Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that circumcising baby/young boys is the equivalent to FGM?

259 replies

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 17:22

I’m part of a baby group - our babies are all younger than 12 months and there are parents looking to get their sons REcircumcised 😢

They’re all based in America. I understand it’s a cultural norm there and nobody is talking about any medical issues to warrant having them circumcised.

It’s a fact that it causes desensitisation and part of me feels that along with the general pain of the operation this is similar to FGM.

The baby can’t consent to the mutilation. Also mutilation isn’t too severe a word, it literally means: act or instance of destroying, removing, or severely damaging a limb or other body part of a person or animal.

YABU - It’s not similar to FGM. There’s nothing wrong with it, snip away!

YANBU - It’s similar / the male equivalent to FGM and unless carried out for medical reasons it should be up to the discretion of the person who is being circumcised

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Bobbotgegrinch · 08/11/2023 18:28

As a circumsised man I'm very against it, think it's tantamount to child abuse. Unless it's a medical necessity, noone should be chopping bits of another humans body off, especially when they're too young to speak, let alone consent.

However, it's not remotely comparable to FGM, which is a thousand times worse and more abhorrent.

Comparisons between the two aren't helpful in either case, they minimise FGM while also stopping people taking your argument against circumcision seriously.

You can be against both while accepting that they're different issues, with different causes and different outcomes, that need to be tackled differently.

mrssanchez · 08/11/2023 18:27

I don't agree with it unless for medical reasons but on the other hand, I've had a Jewish boyfriend who was circumcised due to his religion and he didn't seem any the worse for it or traumatised in any way.
You are bonkers though if you think it's remotely the same thing as FGM!

Sconehenge · 08/11/2023 18:25

The definition of comparable is “capable of being compared; having features in common with something else to permit or suggest comparison.”

FGM and male circumcision DO have features in common - and can be compared.

When we compare them we can say:

-Similarities are that we are cutting off useful and necessary body parts of non-consenting minors, mostly for cultural or religious reasons.

-Differences are how much more horrific FGM is in life long impact on the victim and that sometimes male circumcision can have medical benefits.

Even though FGM is much worse, they are similar in some important ways. I would say that there is no true male equivalent to FGM, but male circumcision is certainly the closest thing to an equivalent.

RufustheFactualReindeer · 08/11/2023 18:24

SugaredCookie · 08/11/2023 17:23

It’s not acceptable but no, it’s not the equivalent of FGM

What many others have said

LoreleiG · 08/11/2023 18:16

I completely disagree. Not that I personally agree with male circumcision (for no medical reason), particularly with no anaesthetic, but they are not comparable.

LittleMooli · 08/11/2023 18:16

JellyMops · 08/11/2023 18:00

I'd say it's equivalent. It's male genital mutilation. It's not as bad as most forms of FGM but if it's not medically necessary, it's mutilation the same as FGM.

This

EasternTennessee · 08/11/2023 18:14

It’s not comparable to FGM, but that doesn’t make it right. No one should be cutting and mutilating healthy body parts for so called cultural or religious reasons or any reason at all.

Rates in the US were falling, I hope they still are. None of my friends back there had there boys circumcised and are disgusted by it.

CyberCritical · 08/11/2023 18:12

No it's different, very different.

Male circumcision is generally unnecessary and I disagree with it unless there is a medical need, but for the significant majority the males who are circumcised retain full use of their penis.

Female genital mutilation at its most severe includes cutting the clitoris off and sewing the labia closed so only a tiny hole remains to urinate and menstruate through. When the woman is married her husband has to literally force his penis through that hole ripping it open to satisfy his needs. The woman can have no sexual pleasure due to the removal of her clitoris and the agony of the process. If she is then impregnated then the act of giving birth causes further tearing in order for the baby to get out.

There really is no comparison.

Ballsbaill · 08/11/2023 18:09

AnotherEmma · 08/11/2023 17:40

YABVU, as PPs have pointed out.
No culture in our patriarchal world would ever systematically subject males to anything as horrific as FGM.

Exactly. Whataboutery makes me sick.

Women aren't allowed to have anything there's always men suffer similar.

They don't. Male circumcision is necessary I'm some cases for medical reasons FGM never is.

We don't even have exclusive rights of the word women anymore in case it upsets some deluded men.

Bendysnap · 08/11/2023 18:07

I think you need to do some research on what FGM entails and the horrific lifelong consequences.

I don’t agree with male circumcision but I think it is very dangerous to equate fgm with male circumcision. Yes it does minimise FGM because in peoples minds they think that the pain and lifelong impact must be broadly equivalent if you’re talking about them in the same breath. But they’re not in any way equivalent.

Ive donated money over the years to clinics in Africa dedicated to helping women who have undergone FGM.

I’ll ask again and echo what others have said - please do read up more on FGM.

crowisland · 08/11/2023 18:07

There is plenty of solid medical evidence (much from South Africa) that there is a strong link between lower rates of HIV and circumcision. Many young boys (e.g., ages 5-8) need it for medical reasons. Being circumcised as a child or adult (as opposed to a newborn) is much more traumatic and painful. So what's the harm in preventitive procedures?

FrostieBoabby · 08/11/2023 18:06

I would never consent to this being done to my child unless it was for medical reasons.

Maybe it isn't as awful as the extreme types of FGM but it's unnecessary and religious beliefs should not excuse it.

TinyTeacher · 08/11/2023 18:05

Not remotely comparable in terms of the extent of the damage done.

I wouldn't do it to my boys without a medical reason, but it's NOT the same. I do think it's a strange cultural practice. But it does relatively little harm so its not one I concern myself about.

OldChinaJug · 08/11/2023 18:05

Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 08/11/2023 17:48

Have you actually read much about the procedures involved in FGM? I have to do training on it every year and it’s hideous.

I don’t agree with unnecessary circumcision either but they are just nothing alike. You can’t ‘bring it up to the same level’ becuase it’s nowhere near it in terms of pain, invasiveness and long term health consequences.

Same.

The first time I sat through one, I fainted and had flashback images for months afterwards.

The thought of girls going through the process are the most upsetting images I've ever had.

Utterly, utterly horrific and in no way comparable. I cannot imagine how those girls/women even begin to live with it.

It's hugely ignorant to suggest a comparison.

Passepartoute · 08/11/2023 18:02

theresnolimits · 08/11/2023 17:49

My husband is circumcised (American - very common). This is what Dr Google tells me:

Is there any benefit to circumcision?
The possible medical benefits of circumcision include: A lower risk of HIV. A slightly lower risk of other sexually transmitted diseases. A slightly lower risk of urinary tract infections and penile cancer.

And of course, there are some conditions where the removal of the foreskin can help and it is supposed to improve hygiene.

Does FGM have any of these benefits?

Your researches are leaving out the other side of the coin in terms of the damage that can be done by circumcision.

slowsundays · 08/11/2023 18:02

FGM is done for the sole reason of controlling women's sexuality.

Circumcision is not. So not comparable.

Passepartoute · 08/11/2023 18:00

NmeChngeFail · 08/11/2023 17:35

There is no medical reason for FGM so it can never be compared.

A lot of grown men have to get circumcised for medical reasons, aswell as a lot of young boys, and it does have some benefit with regards to STI transference.

With FGM there is no benefit.

It is perfectly reasonable to compare circumcisions that are not done for medical reasons, which are probably the majority.

JellyMops · 08/11/2023 18:00

I'd say it's equivalent. It's male genital mutilation. It's not as bad as most forms of FGM but if it's not medically necessary, it's mutilation the same as FGM.

slowsundays · 08/11/2023 18:00

It shouldn't be done without medical necessity but it is absolutely in no way comparable to FGM.

Passepartoute · 08/11/2023 18:00

ohbaby24 · 08/11/2023 17:34

Not comparable and not your concern!

That's ridiculous. It should be a concern for all of us if boys are being mutilated wholly unnecessarily.

Do you think that FGM isn't anyone else's concern either?

GreyCarpet · 08/11/2023 17:59

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 17:32

How am I minimising FGM - if anything I’m bringing male circumcision up to the same level?

Why is it always about minimising something rather than elevating other things?

Edited

Because male circumcision, however much I disagree with it, isn't comparable with FGM.

FGM is designed to destroy sexual pleasure to appease the insecurities of men.

It can cause life long health issues.

Girls/women can die from those issues.

Sex is often unbearably painful.

It serves absolutely no benefit to any girl or woman ever.

I'd suggest that, if you think they are in anyway comparable, you may well need to look up what FGM actually involves.

BurrosTail · 08/11/2023 17:59

Doesn’t fgm completely destroy all sexual pleasure? And circumcised men have orgasms, based on them having kids? Obviously individual cases here and there but that seems to be the general rule.

One thing to have a convo if circumcision is necessary or not, but the comparison is not quite right.

Yerroblemom1923 · 08/11/2023 17:58

No way is circumcision on males on a par with FGM. FGM is barbaric and ruins girls/ women's lives. Circumcision on boys is done with anaesthetic for medical or religious reasons in a safe, sterile environment.

Passepartoute · 08/11/2023 17:58

JenniferJupiterVenusandMars · 08/11/2023 17:26

Absolutely not the equivalent, it’s often done for medical reasons not to ruin someone’s sex life ffs.

In practice it is sadly done much more often for cultural and religious reasons.

TidyDancer · 08/11/2023 17:56

SugaredCookie · 08/11/2023 17:23

It’s not acceptable but no, it’s not the equivalent of FGM

As so frequently happens, the first response absolutely sums it up.