Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that circumcising baby/young boys is the equivalent to FGM?

259 replies

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 17:22

I’m part of a baby group - our babies are all younger than 12 months and there are parents looking to get their sons REcircumcised 😢

They’re all based in America. I understand it’s a cultural norm there and nobody is talking about any medical issues to warrant having them circumcised.

It’s a fact that it causes desensitisation and part of me feels that along with the general pain of the operation this is similar to FGM.

The baby can’t consent to the mutilation. Also mutilation isn’t too severe a word, it literally means: act or instance of destroying, removing, or severely damaging a limb or other body part of a person or animal.

YABU - It’s not similar to FGM. There’s nothing wrong with it, snip away!

YANBU - It’s similar / the male equivalent to FGM and unless carried out for medical reasons it should be up to the discretion of the person who is being circumcised

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Kiki880 · 08/11/2023 20:21

Op, I think it’s dangerous to start taking about extreme cases. In countries where it happens, and indeed in countries where it doesn’t, it’s far too difficult and subjective to draw a line and determine what is extreme and what is not - whatever that means. I think it’s all extreme. I don’t think we should take anything but a “black or white” view.

A woman’s genitals should not be cut full stop, it goes without saying.

PaperSky · 08/11/2023 20:15

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 20:02

I’m assuming you mean the most extreme version of FGM? Which is what most people have jumped to…

So let me get this straight - you think male circumcision is directly comparable to FGM… but if and only if we’re not including the ‘more extreme’ FGM?

I think you need to rethink the equivalence you’re making

PaperSky · 08/11/2023 20:11

Bobbotgegrinch · 08/11/2023 19:40

As someone who had it done as an adult for medical reasons, I can tell you there's definitely a fuck ton of nerves in it. It hurt like a mother fucker for days afterwards, and sex just isn't the same without it. Why the fuck anyone would subject a child to it without being medically necessary I do not know.

Still in no way comparable to FGM though.

Well, I mean all skin is attached to nerves (except maybe the end of the elbow?!?)

My point was a foreskin is just not the equivalent of removal of parts of the labia/clitoris. Not that there’s no risk/it makes no difference iyswim.

OPs question isn’t ‘do you agree with non medical circumcision’ (which I think we’re probably in agreement) it’s ‘is it the equivalent to FGM’.

And imo, no. It’s nowhere near.

WhereIsBebèsChambre · 08/11/2023 20:10

Kiki880 · 08/11/2023 20:05

Some babies are born with very tight foreskin which can cause pain and infection. We know a baby where this was the case.

Btw, I am totally against it unless a paediatrician told me it was medically absolutely necessary to prevent pain or a complication.

This is my child, on top of a urethral web, kidney reflux, kidney valve issues, urethral stricture, spent most of his 5 months catheterisation and iv antibiotics, wish someone had told the surgeons today the circumcision wasn't necessary as it looks so painful.

SweetBirdsong · 08/11/2023 20:07

Mamansparkles · 08/11/2023 19:57

One is a genuine actual medical procedure. The ethical issue in question is whether it is acceptable to carry out surgery that is not medically indicated on babies who can't consent.

The other is barbaric mutilation. The male equivalent would be chopping off the whole penis. Your comparison is ludicrous.

So no, they are not the same thing at all even if you think circumcision is wrong, it is not the same as FGM.

Side effects, short and long term risks and death rates for the two are also worlds apart - because one is an actual medical procedure with risks but ones that are small enough to be clearly acceptable when it is done for medical reasons. The other is butchery.

Intention also matters. FGM is done with the intention of controlling women. Circumcision is done with the intention of a) some ideas about hygiene which arent relevant b) an identifier as part of a community

Can you really not see the difference?

100% this! It boggles my mind that some people are implying they are the same (including the OP.) It's clear they have not educated themselves on FGM at ALL.

There's also the fact that the way the clitoris is removed is BARBARIC. Some girls die from septicemia, and even those that don't die, live with long term unpleasant and sometimes painful after affects.

FGM is utterly horrific. It's not just the fact you can't climax without your clitoris as a previous poster said!!!! FGM is barbaric, and is utter butchery. It is illegal in the UK, and you can be imprisoned for up to 14 years for committing this crime against girls. Should be longer!

@Cress42 You clearly know nothing whatsoever about FGM. Please stop!

Kiki880 · 08/11/2023 20:05

Coffeerum · 08/11/2023 19:46

It has no medical benefits for a baby though, let’s not twist reality.

Some babies are born with very tight foreskin which can cause pain and infection. We know a baby where this was the case.

Btw, I am totally against it unless a paediatrician told me it was medically absolutely necessary to prevent pain or a complication.

Cress42 · 08/11/2023 20:04

Stbextherapist · 08/11/2023 19:33

One is done by qualified medics in a hospital setting with pain relief... the other by medically unqualified members of a community using tin can edges, unsterilised knifes, rocks or jagged bits of glass. Ofc they're not the fucking same

This isn’t true - it’s not done with pain relief in lots of incidences

OP posts:
Cress42 · 08/11/2023 20:02

spidermonkeys · 08/11/2023 19:31

It's not comparable at all.

Do you know FGM actually entails ?!

I’m assuming you mean the most extreme version of FGM? Which is what most people have jumped to…

OP posts:
Kiki880 · 08/11/2023 20:02

Bobbotgegrinch · 08/11/2023 19:40

As someone who had it done as an adult for medical reasons, I can tell you there's definitely a fuck ton of nerves in it. It hurt like a mother fucker for days afterwards, and sex just isn't the same without it. Why the fuck anyone would subject a child to it without being medically necessary I do not know.

Still in no way comparable to FGM though.

Thank you for sharing.

labamba007 · 08/11/2023 20:02

The reasons are different - for women and girls it's to control sexuality. Both are wrong but both are not the same.

RM2013 · 08/11/2023 20:01

It’s not the same as FGM. My youngest was circumcised as a toddler due to a very tight foreskin along with a kidney issue which caused repeated kidney infections. His consultant recommended the procedure from a clinical viewpoint to try and help reduce the risk of repeated infections. My eldest didn’t need it done. I personally don’t agree with it for reasons other than a clinical indication but that’s my personal view.
FGM is carried out illegally, often under poor conditions and doesn’t carry a medical benefit

PonkyPonky · 08/11/2023 20:01

Wholeheartedly agree with you OP. Some people don’t know that in a certain faith once they’ve performed the circumcision the person who has just done that, SUCKS the blood from the wound… of a poor defenceless baby! It is abhorrent. It’s not at all the same as doing it for a legitimate medical reason. It is abusive, painful and with the blood sucking thrown in, I’m not sure how anyone can say it’s too different from FGM

Abhannmor · 08/11/2023 19:59

Ps A baby bled to death here a few years ago after a botched 'snip' . Never good idea to go cutting for no reason.

Mamansparkles · 08/11/2023 19:57

One is a genuine actual medical procedure. The ethical issue in question is whether it is acceptable to carry out surgery that is not medically indicated on babies who can't consent.

The other is barbaric mutilation. The male equivalent would be chopping off the whole penis. Your comparison is ludicrous.

So no, they are not the same thing at all even if you think circumcision is wrong, it is not the same as FGM.

Side effects, short and long term risks and death rates for the two are also worlds apart - because one is an actual medical procedure with risks but ones that are small enough to be clearly acceptable when it is done for medical reasons. The other is butchery.

Intention also matters. FGM is done with the intention of controlling women. Circumcision is done with the intention of a) some ideas about hygiene which arent relevant b) an identifier as part of a community

Can you really not see the difference?

Abhannmor · 08/11/2023 19:57

YANBU . In a very small number of cases it is medically necessary. I had a FB discussion with an American lady about this. First she made some bonkers argument that uncircumcised boys and men would be at risk of Aids / penile cancer etc. Other posters disproved this nonsense with a battery of statistics.

To which she replied ' I don't care , I think an uncut penis looks gross. If I don't circumcise my son he'll never get a girlfriend. ' So there we have it.

maddening · 08/11/2023 19:54

I would not say snip away but it is not equivalent so I haven't voted

Haydug · 08/11/2023 19:52

BoobyDazzler · 08/11/2023 19:48

A poster up thread has said that his was circumcised as an adult and doesn’t enjoy sex as much. It’s the same surely? I could have sex without my clitoris but it’d be no where near as nice as it can be with one.

As much? I wouldn't be able to reach climax without mine, and that's a fact for the majority of females. I don't think that's the case for males. Affects sensation, yes, but I don't think it's the same.

BoobyDazzler · 08/11/2023 19:48

A poster up thread has said that his was circumcised as an adult and doesn’t enjoy sex as much. It’s the same surely? I could have sex without my clitoris but it’d be no where near as nice as it can be with one.

SweetBirdsong · 08/11/2023 19:48

Circumcision is absolutely NOTHING like FGM whatsoever. I am embarrassed for anyone who thinks it is. Confused FGM equivalent on a boy would be chopping off the end of his penis. Unbelievable that some people think circumcision on boys is the same as FGM on girls. I despair for humanity! Shock

endofthelinefinally · 08/11/2023 19:48

FGM is horrific, gratuitous, violent and inexcusable, under any and all circumstances. It destroys lives.

Circumcision for medical reasons by a surgeon, with pain relief, is not relevant to this discussion, as the OP made clear at the beginning of this thread. If it needs doing then it is the same as any other necessary surgical procedure.

The routine circumcision of baby boys at a few days old, strapped to a "circ board" with no pain relief, carried out by obstetricians with varying degrees of skill (or lack of) for a bit of cash was , to me, as a UK trained midwife, pretty distressing. This was in a private hospital in USA. I found it appalling tbh.

3 totally different things that should not be conflated IMO.

MerryMarigold · 08/11/2023 19:47

I work in a nursery. Where I work it is about 40% circumsised. Asian, African, Jewish. They show no signs of being in pain.

I would compare it to ear piercing, which is also non consensual in babies and toddlers.

Coffeerum · 08/11/2023 19:46

Withaddedlint · 08/11/2023 19:32

Fgm has no health benefit and is indeed - mutilation.

male circumcision is scientifically proven to have many health benefits

It has no medical benefits for a baby though, let’s not twist reality.

Haydug · 08/11/2023 19:45

Removing the penis would be the equivalent to removing the clitoris. So, no, not the same.

Snugglemonkey · 08/11/2023 19:42

It may well be at the less severe end of the scale, but no form of genital mutilation is acceptable.

Bobbotgegrinch · 08/11/2023 19:40

PaperSky · 08/11/2023 19:15

But removal of ‘a little bit of skin’ on a female has consequences that the male equivalent just doesn’t. On a boy, it’s just a bit of skin, no nerves etc attached.
It’s just not the same

As someone who had it done as an adult for medical reasons, I can tell you there's definitely a fuck ton of nerves in it. It hurt like a mother fucker for days afterwards, and sex just isn't the same without it. Why the fuck anyone would subject a child to it without being medically necessary I do not know.

Still in no way comparable to FGM though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread