Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a nativity one I’m sorry

87 replies

Toarrie · 08/11/2023 19:31

Please be kind with me I have a rather upset DC, year 1.
So DC has been talking about nativity all week and how they have a minor speaking part. Turns out that part has now been given to another boy, DC was told and told they will just be part of the chorus. Children were apparently asked what they wanted to do (sounds chaotic with a number of changes) and DC specifically said they wanted a speaking part and teacher said they would get them one. Cue one very upset child.
now I understand not everyone can have a part but why ask and then promise parts to 5/6 year olds if they can’t deliver?
DC is gutted that they will be sat on a bench at the very back behind all of the children that have parts.
should I flag to teacher that child is upset? I don’t want to be that parent (and in no way am I expecting them to now have a part) but also I don’t want me/DC to come across as push overs?

OP posts:
Rhayader · 09/11/2023 03:12

Our school nativity managed a line for every child. All 120 of them!

The play had a lot of narration and each kid that didn’t have a part was a narrator and they all sat in order and read their one line.

Gymnopedie · 09/11/2023 00:27

OP I think as long as you do it gently not all guns blazing you absolutely should clarify with the school what's happened. If DS has misunderstood you can explain to him. However if - it's a possibility - he really did have the part and then it's been taken away because a pushy parent demanded a speaking role for their child and the teacher has given in then that's when you too become a pushy parent because that would be absolutely shit on the school's part.

Screamingabdabz · 09/11/2023 00:06

Another idea op - do check what children’s activities are on at your local church - I’m sure they’d welcome you and would love to have your little one in their nativity play.

CloudsNeverStayTheyAlwaysGoAway · 08/11/2023 23:59

User562377 · 08/11/2023 20:13

One year my kid was a sausage 😀
Luckily he was very excited about it because his teacher convinced him it was a very important part, even though he didn't have any lines. I guess a speaking sausage wasn't very realistic.

I love the idea of a speaking sausage and would loved to have seen that. That sounds a great part.

The best part is the donkey because it can be acted funny.

Highlyflavouredgravy · 08/11/2023 23:51

If he is not very academic then perhaps he couldn't read the script?
The main parts need to go to kids who can read the script and speak loudly and confidently and who can follow instructions.

booksandbrooks · 08/11/2023 23:45

Our school tends to give 3 kids all the roles and has a 57 strong chorus. Even those kid's parents were mortified.

Bbq1 · 08/11/2023 23:44

Ds was the donkey in the reception nativity, leading M&J to Bethlehem ans singing . He absolutely stole the show with his unintended comedic asides and funny acting. His role because legendary and the Nursery teacher used to mention it every year afterwards . On his last day in Year 6 one of the teachers commented on how there had never been such a fantastic donkey before or since. Ds had originally wanted to be Jesus until they explained it was possible. Any role van be made your own! I du agree that all children need ti be given axrole in Primary. Ds went on to be a cloud, shepherd, Narrator and singing in the choir. Children can always be singers on the stage to give everyone a role.

fireworksmyass · 08/11/2023 21:33

LylaLee · 08/11/2023 20:01

My kid was a door one year. The line: no room in the inn.

🤣🤣🤣 sorry this made me laugh

Toarrie · 08/11/2023 21:32

CatamaranViper · 08/11/2023 21:10

DHs nativity was a pirate version of the nativity so loads of the pirates had parrots ie repeating the lines.

Apparently was very funny (according to MIL)

Maybe I’ll get DC to do that from bench at the side 😂

OP posts:
Toarrie · 08/11/2023 21:31

wafflingworrier · 08/11/2023 20:55

At my school we write down what parts and how many lines the children get each year to ensure the following year there is a change in terms of making sure each child gets a chance over their school life. But maybe check with the teacher what happened as this does sound like a misunderstanding from your child. As a teacher, the knly time I've ever taken away a child's part once given is upon the request of a parent or for the welfare of the child e.g. severe anxiety/stage fright/ family circumstances / bloody family holidays in term time

Yes I am hopeful it has been a misunderstanding on DC’s part. Although not ideal for DC thinking and telling me they had a part when they didn’t.
I can’t help but think it is a shame they weren’t given something though as they aren’t academic or sporty so I would have been a nice opportunity for a confidence boost.

OP posts:
CatamaranViper · 08/11/2023 21:10

DHs nativity was a pirate version of the nativity so loads of the pirates had parrots ie repeating the lines.

Apparently was very funny (according to MIL)

wafflingworrier · 08/11/2023 20:55

At my school we write down what parts and how many lines the children get each year to ensure the following year there is a change in terms of making sure each child gets a chance over their school life. But maybe check with the teacher what happened as this does sound like a misunderstanding from your child. As a teacher, the knly time I've ever taken away a child's part once given is upon the request of a parent or for the welfare of the child e.g. severe anxiety/stage fright/ family circumstances / bloody family holidays in term time

carddino · 08/11/2023 20:45

My daughter same age, very bright and accurate has told me for weeks she is a sheep.

Letter home today, she is a mouse, the entire class are, there appear to be no sheep.

So she's furious at me reading this out of her homework book as she believes she is a sheep, but I suspect she's either misheard or misunderstood

Sartre · 08/11/2023 20:45

They shouldn’t have giveth then taketh away, that’s rather cruel.

I can sympathise with him not getting the part he wanted though. My DD is much older, she’s in year 7 now but she cried her heart out a few months ago when she wasn’t given a bigger role in the year 6 leavers production. Honestly sobbing for about an hour and she doesn’t usually get upset about things.

TheFifthTellytubby · 08/11/2023 20:32

Toarrie · 08/11/2023 19:45

Two Mary’s!!! That’s madness. I totally get not all can have parts. Just hard consoling DC who just wants to be involved in everything, especially as they thought they had a part.

DCs' school did a production of Bugsy Malone with TWO Blouseys - both on the stage at the same time, singing and saying the lines. It was totally bizarre. There was more than one performance, so they could easily have shared them. Never got to the bottom of that one! 🤔😂

Toarrie · 08/11/2023 20:24

User562377 · 08/11/2023 20:13

One year my kid was a sausage 😀
Luckily he was very excited about it because his teacher convinced him it was a very important part, even though he didn't have any lines. I guess a speaking sausage wasn't very realistic.

Brilliant! DC would probably be happy with that too but the just being shoved in the chorus isn’t sitting well with them.

OP posts:
Toarrie · 08/11/2023 20:22

SouthernBel · 08/11/2023 19:59

Don't be sorry! And I say that as a primary 1 teacher currently rehearsing for a nativity! Firstly, nativities absolutely can be done fairly, it requires thought and extra effort to adapt scripts/ add in parts etc, but I hate if one child has 50 lines to say and there are others sitting there without lines! It's our job as teachers to nurture the children's enthusiasm and enjoyment! Anyway, rant aside, I would definitely (gently) ask the teacher for clarification as to what happened. If the role was up for grabs, and the teacher said 'who would like it' and two boys put their hands up, then it seems like a misunderstanding from your DC (understandable, he's 5!) as to who had been given it, but if she had actually awarded it to your son and then took it away from him, then that isn't ok and needs addressed. I would also, again gently, say how incredibly disappointed your child is not to have a larger role, and was there any way one could be found for them, even if it was one word (roles like this can always be squashed in I say from experience). It wouldn't annoy me if a parent asked me this nicely and sympathetically - I would hate to know there was a child so upset about something that's meant to be fun and would want to try and fix it for them. Good luck!

Thank you. That was really helpful. I need to clarify what has actually happened. It sounds as if things definitely could have been fairer. I believe there are a few big speaking parts, more small speaking parts and then some non speaking parts. Then everyone else is chorus (i.e doesn’t have a part and don’t even go on stage)

OP posts:
User562377 · 08/11/2023 20:13

One year my kid was a sausage 😀
Luckily he was very excited about it because his teacher convinced him it was a very important part, even though he didn't have any lines. I guess a speaking sausage wasn't very realistic.

JoKy · 08/11/2023 20:08

Most teachers just want an easy life and will nearly always pick the same kids that they consider good at acting when they should really try and encourage those that would gain from those roles but needs little push.

JustMarriedBecca · 08/11/2023 20:07

At our school they each have similar numbers of lines except the main characters like Mary and Joseph who are often silent parts.

So they'll give "a main part" to one of the quieter children so they feel more involved and then dunno, the third sheep ends up being the comedic role of the whole performance.

You never know quite what you'll get.

I quite like it.

Lochness1975 · 08/11/2023 20:05

Maybe an understudy part? I was understudy in my year 6 play unfortunately the star got chicken pox on the day. Sorry not sorry lol

LylaLee · 08/11/2023 20:01

My kid was a door one year. The line: no room in the inn.

Pinkpinkpink15 · 08/11/2023 19:59

Zanatdy · 08/11/2023 19:52

Takes me back. For the year 6 production my shy DD actually went for some roles. She only got a minor part and I was quite disappointed it could have really helped bring her out of her shell. The main part had so many lines, god knows how she learnt them all, wish it could be more balanced. What is frustrating is same kids in the main parts year on year.

It was so bad sat a nearby school that the kids ended up being called 'Mary' 'Joseph' etc etc permanently!!

it's a difficult balance between letting them all have a turn & using kids you know you can rely on.

SouthernBel · 08/11/2023 19:59

Don't be sorry! And I say that as a primary 1 teacher currently rehearsing for a nativity! Firstly, nativities absolutely can be done fairly, it requires thought and extra effort to adapt scripts/ add in parts etc, but I hate if one child has 50 lines to say and there are others sitting there without lines! It's our job as teachers to nurture the children's enthusiasm and enjoyment! Anyway, rant aside, I would definitely (gently) ask the teacher for clarification as to what happened. If the role was up for grabs, and the teacher said 'who would like it' and two boys put their hands up, then it seems like a misunderstanding from your DC (understandable, he's 5!) as to who had been given it, but if she had actually awarded it to your son and then took it away from him, then that isn't ok and needs addressed. I would also, again gently, say how incredibly disappointed your child is not to have a larger role, and was there any way one could be found for them, even if it was one word (roles like this can always be squashed in I say from experience). It wouldn't annoy me if a parent asked me this nicely and sympathetically - I would hate to know there was a child so upset about something that's meant to be fun and would want to try and fix it for them. Good luck!

Needmorelego · 08/11/2023 19:57

@user1846385927482658 but the child needs to be able to say the lines and act out the scene. If they literally can't do that - then they can't be that part.
I wanted to be a monkey in my Infants play - but the monkey scene involved doing cartwheels.
I couldn't do cartwheels so I couldn't be a monkey.