Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To deliver a lesson in table manners?

310 replies

Mannersdomatter · 09/11/2023 07:18

My partners child is 12 and just started high school (year 7).

I realised last week that she doesn’t know how to use cutlery. We went to a very nice expensive restaurant and she ate her entire meal, including broccoli, with her fingers. She was holding broccoli in her fist like a banana/lollipop and biting it.

later on I asked her to use her cutlery and she had it in the wrong hands and was totally
clueless how to hold it.

in addition to this she lies down at the table, sits on her phone, spills food down herself, chews with her mouth open and is generally lacking in table manners.

I work in education and have children myself and I am astonished at how immature she is. She behaves more like a 6/7 year old. She is clearly bright, but speaks in a very baby voice and asks the most silly questions for her age. I worry she’ll be targeted at school by bullies.

WIBU to say to my partner I won’t eat out with them again until he teaches her how to use cutlery? I don’t feel it’s my place to pull her up on her table manners (although I have done several times).

I just realised I sound like my mother! 😂

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Whyohwhywyoming · 15/11/2023 12:52

AgnesX · 09/11/2023 18:39

I wouldn't say anything I'd just refuse to go anywhere decent with her.

Until your partner asks why.

OPs partner is the one who has created this situation so she should refuse to eat out with him.

nanamoo · 13/11/2023 21:55

Mannersdomatter · 09/11/2023 07:38

It is widely accepted that if you’re right handed you hold your knife in your right hand and fork in left. If you’re left handed then you would swap around.

It doesn't always work that way! There is no right or wrong handed way to use cutlery, as long as it's used properly. Throughout primary school i was penalised for using my cutlery the 'wrong way'. I was made to sit at the table and not leave until i'd used the cutlery the right way, often having to eat cold food and missing out on break time. All because i use cutlery like a left handed person when i'm right handed!!

LRSD · 13/11/2023 21:09

The wrong hands thing is totally unimportant (I am 30, ambidextrous and ASD). I have ate like a left hander since I was small, I cannot do it the other way. I think this is because my dad is left handed and I copied him. But it doesn’t make a difference. The point is a child of that age should be able to use cutlery.

MarshmallowIck · 13/11/2023 14:47

Could be a lot of reasons. And it's difficult to address them compassionately.

I'd steer away from blaming the kid, or excluding her. It's not like anyone clear sightedly chooses to be behind at life skills at 12.

Maybe some gentle probing about what her upbringing has been like so far will work. Or non judgemental exploration of why she eats like she does.

I'm seeing a little shock and disgust at how she is so behind. But you can probably stay curious and not let that affect your interactions?

MummyToOneRainbowAndOneAngel · 13/11/2023 14:35

Interesting. I would be absolutely hopeless cutting anything with my non-dominant hand, be that with knife or scissors or whatever.

I think maybe the way I explained this distracts from the real point I was trying to make, which is just that I don’t think OP was making any kind of judgement when she used the term “wrong way” (and I note you’ve used the term too, presumably with no judgement intended one way or the other).

DappledThings · 13/11/2023 14:01

There is no right or wrong way, but, generally speaking, it makes sense that if you are right handed the knife would be in your dominant right hand, and if you are left handed it would be in your dominant left hand. Anyone would struggle to cut properly with a knife in their non-dominant hand.
I never understood this. As a left-handed person I've never eaten the wrong way round and I've never seen either the knife or fork as needing to be dominant. You need both of them, you need dexterity and power with both to spear food, hold it, cut it and move to your mouth. I don't see how there's any benefit for a left hander to hold the knife in the left or a right hander to hold it in the right. I'm pretty sure using cutlery requires use of both hands equally.

MummyToOneRainbowAndOneAngel · 13/11/2023 13:45

I feel like OP is getting some really unnecessary heat for the cutlery thing.

There is no right or wrong way, but, generally speaking, it makes sense that if you are right handed the knife would be in your dominant right hand, and if you are left handed it would be in your dominant left hand. Anyone would struggle to cut properly with a knife in their non-dominant hand.

Isn’t what OP is saying just that she isn’t holding it in the way that complements her handedness (and “wrong way” is just shorthand for that)?

I don’t see how it is “bigoted” to notice that.

And I would agree with others it suggests either SEN, or that she has never been properly shown how to cut things - in which case I’d take a dim view of your partner - or that she is wilfully ignoring in an attempt to gain attention (though the latter would not be my first assumption).

Mitchlou84 · 12/11/2023 17:11

Both my ex partners are right handed and eat with the fork in the right hand and the knife in the left. I was a bit confused by this, but why on earth does it matter?

RainbowNinja77 · 12/11/2023 15:56

I’ve just read that he is a boyfriend and you don’t live together. Therefore, my advice is: RUN! He doesn’t care enough to parent his own child; imagine what he will be like with yours.

RainbowNinja77 · 12/11/2023 15:53

By whom will it be noticed? Why on Earth should anyone care?!

RainbowNinja77 · 12/11/2023 15:51

Why does cutlery have a right and a wrong way? Why is that so important to you?

RainbowNinja77 · 12/11/2023 15:50

I think this needs tackling, but the issue is her parents (including your partner), not her. Issuing a statement like that could be absolutely disastrous to your relationship with her. You need to assert rules at your dinner table - no phones, cutlery used, etc but issued to everyone and not just directed at her.

As a step child, I was quite hurt at your words. You seem to really dislike this child and are completely blaming her for the parenting she has received. She is not ‘immature’, but has not had proper meal etiquette drilled into her. Don’t shame her for this, work on her father to correct it.

Also, as an educator, I feel despondent to hear your lack of knowledge of the effect of childhood effects of ACEs. Divorce is an ACE and many children will mimic younger ages when they have experienced trauma - divorce can come with significant trauma, but so can being thrust into a step-mum’s family and being looked down on and shamed.

So, I am voting YABU because your solution to this issue is to shame a 12 year old girl and leave her out of nice family experiences, rather than deal with the real issues: her father.

1mabon · 12/11/2023 11:37

All three of my boys could use a knife, fork, and spoon correctly at age three, so did my grandsons. Why have the parents not taught the child? Maybe there is a disability who knows?

LaurieStrode · 12/11/2023 09:54

Agree, @alexdgr8

I'd stay clear of the lot of them.

alexdgr8 · 12/11/2023 09:33

the child's parents sound neglectful.
why would you want to be coupled with such a person ?
he has neither mentioned it, nor addressed it.
perhaps not enough care for and interest in the child to notice or care.
i don't find any of that attractive.
nor does it bode well for the future.

Greengagesnfennel · 12/11/2023 09:09

How long have you been in her life? Could she be deliberately doing this to push your buttons?

If she is yr7 with no SEN then the brocolli eating and baby talk sounds like she is playing you for a reaction. (And having a laugh with her friends about it afterwards probably).

Bumblepig · 12/11/2023 08:23

@HeffyAgain why will it be noticed in these so called ‘nicer restaurants’? Is the company so boring that they will take to watching everyone around them. Maybe they should keep their noses out and judge less?

Julimia · 11/11/2023 22:42

Don't make a conflict out of this but work through it gently by example and suggestion.

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 11/11/2023 17:36

Theoware · 11/11/2023 16:50

It really doesn’t matter about the ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ hand, but hopefully we can agree that eating broccoli like a lollipop is definitely not acceptable for a 12 year old?!

I wonder how she eats broccoli (or anything else) when she's not seeing her father.

I would not be surprised if she can eat perfectly normally elsewhere. Could she be acting younger and less competent than she is, because she's scared of losing her father altogether? Perhaps she fears that if she acts too grown-up, he'll think she doesn't need to be taken care of, and he'll move on to a new life that doesn't include her.

She wouldn't be thinking any of it consciously, I'm sure. It would be below the surface.

TheBirdintheCave · 11/11/2023 17:12

@Mirabai She was replying to someone who implied that eating with cutlery that way around was bad manners.

Mirabai · 11/11/2023 17:08

starborne · 11/11/2023 13:23

If someone judges me for using my fork in my right hand or letting my children dot he same then their opinion isn't worth anything.

Are you and your children “clueless as to how to use cutlery” and eat broccoli in your fist?

Theoware · 11/11/2023 16:50

It really doesn’t matter about the ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ hand, but hopefully we can agree that eating broccoli like a lollipop is definitely not acceptable for a 12 year old?!

starborne · 11/11/2023 13:23

AuntyX · 11/11/2023 13:21

Using the wrong hands is not outdated. Table manners are sadly underrated these days and parents can be judged if their children exhibit poor manners.

If someone judges me for using my fork in my right hand or letting my children dot he same then their opinion isn't worth anything.

AuntyX · 11/11/2023 13:21

Using the wrong hands is not outdated. Table manners are sadly underrated these days and parents can be judged if their children exhibit poor manners.

Whyohwhywyoming · 11/11/2023 12:51

My SDs talk in baby voices to DP, and only to him, and act very childishly, it’s just a response to their parents divorce and really not something to be contemptuous about.

also, eating with one’s hands is not in and of itself a big deal imo, there are plenty of people around the world who do it. This is less aimed at the OP and all the people fainting at the thought of not eating “properly”

Swipe left for the next trending thread