2023 11:29

Husband and I are both left handed . I use knife in left hand and he uses knife in right hand. All the children are right handed ,but use knife in left hand . It really doesn’t matter 🤷‍♀️As long as food gets into mouth and not thrown around ,is all I care about!

PepeLePugh · 09/11/2023 11:28

InvisibleDuck · 09/11/2023 11:22

Table manners should be about not making others feel uncomfortable when eating. So eating with your mouth wide open is bad manners. Staring at your phone all evening instead of making conversation is bad manners. Using a knife and fork in whichever hands you find most comfortable? Not a manners issue.

I cut up my food and then put my fork in my right hand to eat it. I have a disability that means if I used my left hand I'd likely get food all over myself. The disability is not apparent by looking at me. I used to be embarrassed about this and avoid going to restaurants but now but I am too old to care and anyone who is offended by it can just fuck off. If they don't want to dine with me again because of something so inconsequential, good riddance.

OP I'd say that some of the things you mention are a problem, others really aren't, but in either case it isn't your place to talk to the 12 year old about it. Talk to her father about your concerns if you want, but an ultimatum 'I won't eat with her if she's like this' is only going to cause conflict. Presumably you want to develop a good relationship with the girl even if this is something you don't like about her. Shaming her for the way she eats won't help that and it won't make her change overnight, even if there are no SEN or trauma issues, which is far from certain.

I completely agree with your last paragraph. Shaming the girl herself is not the way forward, this needs addressing with the parents.

Do you always eat at the table together? If you don't then you should start doing now for every meal.

HoppingPavlova · 09/11/2023 11:26

It is widely accepted that if you’re right handed you hold your knife in your right hand and fork in left. If you’re left handed then you would swap around

oh, do give over. My DH is right handed and holds the knife in his left hand, as does one of my kids, as they claim it’s more comfortable. Then I have another who also does it but they are a leftie. I’ve never run screaming from a restaurant because right handed DH and a child are holding knives/forks like a leftie. They immediately swap cutlery over on sitting down, and often the wait person will say ‘oh, left handed’, and DH says ‘no, just preference’. We eat, pay, leave. Who cares.

Azebraisjustanexotichorse · 09/11/2023 11:26

Agree it’s poor table manners but this is down to her parents, including your husband, he is the one you should be addressing this with initially.

Tiddlywinkly · 09/11/2023 11:25

How does your partner eat? Do you eat regularly together at a table?

Willyoujustbequiet · 09/11/2023 11:25

TheBirdintheCave · 09/11/2023 11:17

@Willyoujustbequiet Whilst I agree with you for 90% of that, the way in which the poster described her friends eating is just... bizarre. I eat with my knife in my left hand and can use it for cutting just fine. I don't tear into anything with my fork as the fork is for holding things in place. She was saying that her friends can't manage and just pull things apart with the fork which I can't even make sense of in my head.

Edited

Thank you. I'm the same as you, no issues at all with holding a knife in my left.

PepeLePugh · 09/11/2023 11:24

I had no idea cutlery holding was such a contentious issue. Jeez.

Whatever your view on cutlery holding, OP did not say that despite holding cutlery in the "wrong hands" she ate beautifully. This girl was clearly clueless regarding using cutlery to eat and unless there is an additional need, this will be because nobody has bothered to teach her. The parents are at fault here.

InvisibleDuck · 09/11/2023 11:22

Table manners should be about not making others feel uncomfortable when eating. So eating with your mouth wide open is bad manners. Staring at your phone all evening instead of making conversation is bad manners. Using a knife and fork in whichever hands you find most comfortable? Not a manners issue.

I cut up my food and then put my fork in my right hand to eat it. I have a disability that means if I used my left hand I'd likely get food all over myself. The disability is not apparent by looking at me. I used to be embarrassed about this and avoid going to restaurants but now but I am too old to care and anyone who is offended by it can just fuck off. If they don't want to dine with me again because of something so inconsequential, good riddance.

OP I'd say that some of the things you mention are a problem, others really aren't, but in either case it isn't your place to talk to the 12 year old about it. Talk to her father about your concerns if you want, but an ultimatum 'I won't eat with her if she's like this' is only going to cause conflict. Presumably you want to develop a good relationship with the girl even if this is something you don't like about her. Shaming her for the way she eats won't help that and it won't make her change overnight, even if there are no SEN or trauma issues, which is far from certain.

Willyoujustbequiet · 09/11/2023 11:19

penjil · 09/11/2023 10:32

No, itt didn't.
I don't know where you got that idea from.

It did because now we have greater awareness of neurological science and the concept of a dominant hand.

Jetband · 09/11/2023 11:18

er no, it did not.

TheBirdintheCave · 09/11/2023 11:17

@Willyoujustbequiet Whilst I agree with you for 90% of that, the way in which the poster described her friends eating is just... bizarre. I eat with my knife in my left hand and can use it for cutting just fine. I don't tear into anything with my fork as the fork is for holding things in place. She was saying that her friends can't manage and just pull things apart with the fork which I can't even make sense of in my head.

Astrabees · 09/11/2023 11:17

Table manners should be taught from an early age, including sitting up properly, and not playing with phones. My sons went to a school which said in its prospectus “table manners a speciality” .

porridgeisbae · 09/11/2023 11:17

I'm left handed and I was never told I could choose to use a different hand for my knife and fork. This is the first I've heard of this. I do ok, though I suppose cutting with my right is hard- maybe I should try the other way round if it's considered acceptable. Smile

@Mannersdomatter I think her actions say something about him.

Willyoujustbequiet · 09/11/2023 11:13

sashh · 09/11/2023 10:05

There is a right way and a wrong way to hold cutlery, being left or right handed has nothing to do with it.

The only two people I know who consistently use the wrong hand are both right handed.

It looks so award, using the knife to 'hold' the food and then using the fork to pull the food appart.

Some knives are impossible to use in the wrong hands.

Please educate yourself.

There is no right or wrong hand to hold a knife and fork in. Its literally a neurological instinct for many people. Saying its wrong is telling people they need to go against what their brain is telling them to do. It's ridiculous and for young children could have a developmental impact.

I have older family members that used to get hit by teachers for writing with their left hand. Insisting on using cutlery in particular hands is the same concept.

It's your prejudice that makes you see it as clumsy. Insisting on making people feel physically uncomfortable is very poor etiquette.

Bogofftosomewherehot · 09/11/2023 11:08

EatYourVegetables · 09/11/2023 07:53

The OP is not describing “ Victorian bigotry” or “ableist bullshit”, Christ on a bicycle. She’s describing a 12yo who can’t use a fork and eats broccoli with a fist like a 6mo old. My kids stopped doing that before their first birthday…

This!

Gloriously · 09/11/2023 11:03

I don’t feel it’s my place to pull her up on her table manners (although I have done several times).

”pull her up”......”deliver a lesson”

But you did anyway.

Maybe it’s how you interact with her and/or the situation with her DF that she is rebelling against?

Maybe “deliver a lesson on parenting” instead to the useless parent in her life?

Itsnotchristmasyet · 09/11/2023 11:03

Meeting · 09/11/2023 10:02

My god I am SO sick of every example of shit parenting on here being out down to the child having SEN by so many posters.

I would usually agree but in this case there is obviously something else going on than just your basic shit parenting.

She’s 12 and she acts like a 6yo.

If she doesn’t have SEN then it’s not just shit parenting, it’s negligent parenting or trauma at the very least.

I knew a girl who was the same age as us (11-14) and she’d act like a 6yo.
She was being abused by her dad.
Likewise with so many of the children I work with, they act much older or much younger if they’ve had trauma.

There’s a massive difference between acting a bit immature or young and acting half your age.

GetBackIntoBed · 09/11/2023 11:00

She also struggled tying shoe laces and doing buttons up I suppose you would have looked down at her for that too.

Why would anyone look down on a child who is struggling? To struggle means you are trying. Not like the OP's SD who sits at the table and eats like a chimpanzee at a tea party

PepeLePugh · 09/11/2023 10:58

YANBU. I would expect children half her age to have developed better table manners than this so unless she does have additional needs then this needs resolving. The lack of manners is a more than likely a result of her parents splitting and neither taking the time to correct manners or enforce no phone at the table. Whatever makes for a quiet life eh!

A gentle word with your partner should be the starting point rather than flatly refusing to eat out with them etc. However it will always be difficult (but not impossible) if you and your partner work hard at teaching her if her mum does not also do this consistently.

Thedm · 09/11/2023 10:52

This is called failed parenting. Your partner failed as a parent, as did the girl’s mum.

Think very carefully about this man if you want to have children. This isn’t screaming out the best choice for a father.

Swipe left for the next trending thread