Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do some families still send Boys to Private (Public) Schools while sending Girls to State Schools

61 replies

Coldcaller · 08/11/2023 21:09

My family could have been described as solidly Upper Middle Class my father was a Criminal Lawyer who was public School educated along with his brother and two generations before him. My mother was also Public School educated and Oxford University, before deciding she wanted to serve society, because money was not a problem. My mother therefore became a teacher but would only teach in Grammar Schools. This was the furthest she was prepared to go, in terms of her public service.

Thus it was always certain my brother would follow his father to Prep and then Public School and of course he did. However, there was never any chance that neither I nor my Sister would be given any Private schooling. For us it was the local Primary and then my mum's Grammar School if we passed the 11+. That was not certain for me and i remember my mother telling me that I will go to the school that suits my ability and whether i was Grammar caliber. In the end i passed and from that moment on during my schooling my mother continually called me a 'lazy' underachiever non more so than my 2:2 from a very ordinary University. This in contrast to both siblings Firsts from Oxford and Cambridge respectively. My mum finally apologized to me many years later when I was finely diagnosed with the 'jackpot' of Autism, Dyslexia, Dyscalculia Dyspraxia and Irlens which tend to co -exist within ASD diagnosis .

However, back to the question of the thread, i know of several well of parents of friends at the time who were equally misogynistic about their daughters schooling.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AIstolemylunch · 09/11/2023 10:32

I have sons who are at or went to 3 different independent schools in South London/Surrey so I must know or know of 5 or 600 families that also have or had kids at these schools and I honestly cannot think of one where only the boy was offered private education. So I really don't think this is that common anymore, thankfully, and sorry to the women who were treated like second class children in the past.

I really am wracking my brains and I can't think of any round here. I know people at work who have boys state (becasue the boys werent at all academic so 'no point' and girls private. And I know families where the girl opted to go to state sixth form college at 16 instead of staying at private school sixth form, but very much their choice at that point. I really, really can't think of anyone that has a girl in a state school and a boy in an independent. There might be some girls at the local grammar schools whose brothers didn't get into the equivalent boys grammars and so went to an independent school, but I don't know any. And they would be considered the second class child in that situation round here.

AIstolemylunch · 09/11/2023 10:14

I don't have daughters but I can categorically state that I would not have done this. All the families I know with both boys and girls that have sent the boys to independent have also done the same for the girls (either same school if coed or different school if single sex). I have sons at a boys independent and the vast, vast, vast majority of the boys sister's go to the girls independent up the road, or another independent co-ed and most then try and join them in sixth form, when girls join the school (not always successful as entrance requirements are high).

This isn't still a thing round here, but then it's mainly hard working professionals sending their kids to private school. Maybe the aristo types still do this? I'd be surprised though. In fact what's more common round here is boys to state grammar, girls to independent.

bibblebubblebobble · 09/11/2023 10:06

This thread has really shocked me. I guess, because I grew up in a south London housing estate and went to a failing all girls state school, I don't know anyone of middle or upper classes that could afford private schools.

So I simply never knew this existed in our society, I just assumed people gave their kids equal education whatever that may be

Coldcaller · 09/11/2023 09:48

Gertude: I know you were not being rude, its just for some reason a couple of posters randomly choose this thread to be rude to me . I don't know why but there are some nasty people around. Generally these people have nothing constructive to offer and have boring and bland lives !

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/11/2023 23:29

Coldcaller · 08/11/2023 23:03

Gertude: To be fair to my mother because i had developed a very advanced coping strategy and was exceptional verbally . I am for instance a very good public speaker and due to my Autism have a memory where i can real off facts figures stats at random. This is why perhaps my mother could not understand why i was a B/C pupil at GCSE and BCC at A Level. The facts and instant recall probably saving me there from D and E grades.

I was told years later by a Clinical Psychologist that 'Bright Children' with disabilities who obtained D and E grades at GCSE in the 1990 had done exceptionally !

Sorry, I didn’t mean to sound rude, I was trying to be supportive.

It does sound like you did very well in the circumstances.

You sounds quite a lot like me in your update if I’m honest - my A levels were my best point though because they were all things I was very interested in.

My brothers and I all went to the same mixed comp - in fact my youngest brother got CCD at A level and he’s by far the highest earner of the three of us. I got the best “academics” of the three and a now the lowest earner. Often feel like the poor relation as I’m also the only one of the three of us with children! Expensive children!

Mumof2teens79 · 08/11/2023 23:12

Keepgoing88 · 08/11/2023 23:02

@Mumof2teens79 Yes this was my friend parents ‘theory’ . My parents still believe this! They didn’t have any sons so saved a fortune haha

Those I know that have used that justification genuinely believe it's about the individual needs of the child and its just random that the responsible child is the girl and the one needing a firmer hand is the boy.....I am not convinced. In fairness in both cases the girl is the oldest. I wonder how much of the boys behaviour is down to how their parents treat them.

Coldcaller · 08/11/2023 23:07

And of course at University i had to rewrite my essays three times. I seemed to be the only one working, while everybody else was having a good time.

OP posts:
Coldcaller · 08/11/2023 23:04

Exceptionally good verbally ....

OP posts:
Coldcaller · 08/11/2023 23:03

Gertude: To be fair to my mother because i had developed a very advanced coping strategy and was exceptional verbally . I am for instance a very good public speaker and due to my Autism have a memory where i can real off facts figures stats at random. This is why perhaps my mother could not understand why i was a B/C pupil at GCSE and BCC at A Level. The facts and instant recall probably saving me there from D and E grades.

I was told years later by a Clinical Psychologist that 'Bright Children' with disabilities who obtained D and E grades at GCSE in the 1990 had done exceptionally !

OP posts:
Keepgoing88 · 08/11/2023 23:02

@Mumof2teens79 Yes this was my friend parents ‘theory’ . My parents still believe this! They didn’t have any sons so saved a fortune haha

Keepgoing88 · 08/11/2023 23:01

Yes this was my friend parents ‘theory’ . My parents still believe this! They didn’t have any sons so saved a fortune haha

Keepgoing88 · 08/11/2023 22:59

Yes, one of my best friends in the early 2000s. Her and younger sister both state educated and then the younger brother boy went to an all boys private school . The parents were both teachers.. the theory behind it I think was that it was more likely for him to ‘go off the rails’ in a state school than the girls. I still think it sends a message to the girls that their education / them are not as important or worthy personally . The only other times I’ve known it is not based on gender but on children’s needs (or special needs basically) and I totally understand that.

xanadu123 · 08/11/2023 22:53

I see so many people justify this by saying it's ok if the state school for the boys (or girls is better) than for the opposite sex. And as someone who went private it baffles me that people still don't realise private schools aren't just about the academics or the teaching - but the confidence and opportunities to do different activities/hobbies you wouldn't have access to in a state school. It's like you can have 2 software developers - one starts their career at Google and another at a small company that invests in training. The developer from Google will have a lot more confidence and access to additional training then the one at a small company - even if they perform equally well in a software exam. And that confidence will help one get more/better jobs and promotions. Kids don't know this stuff, so it's upto parents who are aware how the world works to ensure they make these decisions for them.

My friend went to private, his older sister state. And she performed far better than he did at school and uni but never forgave her parents because as she got older she realised how he had access to sports she didn't, trips she'd never do, and a confidence that she had to really work hard to develop in uni.

VenusClapTrap · 08/11/2023 22:53

i know someone who has done this. The boy is very clever and won a highly competitive scholarship. The daughter is less academically inclined, and said she didn’t want to go to the private school because it’s too sport heavy. If she had wanted to go, the parents were going to try to scrape together the fees, but it was a relief to them that she was happy to go to the local comp.

Dh has a friend who ‘joked’ that it would be a waste of money sending his daughter to a private school because ‘she’s just going to get married’.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/11/2023 22:48

Sounds like your parents really let you down, and I’m sorry to hear that.

I would consider it if it were an option (including financially, which it’s not) because my daughter is super academic and would thrive anywhere - she goes to a girls comprehensive and is on the road to getting 9s in her GCSEs so they say. My son has SEN - ADHD and dyslexia- so I’d consider a private school would be useful for him, but then private schools tend to see it the other way around.

That said, it’s not because of their sexes it’s because of their needs and it would be the same if the sexes were reversed.

I always thought that private schools should have to offer free places for kids with SEN or who struggle a lot in other ways long before I had children - the old assisted places for the brightest seemed like nonsense to me - the brightest will do well anywhere.

For disclosure I went to a mixed comp, went on to Oxford Uni and became a criminal lawyer - but criminal law isn’t well paid at all these days. Now I’m in the civil service which also isn’t well paid. I’m a single parent - my ex earns more (private school and then non Oxbridge but good Uni) but he’s diluted his ability to spend on education by having an additional two children and a house bigger than he needs.

WrongSwanson · 08/11/2023 22:44

Mumof2teens79 · 08/11/2023 22:42

There are....but often the reason given is the girl is doing well and will do well anywhere, but the boy needs more discipline/support and won't do as well at a state school.

This would have been broadly my parent's justification. I don't think it was a good one. I think we deserved equal investment in our education.

Mumof2teens79 · 08/11/2023 22:42

There are....but often the reason given is the girl is doing well and will do well anywhere, but the boy needs more discipline/support and won't do as well at a state school.

Coldcaller · 08/11/2023 22:38

Some posters highlight that girls state schools are largely better than boys state schools. This is the case with my foster daughters grammar school, that is substantially highly regarded . The boys grammar reputation is a bit so-so.

OP posts:
Mariposista · 08/11/2023 22:34

My cousin went to Grammar school but his sister went to the comp. They didn’t want her at an all girls school. Both did well in their separate settings.

buttercupcake · 08/11/2023 22:28

I know 2 families that have sent their daughters to private school, and their sons to the local state school. Don’t know their reasons.

pastaandpesto · 08/11/2023 22:28

I knew a family at DC's primary whose grandparents had offered to pay school fees for private secondary schooling for their two sons but not for their daughter.

It put the parents in an awful position. In the end they decided they would accept the offer and try to fund the daughter's fees themselves (I don't think they were on very high incomes themselves).

I like to think that if I was in the same position I would have told them to fuck right off and keep their money, but I do understand why they decided to hold their noses for the sake of the children's education. Awful thing for the GPS to have done.

Coldcaller · 08/11/2023 22:23

Charlotte: Firstly to judge someones academic ability or intelligence based on their difficulties is shameful and absolutely inaccurate !

Secondly you obviously struggle with comprehension, because i made it clear i had one brother and one sister.

OP posts:
NoKnickerElastic · 08/11/2023 22:23

I know someone who does this now. Reason apparently is state girls much better than the state boys or mixed comps in our city (I don't know if this is true)

Peanutcookies · 08/11/2023 22:20

My old boss did, I hated that man.

it wasn’t even that long ago, his kids are in their early/ mid twenties now

charlotte361 · 08/11/2023 22:19

To be fait though , it does sound as though your brothers were a lot morer academically inclined than you were, so that is probably more important than what was in your pants!

Swipe left for the next trending thread