Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that circumcising baby/young boys is the equivalent to FGM?

259 replies

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 17:22

I’m part of a baby group - our babies are all younger than 12 months and there are parents looking to get their sons REcircumcised 😢

They’re all based in America. I understand it’s a cultural norm there and nobody is talking about any medical issues to warrant having them circumcised.

It’s a fact that it causes desensitisation and part of me feels that along with the general pain of the operation this is similar to FGM.

The baby can’t consent to the mutilation. Also mutilation isn’t too severe a word, it literally means: act or instance of destroying, removing, or severely damaging a limb or other body part of a person or animal.

YABU - It’s not similar to FGM. There’s nothing wrong with it, snip away!

YANBU - It’s similar / the male equivalent to FGM and unless carried out for medical reasons it should be up to the discretion of the person who is being circumcised

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
PurpleChrayne · 08/11/2023 18:51

What a time to be Jewish on Mumsnet!

My G-d.

TastesLikeStrawberriesOnASummerEvening · 08/11/2023 18:50

it is NOT comparable to FGM.
If you think it is you need to educate yourself.

TheSpikySpinosaurus · 08/11/2023 18:50

Of course it's not the same as FGM! FGM has lifelong effects re pain, loss of sexual pleasure, loss of function, increased risk off infections, psychological problems, problems during pregnancy and birth, and infertility.

Circumcising does not. 🙄

brunchfiend · 08/11/2023 18:50

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 17:32

How am I minimising FGM - if anything I’m bringing male circumcision up to the same level?

Why is it always about minimising something rather than elevating other things?

Edited

Because removal of foreskin, while awful for non medical reasons would be the equivalent of the removal of the clitoral hood. And that's not what FGM is. FGM is the removal of the outer clitoris, labia and a stitching of the vaginal entrance to make the hole smaller. It's like comparing losing a finger to losing an arm.

StuntNun · 08/11/2023 18:48

Yes you're BU. FGM is much more serious than male circumcision. I agree that circumcision seems totally baffling though. I think you'll just have to stay out of any conversations with Americans about it.

JellyMops · 08/11/2023 18:48

PaperSky · 08/11/2023 18:34

My DS had to be circumcised (for medical reasons).

I don’t feel he’s been been mutilated. (I know you did specify ‘unless for medical reasons’) and I wouldn’t have done it if he didn’t need it, yet ‘mutilated’ feels too strong a word still.

It’s nowhere near comparable imo.

Theres no benefit to FGM, and never a medical need.

I agree with you bit I still think it is mutilation if it is done for no medical reason.

I feel the same with amputees. If they're attacked with a machete-mutilation, if it's done by a surgeon for sound medical reasons-not mutilation. If a woman has her vulva removed due to cancer-not mutilation, if she has them removed with a rusty knife to make her 'clean'-mutilation.

BIossomtoes · 08/11/2023 18:47

Terfosaurus · 08/11/2023 17:29

I can't vote because I don't think "there's nothing wrong with it, snip away" but it's not comparable to FGM.

Same. I’m not about to judge other people’s religious customs either.

Ponderingwindow · 08/11/2023 18:47

I don’t think it compares to the brutality of FGM, but that still doesn’t mean there is any excuse for altering a child’s genitals without compelling medical need.

bodily autonomy and consent supersede any claims to culture or tradition.

Talapia · 08/11/2023 18:47

FGM is carried out to control and suppress girls and women.

Circumcision for supposed hygiene or religious/ cultural beliefs is unacceptable but does not cause the same extent of physical trauma as FGM.

Libertass · 08/11/2023 18:46

In terms of extent, severity & harm male genital mutilation is not as bad as female genital mutilation.

In principle, it is exactly the same. A defenceless, vulnerable child’s body is being mutilated in ways it cannot consent to. FGM is illegal in the U.K., and quite rightly so. MGM should also be banned, that ban should be robustly enforced and if that means certain communities feel unable to remain in the U.K., so be it.

Soubriquet · 08/11/2023 18:46

Yabu

Sometimes boys need it for medical reasons. I don’t agree with it for cultural reasons but sometimes it’s medically necessary. It is in no where comparable to FGM which is just purely barbaric

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 08/11/2023 18:45

@PaperSky hope you don't mind me asking, how long did it take to heal?
My baby (he's only 5 months) had other surgery they did at same time and ontop of general anaesthetic he had a spinal so am a bit stressed from lack of sleep and everything on him just looks so sore!

My idea of using mn as a distraction probably not a good idea opening this thread!

Fionaville · 08/11/2023 18:43

I don't think it's the equivalent of FGM, but it's still barbaric.
I also don't agree with piercing baby ears, so I'm pretty set on how I feel about these things.

tpxqi · 08/11/2023 18:42

So much amateur dramatics from OP. Get a grip. There is no equivalence.

Monkeymonkeymoo · 08/11/2023 18:41

crowisland · 08/11/2023 18:07

There is plenty of solid medical evidence (much from South Africa) that there is a strong link between lower rates of HIV and circumcision. Many young boys (e.g., ages 5-8) need it for medical reasons. Being circumcised as a child or adult (as opposed to a newborn) is much more traumatic and painful. So what's the harm in preventitive procedures?

Because it only slightly lowers the risk of HIV it doesn’t remove it. Saying that circumcised men are less likely to get HIV leads to complacency and anyone having sex with a partner who is HIV positive (or their HIV status is unknown) needs to be using condoms and ideally PrEP medications. Also, the highest risk sexual activity for contracting HIV is receiving anal sex and in that case it won’t make a difference if the person receiving it is circumcised or not.
While there might be some benefit at a population level for circumcision in countries/communities where there is poor access to HIV testing, treatment and education this really can’t be extrapolated to countries where there is better access to sexual health resources that can provide prevention interventions that are far more effective.

Also, the number of boys/men who need circumcision for medical reasons is fairly low. There’s absolutely no justification for circumcising babies just in case they might need a circumcision for medical reasons later on (much like we don’t remove everyone’s tonsils or appendix ‘just in case’).

Male circumcision is very different to FGM (which is truly awful), however that doesn’t make it ok or acceptable.
It’s also worth noting that some of the risks of male circumcision are partly mitigated by the fact that in many countries it’s legal and can therefore be carried out by trained health professionals in hygienic and safe environments. In countries where there is less access to these services male circumcision can definitely lead to serious infections and complications that cause serious long term damage.

endofthelinefinally · 08/11/2023 18:41

Chopping bits off the genitals of any child is unnecessary and barbaric. The routine circumcision of baby boys one one of the (many) reasons I left my nursing job in USA and came back to the UK. I think parents should be forced to watch, that would soon stop it. It is a brutal money making exercise that inflicts pain and distress on baby boys.
FGM is much worse, and neither procedure is acceptable IMO.

BitofaStramash · 08/11/2023 18:40

I don't agree with it if not medically necessary but it's not anything like FGM

Imamumgetmeoutofhere · 08/11/2023 18:38

FGM is illegal in this country, it is also illegal to take a female out of the country to have it done. If you suspect a female is being taken out of the country to have it done and you report it to the authorities they can stop their passports. It is classed as abuse / assault and people can go to prison for it. Females die from it, infection and blood loss is rife. They can die later in life as their vulva and vagina is so badly misshapen they cannot give birth.

Circumcision, whilst unnecessary (medical reasons aside) rarely comes with complications and believe it or not there are lower HPV rates in men and woman in communities where it is common so can have some benefits.

However, the two are at completely different ends of the spectrum to this AIBU is ridiculous to be honest

Georgyporky · 08/11/2023 18:38

"With FGM there is no benefit."

Only to their husbands, who assume the wife won't fuck anyone else because she gets no pleasure from sex.
I've always thought it odd that it's the female relatives that do it to their own daughters.

CurlewKate · 08/11/2023 18:37

It's abhorrent and should be illegal. But not comparable to FGM.

PaperSky · 08/11/2023 18:34

JellyMops · 08/11/2023 18:00

I'd say it's equivalent. It's male genital mutilation. It's not as bad as most forms of FGM but if it's not medically necessary, it's mutilation the same as FGM.

My DS had to be circumcised (for medical reasons).

I don’t feel he’s been been mutilated. (I know you did specify ‘unless for medical reasons’) and I wouldn’t have done it if he didn’t need it, yet ‘mutilated’ feels too strong a word still.

It’s nowhere near comparable imo.

Theres no benefit to FGM, and never a medical need.

LoopyLooooo · 08/11/2023 18:32

Without a medical reason it's child abuse, but still not the same as FGM.

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 08/11/2023 18:31

It is nothing like FGM, although thanks for giving even more stress and guilt that I've 'mutilated' my child, who's currently in hospital post medical circumcision, although you've graciously said this is OK....

Givejamesbluntachance · 08/11/2023 18:31

Your voting options are ridiculously loaded. Posters should be able to choose yes or no to one question. You can't answer several questions with one answer.

fedupandstuck · 08/11/2023 18:28

Of course it's not equivalent. The damage and harm from FGM is much more severe than the removal of a boys foreskin. Even the "less severe" kind of FGM is more damaging. Of course, removing a baby boys foreskin for religious or cultural reasons is unnecessary but that's a separate issue.

Nothing in your description of the discussions around circumcision in this baby group need any kind of comparison to FGM. You can object to the circumcision of boys without needing to mention FGM.