Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a nativity one I’m sorry

87 replies

Toarrie · 08/11/2023 19:31

Please be kind with me I have a rather upset DC, year 1.
So DC has been talking about nativity all week and how they have a minor speaking part. Turns out that part has now been given to another boy, DC was told and told they will just be part of the chorus. Children were apparently asked what they wanted to do (sounds chaotic with a number of changes) and DC specifically said they wanted a speaking part and teacher said they would get them one. Cue one very upset child.
now I understand not everyone can have a part but why ask and then promise parts to 5/6 year olds if they can’t deliver?
DC is gutted that they will be sat on a bench at the very back behind all of the children that have parts.
should I flag to teacher that child is upset? I don’t want to be that parent (and in no way am I expecting them to now have a part) but also I don’t want me/DC to come across as push overs?

OP posts:
TVaddict23 · 09/11/2023 11:00

This brings back memories of having a none speaking part as a donkey every year 🤣. I wanted to be Mary so much but it wasn't meant to be.

Jules912 · 09/11/2023 10:58

Our school always picks scripts where everyone who wants a speaking part can have one. I don't know where they get them but they scale nicely so, for example, you could have one person do all the shepherds lines or 5 do a line each. I don't understand the chorus not being on stage, surely they can stand at the back or something. Ours those who don't want to speak are the sheep/townspeople etc and get to do a song and dance.

whizzbangpopsplutter · 09/11/2023 10:50

Nativities should be inclusive at that age, not divide the children into "proper parts" and "chorus". It's not difficult to do. Our nursery do a lovely musical nativity which is basically children in groups (angels, shepherds, sheep, stars, innkeeper and family, kings, etc) with the story told by all the children singing a song about each group in turn. So every child gets to be on stage and have their own group's special moment (standing up and doing the actions together), without having to be divided into "important characters" and "chorus who don't even get to be on-stage". Or some primary schools do it in year groups - our primary has the youngest ones on stage with very minimal lines divided up between all the characters, and the older years as singing chorus.

Toarrie · 09/11/2023 09:05

Nothanksthanksanyway · 09/11/2023 08:38

I’m not unkind. I’m honest. All my best friends are primary teachers in foundation / year 1. You are the kind of parent that makes their lives a misery at a time that should be full of joy and fun, do you think they don’t already feel loads of pressure to please everyone? Do you not think they try their best to be fair? Do you not think they pick the kids they have the most confidence in for the speaking parts? I’m just trying to save you from yourself, but you obviously know better.

Yes I do think they try to be fair which is why I wanted to understand why my child thinks they had a part that was given to someone else.
I don’t want to be that parent though so I take your point.

OP posts:
Nothanksthanksanyway · 09/11/2023 08:38

Toarrie · 09/11/2023 08:35

Wow aren’t you kind. I don’t think checking if DC has misunderstood so I can support them one time is constant interference. I haven’t been in touch with the teacher before and I am unlikely to be in touch again. There have been plenty of things he hasn’t been picked for which I have not been in touch with the school about.
I actually don’t care if he has the one line he would like or is in the background in the chorus but he is upset and I want to support him.
in our school the chorus don’t get to go on the stage so it would be an absolute lie to say they are playing an important part and he would have unrealistic expectations

I’m not unkind. I’m honest. All my best friends are primary teachers in foundation / year 1. You are the kind of parent that makes their lives a misery at a time that should be full of joy and fun, do you think they don’t already feel loads of pressure to please everyone? Do you not think they try their best to be fair? Do you not think they pick the kids they have the most confidence in for the speaking parts? I’m just trying to save you from yourself, but you obviously know better.

Toarrie · 09/11/2023 08:35

Nothanksthanksanyway · 09/11/2023 08:29

Oh man. Ok. But come early next year , when the teacher is completely fed up of the sight of you and your constant interference, you’ll understand!

And singing is important, just not good enough for you and your precious boy obviously 🤣.

Wow aren’t you kind. I don’t think checking if DC has misunderstood so I can support them one time is constant interference. I haven’t been in touch with the teacher before and I am unlikely to be in touch again. There have been plenty of things he hasn’t been picked for which I have not been in touch with the school about.
I actually don’t care if he has the one line he would like or is in the background in the chorus but he is upset and I want to support him.
in our school the chorus don’t get to go on the stage so it would be an absolute lie to say they are playing an important part and he would have unrealistic expectations

OP posts:
HikingforScenery · 09/11/2023 08:34

it’s not a lie to tell him his singing role is important, because it is. Having the choir ready to sing means transition can happen smoothly. My favourite parts of the nativity are the songs.

Nothanksthanksanyway · 09/11/2023 08:29

Toarrie · 09/11/2023 08:26

Well obviously you don’t understand my posts as I’ve said I don’t fully understand what has happened so wondered about asking the teacher as I know DC might have picked it up wrong. I just want to help DC understand to support them.
also I’m not going to lie to him about having an important singing role! I will help him understand things aren’t fair absolutely but I won’t lie!

Oh man. Ok. But come early next year , when the teacher is completely fed up of the sight of you and your constant interference, you’ll understand!

And singing is important, just not good enough for you and your precious boy obviously 🤣.

Toarrie · 09/11/2023 08:26

Nothanksthanksanyway · 09/11/2023 08:16

Do you really think that the teacher needs drama over the nativity? Do you not think it’s your job to help your kid understand it’s not always about him and he needs to understand his important singing role? Maybe when it came to it your kid didn’t have the confidence of the other child. You don’t know. You were not there. You are taking your kids version of events and going all playground mafia over it.

I completely understand your post, I just don’t understand why it’s such a big deal to you. He will probably forget about it in a few days and you’re obsessing because he isn’t the star you wanted him to be! You are never going to survive school if you feel the need to go running to the teacher everytime it doesn’t go your kids way. Perhaps you need a hobby or something else to use your time and energy on?

Well obviously you don’t understand my posts as I’ve said I don’t fully understand what has happened so wondered about asking the teacher as I know DC might have picked it up wrong. I just want to help DC understand to support them.
also I’m not going to lie to him about having an important singing role! I will help him understand things aren’t fair absolutely but I won’t lie!

OP posts:
PeaPenguin · 09/11/2023 08:25

Get your child to speak to the teacher. You say it is your child who is upset so teach them to speak up for themselves. Most 5 year olds are capable of going up to the teacher and saying please can I have a speaking role in the nativity? Especially if you practice with them beforehand.

Then the teacher will either be able to make a swap, or it is set in stone. Life isn't always fair and you move on.

ludicrouslycapaciousbags · 09/11/2023 08:24

Couldn't agree more @Nothanksthanksanyway

What does running up to the school with your drama teach your son, do parents actually behave that way... get yourself and hobby and your son into the local drama club.

Nothanksthanksanyway · 09/11/2023 08:16

Toarrie · 09/11/2023 08:10

I think you have misunderstood my post. Dc thought they had a part and said that teacher told them they would have and then told me it was given to another child and so is upset. I was asking for advice on whether I should let the teacher know the child is upset to understand what has happen. I am not expecting them to be given the lead role or any part at this stage but I wondered if it was reasonable to approach the teacher to understand why DC is so upset.
I have lots of time and energy to provide support to my upset child, but I cannot do that full if I don’t understand what has happened. i don’t think my DC coming home crying is small

Do you really think that the teacher needs drama over the nativity? Do you not think it’s your job to help your kid understand it’s not always about him and he needs to understand his important singing role? Maybe when it came to it your kid didn’t have the confidence of the other child. You don’t know. You were not there. You are taking your kids version of events and going all playground mafia over it.

I completely understand your post, I just don’t understand why it’s such a big deal to you. He will probably forget about it in a few days and you’re obsessing because he isn’t the star you wanted him to be! You are never going to survive school if you feel the need to go running to the teacher everytime it doesn’t go your kids way. Perhaps you need a hobby or something else to use your time and energy on?

Ballsbaill · 09/11/2023 08:11

Most children come home crying from school many times. This time it's because he hasn't got what he wanted. That's life.

Toarrie · 09/11/2023 08:10

Nothanksthanksanyway · 09/11/2023 08:03

You are massively overthinking it. This is just one of life’s things your kid needs to get over and move on. I honestly don’t know where you find the time and energy in your life to be this bothered over something really, so small. ( it blows my mind you’d ever consider talking to the teacher!!!)

Tell him you’ll be there to see him singing his songs and you can’t wait and will be so proud and then forget about it!

I think you have misunderstood my post. Dc thought they had a part and said that teacher told them they would have and then told me it was given to another child and so is upset. I was asking for advice on whether I should let the teacher know the child is upset to understand what has happen. I am not expecting them to be given the lead role or any part at this stage but I wondered if it was reasonable to approach the teacher to understand why DC is so upset.
I have lots of time and energy to provide support to my upset child, but I cannot do that full if I don’t understand what has happened. i don’t think my DC coming home crying is small

OP posts:
Nineteendays · 09/11/2023 08:08

My ds was the elephant once. I think they ran out of nativity animals so went a bit zoo.

op I would email the teacher and explain that ds is very upset because he thinks he was given a part and then his part was given to someone else. Make sure to put in ‘ds thinks/feels’ so it’s not like youre accusing them of something that might not be the case. I would also ask if they wouldn’t mind clarifying to ds in class as he’s a bit confused.

Nothanksthanksanyway · 09/11/2023 08:03

You are massively overthinking it. This is just one of life’s things your kid needs to get over and move on. I honestly don’t know where you find the time and energy in your life to be this bothered over something really, so small. ( it blows my mind you’d ever consider talking to the teacher!!!)

Tell him you’ll be there to see him singing his songs and you can’t wait and will be so proud and then forget about it!

Ballsbaill · 09/11/2023 08:03

30+ years ago I was new to the school having just moved to the area. I'd been there since September and at Christmas I was given the lead role of Mary in the nativity. I was overjoyed and it made me feel welcome.

All the parents were furious as the new kid didn't deserve it and I got grief from other kids in the playground probably egged on by parents like you.

I was 6.

FFS it's a school play not the National Theatre.

30 kids in a class they can't all get what they want.

HikingforScenery · 09/11/2023 08:02

Sounds like there would be more confident readers, who would then get the part.
I would let it go tbh

Some children have be in the chorus. It’s en opportunity for DC to understand that sometimes you don’t get what you want

Toarrie · 09/11/2023 07:57

Highlyflavouredgravy · 08/11/2023 23:51

If he is not very academic then perhaps he couldn't read the script?
The main parts need to go to kids who can read the script and speak loudly and confidently and who can follow instructions.

He is fine at reading, not top set but second top, reading ORT level 6 definitely able to read and learn a line. Reasonably confident too.

OP posts:
bussteward · 09/11/2023 07:56

Ds had originally wanted to be Jesus until they explained it was possible.
I was Jesus in my sister’s nativity but I was four months old… Shout-out to my parents for that but of cunning childcare that meant they could both watch the show, unencumbered by a baby.

Greaterthanthesumoftheparts · 09/11/2023 07:23

When I was at primary school we did a production of Joseph and the amazing technicolour dream cost. I was a palm tree! I was the only person on stage for the whole play!

Toarrie · 09/11/2023 07:20

Screamingabdabz · 09/11/2023 00:06

Another idea op - do check what children’s activities are on at your local church - I’m sure they’d welcome you and would love to have your little one in their nativity play.

DH is very anti religion so I don’t think that would go down well. Personally I have wonderful memories of being in our local church nativity

OP posts:
Toarrie · 09/11/2023 07:18

Gymnopedie · 09/11/2023 00:27

OP I think as long as you do it gently not all guns blazing you absolutely should clarify with the school what's happened. If DS has misunderstood you can explain to him. However if - it's a possibility - he really did have the part and then it's been taken away because a pushy parent demanded a speaking role for their child and the teacher has given in then that's when you too become a pushy parent because that would be absolutely shit on the school's part.

Thanks. I will will get in touch with the teacher to understand what has happened. I am not expecting anything will change now, I just want to be able to explain to DC and manage their expectations (ie tell them they won’t get to be on stage)

OP posts:
Toarrie · 09/11/2023 07:16

Bbq1 · 08/11/2023 23:44

Ds was the donkey in the reception nativity, leading M&J to Bethlehem ans singing . He absolutely stole the show with his unintended comedic asides and funny acting. His role because legendary and the Nursery teacher used to mention it every year afterwards . On his last day in Year 6 one of the teachers commented on how there had never been such a fantastic donkey before or since. Ds had originally wanted to be Jesus until they explained it was possible. Any role van be made your own! I du agree that all children need ti be given axrole in Primary. Ds went on to be a cloud, shepherd, Narrator and singing in the choir. Children can always be singers on the stage to give everyone a role.

I agree any role can be made their own. But sadly DC hasn’t been given a role, and the chorus don’t get to go on stage.

OP posts:
Somewhereovertherainbowweighapie · 09/11/2023 03:48

I hope the teacher gets a lot of questions from parents. Why on earth would you do a play with only a few roles and a huge class of kids. I would ask your ds if he wants to skip it.